There is significant interest in developing photothermal systems that can precisely control the structure and function of biomolecules through local temperature modulation. One specific application is the denaturation of double-stranded (ds) DNA through femtosecond (fs) laser pulse optical heating of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs); however, the mechanism of DNA melting in these systems is not fully understood. Here, we utilize 55 nm AuNPs with surface-tethered dsDNA, which are locally heated using fs laser pulses to induce DNA melting. By varying the dsDNA distance from the AuNP surface and the laser pulse energy fluence, this system is used to study how the nanosecond duration temperature increase and the steep temperature gradient around the AuNP affect dsDNA dehybridization. Through modifying the distance between the dsDNA and AuNP surface by 3.8 nm in total and the pulse energy fluence from 7.1 to 14.1 J/m2, the dehybridization rates ranged from 0.002 to 0.05 DNA per pulse, and the total amount of DNA released into solution was controlled over a range of 26-93% in only 100 s of irradiation. By shifting the dsDNA position as little as ∼1.1 nm, the average dsDNA dehybridization rate is altered up to 30 ± 2%, providing a high level of control over DNA melting and release. By comparing the theoretical temperature around the dsDNA to the experimentally derived temperature, we find that maximum or peak temperatures have a greater influence on the dehybridization rate when the dsDNA is closer to the AuNP surface and when lower laser pulse fluences are used. Furthermore, molecular dynamics simulations mimicking the photothermal heat pulse around a AuNP provide mechanistic insight into the stochastic nature of dehybridization and demonstrate increased base pair separation near the AuNP surface during laser pulse heating when compared to steady-state heating. Understanding how biological materials respond to the short-lived and non-uniform temperature increases innate to fs laser pulse optical heating of AuNPs is critical to improving the functionality and precision of this technique so that it may be implemented into more complex biological systems.