Triaxial Tests Research Articles

Adopting a systems engineering approach to a feasibility study of a sidings development at the Midsomer Norton railway station

It is planned to reopen Midsomer Norton railway station, which is a station on the Somerset & Dorset Heritage Railway Line, to traffic. As a first step, Midsomer Norton will be a terminus, and it is proposed to build sidings and a depot for the trains that terminate there. However, a ground investigation is essential before commencing construction of the sidings and the depot, as this is a vital part of any civil engineering process. The behaviour of the ground must be known in order for a structure to be supported by it; therefore, data from the ground investigation are used as reference for any kind of structure development. This study covers a site investigation that includes a desk study, walkover survey, sampling and laboratory testing in order to ascertain the feasibility of a suitable design. Moisture content testing, liquid limit and plastic limit tests, standard compaction testing, shear vane tests, and triaxial compression tests were carried out to determine the soil characteristics and to analyse the soil behaviour. A strong recommendation was made to follow a systems engineering approach in the construction phase, as well as in the design stage. The dependability of the system is ensured by the good use of V – process of systems engineering.

Thermo-hydro-mechanical coupling in oil shale: Investigating permeability and heat transfer under high-temperature steam injection

Steam convective heating emerges as a sustainable and effective method for extracting oil shale, where understanding the temperature-dependent evolution of its pyrolytic characteristics, microstructure, and permeability is vital for efficient resource extraction. Through a stress-sensitive micro-CT scanning and a high-temperature and pressure triaxial test apparatus, this research utilizes Balikun oil shale samples to investigate the changes in microstructure and gas production from 20 °C to 550 °C. The study integrates theoretical analysis and numerical simulations to uncover the fundamental connections between internal permeability and heat transfer mechanisms during steam injection. It reveals that oil shale undergoes two critical evolutionary phases: a stability phase below 350 °C, where volatile dispersion occurs, and a rapid increase phase above 350 °C, marked by significant microstructural changes from micro-fractures to extensive through-going fractures due to intense thermal decomposition. This decomposition leads to increased gas production and enhanced thermal fracturing. The threshold temperature is identified at 400 °C, above which the oil shale's mechanical strength and pore pressure increase, leading to decreased volumetric compression until stabilization. These findings demonstrate that higher temperatures enhance fracture connectivity and steam flow, optimizing the heating efficiency in oil shale extraction.

Study on the Shear Strength and Erosion Resistance of Sand Solidified by Enzyme-Induced Calcium Carbonate Precipitation (EICP).

Sand solidification of earth-rock dams is the key to flood discharge capacity and collapse prevention of earth-rock dams. It is urgent to find an economical, environmentally friendly, and durable sand solidification technology. However, the traditional grouting reinforcement method has some problems, such as high costs, complex operations, and environmental pollution. Enzyme-induced calcium carbonate precipitation (EICP) is an anti-seepage reinforcement technology emerging in recent years with the characteristics of economy, environmental protection, and durability. The erosion resistance and shear strength of earth-rock dams solidified by EICP need further verification. In this paper, EICP-solidified standard sand is taken as the research object, and EICP-cemented standard sand is carried out by a consolidated undrained triaxial test. A two-stage pouring method is adopted to pour samples, and the effects of dry density, cementation times, standing time, and confining pressure on the shear strength of cemented standard sand are emphatically analyzed. The relationship between cohesion, internal friction angle, and CaCO3 formation was analyzed. After the optimal curing conditions are obtained through the triaxial shear strength test, the erosion resistance model test is carried out. The effects of erosion angle, erosion flow rate, and erosion time on the erosion resistance of EICP-solidified sand were analyzed through an erosion model test. The results of triaxial tests show that the standard sand solidified by EICP exhibits strain softening, and the peak strength increases with the increase in initial dry density, cementation times, standing time, and confining pressure. When the content of CaCO3 increases from 2.84 g to 12.61 g, the cohesive force and internal friction angle change to 23.13 times and 1.18 times, and the determination coefficients reach 0.93 and 0.94, respectively. Erosion model test results indicate that the EICP-solidified sand dam has good erosion resistance. As the increase in erosion angle, erosion flow rate, and erosion time, the breach of solidified samples gradually becomes larger. Due to the deep solidification of sand by EICP, the development of breaches is relatively slow. Under different erosion conditions, the solidified samples did not collapse and the dam broke. The research results have important reference value and scientific significance for the practice of sand consolidation engineering in earth-rock dams.

Anisotropic behavior and mechanical characteristics of the Montney Formation

This study investigates the rock mechanics and anisotropic properties of the Montney Formation, Alberta, through two sets of experiments: unconfined compressive strength tests and triaxial compression tests, supplemented by ultrasonic wave velocity measurements. These tests enabled the calculation of dynamic and static stiffness properties and Thomsen anisotropy parameters (ε, δ, γ). Our findings reveal that the Montney Formation exhibits weak anisotropy, with ε values generally below 0.10, contrasting with other strongly anisotropic shale formations. Specimens exhibiting higher clay content and total organic carbon levels show more pronounced anisotropy. Static measurements exhibit a higher degree of anisotropy compared to dynamic measurements. The investigation also explored loading and unloading stiffness parameters, noting a higher E loading-to-unloading ratio for rock specimens with lower elastic properties. This provides important information on the rock's response to stress path effects during stimulation and exploitation. The study also discusses other rock mechanics parameters including Poisson's ratio, tensile strength, and brittleness. The research contributes to a more comprehensive understanding of the geomechanical and petrophysical behavior of the Montney Formation, aiding reservoir characterization and hydrocarbon exploration and production.

Damage evolution in layered rock masses of a mining floor under the influence of fluid–structure coupling

AbstractCurrent research on rock damage in mining floors primarily focuses on the seepage‐stress coupling effect, overlooking the fact that rock masses in coal measure strata are predominantly layered. To address this gap, cyclic loading and unloading triaxial tests were conducted. Additionally, theoretical analysis, mathematical statistics, and other methods were used to investigate the damage evolution law of layered rock masses in coal measures. This investigation was carried out under the coupled effects of a specific stress path, characterized by ‘stress concentration‐stress unloading‐stress recovery’, and a high confined water seepage field. The results show that the compression modulus increases with the increase in confining pressure and osmotic pressure, but its increasing trend gradually slows down. Within a certain range, increasing the confining pressure and osmotic pressure helps to close rock fractures and increase stiffness.

Study on Wetting Deformation Characteristics of Damming Materials under Triaxial Compression

The wetting deformation of dam material will lead to uneven settlement of dam body, which will harm dam safety. A large static triaxial test instrument was used to conduct a single line triaxial compression humidification test on dam material in the main rockfill area of a power station. The humidification deformation rule and its relationship with confining pressure and stress level were analyzed. The experimental results show that the wetting axial strain is inversely proportional to the stress level, and the wetting volume strain is proportional to the confining pressure. The wetting model can effectively reflect the changing law of dam materials, and the research results provide experimental basis for the calculation and design of the dam body wetting deformation.

Strength and deformation characteristics of waste mud–solidified soil

The treatment, disposal, and resource utilization of waste mud are challenges for engineering construction. This study investigates the road performance of waste mud–solidified soil and explains how solidifying materials influence the strength and deformation characteristics of waste mud. Unconfined compressive strength tests, consolidated undrained triaxial shear tests, resonant column tests, and consolidation compression tests were conducted to evaluate the solidification effect. The test results show that with an increase in cement content from 5 to 9%, the unconfined compressive strength of the waste mud–solidified soil increased by over 100%, the curing time was extended from 3 to 28 days, and the unconfined compressive strength increased by approximately 70%. However, an increase in initial water content from 40 to 60% reduced the unconfined compressive strength by 50%. With the increase of cement content from 5 to 9%, the cohesion and friction angles increased by approximately 78% and 24%, respectively. The initial shear modulus under dynamic shear increased by approximately 38% and the shear strain corresponding to a damping ratio decay to 70% of the initial shear modulus decreased by nearly 11%. The compression coefficient decreased by approximately 55%. Scanning electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction tests showed that a higher cement content led to the formation of more hydration reaction products, especially an increase in the content of AlPO4, which can effectively fill the pores between soil particles, enhance the bonding between soil particles, and form a skeleton with soil particles to improve compactness. Consequently, the strength of the waste mud–solidified soil increased significantly while its compressibility decreased. This study can provide data support for dynamic characteristics of waste mud solidified soil subgrade.

Effects of Remolding Water Content and Compaction Degree on the Dynamic Behavior of Compacted Clay Soils

The stable and safe operation of highway/railway lines is largely dependent on the dynamic behavior of subgrade fillings. Clay soils are widely used in subgrade construction and are compacted at different remolding water contents and compaction degrees, depending on the field conditions. As a result, their dynamic behaviors may vary, which have not been fully investigated until now. To clarify this aspect, a series of cyclic triaxial tests were carried out in this study with three typical remolding water contents (w = 19%, 24%, and 29%), corresponding to the optimum water content as well as its dry and wet sides, and two compaction degrees (Dc = 0.8 and 0.9), which were selected according to the field-testing data. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) tests were also conducted on typical samples to investigate the corresponding soil fabric variations. The findings indicate the following: (a) The soil fabric at the optimum remolding water content and its dry side was characterized by a clay aggregate assembly with a bimodal pore size distribution. In contrast, the soil fabric on the wet side of the optimum water content consisted of dispersed clay particles with a unimodal pore size distribution. (b) As the compaction degree increased, to ensure the optimum water content and its dry side, large pores were compressed to make them smaller, while small pores remained unchanged. Comparatively, all the pores on the wet side were compressed to make them smaller. (c) For each compaction degree, as the remolding water content increased, a non-monotonic changing pattern was identified for both the permanent strain and resilient modulus; the permanent strain first decreased and then increased, while, for the resilient modulus, an initial increasing trend and then a decreasing trend were identified. In addition, a larger changing rate of the permanent strain (resilient modulus) was observed on the dry side, indicating a larger effect of the remolding water content. (d) For each remolding water content, as the compaction degree increased, the permanent strain exhibited a decreasing trend, but an increasing trend was identified for the resilient modulus. Moreover, the rate of change in the permanent strain (resilient modulus) on the dry side of the optimum water content was larger than that on the wet side. In contrast, the minimum rate of change was identified at the optimum water content. The obtained results allowed for the effects of the remolding water content and compaction degree on the dynamic behavior to be analyzed, and they helped guide the construction and maintenance of the subgrade.

Total stress model of clay considering small strain characteristics

Saturated soft clay has the characteristics of high compressibility, low strength, and high structural sensitivity. Its small strain characteristics have a significant impact on the deformation development and long-term bearing capacity of ocean engineering foundations. A total stress model for undrained cyclic loading of clay considering small strain characteristics was created based on the Overlay model. The proposed model was used to simulate the static or dynamic triaxial test results of over consolidated Chicago clay, remoulded normally consolidated Georgia kaolin, and normally consolidated clay Malaysia kaolin, respectively. The results verified that the model can simulate the static shear characteristics of clay. The model can also simulate the weakening of soil strength and strain accumulation under cyclic loading, and is suitable for analyzing the response of ocean engineering foundations under long-term cyclic loading.

Experimental Study on the Effect of Polycarboxylate Superplasticizer on the Performance of Cement-Based Grouting Materials.

Polycarboxylate superplasticizers BMC-L and BMC-S were utilized as modifiers in the formulation of novel cement-based grouting materials. Indoor tests were conducted on 32 groups of cement slurries, varying by water-cement ratio (0.5:1 and 0.6:1) and modifier content (0, 2‱, 4‱, 6‱, 8‱, 10‱, 12‱, and 14‱), to test their density, funnel viscosity, water separation rate, and stone rate. Four groups of slurry modified with BMC-L were selected as the preferred slurry, and the apparent viscosity test, uniaxial, and triaxial compression test of the slurry stone body were conducted. The study investigated the influence of BMC-L on various properties of the slurry, including its apparent viscosity, uniaxial compressive strength, stress-strain relationships, shear strength parameters, and elastic modulus. Ultimately, the pore structure and phase composition of the slurry stone body were detected by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) and X-ray Diffraction (XRD), and the impact of BMC-L on slurry performance was examined from a microstructural perspective. Results indicate that the two polycarboxylate superplasticizers exert minimal influence on the density and water separation rate of the slurry. Within the effective incorporation range of the polycarboxylate superplasticizer, increasing the dosage correlates with a decrease in both the stone rate and viscosity of the slurry. BMC-L significantly enhances the mechanical properties of the slurry stone body by promoting more complete cement hydration and reducing porosity. The uniaxial compressive strength of slurry stone body with a 6 ‱ BMC-L dosage reached 29.7 MPa after 7 days and 38.5 MPa after 28 days of curing, representing increases of 118.4% and 64%, respectively, compared to masonry with 0 BMC-L dosage. The shear strength parameters and elastic modulus of the slurry stone body also showed corresponding increases.

Energy evolution and damage model of sandstone under seepage-creep-disturbance loading

The geological environment of deep coal seam is complex, and the failure mechanism of coal seam under the action of seepage pressure and disturbance stress is unclear, which restricts the development of deep ground engineering. In this study, triaxial compression test of sandstone under seepage-creep-disturbance loading (SCD) was carried out to analyze the characteristics of disturbance deformation, creep rate and permeability. The focus was on the energy evolution law of sandstone under SCD, and the damage creep model was constructed based on the energy proportion. The results show that the creep increment of sandstone under disturbed load was significantly higher than that under undisturbed load, and the stress level can promote the expansion and development of microcracks, in which the creep increment under high stress level showed a jump increase. The total energy and elastic energy of sandstone showed a step change with time. The damage factor under disturbance load was defined in the form of energy dissipation ratio, and the corresponding coupling damage factor was determined by considering the seepage factor and creep factor, which can reflect the coupled damage deformation of sandstone under SCD. Based on fractional order theory, a nonlinear damage creep model describing sandstone deformation under SCD was established by connecting the acceleration element in series with the Nishihara model and introducing the coupling damage factor. This study can provide research ideas for water inrush of coal seam rock mass.

Silty soil resilient modulus stabilised with cement and recycled aggregate

ABSTRACT The present study analysed the resilient behaviour of silty soils from the southern region of Brazil stabilised with cement and recycled aggregate (RA) from construction and demolition waste, with a maximum diameter of 4.8 mm. Its suitability for use in urban pavement layers has also been assessed. Cyclic triaxial tests were conducted on pure soil, soil-cement, and soil-cement-RA specimens under three compaction efforts: standard, intermediate, and modified. Based on the results of the cyclic triaxial tests, resilience modulus (MR) prediction models were calibrated. Subsequently, using the AEMC software, the useful life of an urban pavement was evaluated, considering the materials tested as base layers and subbase. The results indicate that incorporating cement and RA proved effective in stabilising the soil, significantly improving the resilient modulus compared to pure soil. When compacted at the modified energy and subjected to the highest stress levels, the soil-cement-RA mixture presented MR of 638 MPa, an increase of 50% compared with the soil-cement mixture, with MR of 426 MPa. The mechanistic analysis demonstrated that soil-cement and soil-cement-RA mixtures are suitable for use in base layers and subbase of urban pavements, with the soil-cement-RA mixture presenting better performance as a base material.

Experimental study on the resilient and permanent deformation of a compacted waste foundry sand

The use of Waste Foundry Sands (WFS) as a construction material in geotechnical works is strategic because it allows the consumption of large amounts of this waste worldwide, typically discarded in landfills. Beyond the achievement of environmental requirements, the construction industry needs a comprehensive understanding of its mechanical properties, which is a challenge to enhance the recycling or reuse of WFS. This paper investigates the resilient and permanent deformation of a compacted WFS under repeated load. These features are necessary to understand the behavior of this material in the context of pavement design. A campaign of laboratory tests was carried out based on cyclic triaxial tests to measure resilient modulus (RM) and permanent deformation (PD). Specimens were prepared with different densities, which achieved varying compaction energy (600, 1260, and 2700 kJ/m3) but keeping saturation degree varying in a narrow range. Results demonstrated that the resilient modulus ranges from approximately 80 to 380 MPa, with confining stress controlling its behavior and having a small effect on compaction energy. Permanent deformation reaches almost 3 % after 150.000 load cycles for the maximum confining and deviatoric stresses and is controlled by the confining and deviatoric stress. The WFS reached the shakedown state for all the densities and stress-state evaluated, in a pattern below plastic creep shakedown and plastic limit shakedown. The best models to describe the experimental results were investigated, and the fitting parameters were also found. The authors also demonstrated that the resilient modulus measured on the last 100.000 cycles of permanent deformation tests is similar to the values measured on resilient modulus tests, which allows to characterize the resilient and permanent deformation using only the permanent deformation tests.

Application of time domain reflectometry to triaxial shear tests on hydrate-bearing sediments

Various triaxial shearing apparatus are used to quantify mechanical properties of hydrate-bearing sediments which are basically required to the assessment of risks posed by dissociation of natural gas hydrates. However, the key factor, hydrate saturation, has not been well measured during triaxial shearing tests. This study aims to show how a time domain reflectometry (TDR) method nondestructively measures hydrate saturation for triaxial shear tests on hydrate-bearing sands. Hydrate saturation is determined based on the difference of volumetric water contents measured by using a flexible TDR probe with two rods after calibration. The results suggest that values of hydrate saturation acquired by the TDR method are accurate, and the flexible TDR probe can monitor the kinetic process of hydrate formation and avoid any reinforcement effects on triaxial shearing properties of test specimens.

Strain characteristics of reinforced soft clay around tunnel under metro loads

This study investigates the Strain characteristics of reinforced soft clay surrounding a tunnel subjected to cyclic loading, employing the Global Digital Systems cyclic triaxial test on the saturated reinforced clay near Shanghai Metro Line 4’s Hailun Road station. Initially, the study examines the impacts of frequency, dynamic stress amplitude (DSA), and loading cycles on cumulative plastic strain. Following this, the orthogonal design method was employed to organize tests, and an evaluation method for assessing soil strain was developed through mathematical statistical analysis. The results indicate at the constant vibration frequency, cumulative plastic strain increases with an increase in DSA and decreases with as load frequency increases. DSA is the primary factor influencing the axial deformation of subway tunnels, whereas the interaction between load frequency and vibration frequency is negligible. The findings suggest that measures to prevent and control subway tunnel settlement should concentrate on DSA during the early stages of subway operation.

Mechanical Properties of Rock Salt from the Kłodawa Salt Dome-A Statistical Analysis of Geomechanical Data.

Rock salt is a potential medium for underground storage of energy resources and radioactive substances due to its physical and mechanical properties, distinguishing it from other rock media. Designing storage facilities that ensure stability, tightness, and safety requires understanding the geomechanical properties of rock salt. Despite numerous research efforts on the behaviour of rock salt mass, many cases still show unfavourable phenomena occurring within it. Therefore, the formulation of strength criteria in a three-dimensional stress state and the prediction of deformation processes significantly impact the functionality of storage in salt caverns. This article presents rock salt's mechanical properties from the Kłodawa salt dome and a statistical analysis of the determined geomechanical data. The analysis is divided into individual mining fields (Fields 1-6). The analysis of numerical parameter values obtained in uniaxial compression tests for rock salt from mining Fields 1-6 indicates an average variation in their strength and deformation properties. Upon comparing the results of Young's modulus (E) with uniaxial compressive strength (UCS), its value was observed with a decrease in uniaxial compressive strength (E = 4.19968·UCS2, R-square = -0.61). The tensile strength of rock salt from mining Fields 1-6 also exhibits moderate variability. An increasing trend in tensile strength was observed with increased bulk density (σt = 0.0027697·ρ - 4.5892, r = 0.60). However, the results of triaxial tests indicated that within the entire range of normal stresses, the process of increasing maximum shear stresses occurs linearly ((σ1 - σ3)/2 = ((σ1 + σ3)/2)·0.610676 + 2.28335, r = 0.92). A linear relationship was also obtained for failure stresses as a function of radial stresses (σ1 = σ3·2.51861 + 32.9488, r = 0.73). Based on the results, the most homogeneous rock salt was from Field 2 and Field 6, while the most variable rock salt was from Field 3.

Mechanical Properties and Constitutive Model for Artificially Structured Soils under Undrained Conditions

Triaxial tests are performed for remolded, artificially isotropic, and anisotropic structured samples under undrained conditions at confining pressures of 25, 100, and 200 kPa. Based on these test results, a binary-medium constitutive model is formulated based on homogenization theory and a breakage mechanism to describe the behaviors of structured soils. In this model, the binary-medium material is idealized as a representative volume element (RVE) composed of bonded elements, whose mechanical behaviors are expressed by the linearly elastic model, and frictional elements, whose mechanical behaviors are described by the double-yield surfaces constitutive model. The parameters of the bonded and frictional elements are determined from the test results of structured and remolded samples, respectively. The expressions for the breakage ratio and local stress coefficient matrix are introduced, and their parameters are provided. The computed results are compared with the test results, demonstrating that the model can reflect the main deformation features of structured soil relatively well, including the influence of anisotropy, gradual damage to particle bonding, and pore development.

Evolution of Soil Pore Structure and Shear Strength Deterioration of Compacted Soil under Controlled Wetting and Drying Cycles

This study investigates the evolution of soil pore structure and shear strength deterioration in compacted clayey soil under controlled wetting and drying (wd) cycles, which are expected to become more frequent due to climate change. Thirty soil samples were compacted at optimal moisture content and 90% maximum dry density. These samples were then subjected to 0, 1, 5, 10, and 15 controlled wd cycles from saturation to the wilting point, and volumetric changes were recorded during each cycle. After the wd treatment, the soil samples were scanned using X-ray computed tomography (CT) at 50 μm resolution and then sheared under unconsolidated–undrained and consolidated–undrained conditions in a triaxial test. Significant shrinkage and swelling of soil samples were observed during wd cycles, with average volumetric strain fluctuating between +12% at saturation and −5% at the wilting point. X-ray CT visualisation and analysis revealed higher porosity, more prominent pores, and increased pore length in soil samples with increasing wd cycles. Both undrained and effective soil shear strength markedly decreased with increasing wd cycles. CT-derived macroporosity and pore length were significant predictors of the soil’s undrained and effective shear strength when exposed to wd cycles. The findings emphasise the considerable impact of climate change, specifically wd cycles, on clayey soil, highlighting the need for consideration in the design of earth-based infrastructure.

Multi-angle property analysis and stress–strain curve prediction of cementitious sand gravel based on triaxial test

In order to further promote the application of cementitious sand gravel (CSG), the mechanical properties and variation rules of CSG material under triaxial test were studied. Considering the influence of fly ash content, water-binder ratio, sand rate and lateral confining pressure, 81 cylinder specimens were designed and made for conventional triaxial test, and the influence laws of stress–strain curve, failure pattern, elastic modulus, energy dissipation and damage evolution of specimens were analyzed. The results showed that the peak of stress–strain curve increased with the increase of confining pressure, and the peak stress, peak strain and energy dissipation all increased significantly, but the damage variable D decreased with the increase of confining pressure. Under triaxial compression, the specimen was basically sheared failure from the bonding surface, and the aggregate generally did not break. Sand rate had a significant effect on the peak stress of CSG, and decreased with the increase of sand rate. Under the conditions of the same cement content, fly ash content and confining pressure, the optimal water-binder ratio 1.2 existed when the sand rate was 0.2 and 0.3. After analyzing and processing the stress–strain curve of triaxial test, a Cuckoo Search-eXtreme Gradient Boosting (CS-XGBoost) curve prediction model was established, and the model was evaluated by evaluation indexes R2, RMSE and MAE. The average R2 of the XGBoost model based on initial parameters under 18 different output features was 0.8573, and the average R2 of the CS-XGBoost model was 0.9516, an increase of 10.10%. Moreover, the prediction curve was highly consistent with the test curve, indicating that the CS algorithm had significant advantages. The CS-XGBoost model could accurately predict the triaxial stress–strain curve of CSG.

On the influence of the shearing rate on the monotonic and cyclic response of Malaysian kaolin

This paper experimentally evaluates the influence of shearing rate on the monotonic and cyclic response of isotropically consolidated samples of Malaysian kaolin. On the one hand, a series of undrained monotonic triaxial tests were performed with varying shearing displacement rate. On the other hand, undrained cyclic triaxial tests were conducted considering different deviatoric stress amplitudes and loading frequencies. The well-known soil rate dependency under monotonic loading was confirmed up to a displacement rate threshold. The experimental results under cyclic loading suggest that for the given loading frequency, the variation of the deviatoric stress amplitude remarkably influences the strains and pore water pressure accumulation rates. In addition, the results suggest that, depending on the loading frequency, different shapes of mobilised effective stress loops are obtained. Larger loading frequencies lead to banana-shaped effective stress loops, while smaller frequencies reproduce eight-shaped effective stress loops. Furthermore, higher loading frequencies result in a larger number of cycles required to reach failure conditions. The reasons for the observed differences in the behaviour are thoroughly analysed and discussed.