Reviewed by: Memory and Utopia: The Poetry of José Ángel Valente by Manus O'Dwyer Ricardo Fernández Romero Memory and Utopia: The Poetry of José Ángel Valente. By Manus O'Dwyer. Cambridge: Legenda. 2020. x+ 142 pp. £75. ISBN 978-1-781883-65-5. Discussions of José Ángel Valente (1929–2000), one of the most important and original Spanish writers in the Spanish and Galician languages of the second half of the twentieth century, typically bring to mind a specific image: a modern mystic, a difficult and hermetic 'poet of silence'. This excellent monograph sails against the tide to, as Manus O'Dwyer himself writes, 'desvalentizar' the subject, 'making clear the political and social significance of his poetry' (p. 110). The challenge is considerable, especially given the fact that O'Dwyer identifies an ethical underpinning to the 'poetics of silence' (the questioning of lyrical language, absence, solitude, etc.), which requires a political approach to Valente's signature poetics. Even the title of the monograph points in this direction in its reference to the memory and testimony of the disappeared and those lacking a voice. Valente's desire to recuperate silenced figures indicates an openness to alterity, a poetic quest for a language that gestures towards a utopian future of radical social and political reform. This new vision of the poet is constructed through concise and precise analysis that does not shy away from issues of great philosophical and aesthetic complexity. Highlights include the examination of a fundamental philosophical tradition present in Valente that O'Dwyer connects with a specific religious culture: 'a discourse and understanding of Jewishness that develops in the works of post-war French thinkers—Sartre, Levinas, Derrida, Blanchot' (p. 75). In them, Valente finds '[a notion of community] that resists the atomistic conception of the individual of liberal tradition' and 'a utopian hopefulness': 'radically new forms of social relation and organisation that could be described as secularised versions of Jewish messianism' (p. 75). It is from this same perspective that O'Dwyer situates the importance of Ernst Bloch's utopian thought for understanding the poet. Such observations are complemented towards the end of book through reference to Valente's dialogue with the poets Edmond Jabès and Paul Celan. Of all these thinkers and writers, the relevance of Levinas, Bloch, and Celan comes to the fore in the political approach to Valente's poetry. The result is convincing as long as we understand the political dimension in general terms as opposed to being restricted to specific ideological labels and labelling. On repeated occasions, O'Dwyer reduces the historical backdrop for Valente's poetry to broad brushstrokes: 'the suffocating atmosphere of fascism', 'the intellectual and political mediocrity of the Communist Party', '[Valente's] historical experiences as an exile from a country that had borne the brunt of decades of fascist violence and repression' (p. 112). While O'Dwyer announces at the outset that '[Valente's] poetry and poetics imply a specific political stance' (p. 9), the reader, or at least this reader, is left at the end with the sensation that it is not so much specific as implicit. This, is however, a minor quibble to level at a ground-breaking and informative book that will change the way readers and scholars appreciate this towering figure of Spanish and Galician verse. [End Page 147] Ricardo Fernández Romero University of St Andrews Copyright © 2023 Modern Humanities Research Association