We have demonstrated a systematic trend in the electrocatalytic activity for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and its correlations with transition-metal type, structural order, and electrical conductivity. The materials studied in this work, Ca3FeMn2O8 (CaFe1/3Mn2/3O3-1/3), Ca3Fe1.5Mn1.5O8, and Ca3Fe2MnO8, belong to the family of oxygen-deficient perovskites and show a gradual increase in the ordering of oxygen vacancies. Ca3FeMn2O8 (CaFe1/3Mn2/3O3-1/3) contains randomly distributed oxygen vacancies, which begin to order in Ca3Fe1.5Mn1.5O8, and are fully ordered in Ca3Fe2MnO8. The gradual increase in the structural order is associated with a systematic enhancement of the electrocatalytic activity for HER in acidic conditions, Ca3FeMn2O8 < Ca3Fe1.5Mn1.5O8 < Ca3Fe2MnO8. While the improvement of the HER activity is also associated with an increase in the Fe content, we have shown that the type of structural order plays a more important role. We demonstrated this effect by control experiments on an analogous material where all Mn was substituted by Fe, leading to a different type of structural order and showing an inferior HER activity compared to the above three materials. Furthermore, electrical conductivity studies in a wide range of temperatures, 25-800 °C, indicate that the trend in the electrical conductivity is the same as that of the HER activity. These findings reveal several important structure-property relationships and highlight the importance of synergistic effects in enhancing the electrocatalytic properties.