Sub-nanometer Clusters Research Articles

Subnanometric Pt-W Bimetallic Clusters for Efficient Alkaline Hydrogen Evolution Electrocatalysis.

Rational design and synthesis of subnanometric bimetallic clusters (SBCs) within a narrow size distribution, along with achieving full SBCs exposure on supporting materials, are formidable challenges that must be overcome to realize potential applications. This work details a facile strategy to synthesize fully exposed PtW SBCs with an average size of 0.81 nm on the surface of spherical N-doped carbon (PtW/NC), which is underpinned by the electrostatic interactions between the negatively charged [H3PtW6O24]5- polyanions and the positively charged closed-pore metal-organic framework (MOF) [Zn5(OH)2(AmTRZ)6]2+. The PtW/NC exhibits significant electrocatalytic performance and stability for the alkaline hydrogen evolution reaction with an ultralow overpotential of 4 mV at 10 mA cm-2, a low Tafel slope of 29 mV dec-1, and a long-term electrolysis stability exceeding 140 h. The Pt mass activity of PtW/NC is 34 times higher than that of commercial 20 wt % Pt/C at the 100 mV overpotential. Both theoretical calculations and electrochemical measurements indicate that a synergistic effect between Pt and W is responsible for this notable catalytic performance. The synthetic approach outlined in this work can be applied to other MOFs and coordination networks that lack pores or have limited porosity.

Global Optimization of Molybdenum Subnanoclusters on Graphene: A Consistent Approach toward Catalytic Applications.

The development of novel subnanometer clusters (SNCs) catalysts with superior catalytic performance depends on the precise control of clusters' atomistic sizes, shapes, and accurate deposition onto surfaces. The intrinsic complexity of the adsorption process complicates the ability to achieve an atomistic understanding of the most relevant structure-reactivity relationships hampering the rational design of novel catalytic materials. In most cases, existing computational approaches rely on just a few structures to draw conclusions on clusters' reactivity thereby neglecting the complexity of the existing energy landscapes thus leading to insufficient sampling and, most likely, unreliable predictions. Moreover, modeling of the actual experimental procedure that is responsible for the deposition of SNCs on surfaces is often not done even though in some cases this procedure may enhance the significance of certain (e.g., metastable) adsorption geometries. This study proposes a novel systematic approach that utilizes global search techniques, specifically, the particle swarm optimization (PSO) method, in conjunction with ab initio calculations, to simulate all stages in the beam experiments, from predicting the most relevant SNCs structures in the beam and on a surface, to their reactivity. To illustrate the main steps of our approach, we consider the deposition of Molybdenum SNC of 6 Mo atoms on a free-standing graphene surface, as well as their catalytic properties with respect to the CO molecule dissociation reaction. Even though our calculations are not exhaustive and serve only to produce an illustration of the method, they are still able to provide insight into the complicated energy landscape of Mo SNCs on graphene demonstrating the catalytic activity of Mo SNCs and the importance of performing statistical sampling of available configurations. This study establishes a reliable procedure for performing theoretical rational design predictions.

Highly Stable Subnanometric PtIn Clusters for the Selective Dehydrogenation of Alkanes.

Subnanometric PtIn clusters have been synthesized within pure silica MFI zeolites by post-synthetic incorporation of In to Pt@K-MFI. The optimized PtIn@K-MFI catalyst outcompetes state-of-the-art PtSn formulations in ethane and propane dehydrogenations, avoiding the need of large excess of Pt promoters and harsh reductive conditions.

High Coverage Sub-Nano Iridium Cluster on Core-Shell Cobalt-Cerium Bimetallic Oxide for Highly Efficient Full-pH Water Splitting.

The construction of sub-nanometer cluster catalysts (<1nm) with almost complete exposure of active atoms serves as a promising avenue for the simultaneous enhancement of atom utilization efficiency and specific activity. Herein, a core-shell cobalt-cerium bimetallic oxide protected by high coverage sub-nanometer Ir clusters (denoted as Ir cluster@CoO/CeO2) is constructed by a confined in situ exsolution strategy. The distinctive core-shell structure endows Ir cluster@CoO/CeO2 with enhanced intrinsic activity and high conductivity, facilitating efficient charge transfer and full-pH water splitting. The Ir cluster@CoO/CeO2 achieves low overpotentials of 49/215, 52/390, and 54/243mV at 10mAcm-2 for hydrogen evolution reaction/oxygen evolution reaction (HER/OER) in 0.5m H2SO4, 1.0m PBS, and 1.0m KOH, respectively. The small decline in performance after 300h of operation renders it one of the most effective catalysts for full-pH water splitting. DFT calculations indicate that oriented electron transfer (along the path from Ce to Co and then to Ir) creates an electron-rich environment for surface Ir clusters. The reconstructed interface electronic environment provides optimized intermediates adsorption/desorption energy at the Ir site (for HER) and at the Ir-Co site (for OER), thus simultaneously speeding up the HER/OER kinetics.

Constructing matched sub-nanometric cobalt clusters with multiple oxidation and metallic states for efficient propane dehydrogenation

Modulating unique microenvironment including both oxidation and metallic states on sub-nanocluster metal catalysts remains challenging, since designing heterogeneous catalysis within controllable oxidation state is necessary for achieving optimum performance. Here we construct stable sub-nano-Co clusters, which shows different microenvironment with the reported sub-nanocluster catalysts and reported Co-based catalysts. The coexistence of both ionic bonds of Co-O and metallic bonds of Co-Co shows features of multiple oxidation and metallic states, which changes the electronic orbital configuration of the individual Co atom in clusters. The specific microenvironment within low oxidation state and high electron density promotes combination of empty and filled host orbitals to yield high electron transfer between metal and propane, which exhibits higher reactivity than the reported Co-based and other non-noble metals catalysts. The desired reactivity offers the possibility for the exploitation of highly efficient non-noble metal catalysts for propane dehydrogenation in industrial applications.

Adsorbate-induced adatom formation on Au-Cu bimetallic alloys and its possible consequences for CO2 electroreduction

The adsorbate-induced formation of sub-nanometer clusters on transition-metal single crystals observed in previous high-pressure microscopic studies hinted at the in-situ formation of unique active sites even on large nanoparticle catalysts. We propose that the adatom formation energy can be used as an energetic descriptor for the initial step toward the adsorbate-induced metal-cluster formation process. This descriptor can be efficiently computed using density functional theory (DFT) calculations and applied for screening and identification of metal catalysts where this phenomenon may play an important role in generating active sites in-situ. As a proof of concept, here, we construct an adatom formation energy database for three AuxCuy alloys (x:y = 3:1, 1:1, or 1:3) and eighteen adsorbates (H, C, N, O, F, S, Cl, Br, I, CHx, NHx (x = 1 – 3), CO, NO, and OH) commonly involved in catalytic reactions. The energetics of adatom formation were examined in all cases where the (111) terrace, (211) step-edge, and (874) kink were the sources of the adatom. We demonstrate that the presence of an adsorbate could alter not only the energetics for adatom formation but also the elemental nature of the preferred adatom being formed. Using our database, we identified promising systems which favor adsorbate-induced adatom formation under near-ambient conditions. Specifically, CO-induced adatom formation on all three Au-Cu alloy surfaces could occur under CO2 electroreduction (CO2RR) conditions. This phenomenon offers a qualitative explanation for the experimentally observed CO2RR activity on Au-Cu alloy catalysts. Our methodology offers an easily expandable and efficient approach for large-scale catalyst screening with regards to adatom/cluster formation under reaction conditions and provides insight into the possible nature of active sites on alloy catalysts from a novel perspective.

Construction of high‐loading WO3‐x sub‐nanometer clusters via orderly‐anchored top–down strategy boost acidic hydrogen evolution

AbstractExploring a simple, rapid, and scalable synthesis method for the synthesis of high loading nonprecious metal sub‐nanometer clusters (SNCs) electrocatalysts is one of the most promising endeavors today. Herein, an orderly‐anchored top–down strategy is proposed for fabricating a new type of high loading WO3‐x SNCs on O‐functional group‐modified Ketjen black (WO3‐x‐C(O)) to balance the high loading (49.29 wt.%) and sub‐nanometer size. By optimizing the vacancy number, WO2.71‐C(O) has extremely large electrochemically active surface area (402 m2 g−1) and high turnover frequency value of 1.722 s−1 at −50 mV (vs. reversible hydrogen electrode). The overpotential of WO2.71‐C(O) reaches 22 mV at a current density of 10 mA cm−2, which is significantly better than the commercial Pt/C level (32 mV), achieving a breakthrough in the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) catalytic activity of nonprecious metals in acidic environment. Theoretical calculations and in situ characterization show that this material allows for the enrichment of reactants (H*) and the optimization of intermediate adsorption, which leads to the enhancement of acidic HER catalytic activity.

Controllable selective anchoring of subnanometric Ru clusters or single-atoms/clusters on tungsten nitride for the hydrogen oxidation

Controllable selective anchoring of subnanometric Ru clusters or single-atoms/clusters on tungsten nitride for the hydrogen oxidation

Electronic interaction and band alignment between Cu sub-nanometric clusters and ZnIn2S4 nanosheets towards selective photoreduction of CO2 to CO

Engineering the electronic properties of heterogeneous photocatalysts with charge transfer regulated is an effective strategy to boost their CO2 reduction activity. Here, we drew inspiration from the strong metal-support interaction effect, and fabricated ZnIn2S4 supported-Cu sub-nanometric clusters photocatalyst. Within this catalyst, the formed CuS bond would redistribute interfacial charge, resulting in diverse chemical states of Cu atoms and the establishment of Ohmic contact between ZIS and Cu. The built-in electric field of such Ohmic contact benefited the migration of photoexcited electrons from ZIS to Cu. Further mechanistic studies unveiled the crucial role of positively charged Cu atom near the interface in facilitating H2O dissociation, and its adjacent Cu atom at the top-surface adopting a distinct chemical state could activate linear CO2 molecule into a bent configuration. These features substantially lowered energy barriers for CO2 adsorption and subsequent *COOH formation, and Cu-ZIS, accordingly, exhibited a remarkable CO production rate of 60.2 μmol g-1h−1, approximately 20.8-fold enhancement compared to ZIS counterpart.

Stabilizing ultra-small bimetallic PtSn clusters within S-1 crystals for effective propane dehydrogenation with low Pt loading

It’s a great challenge for enhancing the stability over Pt-based catalysts with low Pt loading during propane dehydrogenation based upon the manipulation of ultra-small PtSn clusters and their compositions. Here, we developed a novel strategy to produce and stabilize sub-nanometer PtSn clusters even atomical dispersion within Silicalite-1 crystals via tailoring calcination atmosphere from air to argon, which could achieve a stable performance of propane dehydrogenation with only 0.15 wt% Pt loading. Argon calcination atmosphere of PtSn@Silicalite-1 significantly decreased the size of PtSn clusters, which further presented a strikingly catalytic performance with the high formation of propylene over 8.0 mol[C3H6]·g[Pt]−1·h−1 even after 3840 min at 600 °C (WHSV=760 g[C3H8]·g[Pt]−1·h−1). Hardly any deactivation was obtained over PtSn8@S-1-Ar-50 after long-term runs for 3840 min with an extremely low deactivation constant of 0.0001 h−1 so far, which was mainly derived from the outstanding stability of PtSn sub-nanometers within S-1 crystals through appropriate flow rate of argon calcination atmosphere.

Sub-nanometric ruthenium clusters prepared by solid-state dispersion for catalytic selective aerobic oxidation of aromatic alcohols

The selective aerobic oxidation of alcohols to corresponding aldehydes is one of the most important challenges in the green chemical industry. In this work, Ru/Al2O3-SSD catalyst with highly dispersed metallic ruthenium clusters (average particle size of 0.97 nm) was prepared by solid-state dispersion (SSD) for efficient selective aerobic oxidation of aromatic alcohols to aldehydes. Compared with the counterpart catalyst Ru/Al2O3-IM prepared by wet impregnation (IM), this catalyst has smaller metal particles (0.97 nm vs. 3.4 nm), resulting in a special electronic structure, and exhibits much higher TOF (234 h−1 vs. 98 h−1) in the aerobic oxidation reaction of benzyl alcohol at 80 °C. The catalyst also shows excellent catalytic activity in the preparation of vanillin by selective aerobic oxidation of vanillyl alcohol at 100 °C, delivering a vanillin yield of 99%. The solid-state dispersion strategy provides an efficient and facile way for the fabrication of high-performance sub-nanometric metal catalysts.

Finding atomic dynamics in metal and alloy subnanometer clusters

Abstract This highlight review explains advanced structural analysis techniques utilizing electron microscopy to uncover various properties and phenomena in subnanometer clusters that were previously unknown in larger nanoparticles. The discoveries introduced the concept of “subnano alloying,” where different elements mix at the atomic level in arbitrary proportions, leading to enhanced catalytic performance. Additionally, the behavior and dynamics of these clusters were examined to gain insights into their stability and reactivity. These findings have significant implications for the design of advanced materials with tailored properties and improved catalytic applications.

Subnanometer palladium-manganese clusters in hydrophilic amino-functionalized zeolites for efficient formic acid dehydrogenation

Formic acid (FA) has emerged as a promising candidate for hydrogen storage, due to its excellent stability, low cost, and renewability. The rational design of catalysts for FA dehydrogenation is crucial for integrating FA into the hydrogen economy system. Herein, subnanometric bimetallic Pd-Mn clusters were encapsulated within hydrophilic amino-functionalized silicalite-1 (S-1) zeolite via an in-situ ligand-protection direct H2 reduction method. The graft of amino groups within zeolites not only endowed the zeolites with alkaline sites, but also significantly improved the hydrophilicity of zeolites, and enhanced the interaction between zeolite supports and encapsulated metal species, forming highly active electron-enriched Pd species. Thanks to the high dispersion of metal species and synergy between Pd and Mn species as well as the additive alkaline sites and hydrophilicity of zeolites, the optimized PdMn0.25@S-1-NH2 catalyst exhibited a superhigh H2 evolution rate from FA decomposition, with a turnover frequency value of 11,401 molH2·molPd−1·h−1 at 333 K without any additives, overcoming almost all of the state-of-the-art heterogeneous catalysts under the similar catalytic condition. This study highlights the effective synergistic effect between metal species and supports for improving catalytic efficiency in FA dehydrogenation reactions, and also opens a new paradigm for the design of functionalized zeolite-encapsulated metal catalysts for other important catalytic reactions.

Unraveling the Unique Strong Metal-Support Interaction in Titanium Dioxide Supported Platinum Clusters for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction.

Strong metal-support interaction (SMSI) is crucial to modulating the nature of metal species, yet the SMSI behaviors of sub-nanometer metal clusters remain unknown due to the difficulties in constructing SMSI at cluster scale. Herein, we achieve the successful construction of the SMSI between Pt clusters and amorphous TiO2 nanosheets by vacuum annealing, which requires a relatively low temperature that avoids the aggregation of small clusters. In situ scanning transmission electron microscopy observation is employed to explore the SMSI behaviors, and the results reveal the dynamic rearrangement of Pt atoms upon annealing for the first time. The originally disordered Pt atoms become ordered as the crystallizing of the amorphous TiO2 support, forming an epitaxial interface between Pt and TiO2. Such a SMSI state can remain stable in oxidation environment even at 400 °C. Further investigations prove that the electron transfer from TiO2 to Pt occupies the Pt 5d orbitals, which is responsible for the disappeared CO adsorption ability of Pt/TiO2 after forming SMSI. This work not only opens a new avenue for constructing SMSI at cluster scale but also provides in-depth understanding on the unique SMSI behavior, which would stimulate the development of supported metal clusters for catalysis applications.

Probing Basal and Prismatic Planes of Graphitic Materials for Metal Single Atom and Subnanometer Cluster Stabilization.

Supported metal single atom catalysis is a dynamic research area in catalysis science combining the advantages of homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. Understanding the interactions between metal single atoms and the support constitutes a challenge facing the development of such catalysts, since these interactions are essential in optimizing the catalytic performance. For conventional carbon supports, two types of surfaces can contribute to single atom stabilization: the basal planes and the prismatic surface; both of which can be decorated by defects and surface oxygen groups. To date, most studies on carbon-supported single atom catalysts focused on nitrogen-doped carbons, which, unlike classic carbon materials, have a fairly well-defined chemical environment. Herein we report the synthesis, characterization and modeling of rhodium single atom catalysts supported on carbon materials presenting distinct concentrations of surface oxygen groups and basal/prismatic surface area. The influence of these parameters on the speciation of the Rh species, their coordination and ultimately on their catalytic performance in hydrogenation and hydroformylation reactions is analyzed. The results obtained show that catalysis itself is an interesting tool for the fine characterization of these materials, for which the detection of small quantities of metal clusters remains a challenge, even when combining several cutting-edge analytical methods.

CO2 hydrogenation over rhodium cluster catalyst nucleated within a manganese oxide framework

Rhodium-based manganese oxide frameworks were explored as a prototype for carbon dioxide reactive capture and conversion. Three-dimensional frameworks of MnOx were utilized as support structures to isolate Rh metal centers. V, Na, and Zn were introduced as counterions to stabilize the structure and for their beneficial effect as promoters. With this multicomponent catalyst, Rh active centers with MnOxs and varied counterions, we were able to selectively tune the catalytic performance of the material via the choice of counterion and structure of the host material. With cryptomelane-type tunnel manganese oxides octahedral molecular sieve (OMS2), we found that Rh-V-OMS2 was highly stable even after 48 hours on stream with a reaction rate of around 1.5×10−4 mol CO2/gRh/s, surpassing the net reactivity of other initially more active combinations. Furthermore, during CO2 hydrogenation, in situ XAFS showed that single Rh atoms nucleated into nanoparticles/ sub-nanometer clusters with a coordination number of 5.5 or less. Our finding of the correlation between the reaction rate and particle size offers the potential for enhanced control over the reaction rate by tuning particle size. Our activity study with control experiments demonstrates that the activities of the catalysts are proved due to the unique metal support interaction offered by the Rh-X-MnO.

Solvent-Free Synthesis Enables Encapsulation of Subnanometric FeOx Clusters in Pure Siliceous Zeolites for Efficient Catalytic Oxidation Reactions.

Metal/metal oxide clusters possess a higher count of unsaturated coordination sites than nanoparticles, providing multiatomic sites that single atoms do not. Encapsulating metal/metal oxide clusters within zeolites is a promising approach for synthesizing and stabilizing these clusters. The unique feature endows the metal clusters with an exceptional catalytic performance in a broad range of catalytic reactions. However, the encapsulation of stable FeOx clusters in zeolite is still challenging, which limits the application of zeolite-encapsulated FeOx clusters in catalysis. Herein, we design a modified solvent-free method to encapsulate FeOx clusters in pure siliceous MFI zeolites (Fe@MFI). It is revealed that the 0.3-0.4 nm subnanometric FeOx clusters are stably encapsulated in the 5/6-membered rings intersectional voids of the pure siliceous MFI zeolites. The encapsulated Fe@MFI catalyst with a Fe loading of 1.4 wt % demonstrates remarkable catalytic activity and recycle stability in the direct oxidation of methane, while also promoting the direct oxidation of cyclohexane, surpassing the performance of conventional zeolite-supported Fe catalysts.

Subnanometric Pt-Ga alloy clusters confined within Silicalite-1 zeolite for n-hexane dehydrogenation

Dehydrogenation of light naphtha followed by catalytic cracking into high-value end products can meet the high demand in the world’s petrochemical market. In this work, at attempting synthesis of novel catalysts for hexane dehydrogenation, a series of bimetallic Pt-Ga clusters encapsulated within Silicalite-1 (S-1) catalysts were synthesized using the ligand-protected direct H2 reduction method. The reduced Pt-Ga@S-1-H catalysts comprised restricted ultra-fine Pt-Ga alloys with an average size 0.86–0.95 nm, mainly corresponding to the Pt3 clusters with coordinate number 1.5–2.1. Ga doping significantly improved the catalytic stability, depending on the Ga content, which ranged from 0.02 to 0.27 wt%. As confirmed by the XPS and EXAFS analysis, after the Ga addition, electron transfer occurred between the Pt-Ga alloys and the skeleton oxygen in zeolite, stabilizing the Pt clusters on the zeolite, thereby inhibiting the growth of Pt crystals. During the n-hexane dehydrogenation, the 0.40Pt0.04 Ga@S-1-H catalyst exhibited a hexene selectivity of 87.1 %, achieving a hexene formation rate of 101.4 molhexene∙gPt-1∙h−1 at 550 °C with a WHSV of 90 h−1. After 1000 min of reaction, this best catalyst experienced only slight deactivation with a deactivation constant of 0.066 h−1. The catalytic activity remained almost unchanged after consecutive five cycles of H2 regeneration. DFT calculation using the synchronous structural models showed that the Gibbs free energy changes (−ΔG) for the first three steps of hexane dehydrogenation over the 0.4Pt0.04 Ga@S-1-H catalyst were much lower than those obtained on the 0.4Pt/S-1-H catalyst, suggesting that the introduction of Ga energetically favored the hexane dehydrogenation.

Bismuth Telluride Supported Sub-1 nm Polyoxometalate Cluster for High-Efficiency Thermoelectric Energy Conversion.

Size plays a crucial role in chemistry and material science. Subnanometer polyoxometalate (POM) clusters have gained attention in various fields, but their use in thermoelectrics is still limited. To address this issue, we propose the POM clusters as an effective second phase to enhance the thermoelectric properties of Bi0.4Sb1.6Te3. Thanks to their subnanometer size, POM clusters improve electrical transport behavior through the superposition of atomic orbitals and the interfacial scattering effect. Furthermore, their ultrasmall size strongly reduces thermal conductivity. Consequently, the introduction of a mere 0.1 mol % of POM into the Bi0.4Sb1.6Te3 matrix realizes a state-of-the-art zT value of 1.46 at 348 K, a 45% enhancement over Bi0.4Sb1.6Te3 (1.01), along with a maximum thermoelectric-conversion efficiency of the integrated module of 6.0%. The enhancement of carrier mobility and the suppression of thermal conduction achieved by introducing the subnanometer clusters hold promise for various applications, such as electronic devices and thermal management.

Density functional theory study of the structure, stability, magnetic properties, and (hyper)polarizability of (sub-nm) rare-earth (RE) doped gold clusters: Au5RE with RE = Sc, Y, La-Lu.

Rare-earth doped materials are of immense interest for their potential applications in linear and nonlinear photonics. There is also intense interest in sub-nanometer gold clusters due to their enhanced stability and unique optical, magnetic, and catalytic properties. To leverage their emergent properties, here we report a systematic study of the geometries, stability, electronic, magnetic, and linear and nonlinear optical properties of Au5RE (RE = Sc, Y, La-Lu) clusters using density-functional theory. Several low-energy isomers consisting of planar or non-planar configurations are identified. For most doped clusters, the non-planar configuration is energetically favored. In the case of La-, Pm-, Gd-, and Ho-doped clusters, a competition between planar and non-planar isomers is predicted. A distinct preference for the planar configuration is predicted for Au5Eu, Au5Sm, Au5Tb, Au5Tm, and Au5Yb. The distinction between the planar and non-planar configurations is highlighted by the calculated highest frequencies, with the stretching mode of the non-planar configuration predicted to be stiffer than the planar configuration. The bonding analysis reveals the dominance of the RE-d orbitals in the formation of frontier molecular orbitals, which, in turn, facilitates retaining the magnetic characteristics governed by RE-f orbitals, preventing spin-quenching of rare earths in the doped clusters. In addition, the doped clusters exhibit small energy gaps between frontier orbitals, large dipole moments, and enhanced hyperpolarizability compared to the host cluster.