Super-elastic bone staples have emerged as a safe and effective alternative for internal fixation. Nevertheless, several biomechanical aspects of super-elastic staples are still unclear and require further exploration. Within this context, this study presents a combined experimental and computational approach to investigate the mechanical characteristics of super-elastic staples. Two commercially available staples with distinct geometry, characterized by two and four legs, respectively, were examined. Experimental four-point bending tests were conducted to evaluate staple performance in terms of generated forces. Subsequently, a finite element-based calibration procedure was developed to capture the unique super-elastic behavior of the staple materials. Finally, a virtual bench testing framework was implemented to separate the effect of geometry from that of the material characteristics on the mechanical properties of the devices, including generated force, strain distribution, and fatigue behavior. The experimental tests indicated differences in the force vs. displacement curves between staples. The material calibration procedure revealed marked differences in the super-elastic properties of the materials employed in staple 1 and staple 2. The results obtained from the virtual bench testing framework have showed that both geometric features and material characteristics had a substantial impact on the mechanical properties of the device, especially on the generated force, whereas their effect on strain distribution and fatigue behavior was comparatively less pronounced. To conclude, this study advances the biomechanical understanding of Nitinol super-elastic staples by separately investigating the impact of geometry and material characteristics on the mechanical properties of two commercially available devices.