Type I interferons have been investigated as radiosensitizer over a long time. Recent clinical data in pancreatic cancer are suggesting an enhanced efficacy of radiation (XRT) and chemotherapy by the simultaneous application with IFN-alpha. On the other hand, a randomized clinical study on the addition of IFN-beta to XRT for the treatment of lung cancer showed a negative result. These observations are suggesting, that the interaction of XRT with type I interferons might be determined by the genetic background of the treated tumors. Since the enhancement of radiation by IFN-beta is associated with an increase of the alpha-component of the survival curves; we assumed that the interaction of IFN-beta with ionizing irradiation is characterized by interference with DNA repair. A number of cell lines representing normal tissue and different tumor types and with known genetic alterations in DNA repair (DNA-PK and Brca2) or cell cycle control (TP53, RB) were used. Cellular repair capacity was modulated by wortmannin (WMN) treatment (in M059K cells) or PRCDK gene transfection (in M059J cells). For experiments, cells were incubated with natural IFN-beta (IFN) (0, 300 I.U./ml or 3000 I.U./ml) 24 h before irradiation. Cycling or confluent cell cultures were used. We measured cellular survival after graded single dose irradiation, split dose (SD), and low dose rate irradiation (LDR), with colony formation as an endpoint. Survival curves were fitted according to the linear-quadratic equation. Sensitizer enhancement ratios were calculated at the 37% survival level, and isobologram analysis was applied to test the IFN-radiation interactions. Apoptosis and DNA-rejoining were measured by standard assays. On the survival level, additive as well as supraadditive interactions of IFN and XRT were observed, depending on the cell lines used. The IFN effectiveness was more pronounced in cycling compared to resting cells. The expression of mutated TP53 or RB did not influence the IFN-induced radiation cytotoxicity. Incubation with 3000 I.U./ml IFN could induce apoptosis, but it did sparsely account for increased radiation toxicity. Supraadditivity of IFN and XRT was always accompanied by increased alpha-values of the respective survival curves. The involvement of repair processes in the IFN effectiveness was supported by the results of the SD and LDR experiments, indicating an inhibition of sublethal damage repair. Initial DSBs or DNA rejoining were not altered by IFN-treatment. DNA-PK deficient M059J cells were radiosensitive and showed a supraadditive IFN-XRT interaction that could be abrogated by the re-transfection of a functional PRKDC gene (M059J-Fus1 cells). DNA-PK proficient M059K cells were radioresistant and showed a solely additive IFN-XRT interaction, which could be converted into supraadditivity by repair-inhibition with WMN. Brca2-deficient CAPAN-1 pancreatic tumor cells were extremely IFN sensitive but showed additive IFN-XRT interaction, while Brca2 proficient pancreatic tumor cells were less IFN sensitive and showed a supraadditive IFN-XRT interaction. Our results are pointing towards an interaction of IFN with the regulation of the repair of radiation-induced damage as the predominant mechanism of IFN-related radiosensitization. Inhibition of the Non-Homologous-End-Joining repair (NHEJ) pathway, as shown in MO59J cells and WMN inhibited MO59K-cells, led to a supraadditive interaction of IFN and XRT, whereas cells with intact NHEJ (MO59K-cells) showed an additive interaction of IFN and XRT. Likely IFN is interfering with the second major pathway of double strand break repair, homologous recombination (HR). This was supported by the observation that mutation in the Brca2-gene in CAPAN-1 cells, which is already associated with impaired HR, did not alter the interaction of IFN with radiation repair
Read full abstract