Although using crumb tire rubber concrete (CTRC) in constructing structural elements is accompanied by various environmental and economic advantages, it always comes with challenges due to a significant loss in some mechanical properties of this concrete type. To tackle this challenge, a novel technique of compressing fresh concrete was used, and its impacts on improving the mechanical features of CTRC were investigated. For this purpose, concrete specimens containing crumb tire rubber (CTR), as the fine aggregate substitute, were constructed considering the variables of the water-to-cement ratio (w/c), volume percentage of CTR, and the fresh concrete pressure level as a fraction of steel tube (mold) yielding stress. After the application of a specified short-term pressure to the fresh mix inside the steel molds and the time required for the concrete setting, the steel tubes were removed after curing, and the concrete core alone was exposed to an axial compressive load. According to the test results, the mechanical properties, weight loss resulting from compressing the fresh concrete, energy absorption, failure pattern, the concrete microstructure, water absorption, and porosity were evaluated. By applying an initial axial pressure of 25–80 MPa on the mixes containing 0 %, 15 %, and 30 % CTR replacing the fine aggregate, the compressive strength, the ultimate strain, the toughness, and the initial modulus of elasticity experienced 100–140 % increase, 130–420 % increase, 120–1140 % increase, and 66–70 % decrease, respectively, compared with the uncompressed specimen. Finally, a regression analysis was employed to propose prediction models for the compressive capacity, modulus of elasticity, peak strain, ultimate strain, and relative toughness of freshly compressed concrete containing CTR particles; these models show proper agreement with the experimental results.