This research investigates the impact of unique spherical ball shoulder enhancement tool pin configurations on the friction stir welding (FSW) of AA2219 aluminum alloy under various parameters. FSW was performed using three different pin shapes: square, hexagonal, and octagonal. Testing samples were prepared using an L9 orthogonal array layout with varying welding parameters. The material behavior in the three distinct weld zones was evaluated for each pin configuration. Results indicated superior microhardness values in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and thermo-mechanically affected zone (TMAZ) compared to the weld nugget zone. Elemental composition analysis of the TMAZ revealed significant differences, highlighting the influence of thermal stress and material behavior due to the tool pin and shoulder configuration. The square-headed tool demonstrated improved tensile strength and microhardness. Optimal welding performance was achieved with a spindle speed of 1000 RPM, a travel speed of 25 mm/min, and a tilt angle of 3°. Variations in Cu content in the TMAZ and HAZ underscored localized modifications within the material structure, driven by the spherical ball spinning effects on the shoulder. Tensile tests showed that welds made with the square pin consistently exhibited higher tensile strength compared to those made with hexagonal and octagonal pins.