BOOK REVIEWS115 passing in value this first part and using more effectively Oriental literature . Eligius M. Buytaert, O.F.M. The Franciscan Institute, St. Bonaventure, N. Y. Palrologie. Leben, Schriften und Lehre der Kirchenvaeler by Berthold Altaner, second edit. Freiburg: Herder Verlag 1950. Pp. XX-492. The first German edition of this work appeared in 1938. How well it was received is shown by the fact it was translated into Italian in 1940 and 1944, into French in 1941, into Spanish in 1944 and 1949, and into Hungarian in 1947. From this second German edition there is already an Italian and an English (New York) translation announced. This edition is bigger than the first one, though not so much as insinuated by the difference in pages (the first edit, had XIX-353 pages); in the new edition a somewhat bigger print is used. The plan remained the same; thirteen "Fathers" are added: Agathangelus, Aprihgius, Basil of Seleucia, Gennadius of Constantinople, Pamphilus an author of the VI century, Theodore of Raithu and Timothy of Jerusalem, — all authors forgotten in the first edition; as also the Anonymus of the Vita Charitonis, Eutropius, Hypatius of Ephesus, Leontius of Jerusalem, Macarius or Symeon of Mesopotamia and the exegete Symmachus, — authors more recently discovered. The main difference between the editions lies in the bibliography; it is now up to date, i.e. generally up to the summer of 1949. In the text small additions are made intended to make understanding easier; small corrections too, following the remarks made for the earlier editions and taking into account recent research. Of course, the additions and corrections respecting authors or problems better studied during the last years are greater . The description of persons and writings, though short, is usually clear; with sound judgment Altaner exposes the problems and the solutions given; the choice of the literature is excellent; the references already present in the first German edition are checked, and thus quite a few faults disappeared; we are especially glad to state that the retrogressive evolution of the corrected (?) Italian edition disappeared too. Surely, not everything is perfect: in the references there are still misprints , which is rather unavoidable in the system adopted by the author; further, it is not clear for instance how Altaner reconciles the fact that Eustathius of Antioch died in 337 and nevertheless wrote the Adversus Pholinum; it is not clear either, why Acacius of Cesárea, Eusebius and Nemesius of Emesa are listed in a chapter on the Ante-Nicene Fathers which is occupied with historical work; why Nemesius of Emesa comes under the heading "Disciples and successors of Eusebius of Cesárea": it is true, he- is a successor of Eusebius of Emesa in the sense he too was a bishop of Emesa ;but we do not see any other relation between Eusebius and Nemesius of Emesa,, and none at all between Eusebius of Cesárea and Nemesius. And so forth. This Palrologie is a valuable work, an aid for both learner and specialist . Eligius M. Buytaert, O.F.M. The Franciscan Institute, St. Bonaventure, N. Y. ...
Read full abstract