Table Mountain Research Articles

Application of a trait‐based climate change vulnerability assessment to determine management priorities at protected area scale

AbstractEstimating and planning for the impacts of climate change on the biodiversity of protected areas is a major challenge for conservation managers. When these areas are topographically heterogenous and contain species' entire ranges, this challenge is exacerbated because the coarse spatial scales of Global Circulation Model projections provide limited information for within‐park management. South Africa's Table Mountain National Park, home to three endemic amphibian species in just ~24,500 hectares, provides a case study for identifying conservation needs under climate change. Selecting the park's herpetofauna as pilot taxa, we identified life history and demographic characteristics believed to make species more sensitive and less able to adapt to climate change. We organized these into assessment frameworks and, through a combination of literature review and expert elicitation, reviewed and used them to assess climate change vulnerability of 18 amphibian and 41 reptile species. The assessment highlighted that 73% and 67% of the park's reptile and amphibian species, respectively, had at least one high‐sensitivity and low‐adaptive capacity trait. Using ordinal and additive scoring methods, we identified the species most vulnerable to climate change and highlight the park areas containing their highest concentrations. These areas will be used to inform landscape‐scale management priorities and park use zones. The current IUCN Red List assessments for these species do not incorporate climate change vulnerability. Considering some species appear to be threatened by climate change, their conservation needs might be underestimated. Identifying the most vulnerable species and the mechanisms underpinning their vulnerability can guide the identification and prioritization of conservation needs, while the highlighted knowledge gaps inform priorities for monitoring and research. While comprehensive climate change adaptation planning for Table Mountain National Park requires additional assessment of other taxonomic groups, this trait‐based assessment example highlights a viable tool for assessing climate change vulnerability in protected areas.

THE INFLUENCE OF SEASONS ON METAL BIOACCUMULATIONAND OXIDATIVE STRESS IN SENTINEL ORGANISMS IN SOUTHAFRICAN URBAN FORESTS

Variations in Al, Fe and Mn concentrations in soil, leaf litter, moss, lichen and pill millipedes, as well as the induced oxidative stress effect of metals on the organisms, between the dry and the wet season within two Afromontane forests in the Western Cape were investigated. The two forests in the closest proximity of the Cape Town city centre and urban pollution sources were chosen to determine the difference of metal contamination between the dry, hot and cold, wet season. Three sampling sites were chosen within each forest at different altitudes on Table Mountain, as well asa control site, where the soil, leaf litter and each organism were randomly collected in both the dry and the wet seasons for metal and biochemical analysis. The metals in the wet season in both of the forests showed higher concentrations, as did the forest closest to the Cape Town city centre.This is indicative of higher levels of pollution due to increased anthropogenic activities in the wetseason. Oxidative stress in organisms was apparent in the varying tGSH levels, of which the dryseason mostly revealed the higher concentrations. Oxidative lipid damage (measured as MDA) levels were generally increased during the wet season when the metal concentrations were higher as a result of prominent brown haze episodes in winter. Urban forest ecosystems in urban cities may suffer irreparable damage resulting from metal contamination, more so in the colder wet season.

Assessing protected area vulnerability to climate change in a case study of South African national parks.

Climate change is challenging the ability of protected areas (PAs) to meet their objectives. To improve PA planning, we developed a framework for assessing PA vulnerability to climate change based on consideration of potential climate change impacts on species and their habitats and resource use. Furthermore, the capacity of PAs to adapt to these climate threats was determined through assessment of PA management effectiveness, adjacent land use, and financial resilience. Users reach a PA-specific vulnerability score and rank based on scoring of these categories. We applied the framework to South Africa's 19 national parks. Because the 19 parks are managed as a national network, we explored how resources might be best allocated to address climate change. Each park's importance to the network's biodiversity conservation and revenue generation was estimated and used to weight overall vulnerability scores and ranks. Park vulnerability profiles showed distinct combinations of potential impacts of climate change and adaptive capacities; the former had a greater influence on vulnerability. Mapungubwe National Park emerged as the most vulnerable to climate change, despite its relatively high adaptive capacity, largely owing to large projected changes in species and resource use. Table Mountain National Park scored the lowest in overall vulnerability. Climate change vulnerability rankings differed markedly once importance weightings were applied; Kruger National Park was the most vulnerable under both importance scenarios. Climate change vulnerability assessment is fundamental to effective adaptation planning. Our PA assessment tool is the only tool that quantifies PA vulnerability to climate change in a comparative index. It may be used in data-rich and data-poor contexts to prioritize resource allocation across PA networks and can be applied from local to global scales.

Mammals of the Cape of Good Hope Nature Reserve, Western Cape, South Africa

The status of all the mammal species that have been recorded in the Cape of Good Hope Nature Reserve (the southern section of the Ta-ble Mountain National Park) is described. A total of 76 species has been recorded, of which 56 occur or have occurred naturally, and 13 are now extinct. More than 20 species have been deliberately or acci-dentally introduced. The history and management of large, non-native herbivores released into the Reserve for public spectacle is described in the context of changing attitudes towards conservation priorities and visitor perceptions.

Using recreational divers to inform more efficient conservation management within a MPA - A case study from the Cape Peninsula, South Africa

In South Africa, recreational scuba diving is a popular coastal activity, which is largely carried out within Marine Protected Areas (MPAs). MPAs act as the basis for marine conservation in the country, operating as the primary tool for the management of the country's marine resources. Effective management of MPAs depends on the uptake of voluntary guidelines, including Codes of Conduct by recreational users, such as the scuba diving community. With a focus on the MPA of Table Mountain National Park (TMNP), this paper aims to determine the value that Cape divers attach to the marine environment in which they dive, their understanding of the role of the TMNP MPA, and their knowledge and attitudes regarding its management. A semi-structured questionnaire with responses from around 30% of the local diving community showed that while users attached a high value to the MPA in which they dive, they presented a lack of knowledge around the regulations and conditions involved with diving within the MPA. This is associated with poor dissemination of user information and general awareness. In-depth interviews with dive operators and management personnel of the MPA indicated a disconnect between the different levels of management, operators and users. Based on this research, we propose alternative and additional management strategies for recreational scuba diving that would contribute to the success of the TMNP MPA including increased collaboration with the dive community for citizen science activities, improved stakeholder engagement and better access to information on management regulations and expectations.

Distribution of Melaleuca rugulosa (Schlechtendal ex Link) Craven (Myrtaceae) in South Africa: Assessment of invasiveness and feasibility of eradication

Several Melaleuca (Myrtaceae) species are invasive globally. Recently an increase in invasive species from this genus have been reported in South Africa. Here we document the first detailed assessment of the distribution and invasive potential of Melaleuca rugulosa in South Africa. We assess population structure, determine the current and potential future distribution in South Africa using climatic variables, conduct a risk analysis, provide recommendations for management, and consider the feasibility of eradication. We found one naturalising population of ∼665 individuals covering more than 1.2 hectares. It was first recorded in 1961 invading the native fynbos vegetation in the Table Mountain National Park (TMNP). Two recent fires – in 2009 and 2016 – likely enhanced spread, this spread happened despite undocumented clearing attempts in the last decade. The south-western Cape is the most climatically suitable for M. rugulosa, with most other wetter areas of the country being only partly suitable regions. The risk analysis indicated a medium risk, and we suggest listing M. rugulosa as category 1a (eradication target) under the South African National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act (10/ 2004). Given the small area occupied, ease of access and the lack of a soil seed bank, the population can be extirpated from Devil's Peak within the TMNP. We highlight that serotinous alien species, particular from the Myrtaceae, should receive more attention as potential invasive species in fire-driven ecosystems and that their lack of invasiveness in areas where fire is suppressed, should not be misinterpreted as being a low-risk species.

Relational Values of Cultural Ecosystem Services in an Urban Conservation Area: The Case of Table Mountain National Park, South Africa

This paper assesses how residents of a developing city in the Global South, recognize and value the multiple diverse cultural ecosystem services associated with freshwater ecosystems, as provided by different landscape features originating in an urban protected area. This objective was achieved by establishing who benefits from freshwater ecosystem services, uncovering the spatial and temporal relationships these beneficiaries have with landscape features, and determining the relational nature of ecosystem service values, benefits and trade-offs as experienced by the different users. Recreation, aesthetic and existence services were valued highest by respondents. People who live closer to the park use, and benefit from, the park’s freshwater ecosystems more frequently than those living further away. Park visitors want ease of access in terms of distance to specific freshwater ecosystems, and then once there, they want a diversity of activity options, such as recreation opportunities, as well as places to reflect and meditate. This study of cultural ecosystem services improves our understanding of social-ecological systems in urban areas by exploring the relationships between park and people which can guide management to ensure equitable and sustainable ecosystem service provision to all city residents.

Neptune’s Moon Triton: Continuing Surface Seasonal Volatile Transport

Observations of Triton’s rotational light curve from Table Mountain Observatory in 2017 show that volatile transport is continuing on its surface. Changes in the light curve are consistent with sustained increases in albedo in two patches near the equator at longitudes of ∼120° and ∼280°, as first reported by Bauer et al. based on observations obtained with the Hubble Space Telescope. An early observation of Triton’s visual albedo shows a substantially lower albedo in the past, when the northern polar region was visible. This result confirms the hypothesis of Moore & Spencer and Spencer & Moore of a net flux of volatile material into the southern hemisphere of Triton over much of the satellite’s history and up to the present. The averaged V-band geometric albedo of Triton has been stable over the past three decades. The color of Triton has also been stable during the past decade.

Characteristics of differential lunar laser ranging

Context. To obtain more details about the lunar interior, a station at Table Mountain Observatory of JPL will enable a new measurement of lunar laser ranging (LLR), known as differential lunar laser ranging (DLLR). It will provide a novel type of observable, namely, the lunar range difference, which is the difference of two consecutive ranges obtained via a single station swiftly switching between two or more lunar reflectors. This previously unavailable observation will have a very high level of accuracy (about 30 μm), mainly resulting from a reduction in the Earth’s atmospheric error. In addition to the intended improvements for the lunar part, it is expected to contribute to improved relativity tests, for instance, the equivalence principle (EP). Aims. This paper focuses on the simulation and investigation of the characteristics of DLLR. Methods. Using simulated DLLR data, we analyzed and compared the parameter sensitivity, correlation, and accuracy obtained by DLLR with those attained by LLR. Results. The DLLR measurement maintains almost the same sensitivity to certain parameters (called group A) as that of LLR, such as the lunar orientation parameters. For other parameters (called group B), such as station coordinates, it is shown to be less sensitive. However, owing to its extraordinary measurement accuracy, it not only retains nearly the same level of accuracy of group B as LLR, but it also improves the estimation of group A significantly (with the exception of reflector coordinates, due to the DLLR measuring mode). Also, DLLR increases the correlations among the reflectors and between stations and reflectors caused by its constellation. Additionally, we compared different switching intervals with respect to sensitivity and correlation. Large switching intervals are more beneficial for group B and the decorrelation of stations and reflectors. Furthermore, DLLR enhances the accuracy of EP tests.

Evaluating the PurpleAir monitor as an aerosol light scattering instrument

Abstract. The Plantower PMS5003 sensors (PMS) used in the PurpleAir monitor PA-II-SD configuration (PA-PMS) are equivalent to cell-reciprocal nephelometers using a 657 nm perpendicularly polarized light source that integrates light scattering from 18 to 166∘. Yearlong field data at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) Mauna Loa Observatory (MLO) and Boulder Table Mountain (BOS) sites show that the 1 h average of the PA-PMS first size channel, labeled “> 0.3 µm” (“CH1”), is highly correlated with submicrometer aerosol scattering coefficients at the 550 and 700 nm wavelengths measured by the TSI 3563 integrating nephelometer, from 0.4 to 500 Mm−1. This corresponds to an hourly average submicrometer aerosol mass concentration of approximately 0.2 to 200 µg m−3. A physical–optical model of the PMS is developed to estimate light intensity on the photodiode, accounting for angular truncation of the volume scattering function as a function of particle size. The model predicts that the PMS response to particles > 0.3 µm decreases relative to an ideal nephelometer by about 75 % for particle diameters ≥ 1.0 µm. This is a result of using a laser that is polarized, the angular truncation of the scattered light, and particle losses (e.g., due to aspiration) before reaching the laser. It is shown that CH1 is linearly proportional to the model-predicted intensity of the light scattered by particles in the PMS laser to its photodiode over 4 orders of magnitude. This is consistent with CH1 being a measure of the scattering coefficient and not the particle number concentration or particulate matter concentration. The model predictions are consistent with data from published laboratory studies which evaluated the PMS against a variety of aerosols. Predictions are then compared with yearlong fine aerosol size distribution and scattering coefficient field data at the BOS site. Field data at BOS confirm the model prediction that the ratio of CH1 to the scattering coefficient would be highest for aerosols with median scattering diameters < 0.3 µm. The PMS detects aerosols smaller than 0.3 µm diameter in proportion to their contribution to the scattering coefficient. The results of this study indicate that the PMS is not an optical particle counter and that its six size fractions are not a meaningful representation of particle size distribution. The relationship between the PMS 1 h average CH1 and bsp1, the scattering coefficient in Mm−1 due to particles below 1 µm aerodynamic diameter, at wavelength 550 nm, is found to be bsp1 = 0.015 ± 2.07 × 10−5 × CH1, for relative humidity below 40 %. The coefficient of determination r2 is 0.97. This suggests that the low-cost and widely used PA monitors can be used to measure and predict the submicron aerosol light scattering coefficient in the mid-visible nearly as well as integrating nephelometers. The effectiveness of the PA-PMS to serve as a PM2.5 mass concentration monitor is due to both the sensor behaving like an imperfect integrating nephelometer and the mass scattering efficiency of ambient PM2.5 aerosols being roughly constant.

Optimization of technogenic landscapes of the Crimea. Report 2. Landfills, embankments and dumps

The problem of waste is one of the most urgent in the world. The Russian Federation and the Republic of the Crimea are no exception. More than 30 billion tons of garbage has been placed on the territory of the Russian Federation, it is expected that almost all Russian landfills will overflow in the next five years. In the Crimea, outside the boundaries of settlements, 293 landfills with a total area of more than 1.054 million square meters remain not liquidated (in comparison with the indicators as of 12.03.2021, the number of non-liquidated landfills outside the boundaries of settlements increased by 4 units, and the area of landfills increased by 889 sq. m.). Optimization of anthropogenic objects is decided by the correct choice of location and operation of the dump, as well as by giving it the appropriate shape and proper landscaping, that is, using what is called the integration of the object into the landscape. Under any circumstances, the formation of a dump should be preceded by the removal of the topsoil, its storage and preservation. The most important form of dump should be considered a terraced table mountain with a steepness of 1:3 and a rounding of the talus base. Dumps above 10 m are terraced with a ledge width of at least 4 m. It is extremely important to ensure control over surface water runoff by laying small canals on the slopes and bordering the perimeter with a plantation strip at least 5 m wide. Phyto-reclamation measures on a poor substrate should be carried out using green manure, combining legumes and cereals (legumes: meadow clover, white clover, yellow alfalfa, horned clover, Hungarian sainfoin, etc.; cereals: orchard grass, desert wheatgrass, awnless brome grass, meadow fescue, pasture ryegrass, etc.). Young plants of avant-garde trees and shrubs are planted according to a layout pattern of 2.5 x 2.5 to 0.75 x 0.75 m. The more difficult the natural conditions, the denser the planting should be. Any types of trees and shrubs that grow rapidly in these conditions are used as vanguard. The main types of trees are initially planted in an amount of 4,000 to 6,000 pieces. This means that the distance between the rows is 1.5-2 m, and the distance between plants in a row is from 1 to 1.5 m. The avant-garde species of trees and shrubs are placed evenly in groups or rows. The main types of trees and shrubs are placed in groups of at least 10 seedlings of the same species.

Natural radioactivity and metal concentration in the Thyspunt area, Eastern Cape Province, South Africa

Naturally occurring radionuclides and metals have adverse human health impacts when they occur at higher activity and concentration above the threshold value, respectively, in the water supply system. This study aimed to establish the baseline radionuclide and metal content in rocks, soils, and water in the Thyspunt area of the Eastern Cape Province, South Africa, which is selected as a potential site for the development of a nuclear power plant. Extensive sampling of rocks, soils, groundwater, and surface water was conducted in the area. The employed methods of sample analyses include ICP-MS, gamma-ray spectrometery (RS 230), and accelerator mass spectrometry. The results indicate that the Ceres Subgroup shale and the Skurwerburg formation quartzite of the Table Mountain Group (TMG) contain the highest activity of most radionuclides, including 238U, 235U, 234U, 226Ra, 232Th, and 210Pb; these are linked to the natural geochemistry of the rocks that have been facilitated by the low-grade metamorphism to which the local geology was subjected. The metamorphism-related radionuclide enrichment is also apparent in the soils and groundwater associated with these rocks. The activity of the radiotoxic and carcinogenic uranium (238U and 235U) and radium (226Ra and 224Ra) isotopes in water was found to be well above the WHO guideline of 0.03 and 1Bq/L, respectively. The exposure dose rate was the highest in the Ceres Subgroup shales (185.7 nS/h), and this is linked to the elevated natural radioactivity in the rocks. The estimate of the ingestion-related effective dose indicates high doses associated with the uranium and radium isotopes, thus signifying the potential adverse impact on human health associated with the ingestion of the widely used groundwater in the area.

Siricid Parasitoids (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) From Eastern White Pine and Associated Pine Species in Southern Appalachia

Siricid Parasitoids (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) From Eastern White Pine and Associated Pine Species in Southern Appalachia

THE COMPLEX OF ANCIENT OBSERVATORIES ON THE TABLE MOUNTAIN IN INGUSHETIA

The proximity of the three ancient sanctuaries to each other on the flat top of the Table Mountain against the background of the sacred peaks of Kazbek and Tsey-Loam, the opportunity to observe the sunrises and sunsets in the highlands of the Caucasus, cosmogonic myths, all this gave an assumption about the astronomical functions of these sanctuaries. The purpose of the study was to prove that these ancient sanctuaries were used by the priests to determine the key moments in the annual cycle of the Sun and were a calendar.
 This is proved by using special computer programs and calculators that determine the azimuth and altitude of the Sun; instrumental observations and measurements on the ground.
 It is established that the shrines of Myat-Seli and Myater-Dyal on Table Mountain in Ingushetia are a complex of medieval solar near-horizon observatories. And it is hypothesized that these sanctuaries were built on the site from which solar cycles were observed from about the beginning of the 1st millennium BC. This work also provides prerequisites for determining various astronomical observations from sanctuaries and the presence of other ancient observatories in the Caucasus. A method has been developed for searching for prehistoric solar, lunar and stellar near-horizon observatories.

Diurnal variability of stratospheric column NO<sub>2</sub> measured using direct solar and lunar spectra over Table Mountain, California (34.38° N)

Abstract. A full diurnal measurement of stratospheric column NO2 has been made over the Jet Propulsion Laboratory's Table Mountain Facility (TMF) located in the mountains above Los Angeles, California, USA (2.286 km above mean sea level, 34.38∘ N, 117.68∘ W). During a representative week in October 2018, a grating spectrometer measured the telluric NO2 absorptions in direct solar and lunar spectra. The stratospheric column NO2 is retrieved using a modified minimum-amount Langley extrapolation, which enables us to accurately treat the non-constant NO2 diurnal cycle abundance and the effects of tropospheric pollution near the measurement site. The measured 24 h cycle of stratospheric column NO2 on clean days agrees with a 1-D photochemical model calculation, including the monotonic changes during daytime and nighttime due to the exchange with the N2O5 reservoir and the abrupt changes at sunrise and sunset due to the activation or deactivation of the NO2 photodissociation. The observed daytime NO2 increasing rate is (1.34±0.24)×1014 cm−2 h−1. The observed NO2 in one of the afternoons during the measurement period was much higher than the model simulation, implying the influence of urban pollution from nearby counties. A 24 h back-trajectory analysis shows that the wind first came from inland in the northeast and reached southern Los Angeles before it turned northeast and finally arrived at TMF, allowing it to pick up pollutants from Riverside County, Orange County, and downtown Los Angeles.

Local-scale environmental filtering shape plant taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity in an isolated Amazonian tepui (Tepequém table mountain)

Understanding how environmental drivers induce changes in plant composition and diversity across evolutionary time can provide important insights into community assembly mechanisms. We evaluated how taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity and structure of plant communities change along a local-scale edaphic and elevational gradient in the Tepequém table mountain, Brazilian Amazon. We selected three phytophysiognomies along the altitudinal gradient: Open Rupestrian Grassland, Shrubby Rupestrian Grassland, and Forest. We compared community composition and taxonomic and phylogenetic diversity between phytophysiognomies, and analysed effects of altitude and soil properties on species richness and phylogenetic metrics using linear mixed-effects models. The highest species richness and phylogenetic diversity were found at a lower elevation for Forest. All standardised phylogenetic metrics were significantly lower in Shrubby Rupestrian Grassland. This phytophysiognomy showed phylogenetic clustering. Forest showed a cluster pattern when only terminal nodes are considered and random dispersion to deep phylogenetic nodes. Open Rupestrian Grassland also showed a random phylogenetic structure. The linear mixed-effects models showed that species richness and different phylogenetic structure metrics were explained by altitude and soil properties. Our study revealed that key plant diversity dimensions (i.e. taxonomic and phylogenetic) are shaped by a local-scale edaphic and elevational gradient on an isolated tepui of Brazilian Amazonian.

Disentangling fine-scale effects of soil properties as key driver of plant community diversity on Roraima table mountain, Guayana Highlands

The Guayana Highlands (GH) represents a major center of Neotropical plant diversity and endemism. Considering the lack of information about the ecology of plant communities in this region, we analyzed the fine-scale pattern of vegetation diversity. Thus, we tested the fine-scale effects of abiotic filters (i.e. soil physicochemical properties and depth) on species richness and community composition in complex rocky outcrop landscapes at the Roraima table mountain summit. This tepui is located on the triple boundary shared by Brazil, Venezuela and Guyana. A total of 60 plots were allocated in three specific previously identified geoenvironments: Peaty Rupestrian Grassland, Bonnetia-Shrubby Rupestrian Grassland and Sandy Rupestrian Grassland. Overall, 4318 individuals were sampled, distributed among 60 species, especially belonging to the families Asteraceae and Bromeliaceae. Of this total, 27 (45%) species are endemic to GH. There were significant differences among the geoenvironments regarding species richness, community composition and soil attributes. The tested models demonstrated that species richness was influenced by variations in potential acidity; however, community composition was explained mainly by soil texture and depth effects. Our study revealed abiotic filters exerted crucial fine-scale effects on plant community diversity on the Roraima table mountain. Supplemental data for this article is available online at https://doi.org/10.1080/11263504.2021.1985003 .

PH variability in catchment flows to estuaries – A South African perspective

River inflow plays an integral role on the water quality characteristics of estuaries, including pH. This study aimed to investigate pH variability in river inflow to South African estuaries and how these might be influenced by catchment characteristics. Specifically, three hypotheses were tested: 1) catchment geology is a dominant influencing factor of pH in river inflow, 2) catchment vegetation and anthropogenic pressures, e.g., urban and agriculture, act as modifiers of geology-driven ambient pH, and 3) seasonality in river flow rates can alter pH levels (e.g., pH decreasing during periods of high flow). First, drivers of pH variability were explored in relation to electrical conductivity, total alkalinity, and catchment geology type, as well as vegetation and key anthropogenic pressures. Thereafter, temporal variability was evaluated considering both inter-annual and seasonal variability also including variability in flow rates. Values of pH displayed an exponential relationship with electrical conductivity and total alkalinity, and as hypothesised pH variability was primarily influenced by catchment geology. Results also indicated that catchment vegetation (e.g., peatlands and fynbos) and/or anthropogenic pressures (e.g., urban and agriculture) act as modifiers causing pH to deviate from geology-driven ambient equilibria, especially in Table Mountain Group sandstone-dominated systems. Only limited trends in inter-annual variability were observed, mostly linked to increases in pH with increases in anthropogenic pressures. Further, a significant inverse relationship between pH and river flows was present, mostly in systems showing marked seasonality in rainfall. This study adds to our understanding of the variability of pH in river inflows to estuaries, and highlights some of the key influencing factors. Indeed, results suggest that anthropogenic pressures in catchments potentially are leading to alkalinisation of river inflow, contrary to the potential effect of ocean acidification. Finally, this study highlights the ripple effects of upstream catchment practices on downstream coastal ecosystems such as estuaries, emphasising the need for integrated catchment-to-coast management.

THE CRIME OF DEFAMATION – STILL DEFENSIBLE IN A MODERN CONSTITUTIONAL DEMOCRACY?

The crime of defamation, known as criminal libel in some jurisdictions, has (along with associated “insult laws”) been identified in the 2007 Declaration of Table Mountain of the World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers as the “greatest scourge of press freedom on the continent”. The Declaration proceeds to call for the abolition of such laws as a matter of urgency. This call has similarly been made in the Caribbean context by the International Press Institute and in the Commonwealth by the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI). Writing on behalf of CHRI, Cowell notes the “chilling effect” of defamation laws (along with the procedural laws and regulations governing libel actions), defining this phenomenon as “partially … self-censorship on the part of individuals but in general…a wider culture of fear and uncertainty within society that limits free speech”. On this basis, Cowell argues (for CHRI) that criminal defamation represents the “clearest threat to the exercise of freedom of speech withCommonwealth states” and that the “threat of criminal sanction can act as asignificant and widespread deterrent against all freedom of speech”, and that they should therefore be repealed. Similar calls forthe abolition of criminal defamation laws have issued from the Organization of American States and the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, and in response to a complaint relating to a criminal libel conviction emanating from the Philippines, the United Nations Human Rights Council stated that “States parties should consider the decriminalization of defamation … application of the criminal law [in the context of defamation] should only be countenanced in the most serious of cases and imprisonment is never an appropriate remedy”.Despite these calls for the abolition of the crime, it is noteworthy that the crime is retained in many jurisdictions, including European jurisdictions and Commonwealth countries. For example, every Commonwealth state in the English-speaking Caribbean (except Grenada) has specific criminal libel laws, Asian Commonwealth countries such as India, Singapore and Malaysia have corresponding criminaldefamation provisions, and so do African Commonwealth countries such as Botswana and South Africa. In addition, Commonwealth members such as Australia and Canada retain criminal defamation laws. An approach from the Commonwealth Press Union arguing for the abolition of the crime of defamation on the basis that such a crime threatens freedom of expression and is subject to abuse, being used in cases which do not involve the public interest, did not find favour with the Commonwealth Law ministers in their meeting in Accra in 2005.

Urban threats and conservation measures relating to aquatic arthropods on the iconic Table Mountain, South Africa: A review

Mountains supply essential resources, making them attractive areas for human settlement. Variation in elevation in mountainous areas determines local and regional climates, leading to complex biodiversity patterns. Mountains in the Cape Floristic Region have high species richness and beta diversity, and very high levels of local endemism. Table Mountain is an iconic mountain in the region, and unusual, as it is in the centre of the city of Cape Town. It is exceedingly rich in biodiversity, including many localized endemic species. However, increasing urbanization in the area is adversely affecting the local biodiversity, especially in the lowlands. Climate change effects to date are minimal, but projected to interact with the impacts of urbanization. Here we review the biodiversity patterns of green and blue spaces in and around Cape Town, including Table Mountain, focusing on aquatic arthropods. We also review the major threats that lead to biotic impoverishment, and provide information on current conservation efforts aimed at protecting the rich biodiversity of Table Mountain and its surrounds. Finally, we focus on the shortcomings of existing conservation actions, and then provide conservation strategies to limit aquatic arthropod biodiversity losses, based on actions that have already worked well. To ensure protection of all arthropods, freshwater habitats across all elevations require further conservation action. Education and creating awareness must continue to close the gaps between scientists, conservation practitioners and civil society as a crucial part of the conservation plan.