Ultrasonic Welding Of Thermoplastic Composites Research Articles

On the use of a rounded sonotrode for the welding of thermoplastic composites

Continuous ultrasonic welding is an attractive welding technique for thermoplastic composite structures. In this process, a metallic sonotrode connected to a piezoelectric transducer and to a press moves along the parts to be welded applying ultrasonic vibrations and a static welding force on the welding overlap. Thus far, the research carried out on this topic makes use of sonotrodes featuring a flat contact surface with the parts to be welded, which limits the use of the process to the welding of overlaps with no curvature in the welding direction. With the final aim of assessing whether this process can also be applied to curved structures, this paper explores the feasibility of using a rounded sonotrode for continuous ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites. The main conclusions drawn from the results obtained in this research is that it is indeed possible to continuously weld thermoplastic composite panels with a rounded sonotrode and that high-quality welds can be obtained from such a process. Furthermore, the use of a rounded sonotrode has the positive effect of lowering the temperatures at the welding interface as well as the temperatures within the adherends. On the other hand, the use of such sonotrode leads to a decreased, although still competitive, welding speed and, potentially, an increased welding force, thereby setting boundary conditions that need to be considered for each specific application.

The effects of misaligned adherends on static ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

Ultrasonic welding is a promising joining technique for thermoplastic composite parts. On the way towards upscaling and industrialisation of this technology, it is crucial to understanding how it is affected by manufacturing tolerances. The objective of the research presented in this paper was to investigate the influence that misaligned adherends have on static ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites. Different angles were created by changing the clamping configuration. The results showed that increasing the angle between adherends decreases the power consumed and increases the process time while decreasing the weld uniformity and increasing the risk of overheating. These effects were associated to the impact of the different clamping configurations on the cyclic strain in the energy director and adherends during the welding process. Decreasing the top adherends bending stiffness by increasing the clamping distance was found to significantly reduce the adverse effects of adherend misalignment on weld quality.

A Study on Through-the-Thickness Heating in Continuous Ultrasonic Welding of Thermoplastic Composites.

Continuous ultrasonic welding is a promising technique for joining thermoplastic composites structures together. The aim of this study was to gain further insight into what causes higher through-the-thickness heating in continuous ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites as compared to the static process. Thermocouples were used to measure temperature evolutions at the welding interface and within the adherends. To understand the mechanisms causing the observed temperature behaviours, the results were compared to temperature measurements from an equivalent static welding process and to the predictions from a simplified heat transfer model. Despite the significantly higher temperatures measured at the welding interface for the continuous process, viscoelastic bulk heat generation and not thermal conduction from the interface was identified as the main cause of higher through-the-thickness heating in the top adherend. Interestingly the top adherend seemed to absorb most of the vibrational energy in the continuous process as opposed to a more balanced energy share between the top and bottom adherend in the static process. Finally, the higher temperatures at the welding interface in continuous ultrasonic welding were attributed to pre-heating of the energy director due to the vibrations being transmitted downstream of the sonotrode, to reduced squeeze-flow of energy director due to the larger adherend size, and to heat flux originating downstream as the welding process continues.

On differences and similarities between static and continuous ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

Continuous ultrasonic welding is a promising high-speed and energy-efficient joining method for thermoplastic composite structures. Our aim was to identify and understand differences between the static and continuous ultrasonic welding process for thermoplastic composites. In particular, melting of the interface, consumed power and energy density, temperature evolution at the weld interface, and optimum welding conditions for both types of processes were investigated. This was done for three combinations of welding force and vibrational amplitude, parameters which are known to have a significant effect in both welding processes. Our results showed that for the continuous process the amount of non-welded area under the sonotrode remains constant, while for the static process the amount of non-welded area gradually decreases to zero. Additionally, the optimum vibration times and welding speeds in both processes are similar.

Advances in Ultrasonic Welding of Thermoplastic Composites: A Review.

The ultrasonic welding (UW) technique is an ultra-fast joining process, and it is used to join thermoplastic composite structures, and provides an excellent bonding strength. It is more cost-efficient as opposed to the conventional adhesive, mechanical and other joining methods. This review paper presents the detailed progress made by the scientific and research community to date in the direction of the UW of thermoplastic composites. The focus of this paper is to review the recent development of the ultrasonic welding technique for thermoplastic composites to thermoplastic composites, and to dissimilar materials. Different ultrasonic welding modes and their processing parameters, namely, weld time, weld pressure, amplitude, type of energy directors (EDs) affecting the welding quality and the advantages and disadvantages of UW over other bonding techniques, are summarized. The current state of the ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites and their future perspectives are also deliberated.

Continuous ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites: Enhancing the weld uniformity by changing the energy director

Continuous ultrasonic welding is a high-speed joining method for thermoplastic composites. Currently, a thin film energy director is used to focus the heat generation at the interface. However, areas of intact energy director remain in the welded seam, which significantly lowers the weld strength, and result in a non-uniformly welded seam. To improve the weld uniformity of continuous ultrasonically welded joints, we changed to a more compliant energy director. A woven polymer mesh energy director was found to give a significant improvement in weld quality. The mesh was flattened in between the composite adherends during the welding process. This flattening promoted a good contact between the energy director and the adherends, fully wetting the adherend surfaces, resulting in a more uniformly welded seam without areas of intact energy director.

Ultrasonic Welding of Thermoplastic Composites

Ultrasonic welding is a very fast and energy-efficient technique for the joining of thermoplastic composites. This article looks into main aspects of ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites, namely energy directors, process parameters, in situ process monitoring, welding of dissimilar composite materials and upscaling routes. From the viewpoint of the author of this paper, these are key topics for deepening our insight into the ultrasonic welding process and, eventually, for enabling its future industrialization.

Investigation on energy director-less ultrasonic welding of polyetherimide (PEI)- to epoxy-based composites

In ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites an energy director (ED) (i.e. neat thermoplastic film), is used between the two adherends to be welded, to promote frictional and viscoelastic heating. For welding of thermoset composites (TSC), a thermoplastic coupling layer is co-cured on the surface to be welded as typical procedure to make the TSC “weldable”. This study focuses on investigating whether a polyetherimide (PEI) coupling layer by itself has the potential to promote heat generation during ultrasonic welding of CF/epoxy and CF/PEI samples, without the need for a separate ED, and if so, what thickness should that coupling layer be. The main findings were that welding without a loose ED resulted in overheating of the CF/PEI adherend and/or coupling layer due to the inability of the latter to promote heat generation efficiently. However, welding of CF/epoxy and CF/PEI samples with the use of a loose ED resulted in high-strength welds.

A numerical analysis of an energy directing method through friction heating during the ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

The ultrasonic spot welding of fiber-reinforced thermoplastic laminates received a wide interest from researchers mainly in the fields of aerospace and automotive industries. This study investigated a new technique for focusing the ultrasonic vibration energy at the desired spot between two mating thermoplastic composite laminates. In this investigated method, no additional energy directing protrusions between the mating laminates were required to focus the vibration energy. It was found that by welding the laminates amid an ultrasonic horn and an anvil in which the prior had a larger contact surface with the laminate as the latter, it was possible to generate a localized friction heating. In the initial phase of the welding, the friction heating softened the interfacial layers and thus caused the focusing of the majority of the cyclic ultrasonic strain energy in the weld spot center. The assumption for the presence of the friction and its influence on the heat generation was investigated by means of finite element method (FEM) mechanical dynamic analysis. Microscopic analysis of the weld spot eventually delivered the proof for the melt initiation by friction at a ring around the weld spot and subsequent spot growth by viscoelastic heating.

A study on amplitude transmission in ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composite materials is a promising joining technique that is now moving towards up-scaling, i.e. the assembling of large industrial parts. Despite its growing technological maturation, the assumed physical mechanisms underlying ultrasonic heating (viscoelastic heating, friction) are still insufficiently understood and modelled. In particular, the hammering phenomenon, resulting from the periodic loss of contact between the sonotrode and adherends due to the high frequency vibration caused to the former, directly impacts the heating efficiency. We propose in this work an original experimental and modelling approach towards a better understanding of the hammering effect. This approach makes combined use of: (i) an experimental static welding setup provided with a high-frequency laser sensor to analyse the vibration amplitude transmitted to the adherends and (ii) an improvement of the multiphysical finite element model already presented in previous works. Results show it is possible to obtain a good estimation of the vibration transmitted to the upper adherend from laser measurements close to the sonotrode. The hammering effect is shown to decrease during the welding process, due to the heating of the interface which directly affects further heat generation. Quantitative introduction of this hammering effect in the existing numerical model results in improved predictions in terms of dissipated power in time.

Towards robust sequential ultrasonic spot welding of thermoplastic composites: Welding process control strategy for consistent weld quality

The research in this paper is an essential part of a bigger effort on developing robust sequential ultrasonic welding of multi-spot welded joints in thermoplastic composites. It mainly focused on assessing the impact of the changes in boundary conditions on the welding process and whether it could be circumvented by using an appropriate process control strategy. A two-step approach was followed by investigating: (1) the effect of boundary conditions on displacement- and energy-controlled single-spot welded joints and (2) displacement- and energy-controlled sequential ultrasonic welding of double-spot welded joints. The results showed that previous spots indeed affect the energy required to obtain an optimum new welded spot, which challenges the use of energy-controlled welding for this application. Contrarily, displacement-controlled welding was shown to provide consistent-quality welds with a constant set of welding parameters and it was hence identified as the most promising welding strategy for sequential ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites.

On the effect of flat energy directors thickness on heat generation during ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

This paper presents a detailed experimental assessment of the effect of the thickness of flat energy directors (ED) on heat generation at the interface during ultrasonic welding. Power and displacement data showed clear differences caused by the change of thickness, related to heat concentration at the weld line during the process. The extent of the heat-affected zone was assessed by welding specimens without consolidation at different stages of the process. It was confirmed through optical microscopy that heat is generated at the interface and transferred to the bulk adherends earlier in the process for thinner ED. The analysis of their fracture surface under optimum welding conditions revealed signs of matrix degradation, leading to less consistent quality, likely due to faster heat generation rate in both the ED and the substrates, and incidentally, higher temperatures surrounding the energy director.

Experimental Investigation of Ultrasonic Welding on Non-metallic Material

In the present scenario of developing plastic utility in engineering applications, demand for reliable and faster joining processes has increased. Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic is one of those joining methods which is based on application of high- frequency vibratory energy in that work pieces are held together under pressure without melting. Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites has become an important process in industry because of its relatively low cost and high quality resultant joints This study involves modelling of experimental data of joint strength of acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) material for ultrasonic welding on welding parameters (welding pressure, welding time, amplitude). In order to determine critical states of the welding parameters, analysis of variances has applied while optimisation of the parameters affecting the joint strength has achieved with centre composite method of the Response Surface Methodology.

A comparative evaluation between flat and traditional energy directors for ultrasonic welding of CF/PPS thermoplastic composites

Energy directors, responsible for local heat generation in ultrasonic welding, are neat resin protrusions traditionally moulded on the surfaces to be welded. This study evaluates an alternative energy directing solution for ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites based on the usage of a loose flat layer of neat resin at the welding interface, referred to as ‘flat energy director’. Analysis of dissipated power, displacement of the sonotrode, welding energy and time as well as weld strength compared to more traditional energy directing solutions showed that flat energy directors, which significantly simplify ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites, do not have any substantial negative impact in the welding process or the quality of the welded joints.

Strength development versus process data in ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites with flat energy directors and its application to the definition of optimum processing parameters

Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites is a very interesting joining technique as a result of good quality joints, very short welding times and the fact that no foreign material, e.g. a metal mesh, is required at the welding interface in any case. This paper describes one further advantage, the ability to relate weld strength to the welding process data, namely dissipated power and displacement of the sonotrode, in ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composite parts with flat energy directors. This relationship, combined with displacement-controlled welding, allows for fast definition of optimum welding parameters which consistently result in high-strength welded joints.

Modeling of the heating phenomena in ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites with flat energy directors

A model for the mechanics (oscillating deformation), heat transfer including viscoelastic heat generation and friction dissipation, and degree of adhesion (intimate contact and healing) is proposed for the initial transient heating phase.Numerical resolution was performed using a multi-physical finite element code. The predicted dissipated power evolution exhibits a good correlation with previous experimental measurement of delivered power, and shows that the apparatus has a global efficiency of 13%. The predicted degree of adhesion also confirms the experimental observation that adhesion starts at the edge of the contact area, and progressively extends to the whole contact area.The numerical model was further used to investigate the physical mechanisms occurring during the welding process. As suggested in the literature, the first heating mechanism is confirmed to be due to interfacial friction. Bulk viscoelastic dissipation becomes predominant when the interface reaches higher temperatures. The dissipated power is suddenly increased when the whole interface reaches the glass transition temperature.

In situ monitoring of ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites through power and displacement data

Ultrasonic welding is a very fast joining technique well suited for thermoplastic composites, which does not require the use of foreign materials at the welding interface for either carbon or glass fibre-reinforced substrates. Despite very interesting investigations carried out by several researchers on different aspects of the process, ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composite parts is not well understood yet. This article presents a deep experimental analysis of the transformations and heating mechanisms at the welding interface and their relationship with the dissipated power and the displacement of the sonotrode as provided by a microprocessor-controlled ultrasonic welder. The main aim of this research is to build up the knowledge to enable straightforward monitoring of the process and ultimately of the weld quality through the feedback provided by the ultrasonic welder.

Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites: a numerical analysis at the mesoscopic scale relating processing parameters, flow of polymer and quality of adhesion

Ultrasonic continuous welding of thermoplastic composite plates is a very promising process of particular interest for the assembly of aeronautics large parts. Its modeling and simulation however suffers from the difficulty of accounting for the very different time scales that rule the thermo-mechanical phenomena at the level of the adhesion zone. This problem was addressed in our previous works and led to an original simulation tool presented in Levy et al. (Eur J Mech A, Solids 30(4):501–509, 2011a). In this paper, the adopted time-homogenized multiphysical modeling of the flow at the mesoscopic scale of the energy directors is first presented. Then, using the numerical software in a 2D approach, an extensive numerical parametric study of the process is presented. The phenomena allowing welding are confirmed to be an initial strain concentration in the energy director, and the formation of a flowing fold. The influence of the following process parameters are finally investigated: amplitude of vibrations, holding force of the sonotrode, thickness of the plates, radius of curvature at the tip of the director, angle of the director. Process efficiency and weld quality is evaluated through simple indicators such as the equivalent stiffness analysis, the healing degree and the risk of porosity entrapment. The present study, carried at the mesoscopic scale, provides a better understanding of the complex interactions between physical and process parameters and enables to draw important technological conclusions for the design of energy directors.

A level set based approach for the finite element simulation of a forming process involving multiphysics coupling: Ultrasonic welding of thermoplastic composites

Abstract Thermoplastic composite materials offer new perspective in the mechanical industry, especially in aeronautic industry. The assembly of huge structures by welding is made possible by the ability of the matrix to melt. This paper focuses on ultrasonic welding process where heating is confined at the welding interface. This is achieved thanks to a local mechanical dissipation in triangles specially located at the interface, called energy director. In order to better understand the phenomena that occur at the energy director scale, we propose to model and simulate the polymer flow at the interface. Based on a previous work, the flow under vibration is modeled using three coupled boundary value problems. A specific simulation tool is then developed for solving those three problems. It entails specific numerical methods: a level set method allows to handle the large geometry change, and an iterative solver manages the multiphysical aspects. The novel simulation obtained is validated with a qualitative comparison to experiments. Then, an analysis of the numerical results allows to understand the phenomena that enable welding. A thermomechanical localization heats the tip of the energy director. This initiates a fold of polymer that progressively fills the gap between the two plates to weld, and ensures conditions for adhesion.

Ultrasonic Welding of Thermoplastic Composites, Modeling of the Process.

The process of ultrasonic welding is widely used in the industry. Nevertheless, its numerical modelling, essential for the aeronautic industry, is quite difficult because of the two time scales present in the process. After explaining principle of the welding, a method of time homogenization is presented in order to write down three different thermal and mechanical systems of equations. Since one of those problems implies moving free surface, a numerical tool using the level-set method was used to solve them.