Tropical Cyclone Intensity Forecasts Research Articles

Improving the Statistical Representation of Tropical Cyclone In-Storm Sea Surface Temperature Cooling

Abstract This study uses fixed buoy time series to create an algorithm for sea surface temperature (SST) cooling underneath a tropical cyclone (TC) inner core. To build predictive equations, SST cooling is first related to single variable predictors such as the SST before storm arrival, ocean heat content (OHC), mixed layer depth, sea surface salinity and stratification, storm intensity, storm translation speed, and latitude. Of all the single variable predictors, initial SST before storm arrival explains the greatest amount of variance for the change in SST during storm passage. Using a combination of predictors, we created nonlinear predictive equations for SST cooling. In general, the best predictive equations have four predictors and are built with knowledge about the prestorm ocean structure (e.g., OHC), storm intensity (e.g., minimum sea level pressure), initial SST values before storm arrival, and latitude. The best-performing SST cooling equations are broken up into two ocean regimes: when the ocean heat content is less than 60 kJ cm−2 (greater spread in SST cooling values) and when the ocean heat content is greater than 60 kJ cm−2 (SST cooling is always less than 2°C), which demonstrates the importance of the prestorm oceanic thermal structure on the in-storm SST value. The new equations are compared to what is currently used in a statistical–dynamical model. Overall, since the ocean providing the latent heat and sensible heat fluxes necessary for TC intensification, the results highlight the importance for consistently obtaining accurate in-storm upper-oceanic thermal structure for accurate TC intensity forecasts. Significance Statement The ocean provides the heat and moisture necessary for tropical cyclone (TC) intensification. Since the heat and moisture transfer depend on the sea surface temperature (SST), we create statistical equations for the prediction of SST underneath the storm. The variables we use combine the initial SST before the storm arrives, the upper-ocean thermal structure, and the strength and translation speed of the storm. The predictive equations for SST are evaluated for how well they improve TC intensity forecasts. The best-performing equations can be used for prediction in operational statistical models, which can aid intensity forecasts.

Improvement of Global Forecast of Tropical Cyclone Intensity by Spray Heat Flux and Surface Roughness

AbstractIn global forecasting systems, tropical cyclone (TC) intensity is usually underestimated, which is one of the major challenges for TC forecasting. One possible reason is the deficiency of physical parameterizations associated with ocean surface waves. To improve the TC intensity forecast, effects of two powerful wave‐related processes, the spray‐mediated heat flux and surface roughness, are considered in a global coupled ocean‐atmosphere‐wave system (CFSv2.0‐WW3). Serial 24 hr forecasting experiments for all TCs from May to October 2019 are conducted, and comparisons are made against the International Best Track TC data. The results show that for strong TCs the underestimation of TC intensity in CFSv2.0‐WW3 is significantly improved by the modified surface roughness parameterization and the accelerated spray heat flux parameterization based on Gaussian Quadrature. For major hurricanes with initial wind speeds above 30 m/s, the error of TC maximum wind speed decreases by about 34.4%. To understand the associated dynamic and thermodynamic processes, a series of 120 hr simulations for major hurricane Hagibis is conducted. The effect of spray‐mediated heat flux accounts for 91.7% of the TC intensity improvement. The increased heat fluxes offset the negative contributions of vertical advection and ventilation, leading to enhanced entropy. The low‐level pressure is then decreased, resulting in enhanced convergence of absolute vorticity, which overpowers the negative effects of frictional dissipation and vertical momentum advection. The study indicates that the application of these two wave‐related parameterizations can potentially improve the global forecast and reanalysis of TC intensity.

Improvement in Forecasting Short-Term Tropical Cyclone Intensity Change and Their Rapid Intensification Using Deep Learning

Abstract Forecasting the intensity of a tropical cyclone (TC) remains challenging, particularly when it undergoes rapid changes in intensity. This study aims to develop a convolutional neural network (CNN) for 24-h forecasts of the TC intensity changes and their rapid intensifications over the western Pacific. The CNN model, the DeepTC, is trained using a unique loss function, an amplitude focal loss, to better capture large intensity changes, such as those during rapid intensification (RI) events. We showed that the DeepTC outperforms operational forecasts, with a lower mean absolute error (8.9%–10.2%) and a higher coefficient of determination (31.7%–35%). In addition, the DeepTC exhibits a substantially better skill at capturing RI events than operational forecasts. To understand the superior performance of the DeepTC in RI forecasts, we conduct an occlusion sensitivity analysis to quantify the relative importance of each predictor. Results revealed that scalar quantities such as latitude, previous intensity change, initial intensity, and vertical wind shear play critical roles in successful RI prediction. Additionally, the DeepTC utilizes the three-dimensional distribution of relative humidity to distinguish RI cases from non-RI cases, with higher dry–moist moisture gradients in the mid-to-low troposphere and steeper radial moisture gradients in the upper troposphere showed during RI events. These relationships between the identified key variables and intensity change were successfully simulated by the DeepTC, implying that the relationship is physically reasonable. Our study demonstrates that the DeepTC can be a powerful tool for improving RI understanding and enhancing the reliability of TC intensity forecasts.

Why does tropical cyclone intensify faster under weaker parameterized horizontal diffusion in three-dimensional numerical simulations?

The mechanisms by which the parameterized horizontal diffusion impacts the tropical cyclone (TC) intensification are investigated via a series of numerical simulations of Supertyphoon Lekima (2019) with different horizontal mixing lengths (Lh). Consistent with previous studies, the TC intensifies faster and attains a higher peak intensity as Lh decreases, which is attributed to a more compact wind structure and the stronger eyewall convective heating. The azimuthal-mean tangential wind and vertical momentum budgets are conducted to explain the differences in TC size and convective strength between the simulations. It is found that when horizontal diffusion weakens, the eddy mixing of tangential momentum becomes larger inside the radius of maximum wind, therefore promoting size contraction. The stronger eddy mixing is attributed to the more active eyewall mesovortices whose growth is suppressed when horizontal diffusion strengthens. The vertical momentum budget results indicate that the air parcels in the simulation with smaller Lh experience stronger upward buoyancy force in the lower-to-mid troposphere (3–7 km) than those in the larger-Lh simulation, leading to more vigorous eyewall convection. It is further revealed that the reduced horizontal diffusion helps maintain the strength of virtual potential temperature perturbations and therefore the buoyancy in the eyewall updrafts. The findings from this study imply that the horizontal diffusion plays an important role in regulating the mesoscale and convective-scale processes in the inner-core region and improvements in its parameterization are urged for improving TC intensity forecast.

Influence of Spatial Heterogeneity in Sea Surface Temperature on Tropical Cyclone Intensity Over the Western North Pacific

AbstractThis study explores the impact of sea surface temperature (SST) spatial heterogeneity on tropical cyclone (TC) intensity through a combination of observations and simulations, aiming to provide a reference for further improving TC intensity forecasting skills. Two distinct patterns of SST spatial heterogeneity are identified based on a statistical analysis of observational data, when the SST at the TC center is above and below 29.3°C, respectively. One is a warm‐core pattern (WCP) with a warm peak SST at the TC center decreasing centrifugally which favors TC development, and the other one is a poleward‐decreasing pattern (PDP) with a warm SST at the south decreasing poleward which suppresses TC development. The numerical simulations confirm the opposite influence of the WCP and the PDP on TC intensity. The WCP intensifies TC intensity by strengthening TC secondary circulation, increasing the conversion from ocean heat energy to TC kinetic energy, and compacting TC structure. In contrast, the PDP weakens TC intensity by inducing opposing responses of these processes. The magnitude of TC intensity change caused by SST spatial heterogeneity is comparable to those caused by a 1°C change in SST at the TC center. These findings offer valuable insights into the role of SST spatial heterogeneity in TC development and provide a new perspective to improve TC intensity forecasting by incorporating SST spatial heterogeneity into statistical‐dynamic models.

Tropical cyclone trajectory based on satellite remote sensing prediction and time attention mechanism ConvLSTM model

The accurate and timely prediction of tropical cyclones is of paramount importance in mitigating the impact of these catastrophic meteorological events. Presently, methods for predicting tropical cyclones based on satellite remote sensing images encounter notable challenges, including the inadequate extraction of three-dimensional spatial features and limitations in long-term forecasting. As a response to these challenges, this study introduces the Temporal Attention Mechanism ConvLSTM (TAM-CL) model, designed to conduct thorough spatiotemporal feature extraction on three-dimensional atmospheric reanalysis data of tropical cyclones. By leveraging ConvLSTM with three-dimensional convolution kernels, our model enhances the extraction of three-dimensional spatiotemporal features. Furthermore, an attention mechanism is integrated to bolster long-term prediction accuracy by emphasizing crucial temporal nodes. In the evaluation of tropical cyclone track and intensity forecasts across 24, 48, and 72 h, TAM-CL demonstrates a notable reduction in prediction errors, thereby underscoring its efficacy in forecasting both cyclone tracks and intensities. This contributes to an effective exploration of the application of deep networks in conjunction with atmospheric reanalysis data.

Bias Correction of Tropical Cyclone Intensity for Ensemble Forecasts Using the XGBoost Method

Abstract In this study, the extreme gradient boosting (XGBoost) algorithm is used to correct tropical cyclone (TC) intensity in ensemble forecast data from the Typhoon Ensemble Data Assimilation and Prediction System (TEDAPS) at the Shanghai Typhoon Institute (STI), China Meteorological Administration (CMA). Results show that the forecast accuracy of TC intensity may be improved substantially using the XGBoost algorithm, especially when compared with a simple ensemble average of all members in the ensemble forecast [as depicted by the ensemble average (EnsAve) algorithm in this study]. The forecast errors for maximum wind speed (MWS) and minimum sea level pressure (MSLP) have been reduced by a significant margin, ranging from 6.3% to 18.4% for MWS and from 4% to 14.9% for MSLP, respectively. The performance of the XGBoost algorithm is overall better than that of the EnsAve algorithm, although there are a few samples when it is worse. The bias analysis shows that TEDAPS underpredicts the MWS and overpredicts the MSLP, meaning that the TEDAPS underestimates TC intensity. However, the XGBoost algorithm can reduce the bias to improve the forecast accuracy of TC intensity. Specifically, it achieves a reduction of over 20% in forecast errors for both the MWS and MSLP of typhoons compared to the EnsAve algorithm, indicating the XGBoost algorithm’s particular advantage in forecasting intense TCs. These results indicate that the TC intensity forecast can be substantially improved using the XGBoost algorithm, relative to the EnsAve algorithm.

Comparison of different global ensemble prediction systems for tropical cyclone intensity forecasting

AbstractMany meteorological centers have operationally implemented global model‐based ensemble prediction systems (GEPSs), making tropical cyclone (TC) forecasts from these systems available. The relatively low resolution of these GEPSs means that limits previous studies primarily focused on TC track forecasting. However, recent GEPS upgrades mean that TC intensity predictions from GEPSs are now also becoming of interest. This study focuses on the verification and comparison of the latest generation of GEPSs for TC intensity forecasts, particularly during the rapid intensification (RI) period over the western North Pacific (WP), eastern North Pacific (EP), and North Atlantic (NA) basins in 2021–2022. On average, the National Centers for Environmental Prediction (NCEP) GEPS performed best in predicting both TC intensity and RI across all three basins. Nevertheless, the exact timing of RI remains highly uncertain for these GEPS, indicating significant limitations in using GEPSs to forecast RI.

Predicting Short-Term Intensity Change in Tropical Cyclones Using a Convolutional Neural Network

Abstract This study details a two-method, machine learning approach to predict current and short-term intensity change in global tropical cyclones (TCs), “D-MINT” and “D-PRINT.” D-MINT and D-PRINT use infrared imagery and environmental scalar predictors, while D-MINT also employs microwave imagery. Results show that current TC intensity estimates from D-MINT and D-PRINT are more skillful than three established intensity estimation methods routinely used by operational forecasters for North Atlantic and eastern and western North Pacific TCs. Short-term intensity predictions are validated against five operational deterministic guidances at 6-, 12-, 18-, and 24-h lead times. D-MINT and D-PRINT are less skillful than NHC and consensus TC intensity predictions in North Atlantic and eastern North Pacific TCs, but are more skillful than the other guidances for at least half of the lead times. In western North Pacific, north Indian Ocean, and Southern Hemisphere TCs, D-MINT is more skillful than the JTWC and other individual TC intensity forecasts for over half of the lead times. When probabilistically predicting TC rapid intensification (RI), D-MINT is more skillful in North Atlantic and western North Pacific TCs than three operationally used RI guidances, but less skillful for yes–no RI forecasts. In addition, this work demonstrates the importance of microwave imagery, as D-MINT is more skillful than D-PRINT. Since D-MINT and D-PRINT are convolutional neural network models interrogating two-dimensional structures within TC satellite imagery, this study also demonstrates that those features can yield better short-term predictions than existing scalar statistics of satellite imagery in operational models. Finally, a diagnostics tool is revealed to aid the attribution of the D-MINT/D-PRINT intensity predictions. Significance Statement This study develops a method to predict current and short-term forecasts of tropical cyclone (TC) intensity using artificial intelligence. The resultant models use a convolutional neural network (CNN) that can identify two-dimensional features in satellite imagery that are indicative of TC intensity and future intensity change. The performance results indicate that in several TC basins, the CNN approach is generally more skillful than alternative satellite-based estimates of TC intensity as well as operational short-term forecasts of deterministic intensity change and of similar skill to probabilistic rapid intensification forecasts.

A modified vertical eddy diffusivity parameterization in the HWRF model based on large eddy simulations and its impact on the prediction of two landfalling hurricanes

Vertical eddy diffusivity (VED) in the planetary boundary layer (PBL) has a significant impact on forecasts of tropical cyclone (TC) structure and intensity. VED uncertainties in PBL parameterizations can be partly attributed to the model’s inability to represent roll vortices (RV). In this study, RV effects on turbulent fluxes derived from a large eddy simulation (LES) by Li et al. (Geophys. Res. Lett., 2021, 48, e2020GL090703) are added to the VED parameterization of the PBL scheme within the operational Hurricane Weather Research and Forecasting (HWRF) model. RV contribution to VED is parameterized through a coefficient and varies with the RV intensity and velocity scale. A modification over land has also been implemented. This modified VED parameterization is compared with the original wind-speed-dependent VED scheme in HWRF. Retrospective HWRF forecasts of Hurricanes Florence (2018) and Laura (2020) are analyzed to evaluate the impacts of the modified VED scheme on landfalling hurricane forecasts. Results show that the modified PBL scheme with the RV effect leads to an improvement in 10-m maximum wind speed forecasts of 14%–31%, with a neutral to positive improvement for track forecasts. Improved wind structure and precipitation forecasts against observations are also noted with the modified PBL scheme. Further diagnoses indicate that the revised PBL scheme enhances moist entropy in the boundary layer over land, leading to improved TC intensity prediction compared to the original scheme.

The Quagmire of Arrested Development in Tropical Cyclones

Abstract The 48-h intensity forecasts for Hurricane Pamela (2021) from numerical weather prediction models, statistical–dynamical aids, and forecasters were a major forecast bust with Pamela making landfall as a minor rather than major hurricane. From the satellite presentation, Pamela exhibited a symmetric pattern referred to as central cold cover (CCC) in the subjective Dvorak intensity technique. Per the technique, the CCC pattern is accompanied by arrested development in intensity despite the seemingly favorable convective signature. To understand forecast uncertainty during occurrences, central cold cover frequency from 2011 to 2021 is documented. From these cases, composites of longwave infrared brightness temperatures from geostationary satellites for CCC cases are presented, and the surrounding tropical cyclone large-scale environment is quantified and compared with other tropical cyclones at similar latitudes and intensities. These composites show that central cold cover has a consistent presentation, but varies in the preceding hours for storms that eventually intensify or weaken. And, the synoptic-scale environment surrounding the tropical cyclone thermodynamically supports the vigorous deep convection associated with CCC. Finally, intensity forecast errors from numerical weather prediction models and statistical–dynamical aids are examined in comparison to similar tropical cyclones. This work shows that guidance struggles during CCC cases with intensity errors from these models being in the lowest percentiles of performance, particularly for 24- and 36-h forecasts. Significance Statement The appearance of symmetric cold clouds near the center of developing tropical cyclones is most often associated with future intensification. This simple relationship is widely used by statistical tropical cyclone intensity forecast models. Here, we reexamine and confirm that one subjectively determined nighttime cold cyclone cloud pattern termed the “central cold cover” pattern in Vern Dvorak’s seminal technique for estimating tropical cyclone intensity from infrared satellite images is indeed related to slow or arrested development, and represents a failure mode for these simple forecast models.

Tropical Cyclone Forecasts in the DIMOSIC Project—Medium‐Range Forecast Models With Common Initial Conditions

AbstractThe tropical cyclone (TC) forecast skill of the eight global medium‐range forecast models which are participating in the DIfferent Models, Same Initial Conditions project is investigated in this study. Each model was used to generate 10‐day forecasts from the same initial conditions provided by the European Centre for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasts. There are a total of 123 initial dates spanning in one year from June 2018 to June 2019 at 3‐day intervals. The TC track and intensity forecasts are evaluated against the best track data set. TC‐related precipitation and tropical cyclogenesis forecasts are also compared to explore the differences and similarities of TC forecasts across the models. This comparison of TC forecasts allows model developers in different centers to benchmark their model against other models, with the impact of the initial condition quality removed. The verifications reveal that most models show slow‐moving and right‐of‐track biases in their TC track forecasts. Also, a common dry bias in TC‐related precipitation indicates a general deficiency in TC intensity and convection in the models which should be related to insufficient model resolution. These findings provide important references for future model developments.

Can Tibetan Plateau Snow Depth Influence the Interannual Association between Tropical Indian Ocean Sea Surface Temperatures and Rapidly Intensifying Typhoons?

Abstract This study finds that the observed decrease in winter–spring Tibetan Plateau snow depth since 2000 has played an important role in weakening the correlation between rapidly intensifying tropical cyclones over the western North Pacific and tropical Indian Ocean sea surface temperatures (SSTs). Tibetan Plateau snow depth modulates convective activity through changes in the South Asian high. Increased Tibetan Plateau snow depth promotes basinwide tropical Indian Ocean cooling in spring through a Gill-type response. In the following seasons, downward latent heat flux anomalies associated with a weaker monsoon circulation contributes to warm SST anomalies over the western tropical Indian Ocean, thus favoring a positive phase of the Indian Ocean dipole. This evolution of tropical Indian Ocean SSTs associated with anomalously high Tibetan Plateau snow depth potentially weakens the relationship between rapidly intensifying tropical cyclone frequency and spring tropical Indian Ocean SSTs. When the effect of Tibetan Plateau snow depth is removed via partial correlation analysis, we find a significant relationship between spring tropical Indian Ocean SSTs and rapidly intensifying tropical cyclones as well as corresponding large-scale environmental factors. The results of this study enhance understanding of changes in tropical cyclone intensity and have implications for seasonal forecasting of tropical cyclone intensity over the western North Pacific basin. This study also emphasizes the importance of Tibetan Plateau thermal forcing in atmosphere–ocean coupling.

Assimilation of Coyote Small Uncrewed Aircraft System Observations in Hurricane Maria (2017) Using Operational HWRF

Abstract This study presents an initial demonstration of assimilating small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) data into an operational model with a goal to ultimately improve tropical cyclone (TC) analyses and forecasts. The observations, obtained using the Coyote sUAS in Hurricane Maria (2017), were assimilated into the operational Hurricane Weather Research and Forecast (HWRF) system as they could be in operations. Results suggest that the Coyote data can benefit HWRF forecasts. A single-cycle case study produced the best results when the Coyote observations were assimilated at greater horizontal resolution with more relaxed quality control (QC) than comparable flight-level high-density observations currently used in operations. The case study results guided experiments that cycled HWRF for a roughly 4-day period that covered all Coyote flights into Maria. The cycled experiment that assimilated the most data improved initial inner-core structure in the analyses and better agreed with other aircraft observations. The average errors in track and intensity decreased in the subsequent forecasts. Intensity forecasts were too weak when no Coyote data were assimilated, and assimilating the Coyote data made the forecasts stronger. Results also suggest that a symmetric distribution of Coyote data around the TC center is necessary to maximize its benefits in the current configuration of operational HWRF. Although the sample size was limited, these experiments provide insight for potential operational use of data from newer sUAS platforms in future TC applications. Significance Statement This study represents the first time that observations from a small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) have been assimilated into an operational numerical model. Including these data was shown to have potential for improving forecasts of tropical cyclone track and intensity. The data were obtained using the Coyote sUAS, but these results are expected to be applicable to newer platforms that will be operational soon.

Transformer-based tropical cyclone track and intensity forecasting

Tropical cyclone (TC) is one of the most destructive natural disasters, and hence it is very crucial to predict attributes of TC accurately. In this paper, a transformer-based method for short-term prediction of the track and intensity of TCs, including the central latitude, the central longitude, the minimum sea level pressure and the maximum sustained wind speed, in the Northwest Pacific Basin is proposed. The data set used in this study ranging from 1980 to 2021 was released by China Meteorological Administration (CMA). A data preprocessing step including feature augmentation is adopted, which can make full use of the historical information of TCs. The transformer networks can model the complex dynamic relationships between the time series data and dig the relationship between different attributes based on the multi-head self-attention mechanism. The transformer-based method proposed in this study exhibits excellent performance in the prediction task. Meanwhile, compared to the traditional recurrent neural network models including gated recurrent units model and long short-term memory model, the transformer model has a better performance in predicting all attributes. This method provides a practical guidance of using advanced AI-based approaches to predict TC attributes.

Probabilistic forecasting of tropical cyclones intensity using machine learning model

This study proposes a machine learning approach to probabilistic forecasting of tropical cyclone (TC) intensity. The earth system is complex and nonlinear, leading to inherent uncertainty in TC forecasting at all times, and therefore a representation of this uncertainty should be provided. Previous studies construct this uncertainty through ensemble or statistical methods, neither of which can directly characterize this uncertainty and suffer from problems such as excessive computational effort. And for this reason, we propose to assess the forecast without this uncertainty through the forecast distribution. Meanwhile, none of the previous studies on TC intensity forecasting by artificial intelligence methods characterize the uncertainty, so this study is a new supplement to data-driven TC forecasting. During the 2010–2020 evaluation period, the model’s point forecast can outperform the current state-of-the-art operational statistic-dynamical model results, and can obtain forecast intervals to provide reliable probabilistic forecasts, which are critical for disaster warnings.

Improving Tropical Cyclogenesis Forecasts of Hurricane Irma (2017) through the Assimilation of All-Sky Infrared Brightness Temperatures

Abstract The assimilation of satellite all-sky infrared (IR) brightness temperatures (BTs) has been shown in previous studies to improve intensity forecasts of tropical cyclones. In this study, we examine whether assimilating all-sky IR BTs can also potentially improve tropical cyclogenesis forecasts by improving the pregenesis cloud and moisture fields. By using an ensemble-based data assimilation system, we show that the assimilation of upper-tropospheric water vapor channel BTs observed by the Meteosat-10 SEVIRI instrument two days before the formation of a tropical depression improves the genesis forecast of Hurricane Irma (2017), a classic Cape Verde storm, by up to 24 h while also capturing its later rapid intensification in deterministic forecasts. In an experiment that withholds the assimilation of all-sky IR BTs, the assimilation of conventional observations from the Global Telecommunications System (GTS) leads to the premature genesis of Hurricane Irma by at least 24 h. This premature genesis is shown to result from an overestimation of the spatial coverage of deep convection within the African easterly wave (AEW) from which Irma eventually forms. The gross overestimation of deep convection without all-sky IR BTs is accompanied by higher column saturation fraction, stronger low-level convergence, and the earlier spinup of a low-level meso-β-scale vortex within the AEW that ultimately becomes Hurricane Irma. Through its adjustment to the initial moisture and cloud conditions, the assimilation of all-sky IR BTs leads to a more realistic convective evolution in forecasts and ultimately a more realistic timing of genesis. Significance Statement Every year hurricanes impact the lives of thousands of people living along the eastern coast of the United States. Many of these storms originate from tropical disturbances that exit the west coast of Africa. To give the public more warning time ahead of these storms, it is important to improve the forecasts of their formation. This study uses a system developed at The Pennsylvania State University to incorporate satellite observations into forecasts of a classic Cape Verde storm, Hurricane Irma (2017), two days before it formed. By using satellite-collected radiances, we improve the timing of its formation by up to 24 h due to a better representation of the mesoscale tropical disturbance from which it originated.

On the Combination of Physical Parameterization Schemes for Tropical Cyclone Track and Intensity Forecasts in the Context of Uncertainty

AbstractThe selection of physical parameterization schemes for tropical cyclone (TC) forecasts has required a substantial amount of effort. In general, the evaluation of physical parameterization schemes and their combined performance was based solely on the deterministic forecast, which had inherent limitations in representing the overall performance of physical parameterization schemes due to the model uncertainty. This study introduces an uncertainty‐informed framework of evaluating and selecting the combination of physical parameterization schemes for TC forecasts, based on the ensemble forecast that could include the model uncertainty roles. The performance ranking of the scheme combination based on the ensemble mean error is found to be distinct from that based on the deterministic forecast error. Moreover, differences in both ensemble mean errors and ensemble spreads for various scheme combinations highlight the importance of considering two metrics concurrently, that is, via the quality of the forecast distribution as a whole, to assess the forecast performance. Consequently, the ensemble Continuous Ranked Probability Score (eCRPS) is used to quantify the performance of the scheme combinations, and it is demonstrated that the performance is more comprehensive than that in the deterministic context. Finally, the well‐performed scheme combination for the forecasts of six intense TCs is chosen from the evaluated schemes in the context of model uncertainty, based on the overall quality of TC track and intensity forecast distributions.

A review of recent advances (2018–2021) on tropical cyclone intensity change from operational perspectives, part 2: Forecasts by operational centers

This paper summarizes the progress and activities of tropical cyclone (TC) operational forecast centers during the last four years (2018–2021). It is part II of the review on TC intensity change from the operational perspective in the rapporteur report presented to the 10th International Workshop on TCs (IWTC) held in Bali, Indonesia, from Dec. 5–9, 2022. Part I of the review has focused on the progress of dynamical model forecast guidance. This part discusses the performance of TC intensity and rapid intensification forecasts from several operational centers. It is shown that the TC intensity forecast errors have continued to decrease since the 9th IWTC held in 2018. In particular, the improvement of rapid intensification forecasts has accelerated, compared with years before 2018. Consensus models, operational procedures, tools and techniques, as well as recent challenging cases from 2018 to 2021 identified by operational forecast centers are described. Research needs and recommendations are also discussed.

On the Existence of Low-Dimensional Chaos of the Tropical Cyclone Intensity in an Idealized Axisymmetric Simulation

Abstract This study examines the potential limit in predicting tropical cyclone (TC) intensity under idealized conditions. Using the phase-space reconstruction method for TC intensity time series obtained from the CM1 idealized simulations, it is found that CM1 axisymmetric dynamics contain low-dimensional chaos at the maximum intensity equilibrium. Examination of several attractor invariants including the largest Lyapunov exponent, the Sugihara–May correlation, and the correlation dimension captures a consistent range of the chaotic attractor dimension between 4 and 5 for TC intensity at the maximum intensity equilibrium. In addition, the intensity error doubling time estimated from the largest Lyapunov exponent is roughly 1–3 h, which accords with the decay time obtained from the Sugihara–May correlation. Furthermore, the findings in this study reveal a relatively short TC intensity predictability limit for CM1, which is ∼3–9 h based on the maximum tangential wind but noticeably longer for the minimum central pressure (∼12–18 h) after reaching the mature stage. So long as the traditional metrics for TC intensity such as the maximum surface wind or the minimum central pressure is used for intensity forecast, our results support that TC intensity forecast errors will not be reduced indefinitely in any model, even in the absence of all model and observational errors. As such, the future improvement of TC intensity forecast should be based on different metrics beyond the absolute intensity errors that are currently used in real-time intensity verification. Significance Statement Using the phase-space reconstruction method for tropical cyclone (TC) intensity time series obtained from idealized axisymmetric simulations, we show that TC axisymmetric dynamics in CM1 possesses low-dimensional chaos at the maximum intensity equilibrium. This low-dimensional dynamics explains the long tradition of representing TC intensity by a few measures as in the current practice. The chaotic property of CM1 axisymmetric dynamics also suggests a relatively short predictability range for TC intensity at the maximum intensity equilibrium. The potential existence of low-dimensional chaos for TC intensity in CM1 idealized simulations as found in this study supports the use of different intensity verification metrics beyond the traditional absolute intensity errors currently used in operational model evaluation.