Disuse muscle atrophy is usually accompanied by changes in skeletal muscle structure, signaling, and contractile potential. Different models of muscle unloading can provide valuable information, but the protocols of experiments with complete immobilization are not physiologically representative of a sedentary lifestyle, which is highly prevalent among humans now. In the current study, we investigated the potential effects of restricted activity on the mechanical characteristics of rat postural (soleus) and locomotor (extensor digitorum longus, EDL) muscles. The restricted-activity rats were kept in small Plexiglas cages (17.0 × 9.6 × 13.0 cm) for 7 and 21 days. After this, soleus and EDL muscles were collected for ex vivo mechanical measurements and biochemical analysis. We demonstrated that while a 21-day movement restriction affected the weight of both muscles, in soleus muscle we observed a greater decrease. The maximum isometric force and passive tension in both muscles also significantly changed after 21 days of movement restriction, along with a decrease in the level of collagen 1 and 3 mRNA expression. Furthermore, the collagen content itself changed only in soleus after 7 and 21 days of movement restriction. With regard to cytoskeletal proteins, in our experiment we observed a significant decrease in telethonin in soleus, and a similar decrease in desmin and telethonin in EDL. We also observed a shift towards fast-type myosin heavy chain expression in soleus, but not in EDL. In summary, in this study we showed that movement restriction leads to profound specific changes in the mechanical properties of fast and slow skeletal muscles. Future studies may include evaluation of signaling mechanisms regulating the synthesis, degradation, and mRNA expression of the extracellular matrix and scaffold proteins of myofibers.