Sum-frequency Vibrational Spectra Research Articles

Surface populations as a model for the distance-dependence of the interfacial refractive index.

Vibrational sum frequency spectra provide information about interfaces that is sensitive to the orientation of molecules, their electronic environment, and the local electric fields. Here, we use molecular dynamics simulations in order to study a surfactant, para-cyanophenol, at the air-water interface. The volume fractions of water and the organic surfactant are considered at various points over the nanometer-scale region in a Lorentz-Lorenz model. We find that the calculated ratios of nonlinear susceptibility tensor elements are in agreement with experimental data only when this depth profile was considered. We also use these data to evaluate the ratio of the C-N hyperpolarizability tensor elements in the interfacial region.

Comparative Thermodynamic and Structural Analysis of Polyfluorinated Dodecylphosphonic Acid Adsorption to Distilled and River Water Interfaces.

As concerns rise about the health risks posed by per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in the environment, there is a need to understand how these pollutants accumulate at environmental interfaces. Untangling the details of molecular adsorption, particularly when there are potential interactions with other molecules in environmental systems, can obscure the ability to focus on a particular contaminant with molecular specificity. Often adsorption studies of environmental interfaces require a reductionist approach, where laboratory experiments may not be fully tractable to environmental systems. In this work, we study polyfluorinated dodecylphosphonic acid (F21-DDPA) at the aqueous surfaces of distilled water (the most reduced "environmental" surface) and river water to explore the use of vibrational sum-frequency (VSF) spectroscopy as an experimental probe of fluorinated contaminants at natural environmental surfaces. We demonstrate how VSF spectroscopy offers advantages over nonspecific surface tension measurements when measuring PFAS adsorption isotherms at river water surfaces. VSF spectra of the C-F stretching region selectively probe the presence of F21-DDPA and can be used to extract meaningful structural insights and calculate surface concentrations, even at the complex river water surface. This study highlights the potential for VSF spectroscopy to be developed as a probe of fluorinated contaminants at natural environmental interfaces.

Twist and Stretch: Assignment and Surface Charge Sensitivity of a Water Combination Band and Its Implications for Vibrational Sum Frequency Spectra Interpretations.

The vibrational spectrum of water at hydrophobic/hydrophilic interfaces is crucial to understanding complex surface chemistry phenomena. Vibrational sum frequency (VSF) spectroscopy is a valuable nonlinear spectroscopic technique for exploring the details of vibrational spectra of molecules at surfaces. However, spectral assignments and analysis of VSF spectra are often more nuanced than in linear spectroscopy. This study is aimed at understanding the source of the broad VSF signal in the oil-water surface water spectrum at energies slightly higher than traditionally examined, beyond the unbound free OH oscillator of surface water molecules. Analyzing isotopic dilutions of the aqueous solvent with VSF spectroscopy, we demonstrate that this signal is due to a combination band of water stretch and libration motions. The spectral characteristics of this band are found to be highly sensitive to the sign and magnitude of the surface charge induced by adsorption of both anionic and cationic surfactants. The results have implications for VSF measurements of the C-H stretching vibrations of various adsorbates when studied with D2O as the aqueous solvent. Because the vibrational signal from the water combination band is dependent on surface charge, it is imperative to include the presence of the combination band when fitting surface spectra.

Assessing the Molecular Specificity and Orientation Sensitivity of Infrared, Raman, and Vibrational Sum-Frequency Spectra

Linear programming was used to assess the ability of polarized infrared absorption, Raman scattering, and visible–infrared sum-frequency generation to correctly identify the composition of a mixture of molecules adsorbed onto a surface in four scenarios. The first two scenarios consisted of a distribution of species where the polarity of the orientation distribution is known, both with and without consideration of an arbitrary scaling factor between candidate spectra and the observed spectra of the mixture. The final two scenarios have repeated the tests, but assuming that the polarity of the orientation is unknown, so the symmetry-breaking attributes of the second-order nonlinear technique are required. The results indicate that polarized Raman spectra are more sensitive to orientation and molecular identity than the other techniques. However, further analysis reveals that this sensitivity is not due to the high-order angle dependence of Raman, but is instead attributed to the number of unique projections that can be measured in a polarized Raman experiment.

High-resolution phase-sensitive sum frequency generation spectroscopy by time-domain ptychography

We demonstrate that time-domain ptychography, when applied to a set of broadband vibrational sum frequency spectra, reconstructs amplitude and phase of the vibrational free induction decay from an interfacial sample with a resolution that is independent of up-converting pulse bandwidth and spectrometer resolution. These important improvements require no modifications to most standard homodyne setups, and the method is applicable to other coherent homodyne spectroscopies such as coherent anti-Stokes Raman spectroscopy and transient grating spectroscopy.

Coming to Order: Adsorption and Structure of Nonionic Polymer at the Oil/Water Interface as Influenced by Cationic and Anionic Surfactants.

Polymer-surfactant mixtures are versatile chemical systems because of their ability to form a variety of complexes both in bulk solution and at surfaces. The adsorption and structure of polymer-surfactant complexes at the oil/water interface define their use surface chemistry applications. Previous studies have investigated the interactions between charged polyelectrolytes and surfactants; however, a similar level of insight into the interfacial behavior of nonionic polymers in mixed systems is lacking. The study herein uses vibrational sum frequency (VSF) spectroscopy to elucidate the molecular details of nonionic polyacrylamide (PAM) adsorption to the oil/water interface in the presence of surfactant. The polymer's adsorption and conformational structure at the interface is investigated as it interacts with cationic and anionic surfactants. Where the polymer will not adsorb to the interface on its own in solution, the presence of either cationic or anionic surfactant causes favorable adsorption of the polymer to the oil/water interface. VSF spectra indicate that the cationic surfactant interacts with PAM at the interface through charge-dipole interactions to induce conformational ordering of the polymer backbone. However, conformational ordering of polymer is not induced at the interface when anionic surfactant is present.

Cooperative Adsorption of Trehalose to DPPC Monolayers at the Water-Air Interface Studied with Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation.

A combination of surface tension, surface-specific vibrational spectroscopy, and differential scanning calorimetry experiments was performed to examine the ability of lipid films to enrich interfacial organic content by attracting soluble, neutral saccharides from bulk aqueous solution. This "cooperative adsorption" hypothesis has been proposed as a possible source of the high organic fractions found in sea spray aerosols and is believed to be responsible for cryoprotection in some organisms. Experiments described in this work show that the neutral disaccharide trehalose (Tre) is drawn to lipid films composed of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), a saturated lipid that is a major component of most eukaryotic cells. The effects of Tre on DPPC monolayer structure and organization were tested with tightly packed monolayers in the two-dimensional solid phase (40 Å2/molecule) and more expanded monolayers in the two-dimensional liquid condensed phase (55 Å2/molecule). Surface tension data show that DPPC monolayer behavior remains largely unchanged until Tre bulk concentrations are sufficiently high (≥50 mM). In contrast, surface-specific vibrational sum frequency spectra show that when Tre bulk concentrations are ≥10 mM, DPPC monolayers in their liquid condensed state (55 Å2/molecule) became more ordered, implying relatively strong noncovalent interactions between the two species. Tre also induces changes in DPPC bilayer behavior as evidenced by a gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transition temperature that increases with increasing Tre concentration. This result suggests that Tre associates with the DPPC headgroups in very specific ways leading to partial dehydration. Together, these results support the cooperative adsorption mechanism under some circumstances, namely, that there is a minimum aqueous phase Tre concentration required to induce observable structural changes in a lipid monolayer and that these effects are most pronounced with DPPC monolayers in their liquid condensed state compared to those of a tightly packed two-dimensional solid.

Plasmonic Effects of Au Nanoparticles on the Vibrational Sum Frequency Spectrum of 4-Nitrothiophenol

Vibrational sum frequency spectra (vSFS) of 4-nitrothiophenol (4-NTP) have been utilized to study plasmonic effects arising from its interaction with gold nanoparticles (Au NPs). To this end three systems have been studied: 4-NTP adsorbed on deposited Au nanoparticles, a self-assembled monolayer of 4-NTP on flat Au with dispersed Au NPs atop and, as reference, a self-assembled monolayer of 4-NTP. For 4-NTP on 50 and 80 nm Au NPs an enhancement of the SF intensity due to plasmonic effects by less than 1 order of magnitude is inferred in comparison to the monolayer system after taking the particle density into account. The addition of Au NPs to the monolayer system on flat Au also selectively enhances the response to an in-plane field component of the 532 nm upconversion light.

Vibrational spectra of dissociatively adsorbed D2O on Al-terminated α-Al2O3(0001) surfaces from ab initio molecular dynamics.

Water can adsorb molecularly or dissociatively onto different sites of metal oxide surfaces. These adsorption sites can be disentangled using surface-sensitive vibrational spectroscopy. Here, we model Vibrational Sum Frequency (VSF) spectra for various forms of dissociated, deuterated water on a reconstructed, Al-terminated α-Al2O3(0001) surface at submonolayer coverages (the so-called 1-2, 1-4, and 1-4' modes). Using an efficient scheme based on velocity-velocity autocorrelation functions, we go beyond previous normal mode analyses by including anharmonicity, mode coupling, and thermal surface motion in the framework of ab initio molecular dynamics. In this way, we calculate vibrational density of states curves, infrared, and VSF spectra. Comparing computed VSF spectra with measured ones, we find that relative frequencies of resonances are in quite good agreement and linewidths are reasonably well represented, while VSF intensities coincide not well. We argue that intensities are sensitively affected by local interactions and thermal fluctuations, even at such low coverage, while absolute peak positions strongly depend on the choice of the electronic structure method and on the appropriate inclusion of anharmonicity.

Resolving the chemical identity of H2SO4 derived anions on Pt(111) electrodes: they're sulfate.

Understanding how electrolyte composition controls electrocatalytic reactions requires molecular-level insight into electrode/electrolyte interaction. Perhaps the most basic aspect of this interaction, the speciation of the interfacial ion, is often controversial for even relatively simple systems. For example, for Pt(111) in 0.5 M H2SO4 it has long been debated whether the adsorbed anion is SO42-, HSO4- or an H3O+SO42- ion pair. Here we apply interface-specific vibrational sum frequency (VSF) spectroscopy and theory to this problem and perform an isotope exchange study: we collect VSF spectra of Pt(111) in H2SO4(H2O) and D2SO4(D2O) as a function of bias and show that at all potentials they are identical. This is the most direct spectroscopic evidence to date that SO42- is the dominant adsorbate, despite the fact that at 0.5 M H2SO4 bulk solution is dominated by HSO4-. This approach is based on the unique selection rule of the VSF spectroscopy and thus offers a new way of accessing general electrode/electrolyte interaction in electrocatalysis.

Communication: Vibrational sum-frequency spectrum of the air-water interface, revisited.

Before 2015, heterodyne-detected sum-frequency-generation experiments on the air-water interface showed the presence of a positive feature at low frequency in the imaginary part of the susceptibility. However, three very recent experiments indicate that this positive feature is in fact absent. Armed with a better understanding, developed by others, of how to calculate sum-frequency spectra, we recalculate the spectrum and find good agreement with these new experiments. In addition, we provide a revised interpretation of the spectrum.

Unusual Structure and Dynamics at Silica/Methanol and Silica/Ethanol Interfaces--A Molecular Dynamics and Nonlinear Optical Study.

Vibrational sum frequency (VSF) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations are used to investigate ethanol-silica and methanol-silica interfaces. We describe the subtle differences in molecular organization that result in the observed differences in the VSF spectra for methanol and ethanol at the alcohol-silica interface. Alcohol molecules hydrogen-bonded to the silica surface induce orientational opposition in an adjacent low-population region, which implies VSF signal reduction. This low population region is essentially of zero density in the ethanol system, implying less signal cancelation. Simulated silica defect sites increase the population of this region in both systems. Interestingly, the induced orientation in this region influences subsequent molecular orientation only in the ethanol-silica system, preserving the interfacial anisotropy. These effects suggest a stronger VSF response from the ethanol-silica system versus the methanol-silica system, where more methanol molecules reside in the low-population region, and this region does not induce order in subsequent solvent layers.

Solvation station: microsolvation for modeling vibrational sum-frequency spectra of acids at aqueous interfaces.

Vibrational sum-frequency spectra of a pair of poly(methacrylic acid) isomers at an oil/water interface and glutaric acid at an air/water interface were calculated in the carbonyl stretching region. Orientational, conformational, and solvation information was determined using classical molecular dynamics (MD), while second-order susceptibility vibrational response tensors were determined for a set of density functional theory (DFT) structures. The DFT structures were microsolvated with water molecules corresponding to the major solvation states present in the MD calculations. The inclusion of the microsolvating waters incorporates solvation effects important to the carboxylic acid stretching modes in the studied spectral region. The calculated spectra strongly agree with experimental spectra when a cutoff of 1.975 Å is used to define a hydrogen bond in the MD trajectories. With the chosen cutoff, the most common solvation state of the carboxylic acid moieties involves a single hydrogen bond to the carbonyl oxygen and a single hydrogen bond to the carboxylic acid hydrogen. The sensitivity of the spectra to the hydrogen bond cutoff definition and the included DFT structures was investigated. Moderate changes in the relative intensities of the contributing peaks were found in both cases. Shortening the hydrogen bond cutoff definition predictably leads to a decrease in the relative intensity of peaks corresponding to well-solvated structures, while altering the set of DFT solvation structures results in more complex behavior that is dependent on the specific structures included.

Twist and turn: effect of stereoconfiguration on the interfacial assembly of polyelectrolytes.

Understanding the conditions that promote the adsorption, assembly, and accumulation of charged macromolecules at the interface between aqueous and hydrophobic liquids is important to a multitude of biological, environmental, and industrial processes. Here, the oil-water interfacial behavior of stereoisomers of polymethacrylic acid (PMA), a model system for both naturally occurring and synthetic polyelectrolytes, is investigated with a combination of vibrational sum-frequency (VSF) spectroscopy, surface tension, and computations. Syndiotactic and isotactic isomers both show rapid adsorption to the oil-water interface with a net orientation indicative of a high degree of ordering. The stereoconfiguration is found to affect whether only a single layer or multiple layers assemble at the interface. Surface tension measurements show additional adsorption for syndiotactic PMA over time. The additional layers do not contribute to the VSF spectrum indicating disorder in all but the initial layer. The isotactic isomer shows no evidence of accumulation at the interface beyond the single ordered layer. Molecular dynamics calculations show marked differences between the two isomers in the orientation of their substituent groups at the interface. The hydrophilic and hydrophobic moieties in the isotactic isomer are easily partitioned to the water and oil phases, respectively, whereas a fair portion of hydrophobic groups remain in the water phase for the syndiotactic PMA. The available hydrophobic contacts in the water phase at the interface are credited with allowing further adsorption.

Doubling down: delving into the details of diacid adsorption at aqueous surfaces.

The behavior of complex interfacial systems is central to an ever-increasing number of applications. Vibrational sum frequency (VSF) spectroscopy is a powerful technique for obtaining surface specific structural information. The coherent nature of VSF that provides surface specificity, however, also creates difficulty in spectral interpretation especially as the system complexity increases. Computations of VSF spectra shed light on the molecular level source of the experimental VSF signal, allowing for the analysis of more complicated systems. Unfortunately, the majority of calculations of VSF spectra look at the response of the solvent or of rigid molecules and therefore often poorly reflect the experimental environment of most VSF spectroscopic measurements. In this work, flexible solute molecules at interfaces are investigated by doubling down, obtaining and comparing experimental and theoretical spectra, to determine a more accurate computational treatment. The surface behavior and VSF spectra of glutaric acid and adipic acid at the air/water interface are determined experimentally and calculated using a combination of classical molecular dynamics and density functional theory. Both diacids are found to be surface active. At high concentrations, glutaric acid forms dimers altering its VSF response and acidic properties. Calculated VSF spectra are found to be sensitive to vibrational mode frequencies, with ordering and spacing affecting relative intensities, as well as molecular conformation. A proper description requires consideration of multiple conformers and anharmonic effects on the molecular vibrational energies.

Intrinsic chirality and prochirality at Air/R-(+)- and S-(-)-limonene interfaces: spectral signatures with interference chiral sum-frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy.

We report in this work detailed measurements of the chiral and achiral sum-frequency vibrational spectra in the C-H stretching vibration region (2800-3050 cm(-1)) of the air/liquid interfaces of R-(+)-limonene and S-(-)-limonene, using the recently developed high-resolution broadband sum-frequency generation vibrational spectroscopy (HR-BB-SFG-VS). The achiral SFG spectra of R-limonene and S-limonene, as well as the RS racemic mixture (50/50 equal amount mixture), show that the corresponding molecular groups of the R and S enantiomers are with the same interfacial orientations. The interference chiral SFG spectra of the limonene enantiomers exhibit a spectral signature from the chiral response of the Cα-H stretching mode, and a spectral signature from the prochiral response of the CH(2) asymmetric stretching mode, respectively. The chiral spectral feature of the Cα-H stretching mode changes sign from R-(+)-limonene to S-(-)-limonene surfaces, and disappears for the RS racemic mixture surface. While the prochiral spectral feature of the CH(2) asymmetric stretching mode is the same for R-(+)-limonene and S-(-)-limonene surfaces, and also surprisingly remains the same for the RS racemic mixture surface. Therefore, the structures of the R-(+)-limonene and the S-(-)-limonene at the liquid interfaces are nevertheless not mirror images to each other, even though the corresponding groups have the same tilt angle from the interfacial normal, i.e., the R-(+)-limonene and the S-(-)-limonene at the surface are diastereomeric instead of enantiomeric. These results provide detailed information in understanding the structure and chirality of molecular interfaces and demonstrate the sensitivity and potential of SFG-VS as a unique spectroscopic tool for chirality characterization and chiral recognition at the molecular interface.

Why Fluorination of the Polar Heads Reverses the Positive Sign of the Dipole Potential of Langmuir Monolayers: A Vibrational Sum Frequency Spectroscopic Study

Natural nonionic amphiphiles forming monolayers, bilayers, micelles, or biomembranes create a positive dipole potential at the boundary with water. In a series of papers we have reported on Langmuir monolayers with CF3 terminals of the polar heads, which show a negative surface dipole potential ΔV (Petrov , J. G.; Andreeva, T. D.; Kurt, D. K.; Möhwald, H. J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109, 14102). Here we use vibrational sum frequency spectroscopy (SF) to study the origin of the opposite ΔV signs of Langmuir films of CH3(CH2)20COCH2CH3 (ethyl ether, EE) and CH3(CH2)20COCH2CF3 (fluorinated ethyl ether, FEE). The vibrational sum frequency spectra are recorded at the same film density of the S-phase of the EE and FEE monolayers and analyzed in the spectral regions of OH, COC, CH3, and CF3 stretching vibrations because these functional groups could be responsible for the different dipole potentials. We compare the rearrangement of the pure water surface by EE and FEE monolayers and the conformations of EE and FEE polar heads. The analysis is performed according to the three-capacitor model of the dipole potential of Langmuir monolayers (Demchak, R. T.; Fort, T., Jr. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 1974, 46, 191). The results show that reversal of the ΔV sign caused by fluorination of the polar heads originates from the upward-oriented CF3 terminals of the FEE heads, whose negative normal dipole moment component determines the negative dipole potential of the FEE monolayer.

Vibrational Sum-Frequency Spectrum of the Water Bend at the Air/Water Interface

We present the spectrum of the water bend vibrational mode (ν2) at the air/water interface measured using vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG). The blue-shift of the ν2 frequency from the gas phase value reports on the hydrogen bonding in the interfacial region. The ν2 line shape of surface water is inhomogeneously broadened and structured. The dominant feature is the least blue-shifted and relatively narrow Lorenztian, tentatively assigned to water molecules straddling the interface, those with free OH bonds. This feature appears at different frequencies in the SFG spectra recorded using different polarization combinations (SSP and PPP for SFG-visible-IR), pointing to possible orientational inhomogeneity. Weaker features are observed at higher frequencies, tentatively assigned to fully H-bonded water molecules. Small but measurable changes of the line shape with temperature are observed in the 0 to +20 °C range.

Ambiguities in surface nonlinear spectroscopy calculations

Recent molecular simulations of liquid interfaces yield surface sum-frequency vibrational spectra that can be highly sensitive to the seemingly-arbitrary choice of molecular center in the calculation method. We show that the ambiguity arises because widely-used approaches, focusing exclusively on electric-dipole contributions from the surface, neglect coordinate-dependent quadrupole-order contributions of comparable magnitude from the bulk. The correct calculation includes both surface and bulk responses. With a judicious choice of molecular center, however, it may be possible to minimize the bulk contribution, allowing the surface-only calculation to produce a reasonably accurate spectrum. We use water as an example to elucidate the problem.

Interpretation of the water surface vibrational sum-frequency spectrum

We propose a novel interpretation of the water liquid-vapor interface vibrational sum-frequency (VSF) spectrum in terms of hydrogen-bonding classes. Unlike an absorption spectrum, the VSF signal can be considered as a sum of signed contributions from different hydrogen-bonded species in the sample. We show that the recently observed positive feature at low frequency, in the imaginary part of the signal, is a result of cancellation between the positive contributions from four-hydrogen-bonded molecules and negative contributions from those molecules with one or two broken hydrogen bonds. Spectral densities for each of these subgroups span the entire relevant spectral range. Three-body interactions within our newly developed E3B water simulation model prove to be critical in describing the proper balance between different hydrogen-bonded species, as (two-body) SPC/E, TIP4P, and TIP4P/2005 models fail to reproduce the positive feature. The results clarify the molecular origin of the VSF signal, and highlight the importance of many-body interactions for water in heterogeneous situations.