INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES: Tubeless PCNL is underutilized, usually as an option in nonbleeding, uncomplicated monotracts with complete stone clearance & decided intraoperatively. In this study we evaluated its feasibility, safety and efficacy in a tertiary teaching institute. METHODS: Forty (40) patients were alternately randomized (1:1) into tube (T) and tubeless (TL) PCNL groups. Tract dilatations were done using Alken metal dilators, no sealant or electrocautery was used for hemostasis and a 6 Fr JJ stent was kept. In T group 24 Fr nephrostomy tubes were placed. In TL group JJ stent was removed at 48 hours after operation and in tube group it was removed 1 week after drying of nephrostomy site. In TL group deep skin stitched were applied. Analgesic (intravenous tramadol) requirement and Visual Analogue Scores (noted every 3 hours) were recorded in first 48 hours (hrs). Postoperative X-ray KUB (on Day1) and ultrasound scans (on postoperative days 1, 2, 3 and 3 weeks) were done in all to see stone clearance and perinephric/puncture tract/intrarenal collection or hematoma. RESULTS: Demographic data and outcomes are shown in table 1. One procedure in TL required conversion to tube because of intraoperatively diagnosed pleural violation. Despite complicated calculi (55%) and high risk situations (50%), none in TL group had any significant perinephric collection or severe postoperative bleeding requiring any intervention. Patient age, size and type of stones, punctures, stone clearance rate, hematuria clearance time, mean haemoglobin drop, transfusion requirements, and complication rate were similar in both groups. TL-PCNL is superior (p values 0.05) to T-PCNL in terms of VAS pain scores and analgesic requirement in first 48 hrs, leak from tract site and hospital stay. CONCLUSIONS: In TL PCNL, deep skin stitches with JJ stenting for 48 hrs ensure a good local bleeding control and a dry tract site. TL-PCNL may be considered a new standard for PCNL. Nephrostomy should only be used for specific purposes like intraoperative pleural violation, major pelvicalyceal injury, balloon tamponading or relook. Parameter Tube group Tubeless group Number of patients(Right/left side) 20(13/7) 20(11/9) Age in years(mean/range) 33.2(15-55) 36.7(17-52) Sex(M:F) 2.3:1 3:1 Stone burden(maximum diameter in cms) (mean/range) 2.72(1.8-3.8) 2.56(1.9-4.2) No. of patients with Simple Calculi(Pelvis/ Calyceal) 8(6/2) 9(7/2) No. of patients with Complex Calculi(Multiple pole calculi/ Staghorns) 12(7/5) 11(7/4) No.of punctures(mean/range) 1.4(1-3) 1.3(1-3) Tracts: single/multiple(No.of pts.) 14/6 15/5 High risk situations : Infundibular tear/ Extravasation & tract loss/ Obvious bleeding/ Stone guided punctures (No.of pts.) 2/1/4/1 2/1/5/2 Operative time in minutes (mean/range) 106(60-170) 108(80-130) Hemoglobin drop in gm/dl (mean/range) 1.36(0-4.1) 1.21(0-3.1) VAS score in 0-24 hrs & 25-48 hrs(mean/range) 3.5(2.1-4.6) & 2.5(1-3.5) 2.4(0-3.8) & 1.9(0.5-2.5) Analgesic (tramadol in mg)requirement in 0-48 hrs (mean/range) 165(100-250) 85(50-100) Hematuria settling time in hrs(mean/range) 29.1(6-192) 36(3-160) Nephrostomy removal time in hrs(mean/range) 42.6(30-72) Not applicable(NA) Tract site leak duration in hrs(mean/range) 13.8(0-72) 0 Hospital stay in hrs(mean/range) 121.4(50-168) 88.3(52-210) Blood transfusion(No.of pts.) 4 3 Complications:Hydro-pneumothorax/ UTI/Late hematuria(No.of pts.) 1/3/0 1/2/1 Complete stone clearance rate : after first procedure/ after relook/ At 3 weeks follow up(in %) 70/80/90 70/NA/85
Read full abstract