Bitonic st-orderings for st-planar graphs were introduced as a method to cope with several graph drawing problems. Notably, they have been used to obtain the best-known upper bound on the number of bends for upward planar polyline drawings with at most one bend per edge in polynomial area. For an st-planar graph that does not admit a bitonic st-ordering, one may split certain edges such that for the resulting graph such an ordering exists. Since each split is interpreted as a bend, one is usually interested in splitting as few edges as possible. While this optimization problem admits a linear-time algorithm in the fixed embedding setting, it remains open in the variable embedding setting. We close this gap in the literature by providing a linear-time algorithm that optimizes over all embeddings of the input st-planar graph. The best-known lower bound on the number of required splits of an st-planar graph with n vertices is n-3. However, it is possible to compute a bitonic st-ordering without any split for the st-planar graph obtained by reversing the orientation of all edges. In terms of upward planar polyline drawings in polynomial area, the former translates into n-3 bends, while the latter into no bends. We show that this idea cannot always be exploited by describing an st-planar graph that needs at least n-5 splits in both orientations. We provide analogous bounds for graphs with small degree. Finally, we further investigate the relationship between splits in bitonic st-orderings and bends in upward planar polyline drawings with polynomial area, by providing bounds on the number of bends in such drawings.