Between Cairo and the Volga-UralsAl-Manar and Islamic Modernism, 1905–17 Roy Bar Sadeh (bio) In 1905, a student protest erupted in the Islamic seminary (madrasa) of the Muhammediye (est. 1881), one of the most important institutions of Islamic learning in the Volga-Urals city of Kazan. The protest was led by the Reform Society (Islâh Cem’iyeti; est. 1904), which advocated reform of the madrasa’s curriculum and further instruction in modern subjects. The demonstrations ended in the resignation of 82 students following the expulsion of 4 of their schoolmates.1 Observing these events from Cairo, the Syrian-born Islamic scholar (‘alim) Muhammad Rashid Rida (1865–1935) published several letters by and articles in support of the protesters in al-Manar (The Lighthouse; 1898–1935), a renowned Arabic journal circulated throughout Muslim communities worldwide. [End Page 525] Al-Manar’s articles on the Muhammediye events signaled more than passing interest in a piece of news; they marked increasing interactions between Islamic scholars in Cairo and the Volga-Urals during the revolutionary turmoil of 1905–17 in Russia. In particular, al-Manar’s publications on the Volga-Urals demonstrate not only how proponents of “jadidism,” the multifaceted modernist movement of Islamic reform across the Russian Empire, became a subject of significance for enterprises of Islamic reform in Cairo, but also how jadids utilized Arabic journals to display and project their views and experiences to readership beyond the Russian Empire.2 Al-Manar was established in Cairo in 1898 by Rida, who had immigrated to Egypt from Ottoman Syria following the press censorship ordered by Ottoman Sultan Abdülhamid II (r. 1876–1909).3 Supported by his Egyptian [End Page 526] mentor, Shaykh Muhammad ‘Abduh (1849–1905), Rida initially established al-Manar as a bimonthly journal, later switching to monthly publication. The journal covered various themes such as politics, theology, education, sciences, economics, poetry, and history. The journal’s main message was a call for Islamic unity alongside educational and socio-political reforms based on the mastery of Arabic. Advocating the use of independent reasoning (ijtihad) alongside an emphasis on the compatibility between Islam and reason, Rida rejected what he viewed as “blind following” (taqlid) of the four Sunni schools of jurisprudence (madhahib), considering them a major obstacle to progress.4 He sought to promote this message of Islamic reform through the fatawa (legal opinions) he published in al-Manar in response to inquiries from Muslims living across Europe, Africa, Asia, and Latin America.5 Comprising nearly 14 million subjects (according to the 1897 Russian imperial census), Muslims living under Russian imperial rule were one of the most important target audiences for al-Manar.6 Although the journal touched on and corresponded with Muslims living under tsarist-governed regions such as Crimea, Dagestan, and Turkestan, its articles and interactions with Muslim subjects of the Russian Empire centered on the Volga-Urals, especially during the period between the 1905 and October 1917 revolutions. As Stéphane A. Dudoignon has shown in his pathbreaking study on the utilization and circulation of al-Manar’s ideas in the Russian Empire through the Orenburg-based Turkic biweekly Shura (Council, 1908–18), the popularity of Rida’s journal among Islamic reform enterprises in the Volga-Urals was tremendous. Islamic scholars in the Volga-Urals adopted al-Manar’s message or used the journal’s publications to reinforce and affirm their ideas, while modeling their journals’ organization on that of al-Manar. However, as Dudoignon has himself noted, even after the short-lived liberalization of the Russian press in the aftermath of the 1905 revolution, Muslim journals in the Russian Empire remained under the tight control of the tsarist state, whose officials feared the appearance of any so-called “Pan-Islamic” or “Pan-Turkic” ideas among the empire’s Muslim subjects. Thus Dudoignon suggests [End Page 527] that the “intellectual borrowings made by the new Muslim press of Russia from al-Manar, and from other periodicals of the external Islamic world, took place during a relatively short period, and were restricted to questions which would not arouse the concern of censors.”7 Dudoignon’s assumption concerning the restriction of al-Manar and other non...
Read full abstract