In this paper, a Stirling cycle heated by a finite reservoir is analyzed and optimized with the entropy generation minimization and the entransy theory based on generalized heat transfer law. Taking the output power and the heat-work conversion efficiency as the optimization objectives, we discuss the optimization applicability of the concepts of entransy loss rate, entransy variation rate associated with work, entransy dissipation rate, entransy loss coefficient, entropy generation rate, entropy generation number and revised entropy generation number in detail. Three numerical cases are presented. The results show that both the entransy loss rate and the entransy variation rate associated with work always increase with the increase of output power, and the entransy loss coefficient always increases with the increase of heat-work conversion efficiency. However, larger entransy dissipation rate and smaller entropy generation rate do not always lead to larger output power, while smaller entropy generation number and smaller revised entropy generation number do not always lead to larger heat-work conversion efficiency, either. Therefore, with the three numerical cases discussed in this paper, we can conclude that the concepts of entransy loss rate, entransy variation rate associated with work and entransy loss coefficient are applicable for the optimization analysis, while the other parameters are not always applicable. Based on the results above, the controversy about the entransy theory is also discussed. The main problems in some negative comments of the entransy theory are summerized and analyzed, such as tampering the original text, logical inconsistency, simple repetition of academic views, renaming key concepts and even personal attacks, etc. It should be noticed that these negative comments are not real academic discussions. To some extent, the results in this paper can also be a responce to some negative comments.
Read full abstract