Strong Southward IMF Research Articles

SUBSTORMS CAUSED BY LARGE-AMPLITUDE SOLAR WIND DYNAMIC PRESSURE PULSES: CASE STUDY ON 3 NOVEMBER 2021

We studied the geomagnetic effects of abrupt and large-amplitude changes in the solar wind dynamic pressure (Psw) on 3 November 2021. when there were observed three large-amplitude Psw pulses (up to 20 nPa) under the strong (up to −18 nT) southward IMF Bz and significantly varying IMF By (from +20 to −15 nT). Basing on IMAGE magnetometer data, we found three substorms associated with these Psw impulses. These substorms followed one after another with a short interval and each subsequent substorm began developing during the unfinished recovery phase of the previous one under disturbed space weather conditions. Under strong negative IMF Bz there was significant input of energy into the magnetosphere that indicated by the increasing PC-index values. It was shown that the spatial-temporal features of the substorm subsequence development was complicated, differed from a typical isolated “normal” substorm and changed from one substorm to another. According to the AMPERE 66 ionospheric satellite data, the global distribution of the ionospheric and field-aligned currents (FAC) was established during the considered substorms. We found that during all these substorms, there were strong FACs and corresponding ionospheric electrojets in the morning sector indicating an enhanced magnetospheric convection which formed the DP2 current system. In addition, in the night sector, the DP1 current system was observed, the clearest in the second event.

Thin Current Sheet Formation and Reconnection at X ∼ −10 RE During the Main Phase of a Magnetic Storm

AbstractThe main question addressed in this study is whether particles with relativistic energy can be injected directly into the inner magnetosphere by very near‐Earth reconnection during magnetic storms. We study a sequence of events observed in the solar wind, in the magnetotail, at geosynchronous orbit (GEO), in the inner magnetosphere, and in the ionosphere during the main phase of a geomagnetic storm on 16 June 2012–17 June 2012. The storm was caused by a magnetic cloud with a high dynamic pressure and a strong southward IMF lasting about 10 hr. These conditions caused an extreme compression of the magnetosphere (SymH reached ∼150 nT) and an enhancement of the lobe magnetic field strength to ∼90 nT at R ∼ 10 Earth radii (RE). We focus on an hour‐long interval between 1050 and 1150 UT on 17 June 2012 when the Time History of Events and Macroscale Interactions during Substorms (THEMIS) satellites were at apogee at geocentric distances R ≈ 12 RE near midnight. At that time a thin current sheet formed between cis‐GEO distances and THEMIS. This thin current sheet reconnected between GEO and THEMIS. A strong lobe magnetic field enabled ion and electron energization to energies E ≈ 600 keV. Fluxes of high energy (up to relativistic) particles at GEO increased within ≈20 s after reconnection onset detected by THEMIS. Fluxes of relativistic electrons at L ∼ 4 in the morning sector increased within about 600 s after reconnection onset. We interpret these observations as signatures of direct injection of reconnected particles into the inner magnetosphere.

Magnetic Field Gradient Across the Flank Magnetopause

Magnetic pressure inside the magnetopause is usually balanced with a sum of thermal plasma and magnetic pressures on the magnetosheath side. However, observations reveal that the magnetosheath magnetic field can be frequently larger than that in the magnetosphere (inverse magnetic field gradient across the magnetopause), and thus, the enhanced pressure from the magnetosheath side seems to be uncompensated. Such events are rare in the subsolar region, but their occurrence rate increases toward flanks. The analysis, based on statistical processing of about 35,000 THEMIS magnetopause crossings collected in the course of the years 2007–2017, shows that these events are more frequently observed under enhanced geomagnetic activity that is connected with a strong southward IMF. Case studies reveal that such a state of the magnetopause boundary layers can persist for several hours. This study discusses conditions and mechanisms keeping the pressure balance across the magnetopause under these conditions.

Stormtime substorm onsets: occurrence and flow channel triggering

Bright auroral emissions during geomagnetic storms provide a good opportunity for testing the proposal that substorm onset is frequently triggered by plasma sheet flow bursts that are manifested in the ionosphere as auroral streamers. We have used the broad coverage of the ionospheric mapping of the plasma sheet offered by the high-resolution THEMIS all-sky-imagers (ASIs) and chose the main phases of 9 coronal mass ejection (CME) related and 9 high-speed stream (HSS)-related geomagnetic storms, and identified substorm auroral onsets defined as brightening followed by poleward expansion. We found a detectable streamer heading to near the substorm onset location for all 60 onsets that we identified and were observed well by the ASIs. This indicates that substorm onsets are very often triggered by the intrusion of plasma with lower entropy than the surrounding plasma to the onset region, with the caveat that the ASIs do not give a direct measure of the intruding plasma. The majority of the triggering streamers are “tilted streamers,” which extend eastward as their eastern tip tilts equatorward to near the substorm onset location. Fourteen of the 60 cases were identified as “Harang streamers,” where the streamer discernibly turns toward the west poleward of reaching to near the onset latitude, indicating flow around the Harang reversal. Using the ASI observations, we observed substantially less substorm onsets for CME storms than for HSS storms, a result in disagreement with a recent finding of approximately equal substorm occurrences. We suggest that this difference is a result of strong non-substorm streamers that give substorm-like signatures in ground magnetic field observations but are not substorms based on their auroral signature. Our results from CME storms with steady, strong southward IMF are not consistent with the ~ 2–4 h repetition of substorms that has been suggested for moderate to strong southward IMF conditions. Instead, our results indicate substantially lower substorm occurrence during such steady driving conditions. Our results also show the much more frequent occurrence of substorms during HSS period, which is likely due to the highly fluctuating IMF.

Equatorial ionospheric responses in relation to the occurrence of main phase of intense geomagnetic storms in the local dusk sector

During five intense geomagnetic storms with main phases occurring around local dusk sector, equatorial ionosonde and electrojet data, VHF/UHF scintillation data of Calcutta, and several solar wind parameters are investigated to ascertain the polarity of prompt penetration electric field (PPEF). Abrupt increases in AE, ASY-H and/or sharp decreases in D st /SYM-H with strong southward IMF B z may symbolize eastward PPEF to equatorial latitude leading to evolution of density irregularities if the period is associated with arrival and sustenance of large magnetospheric shock compression. On the contrary, westward PPEF is more feasible if the shock reduces suddenly or fluctuates with small values.

Cluster Observations of the Magnetospheric Low-Latitude Boundary Layer and Cusp during Extreme Solar Wind and Interplanetary Magnetic Field Conditions: I. 10 November 2004 ICME

We present a study of the magnetospheric cusp response to extreme external parameters during passage of the ICME over the Earth on 10 November 2004, based on Cluster observations of the plasma properties inside the low-latitude boundary layer (LLBL)/cusp regions. Two separate events are observed while Cluster is in the dawn sector, 07 – 08 h magnetic local time (MLT). First, a LLBL/cusp crossing occurs during a period of strong southward IMF. During this time, the LLBL/cusp is very small, ∼0.8 – 1° invariant latitude (ILAT) and moves equatorward, down to 67° ILAT. This can be explained by the occurrence of significant magnetopause erosion due to enhanced dayside sub-solar reconnection. The energy of the plasma inside this region is higher than normal, and the low-energy cut-off often observed in the ion data is also unusually high. This might be explained by the suggestion that the local magnetosheath Alfven velocity and deHoffmann – Teller velocity are also both extremely high. However, the plasma convection and parallel velocity inside this region are not very high. The second event discussed in this paper is a LLBL/cusp crossing during strong equatorial IMF (mostly due to the dominant dawn – dusk component). Under these conditions, occurring at the same time as pulses of solar wind dynamic pressure, the observations are very complicated. However, we suggest that in the polar region of the southern hemisphere, Cluster cross two LLBLs/cusps, spatially separated by polar cap plasma. The first LLBL/cusp is formed by anti-parallel reconnection in the dusk sector of the southern hemisphere and the second is formed by anti-parallel reconnection in the dawn sector of the northern hemisphere. The second LLBL/cusp is located at extremely low latitude, less than ∼66.3° ILAT. During all LLBL/cusp crossings, strong ionospheric O+ ion outflow is detected in the form of a narrow beam with limited pitch-angle range.

Observation of two distinct cold, dense ion populations at geosynchronous orbit: local time asymmetry, solar wind dependence and origin

Abstract. We report on the observation of two distinct cold (Ti<5 keV), dense (Ni>2 cm−3) ion populations at geosynchronous orbit. A statistical study was performed on measurements from the geosynchronous Los Alamos plasma instruments, for the period 1990–2004, and complemented by corresponding large-scale plasma sheet data obtained by mapping DMSP observations in the tail. The first population, which has previously been reported in several studies, is observed in the midnight region of geosynchronous orbit. The second population, which has drawn less attention, is detected on the dawn side of geosynchronous orbit. No such cold, dense population is observed on the dusk side of geosynchronous orbit on a frequent basis. The temporal evolution of various plasma parameters as a function of local time shows that the two populations appear at geosynchronous orbit as distinct populations, since the appearance of a midnight population is not usually associated with that of a dawn population, and vice versa. The midnight ion population is typically observed after the IMF has been northward for some time and is convected inward toward geosynchronous orbit after an observed mild southward turning of the average IMF. It is interpreted that the source of the midnight population is the cold, dense plasma sheet (CDPS). The dawn-side cold and dense ion population is associated with previously strong southward IMF and consequently occurs during substantial geomagnetic activity. These events are typically observed around the end of the main phase of the corresponding Dst decrease, down to −50 nT on average. It is unlikely that this dawn population is simply the low-latitude boundary layer (LLBL) moving closer to Earth because (1) no symmetric dusk population is observed and (2) on average a small sunward flow (~15 km/s) is observed for those events. The cold, dense population at dawn is thus observed during active times (based on Dst, Kp and AE indices) in comparison with the midnight case. However, since the dawn population is observed only around the end of the main Dst decrease, it is concluded that this population does not typically contribute to the Dst decrease during the main phase. This population may rather be transported to geosynchronous orbit by means of a compression and convection enhancement in the magnetosphere, with a preferential access from the dawn flank with no apparent counterpart at dusk. DMSP data suggest that a cold and dense plasma source is mainly present at dawn.

A study of the storm event on October 21–22, 1999 by the MHD simulation

Abstract We carried out a high resolution three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation of the interaction between the solar wind and the Earth’s magnetosphere during a strong magnetic storm on October 21–22, 1999. The input to the simulation was from WIND solar wind observations. As the IMF is strongly southward (−20 nT to −30 nT) for 6 hours, the geomagnetic field lines in the dayside magnetopause are eroded to the geosynchronous orbit (GEO) region by reconnection. The associated magnetic flux is transferred from the dayside magnetosphere to the tail. The reconnection region still appears near GEO region on the dayside magnetopause, even though the IMF B z component becomes small or northward, because of the influence of the strong IMF B y (30 nT). IMF lines can successively reconnect with the naked and large geomagnetic field line in the dayside flank regions. Thus, the cross polar cap potential is maintained to be large value and convection in the ionosphere is enhanced. The cross polar cap potential is governed by IMF B y as well as B z (ф ≈250 kV for B z ≈ −20 nT and ф ≈ 300 kV for B z ≈ − 30 nT), and it saturates during the strong southward IMF. A large energy flux enters the ionosphere at very low latitudes (50°) and the inner edge of the plasma sheet becomes very close to the Earth X = −3.2 R E for a strong magnetic storms. The open-closed boundary extends to 60° latitudes on the nightside, 72° on the dayside, 62° on dawn, and 66° on dusk. Enhanced energy flux appears at low latitudes (50°) on the nightside in simulation. Moreover, the energy flux in the dusk region (19 MLT) appears down to 55° latitude in simulation, which is consistent with the low latitude boundary of the 0.02-20 keV particles detected by TED of the NOAA-15. A convective electric field, which is penetrating to the Earth-side of the NENL, is almost comparable to that of the solar wind. The present MHD simulation study give reasonable results even for extreme conditions and thereby its usefulness is demonstrated as a physical model for space weather studies.

Flux Transfer Events: 1. generation mechanism for strong southward IMF

Abstract. We use a global numerical model of the interaction of the solar wind and the interplanetary magnetic field with Earth's magnetosphere to study the formation process of Flux Transfer Events (FTEs) during strong southward IMF. We find that: (i) The model produces essentially all observational features expected for FTEs, in particular the bipolar signature of the magnetic field BN component, the correct polarity, duration, and intermittency of that bipolar signature, strong core fields and enhanced core pressure, and flow enhancements; (ii) FTEs only develop for large dipole tilt whereas in the case of no dipole tilt steady magnetic reconnection occurs at the dayside magnetopause; (iii) the basic process by which FTEs are produced is the sequential generation of new X-lines which makes dayside reconnection inherently time dependent and leads to a modified form of dual or multiple X-line reconnection; (iv) the FTE generation process in this model is not dependent on specific assumptions about microscopic processes; (v) the average period of FTEs can be explained by simple geometric arguments involving magnetosheath convection; (vi) FTEs do not develop in the model if the numerical resolution is too coarse leading to too much numerical diffusion; and (vii) FTEs for nearly southward IMF and large dipole tilt, i.e., near solstice, should only develop in the winter hemisphere, which provides a testable prediction of seasonal modulation. The semiannual modulation of intermittent FTE reconnection versus steady reconnection is also expected to modulate magnetospheric and ionospheric convection and may thus contribute to the semiannual variation of geomagnetic activity.

Evaluation of the geometry of ionospheric current systems related to rapid geomagnetic variations

Abstract. To learn about the geometry and sources of the ionospheric current systems which generate strong geomagnetically induced currents, we categorize differential equivalent current systems (DEC) for events with strong dB/dt by decomposing them into the contributions of electrojet-type and vortex-type elementary systems. By solving the inverse problem we obtain amplitudes and locations of these elementary current systems. One-minute differences of the geomagnetic field values at the IMAGE magnetometer network in 1996–2000 are analysed to study the spatial distributions of large dB/dt events. The relative contributions of the two components are evaluated. In particular, we found that the majority of the strongest dB/dt events (100–1000nT/min) appear to be produced by the vortex-type current structures and most of them occur in the morning LT hours, probably caused by the Ps6 pulsation events associated with auroral omega structures. For strong dB/dt events the solar wind parameters are shifted toward strong (tens nT) southward IMF, enhanced velocity and dynamic pressure, in order for the main phase of the magnetic storms to occur. Although these events appear mostly during magnetic storms when the auroral oval greatly expands, the area of large dB/dt stays in the middle part of the auroral zone; therefore, it is connected to the processes taking part in the middle of the magnetosphere rather than in its innermost region populated by the ring current. Key words. Geomagnetism and paleomagnetism (rapid time variations) – Ionosphere (auroral ionosphere; ionospheric disturbances)

Delivery of cold, dense plasma sheet material into the near‐Earth region

Observations from several satellites in geosynchronous orbit, combined with solar wind observations from the ACE spacecraft, demonstrate that cold, dense plasma sheet material can be delivered into the inner magnetosphere under two scenarios: (1) a sudden southward IMF preceded by an extended interval of northward field and (2) a very strong magnetospheric compression caused by a large increase in the solar wind dynamic pressure, also under conditions of northward IMF. Examination of 30 “superdense” plasma sheet events observed during 15 months in 2001 and 2002 shows that these two mechanisms are probably responsible for the occurrence of most superdense events, if “northward IMF” is generalized to “northward or very weak IMF Bz.” Previous work has shown that a superdense plasma sheet contributes to a strong ring current and geomagnetic disturbance if it is accompanied by strong magnetospheric convection (which requires southward IMF). Hence this study suggests that the formation of a strong geomagnetic storm should be favored by an extended interval of strong southward IMF that is preceded by an earlier interval of northward field or very weak Bz, during which the plasma sheet fills with cool, dense plasma.

Mid-latitude ionospheric perturbation associated with the Spacelab-2 plasma depletion experiment at Millstone Hill

Abstract. Elevation scans across geomagnetic mid latitudes by the incoherent scatter radar at Millstone Hill captured the ionospheric response to the firing of the Space Shuttle Challenger OMS thrusters near the peak of the F layer on July 30, 1985. Details of the excitation of airglow and the formation of an ionospheric hole during this event have been reported in an earlier paper by Mendillo et al.. The depletion (factor ~2) near the 320 km Shuttle orbital altitude persisted for ~35 min and then recovered to near normal levels, while at 265 km the density was reduced by a factor of ~6; this significant reduction in the bottomside F-region density persisted for more than 3 hours. Total electron content in the vicinity of the hole was reduced by more than a factor of 2, and an oscillation of the F-region densities with 40-min period ensued and persisted for several hours. Plasma vertical Doppler velocity varied quasi-periodically with a ~80-min period, while magnetic field variations observed on the field line through the Shuttle-burn position exhibited a similar ~80-min periodicity. An interval of magnetic field variations at hydromagnetic frequencies (~95 s period) accompanied the ionospheric perturbations on this field line. Radar observations revealed a downward phase progression of the 40-min period density enhancements of -1.12° km-1, corresponding to a 320-km vertical wavelength. An auroral-latitude geomagnetic disturbance began near the time of the Spacelab-2 experiment and was associated with the imposition of a strong southward IMF Bz across the magnetosphere. This created an additional complication in the interpretation of the active ionospheric experiment. It cannot be determined uniquely whether the ionospheric oscillations, which followed the Spacelab-2 experiment, were related to the active experiment or were the result of a propagating ionospheric disturbance (TID) launched by the enhanced auroral activity. The most reasonable conclusion is that the ionospheric oscillations were a result of the coincident geomagnetic disturbance. The pronounced depletion of the bottomside ionosphere, however, accentuated the oscillatory behavior during the interval following the Shuttle OMS burn..Key words. Ionosphere (active experiments; ionospheric disturbances) · Magnetospheric physics (storms and substorms)

A multipoint study of a substorm occurring on 7 December, 1992, and its theoretical implications

Abstract. On 7 December 1992, a moderate substorm was observed by a variety of satellites and ground-based instruments. Ionospheric flows were monitored near dusk by the Goose Bay HF radar and near midnight by the EISCAT radar. The observed flows are compared here with magnetometer observations by the IMAGE array in Scandinavia and the two Greenland chains, the auroral distribution observed by Freja and the substorm cycle observations by the SABRE radar, the SAMNET magnetometer array and LANL geosynchronous satellites. Data from Galileo Earth-encounter II are used to estimate the IMF Bz component. The data presented show that the substorm onset electrojet at midnight was confined to closed field lines equatorward of the pre-existing convection reversal boundaries observed in the dusk and midnight regions. No evidence of substantial closure of open flux was detected following this substorm onset. Indeed the convection reversal boundary on the duskside continued to expand equatorward after onset due to the continued presence of strong southward IMF, such that growth and expansion phase features were simultaneously present. Clear indications of closure of open flux were not observed until a subsequent substorm intensification 25 min after the initial onset. After this time, the substorm auroral bulge in the nightside hours propagated well poleward of the pre-existing convection reversal boundary, and strong flow perturbations were observed by the Goose Bay radar, indicative of flows driven by reconnection in the tail.Key words. Ionosphere (auroral ionosphere; plasma convection) · Magnetospheric physics (storms and substorms)

Layered structure of energetic oxygen ions in the dayside magnetosheath

On January 10 and 11, 1997, a coronal mass ejection (CME) encountered the Earth's magnetosphere and produced a moderate geomagnetic storm (Dst = −84 nT). During this event, the GEOTAIL spacecraft was skimming the dayside magnetopause, and observed a number of magnetopause crossings in response to the varying solar wind dynamic pressure. Around 1200 UT on January 10, GEOTAIL was traveling in the vicinity of the magnetopause at 1500 LT. Energetic oxygen ion bursts were repeatedly observed by the HEP/LD spectrometer on board GEOTAIL. This was a period of strong southward IMF related to the magnetic cloud structure of the CME. Two of these events with clear energy dispersion effects lasted from 1050 to 1113 UT, on January 10. This can be explained by invoking a quasi‐steady layered structure of the energetic oxygen ions in the magnetosheath with the higher energy particles further away from the magnetopause than the lower energy ones. The observed energy dispersion is interpreted as a result of a crossing through this spatial layer due to the arrival of a filamentory pressure pulse in the solar wind. It is suggested that the existence of the structured oxygen layer is the result of particle leakage through the dayside magnetopause into magnetosheath.

Short‐duration convection bays and localized interplanetary magnetic field structures on November 28, 1995

We present ground‐based, plasma sheet, and magnetosheath observations of two subsequent short‐duration (10–20 min) increases of the postmidnight westward electrojet on November 28, 1995. Appearing as though small (150–200 nT) substorms, they were not accompanied by any substorm expansion onset signatures. Auroral breakup, worldwide Pi2 pulsations, and the corresponding plasma sheet activity, such as fast flows, current disruption, and plasmoid generation, were all observed only at the recovery of the second electrojet increase. These convection bays were associated with the equatorward expansion of the auroras and simultaneous magnetic variations in the polar cap and middle latitudes. Growth phase signatures of the lobe field increase and tailward stretching of magnetic field were also observed in the plasma sheet. Bursty bulk flows in the plasma sheet seem to be quenched at the onset of first convection bay and did not resume until the auroral breakup which concluded the second convection bay. A point of interest of this event was the “incomplete” convection/current system with a well‐developed dawn vortex in the absence of well‐defined dusk vortex; instead, a complicated transient activity dominated over the afternoon‐dusk local time sector. We interpret this asymmetry either in terms of the magnetopause encounter with the edge of the solar wind driver, i.e., strong southward IMF, which hits only the dawn part of the magnetosphere, or with an extremely slant interplanetary discontinuity. This unique configuration was inferred from observations of uncorrelated strong southward Bz events by the Wind and IMP 8 spacecraft in the dusk and dawn magnetosheath, respectively, as well as from the directional analysis of the interplanetary discontinuities which form the edges of these structures. We suggest that interaction of the magnetosphere with very slant solar wind discontinuities may bring various specific features to magnetospheric and ionospheric dynamics that have not been reported.