Virtual Reality Learning Research Articles

Designing for collaborative learning in immersive virtual reality: a systematic literature review

Immersive learning technologies such as virtual reality have long been deemed as the next generation of digital learning environments. There is a limited number of studies addressing how immersive technologies can be designed, applied, and studied in collaborative learning settings. This paper presents a systematic review of empirical studies reporting on use of immersive virtual reality in collaborative learning within educational and professional learning settings. 11 studies have been grouped and coded in a textual narrative synthesis, outlining the pedagogical concepts behind the learning design, as well as the design of virtual reality environments and the collaborative learning activities in which the technology is employed. The results suggest that collaborative learning in virtual reality can currently be conceptualised as a shared experience in an immersive, virtually mediated space, where there is a shared goal/problem which learners must attend to collaboratively. This conceptualisation implies a need to design technologies, environments, and activities that support participation and social interaction, fostering collaborative learning processes. Based on the outlined conceptualisation, we present a series of recommendations for designing for collaborative learning in immersive virtual reality. The paper concludes that collaborative learning in virtual reality creates a practice- and reflection space, where learning is perceived as engaging, without the risk of interfering with actual practices. Current designs however struggle with usability, realism, and facilitating social interaction. The paper further identifies a need for future research into what happens within virtual reality, rather than only looking at post-virtual reality evaluations.

Level of Satisfaction and Confidence After Using Virtual Reality Simulation of Wound Care Skills in Nursing Students

Virtual laboratory practice using virtual reality provides conveniences and increases learning outcomes, beside physical laboratories requires expensive costs, ineffective and efficient, and limited space causes a decrease in learning levels and impacted to satisfaction and confidence. This study aims to identify satisfaction and confidence of nursing students in learning using Virtual Reality of Wound Care Skills. The research design using descriptive quantitative. In this study, 56 nursing students used as samples using quota sampling technique. Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning Scale (SCSL) is the instrument used in this study. Meanwhile, data analysis was performed using IBM SPSS software version 26 with univariate analysis method and presented in the form of distribution frequency tables, yield percentages, mean, and deviations standard. This study shows that students are very satisfied (M = 4.400; SD = 0.670) and very confident (M = 4.357; SD = 0.622) in learning using Virtual Reality of Wound Care Skills. Results obtained from the use of virtual reality learning simulations on student satisfaction and confidence obtained high scores. Therefore, this learning method can used as an alternative to learning and support student skills and knowledge in another nursing skills.

Inclusive Virtual Reality Learning: Review and 'Best-Fit' Framework for Universal Learning

The rise of Virtual Reality (VR) in educational contexts has highlighted the need to design Virtual Reality Learning Applications (VRLAs) that prioritize inclusivity, accommodating a spectrum of learner needs. Despite the surging interest, there is a noticeable gap in research that delves into the specifics of creating VRLAs that are rooted in inclusive educational theory. This research sought to extract insights and recommendations for the development of VRLAs tailored for diverse student populations. The intention was to scrutinize research focused on the inclusive design elements of VRLAs, leading to the establishment of preliminary Inclusion Guidelines for VR Learning (IGVRL). Adopting the "best-fit" framework synthesis technique, the research anchored its findings in the Universal Design for Learning (UDL) framework. UDL was developed to mold learning experiences to meet the requirements of heterogenous learners. Using UDL as a coding framework, a comprehensive literature review was undertaken, adhering to the SPIDER search strategy. The review of literature revealed distinct design recommendations that facilitate inclusive learning within VRLAs. Information was systematically categorized based on UDL's nine classifications and subsequently distilled into the preliminary IGVRL. It's pertinent to note that these guidelines, while offering a foundational perspective, necessitate further in-depth evaluations for validation. The analytical process brought to the fore several themes that UDL did not adequately encompass, such as the nuances of embodied learning, the focus on VR contents and their immersive properties, and the pivotal role of collaboration and cooperation in VRLAs. These insights underscore the further need for research in these areas. Although some facets of VR accessibility were discussed, a deeper exploration into this domain was identified as crucial, reiterating the importance of accessibility in underpinning inclusive education. The research underscores the potential of VRLAs in promoting inclusivity within educational settings and introduces the preliminary IGVRL for VRLA design, specifically targeting K-12 contexts. This paper emphasizes the continuum of research required to refine and validate these guidelines, ensuring their applicability and efficacy in diverse educational scenarios.

Design and assessment of a virtual reality learning environment for firefighters

The use of virtual reality (VR) in firefighter training is promising because it provides cost-effective, safe environments that arouse similar behavioral responses to real-life scenarios. However, the pedagogical potential of VR and its impact on learning outcomes compared to traditional methods is currently an under-explored area. This research investigates how well VR can support learning compared to traditional methods in the context of training firefighters in combating vegetation fires. A VR learning environment was developed, informed by a “design for learning” framework providing a pedagogical underpinning. A between-subjects experiment was conducted with 40 participants to measure the knowledge transfer of the VR learning environment against the official textbook. In addition, VR's theorized learning benefits of intrinsic motivation, situational interest, and self-efficacy were compared with textbook-based learning. Lastly, the design quality of the learning environment was assessed based on its learning and user experience. We employed a primarily quantitative approach to data collection and analysis, using a combination of knowledge test results and questionnaires, with supporting qualitative data from semi-structured interviews and observation notes to answer our hypotheses. The results found a significant difference between the knowledge transfer of both conditions, with textbook-based learning more effectively transferring factual and conceptual knowledge than VR. No significant difference was found in reported self-efficacy between the two conditions but was found in reported levels of intrinsic motivation and situational interest, which were higher in the VR condition. The design was found to have facilitated a good user and learning experience, assessed via questionnaire responses. During interviews, VR participants reported high levels of satisfaction with the experience, praising the hands-on learning approach and interactivity, while reporting frustration with the lack of knowledge reinforcement and initial difficulties with the controls. A key finding was that presence was found to be negatively associated with knowledge transfer, which we theorize to be caused by the novelty of the realistic VR environment distracting participants from the more familiar lesson content. This research contributes to the body of work related to knowledge transfer within VR in this domain while highlighting key pedagogical and design considerations that can be used to inform future design implementations.

The Effect of Using Interactive Multimedia Design with the STEM VR Approach to Strengthening Pancasila Student Profiles in Elementary School

In producing interactive multimedia, based on STEM VR, with the help of virtual reality which elementary school students need in studying human digestion material, it is hoped that virtual packaging of human digestion material will increase students’ understanding of the topic that cannot be seen by the naked eye. Critical and creative research was carried out on the development of interactive multimedia based on virtual reality for learning about human digestion in fifth-grade elementary schools. This research uses the MDLC stage model with six stages, namely concept, design, material collection, assembly, testing, and distribution. The subject is fifth-grade elementary school. The VR-based interactive multimedia product was validated by experts and continued with a posttest and user response questionnaire with the following results. The science material interactive multimedia product has been validated by material and media experts with results that are very suitable for use in the learning process. Then the product was tested on a limited basis at the SDN Rejosari 01 Semarang school with the influence of 84.4% of students really liking VR-based interactive multimedia products and 15.6% being influenced. Other factors that prevent students from achieving optimal learning outcomes include the school’s lack of VR-related infrastructure so that students are not optimal.
 Keywords: the effect, interactive multimedia, STEM VR, Science material, elementary school

Effectiveness of an Immersive VR System for Construction Site Planning Education

Virtual reality (VR) has been widely used in education and training, but few studies have used it in education on construction site planning. Accordingly, this study developed an immersive VR-based education system for construction site planning and evaluated it in classroom-based tests with 114 students. Statistical analyses revealed that the VR system improved students' learning outcomes compared when conventional paper-based learning. Specifically, students with lower pretest subject knowledge achieved similar scores to top-ranked students after undergoing VR education. Moreover, VR education was more effective for learning concepts than it was for memorization. A single-source teaching approach was also more effective in improving learning outcomes than a multisource approach for VR learning. In summary, this study investigated three previously unexplored areas: targeting the ideal recipients for VR education and training, determining the appropriate problem types for VR education and training, and identifying the effectiveness of VR education and training for construction site planning.

Creating a Framework for Virtual Reality Learning Environment (VRLE) for Studio-Based Learning

Higher education academics are lacking the knowledge on how to implement Design Thinking (DT) for transdisciplinary design studies that would produce Fourth Industrial Revolution Workforce Skills (4IRSkills), due to the sparsity in literature and implementation guidelines. This article discusses on the creation process of a Teaching and Learning Framework (TLF) for transdisciplinary design studies with a desktop-based Virtual Reality Learning Environment (VRLE) simulation of studio-based learning. The framework was created using a Selander’s Learning Design Sequence (LDS) with DT approach. The LDS helped the researcher to understand the processes of teaching and learning, especially on the affordances of various modes. The DT approach was used to facilitate the process of solving problems through the practice of empathy, reframing, prototyping, experimentation, testing, and redesign. A sequential explanatory mixed method was used, and the data were analyzed through inferential statistical analysis, thematic analysis and convergent coding matrix triangulation protocol. The findings indicated that the TLF with VRLE showed a positive and significant relationship with students' achievement of 4IRSkills. The TLF Design Process and Collaborative Design variables were positively correlated with students' 4IRSkills, while there was no correlation for the VRLE Representational Fidelity and Learner Interaction variables. In conclusion, the TLF with VRLE proves to be an effective and suitable method for guiding the implementation of pedagogies that teaches 4IRSkills at the tertiary level in fully online learning environments.

Survey on Multifaceted Impacts: Assessing the Integration of Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality(VR) in Education for Autistic Children

This project seeks to develop a groundbreaking Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR) learning platform tailored for autistic children, addressing their unique educational and social challenges. Featuring multi-user access for collaborative learning, the platform incorporates behavioral analysis to customize learning paths based on individual preferences and challenges. Immersive AR/VR environments simulate real-world scenarios, facilitating the practice of everyday life skills and social interactions in a controlled virtual space. Parental involvement is key, with features for progress tracking and guidance, aiming to empower autistic children with a personalized, inclusive, and supportive learning experience that bridges the gap between home and school. The user-friendly interface ensures accessibility, contributing to the educational empowerment of autistic children in an engaging virtual environment.

Validation of technology acceptance model for virtual reality usage in collaborative learning to enhance learner performance

ABSTRACT The growing influence of technology has prompted numerous scholars to explore how virtual reality (VR) affects performance. This study aims to validate the technology acceptance model (TAM) for VR in collaborative learning to enhance performance. We employed a questionnaire for data collection, distributed to 423 master’s students in China engaging in VR-based collaborative learning. We employed partial least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) to analyse the data. The findings reveal that perceived usefulness and ease of use positively influence the intention to use VR and engage in collaborative learning. Furthermore, the intention to use VR and collaborative learning positively affect learner performance. Notably, habit does not significantly moderate the relationship between the intention to use VR and learner performance. Therefore, the proposed model can serve as a valuable tool for educators and decision-makers, aiding in the development of strategies to encourage students to use VR for enhanced performance.

VR-Peas: a Virtual Reality PEdAgogical Scenarisation tool

ABSTRACT In this paper, we address the issue of the design and deployment of VR-oriented pedagogical scenarios by teachers as designers. To provide practical and theoretical solutions, we analyse the various existing models and tools for assisting teachers in the design and deployment of virtual reality learning environments (VRLEs). We identify a need for a model that covers the pedagogical needs of teachers, including the modelling of pedagogical structuring and the consideration of the specificities of the VR environment. Our main contributions are a pedagogical scenario model and the development of an editor called VR-PEAS (Virtual Reality PEdAgogical Scenarisation tool), which provides a solution that can support and help teacher-designers to design, adapt and reuse pedagogical scenarios oriented towards VR. We proposed a literature review to identify the main concepts of pedagogical scenario design and developed the computer solution according to an agile approach. To validate the basic concepts of our contribution and the impact of our implementation, we define a case study evaluation based on four different pedagogical situations using a qualitative method based on questionnaires. Our findings indicated that teachers could design VRLEs that were aligned with their pre-defined scenario and operate them successfully.

Effects of integrating a role‐playing game into a virtual reality‐based learning approach on students' perceptions of immersion, self‐efficacy, learning motivation and achievements

AbstractVirtual contexts play a crucial role in assisting students' learning. Researchers have taken advantage of the potential of immersive virtual reality (VR) for situating students in inaccessible places, and for engaging them in learning activities. Meanwhile, several previous studies have reported that, in VR‐based learning contexts, students' perception of immersion and learning motivation could be low owing to the lack of clear objectives and problem‐solving scenarios. On the other hand, digital game‐based learning is capable of enhancing students' engagement in a task. In this study, we designed a learning approach (namely RPG‐VR) by means of integrating a role‐playing game with VR technology to enhance students' science learning. Furthermore, a quasi‐experiment was conducted to evaluate the students' learning effectiveness via, respectively, providing the RPG‐VR learning approach and the conventional VR (called C‐VR) learning approach for the experimental and control groups. The experimental results indicated that this approach significantly enhanced the students' perceptions of immersion, self‐efficacy and extrinsic learning motivation, in comparison with the C‐VR learning approach. Specifically, students who learned with the RPG‐VR learning approach perceived more immersion in the engagement and the total immersion stages. This study contributes to existing knowledge of VR technology by providing that a digital role‐playing game could reinforce the main characteristics of VR‐based learning environments and enhance students' concentration on a learning task. However, no significant difference was found between the two groups in terms of promoting students' learning achievements, implying that more instructional assistance is needed to improve students' knowledge gains in VR‐based learning environments. Practitioner notesWhat is already known about this topic Virtual contexts play a crucial role in promoting students' learning performances. Virtual reality has been adopted for situating students in inaccessible places to promote their learning. A DGBL context provides students with opportunities for learning that emphasize immersion in practice, resulting in concept acquisition and skill development. What this paper adds An RPG‐VR learning approach was designed by means of integrating a role‐playing game with VR technology to enhance students' science learning. A virtual reality learning system with a role‐playing game was developed based on the proposed approach. This approach significantly enhanced the students' perceptions of self‐efficacy, extrinsic learning motivation and immersion, especially in the engagement and the total immersion stages. A digital role‐playing game could reinforce the main characteristics of VR‐based learning environments. Implications for practice and/or policy The RPG‐VR learning approach could be a notable reference for further research on VR‐based learning environments. More instructional assistance is needed to improve students' knowledge gains in VR‐based learning environments.

Assessing User Experiences in Virtual Reality Learning Environments

Assessing User Experiences in Virtual Reality Learning Environments

Evaluation of the novelty effect in immersive Virtual Reality learning experiences

In this study, the novelty effect or initial fascination with new technology is addressed in the context of an immersive Virtual Reality (iVR) experience. The novelty effect is a significant factor contributing to low learning outcomes during initial VR learning experiences. The aim of this research is to measure the effectiveness of a tutorial at mitigating the novelty effect of iVR learning environments among first-year undergraduate students. The iVR tutorial forms part of the iVR learning experience that involves the assembly of a personal computer, while learning the functions of the main components. 86 students participated in the study, divided into a Control group (without access to the tutorial) and a Treatment group (completing the tutorial). Both groups showed a clear bimodal distribution in previous knowledge, due to previous experience with learning topics, giving us an opportunity to compare tutorial effects with students of different backgrounds. Pre- and post-test questionnaires were used to evaluate the experience. The analysis included such factors as previous knowledge, usability, satisfaction, and learning outcomes categorized into remembering, understanding, and evaluation. The results demonstrated that the tutorial significantly increased overall satisfaction, reduced the learning time required for iVR mechanics, and improved levels of student understanding, and evaluation knowledge. Furthermore, the tutorial helped to homogenize group behavior, particularly benefiting students with less previous experience in the learning topic. However, it was noted that a small number of students still received low marks after the iVR experience, suggesting potential avenues for future research.

SONIA: an immersive customizable virtual reality system for the education and exploration of brain networks

While mastery of neuroanatomy is important for the investigation of the brain, there is an increasing interest in exploring the neural pathways to better understand the roles of neural circuitry in brain functions. To tackle the limitations of traditional 2D-display-based neuronavigation software in intuitively visualizing complex 3D anatomies, several virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) solutions have been proposed to facilitate neuroanatomical education. However, with the increasing knowledge on brain connectivity and the functioning of the sub-systems, there is still a lack of similar software solutions for the education and exploration of these topics, which demand more elaborate visualization and interaction strategies. To address this gap, we designed the immerSive custOmizable Neuro learnIng plAtform (SONIA), a novel, user-friendly VR software system with a multi-scale interaction paradigm that allowed flexible customization of learning materials. With both quantitative and qualitative evaluations through user studies, the proposed system was shown to have high usability, attractive visual design, and good educational value. As the first immersive system that integrated customizable design and detailed narratives of the brain sub-systems for the education of neuroanatomy and brain connectivity, SONIA showcased new potential directions and provided valuable insights regarding medical learning and exploration in VR.

The Effect of Virtual Reality Learning Media on Student Social Studies Learning Outcomes in Junior High Schools

Digital transformation in the Industrial Revolution 4.0 era demands learning activities that reduce the application of the lecture method and influences learning methods as well as the media used. Virtual reality technology permits students to be acquainted with live learning with objects seen directly. This study aims to determine the efficacy of virtual reality learning media in upgrading student learning outcomes in social studies classes. The population group was composed of 72 class VII students of Sekolah Menengah Pertama Negeri 30 Jakarta. This study uses experimental research techniques using experimental class and control class with pre-test and post-test. In this study, data analysis was carried out using inferential analysis using the t-test. According to the findings, the use of virtual reality learning media has a positive impact on student learning outcomes. Students can use immersive virtual reality to achieve better learning outcomes. Students are also more interested in learning and effortlessly understand and discover new knowledge and experiences. In addition, students find it more enjoyable to learn using virtual reality learning materials, which is virtual reality.
 Keywords: virtual reality, social studies, learning outcomes

An exploratory study of social presence and cognitive engagement association in a collaborative virtual reality learning environment

As the utilization of virtual reality (VR) in engineering education increases, researchers are increasingly focused on enhancing teaching and learning within VR environments. Cognitive engagement among the participants is a fundamental outcome in any learning environment, where social interaction often plays a pivotal role. This study contributes to VR teaching and learning research by investigating the association between social presence indicators and modes of cognitive engagement in a desktop collaborative virtual reality (VR) learning environment based on the social presence theory and the cognitive engagement definition of the Interactive-Constructive-Active-Passive framework. The study participants logged into the VR platform to collaboratively solve simulated engineering statics problems. The transcripts of students' interaction videos were coded based on codebooks for both social presence and cognitive engagement. The study revealed that social presence indicators are significantly associated with the three modes of cognitive engagement (active, constructive, and interactive). Additionally, interactive open communication emerged as the primary social presence element utilized by students during cognitive engagement with peers in the learning environment. This study's findings have implications for research and practice in enhancing students' cognitive engagement through their social interactions within VR learning environment.

Mathematical Modeling of Embodied Cognition and Personalized Learning in Interactive Virtual Reality: A Nonlinear Systems Approach

Abstract This study develops a mathematical model of embodied cognition integrated with personalized learning within an interactive Virtual Reality (VR) environment, employing nonlinear systems theory to optimize educational outcomes. The study mathematically formulates the interactions between learners’ cognitive states, bodily actions, and environmental inputs by applying state-space models and multi-modal data analysis. The framework incorporates real-time affective feedback and dynamic adjustment mechanisms, improving mental performance and reducing cognitive load. A randomized controlled trial validates the model, demonstrating significant enhancements in learning satisfaction and knowledge retention. This research provides a novel quantitative basis for integrating nonlinear mathematical methods into the design and optimization of personalized learning systems in VR.

Enhanced Soccer Training Simulation Using Progressive Wasserstein GAN and Termite Life Cycle Optimization in Virtual Reality

Virtual Reality (VR) offers the possibility of creating engaging and intensive training programs to enhance sports performance. Football, a widely popular sport worldwide, attracts millions of spectators. However, the physical demands and risks inherent in the game necessitate the creation of a training environment immune to external influences, minimizing sports-related injuries while enhancing player immersion. Existing training methods are affected by external factors like, weather, injuries, and space limitations, hindering effectiveness and skill development. To overcome these issues, in this research, enhanced soccer training simulation using Progressive Wasserstein GAN and Termite Life Cycle Optimization in Virtual Reality (PWGAN-TLCOA-ST-VRT) are proposed. This study begins by analyzing the fundamental features of computer-generated soccer training techniques and introduces the implementation of VRT in football training via PWGAN technology. The goal is to develop virtual systems resilient to external factors and provide theoretical support for the expansion of virtual football sports software. By overcoming constraints like, weather, player injuries, space limitations, and financial constraints, the proposed approach aims to enhance training effectiveness, teaching techniques, and football skill development. Software tools like Poser 8.0, 3Ds MAX and EON Studio are introduced for system development. Evaluation of the proposed PWGAN-TLCOA-ST-VRT method is examined using performance metrics including, precision, accuracy, F1-score, recall, specificity, error rate, computation time, and Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis. The proposed PWGAN-TLCOA-ST-VRT technique achieves significant improvements compared to existing approaches like, Analysis of the application of virtual reality technology in football training (AI-ST-VRT), Cortex VR: Immersive analysis and training of cognitive executive functions of soccer players using VR and machine learning, Predict the value of football players using FIFA video game data and machine learning techniques (MLR-ST-VRT)

Experiencing COVID-19 Through the Patient Lens to Promote Empathy: Pilot Testing a Virtual Reality Learning Opportunity.

Understanding the patient's experience with COVID-19 was essential to providing high-quality, person-centered care during the pandemic. Having empathy or being able to understand and respond to the patient's experience may lead to improved outcomes for both patients and clinicians. There is mixed evidence about how best to teach empathy, particularly related to promoting empathy during COVID-19. Literature suggests that virtual reality may be effective in empathy-related education. In collaboration with four patient partners with lived experience, a 360° VR video was developed reflecting their stories and interactions with the healthcare system. The aim of this study was to pilot test the video with interprofessional healthcare providers (HPs) to explore acceptability and utility, while also seeking input on opportunities for improvement. Eleven HPs reviewed the video and participated in one of three focus groups. Focus group data were analyzed using thematic analysis. Data suggest that video content is acceptable and useful in promoting a better understanding of the patient's experience. Building on these encouraging findings, additional iterations of videos to promote empathy will be developed and tested.

A Comprehensive Literature Review on the Emerging Trends in Educational Research concerning E-learning

This research is a literature review study that intends to determine trends in the use of E-learning for education, The method used is a literature study method where researchers search literature from 2018 to 2023 from various articles that have been published and journals indexed by Scopus, Sinta, Wos, Ebsco, Copernicus and Google Scholar. The result of this study is that currently the use of learning media has changed which previously only used blog-based media and changed to Virtual reality and is currently most widely used as a learning media. This can make it easier for learners to visualize learning. The conclusion obtained is that the use of e-learning media can increase learning value and can facilitate the understanding of lessons. The trend that is changing today is to use Virtual reality-based learning media. Researchers hope that this article will have a significant impact on learning and teaching staff can use learning media that are currently trending. The use of Virtual reality learning media makes it easier for students to understand visual learning and in terms of cost can be more efficient.