The paper describes experimental stamping punch production from the view machinability and quality of stamping punch active surfaces. The tin car-body stamping punch has been chosen as a subject of experimental work. Two unconventional materials such as Textit J and Fibroflex 5 have been chosen for stamping punch. Milling strategies have been proposed, optimized and verified using CAM software SolidCAM considering the maximum Scallop Height. The final surface quality on selected areas of stamping punch shaped surface has been evaluated by surface roughness parameters Ra and Rz. These have been compared to Scallop Height set in CAM software. Manufactured areas on shaped surface were optically evaluated as well.