Reviewed by: Music in Chopin’s Warsaw Jonathan Kregor Music in Chopin’s Warsaw. By Halina Goldberg. New York: Oxford University Press, 2008. [viii, 330 p. ISBN: 9780195130737. $45.00.] Music examples, illustrations, bibliographic references, index. Despite the polonaises and mazurkas, the Krakowiak, and numerous solo songs set in the vernacular, most listeners of Frédéric Chopin’s music would not likely recognize his style as being particularly Polish. His compositions—almost all of them for solo piano—have long been recognized as cornerstones of a Romantic stylistic orientation whose chief practitioners spent most of their time in the artistic metropolises of Leipzig, Vienna, and especially Paris. Indeed, while Chopin was actively involved in Warsaw’s cultural life for more than a decade—composing for the aristocracy, attending university, even working as Sunday organist at a nearby church—most accounts [End Page 781] of his artistic formation begin in earnest with his departure for Vienna in 1829 and especially his move to Paris in 1831. For instance, Tad Szulc’s Chopin in Paris: The Life and Times of the Romantic Composer (New York: Scribner, 1998) glosses over the Warsaw period, and William G. Atwood’s more academic The Parisian Worlds of Frédéric Chopin (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999) avoids it completely. To be sure, most of the compositions for which Chopin is known today were written in Paris, but the popular and scholarly involvement with Chopin’s career after leaving Warsaw only reinforces our lack of familiarity with the content and context of his early period. Even the ostensibly innocent substitution of “Frédéric” for “Fryderyk” on recordings and concert programs unintentionally alienates modern listeners from the milieu of Chopin’s adolescent years. Halina Goldberg’s Music in Chopin’s Warsaw, therefore, is a welcome publication: a thorough introduction to the political, commercial, intellectual, and artistic worlds of Chopin’s youth; a primer of his early works; and a rich presentation and analysis of documents previously inaccessible to the English reader. For its level of detail about this vibrant community, Goldberg’s volume goes far beyond Iwo and Pamela Załuski’s biographically-driven Chopin’s Poland (London: Peter Owen Publishers, 1996). Music in Chopin’s Warsaw is a revision of Goldberg’s dissertation (“Musical Life in Warsaw during Chopin’s Youth, 1810–1830” [Ph.D. diss., City University of New York, 1997]), and the change of title is revealing. For rather than presenting a musical history of Warsaw between 1810 and 1830, she anchors her discussions of Warsaw’s institutions around the figure of Chopin himself. As such, Goldberg must juggle several stories simultaneously: the sometimes tragic history of the forging of a distinctly Polish identity in the midst of constant foreign occupation, the birth of Polish Romanticism, the relationship between folk, bourgeois, and aristocratic culture, and the rise and fall of Warsaw’s institutions of learning and culture. This structure is largely successful, but at times Chopin’s involvement in these issues is so tangential that his perfunctory inclusion detracts from the flow of her gripping narrative. Central to all eight chapters is Polish nationalism, a topic that regarding Chopin has largely been dealt with inductively through examples from his Paris years, especially the Polonaise-Fantasy, op. 61, and selected ballades and nocturnes. But what efforts were made within Poland to assert a distinctly cultural identity during Chopin’s youth? Goldberg identifies the university (chapter 4, “Musical Education”) and the bourgeois salon (chapter 5, “Salons: Background and Intellectual Trends,” and chapter 6, “Music in Salons”) as particularly important points of convergence between nationalist sentiments and the arts. The salon tradition hearkened back to Poland’s last king, Stanisław August, who “saw [the salon] as a means of encouraging the advancement of learning and arts in his country” (p. 149). Despite—or perhaps because of—Prussian and later Russian occupation of the Polish lands in the first decades of the nineteenth century (the subject of chapter 1, “Historical and Cultural Background”), bourgeois salons exhibited “much more intense political and national atmosphere” (p. 153) than their counterparts to the west. Even a work like Der Freischütz resonated with Polish poets and musicians intent...
Read full abstract