Laser-produced Sn plasma sources are used to generate extreme ultraviolet (EUV) light in state-of-the-art nanolithography. An ultraviolet and optical spectrum is measured from a droplet-based laser-produced Sn plasma, with a spectrograph covering the range 200 - 800 nm. This spectrum contains hundreds of spectral lines from lowly charged tin ions Sn$^{1+}$ - Sn$^{4+}$ of which a major fraction was hitherto unidentified. We present and identify a selected class of lines belonging to the quasi-one-electron, Ag-like ([Kr]$4d^{10} nl$ electronic configuration), Sn$^{3+}$ ion, linking the optical lines to a specific charge state by means of a masking technique. These line identifications are made with iterative guidance from COWAN code calculations. Of the 53 lines attributed to Sn$^{3+}$, some 20 were identified from previously known energy levels, and 33 lines are used to determine previously unknown level energies of 13 electronic configurations, i.e., $ 7p $, $ (7,8)d $, $ (5,6)f $, $ (6-8)g $, $ (6-8)h $, $ (7,8)i $. The consistency of the level energy determination is verified by the quantum-defect scaling procedure. The ionization limit of Sn$^{3+}$ is confirmed and refined to 328908.4 cm$^{-1}$ with an uncertainty of 2.1 cm$^{-1}$. The relativistic Fock space coupled cluster (FSCC) calculation of the measured level energies are generally in good agreement with experiment, but fail to reproduce the anomalous behavior of the $5d$ $^2$D and $nf$ $^2$F terms. By combining the strengths of FSCC, COWAN code calculations, and configuration interaction many-body perturbation theory (CI+MBPT), this behavior is shown to arise from interactions with doubly-excited configurations.