REVIEWS 577 and milk. Besides, ethnological ideas were changing: promoting distinctive Kazakh lifestyles fitted with the new view of nations as ancient and longlasting . In practice the new ranch-type kolkhozy became clan strongholds. To return to the question I posed in the first paragraph: it seems likely that traditional Kazakh culture was comprehensively destroyed in the 1930s. Then the massive immigrations of the Second World War and the virgin lands campaign turned the republic into an inter-ethnic microcosm of the Soviet Union itself; the titular nation was actually in a minority. There was moreover, no alternative to placing one’s trust in the authorities: this was ‘forced trust’, as depicted by Alexey Tikhomirov. Even after the Soviet collapse, Kindler notes, the plan to erect a monument to the victims of the great famine has never been fulfilled, leaving only a bare plinth (photographed on page 342) with the words ‘In this place will be erected a monument to the victims of the famine of 1931–33’. No better symbol could be imagined of the loss of national memory. Kindler’s book complements the research of Isabelle Ohayon (La sédentarisation des Kazakhs dans L’URSS de Staline, Paris, 2006) by providing a greater variety of local examples and by tracing through all-Union and Kazakh archives the interweaving of central and local policies. He also draws on social science and cultural theory to illuminate the results of his research. He goes far towards explaining what I think of as ‘the great Kazakh mystery’. UCL SSEES Geoffrey Hosking Pudłocki, Tomasz. Ambasadorzy idei: Wkład intelektualistów w promowanie pozytywnego wizerunku Polski w Wielkiej Brytanii w latach 1918–1939. Studia z Historii XX Wieku, 18, Historia Iagellonica, Kraków, 2015. 382 pp. Illustrations. Notes. Bibliography. Summary in English. Indexes. Zł50.00. Poland’s position in the interwar period was unenviable: it was surrounded by unfriendly nations, particularly the Soviet Union to the East against whom it achieved a slim victory, Germany to the West, and also to a greater or lesser degree Czechoslovakia and Lithuania, whose relations with Poland were rather strained due to Polish expansionism. Poland needed to establish effective treaties with other European powers, but as a new country it had little political, economic or popular clout, if the peoples of those powers knew anything about Poland at all. Additionally, it was jostling for a diplomatic position against a strong German anti-Polish propaganda machine as well as the broad popularity of Czechoslovakia. TomaszPudłocki’smonographexaminestheroleintellectualsplayedinPolish foreign policy in Great Britain, as Poland tried to establish a positive attitude SEER, 95, 3, JULY 2017 578 in the British population. He expertly weaves intellectual, cultural, diplomatic and social history to create a narrative about the successes and failures of this propaganda mission. Pudłocki draws on a wealth of sources, from archives across Poland, Britain and the United States, to biographies and contemporary publicity documents, and successfully combines these into a coherent story of the development of Polish public relations in Great Britain. The book is divided into five chapters that each examine a different aspect of the diplomatic process. The first chapter provides an overview of the British impression of Poland in the interwar era, paying careful attention to the various plusses and minuses in British public opinion, such as Britain’s wariness of Polish treatment of minorities and its aristocracy on the one hand, and fascination with Polish villages and folklore on the other. Chapter two outlines the official efforts of the ambassadors in Britain, giving the reader background on the official relations between the two countries as well as an introduction to the intellectuals and institutions discussed later in the book. In the third chapter, Pudłocki highlights British intellectuals who were friendly towards Poland, such as G. K. Chesterton and the critics Monica Mary Gardner and William John Rose, who would eventually become director of the School of Slavonic and East European Studies (SSEES) in London. The role SSEES played in Polish public relations constitutes the fourth chapter. The final, and best, chapter is dedicated to Roman Dyboski, the Polish scholar of English literature, who forms the backbone of the entire study. The...
Read full abstract