Human cutaneous microdialysis approaches for assessing nitric oxide (NO)-dependent blood flow include local heating (LH) of the skin until a plateau is reached, followed by infusion of a NO synthase inhibitor such as L-NAME; however, varied methods of quantifying and expressing NO-dependent vasodilation can obfuscate data interpretation and reproducibility. We retrospectively assessed NO-dependent vasodilation during LH to 39°C or 42°C, calculated as the: (1) absolute contribution of the NO-dependent component (along with baseline and the non-NO-dependent component) to the total cutaneous vascular conductance (CVC) response to LH, normalized to maximal CVC (%CVCmax); (2) difference in %CVCmax (∆%CVCmax) between the LH plateau and post-NO inhibition (L-NAME plateau; ∆%CVCmax=LH plateau-L-NAME plateau); (3) percentage of the LH plateau attributable to ∆%CVCmax (%Plateau = ∆%CVCmax/LH plateau*100); and (4) %Plateau when correcting for baseline. The LH plateaus during 39°C and 42°C were 48±17 %CVCmax (9±5% baseline; 2±4% non-NO-dependent; 36±15% NO-dependent) and 88±10 %CVCmax (15±8% baseline; 9±10% non-NO-dependent; 64±13% NO-dependent), respectively. The absolute contributions of the non-NO-dependent and NO-dependent components of the response (p<0.0001) and the ∆%CVCmax (66±14% vs. 38±15%) were greater during 42°C compared with 39°C (all p≤0.02); however, there were no differences between the two protocols in %Plateau (75±13% vs. 80±10%; p=0.57) or %PlateauBL (88±14% vs. 95±8%; p=0.31). For both protocols, the values were greater for %PlateauBL versus ∆%CVCmax and %Plateau (p≤0.0001), and for %Plateau versus ∆%CVCmax (p≤0.05). Quantification of NO-dependent skin vasodilation responses to LH is dependent upon the mathematical approach and verbal description, which can meaningfully impact data interpretation and reproducibility.