Carotid Sinus Massage (CSM) is recommended in the work-up of syncope. Opinions vary as to whether CSM is best done supine or upright to evoke a significant hemodynamic response. CSM was performed in 39 patients ( 23M/16F; age 49±17) undergoing tilt table testing for suspected neurocardiogenic syncope. Right and left Carotid Artery (CA) bifurcations were located by ultrasound (US), marked in ink, and CSM performed at this location supine on the right (RCSMsup) and left (LCSMsup). The participant was then tilted (60°) and CSM repeated 4-6 minutes following tilt on the right (RCSMtilt) and left (LCSMtilt). CSM was done for 10 sec while the breath was held beginning 5 sec after end-expiration. In 17 participants, sham CSM was also done supine (RCSMsham, LCSMsham) while the breath was held and a finger was place on the skin without pressure. The difference (Δ) between maximum sinus cycle length (SCL) during CSM and SCL just prior to CSM, as well as Δ between minimum systolic blood pressure (SBP) during CSM and that just prior to CSM and Δ diastolic (D)BP were measured. No significant ΔSCL was observed with RCSMsham (13±38 ms) and LCSMsham (10±40 ms). SCL prolongation of at least 50 ms (Mean+1SD of sham effect) occurred in 28/39 subjects to at least one of RCSMsup or LCSMsup, but only in 22/39 on tilt. However, there was no statistically significant difference in effect of CSM supine or upright (ΔRCSMsup: 61± 82 ms; ΔRCSMtilt: 42± 89 ms; ΔLCSMsup: 47± 67 ms; ΔLCSMtilt: 38± 52 ms) using t-test or non-parametric testing (Friedmann). Similarly, there was no difference in ΔSBP whether supine or upright (ΔRCSMsup : -7±17 mm Hg; ΔRCSMtilt : -7±17 mm Hg; ΔLCSMsup : -6±12 mm Hg; ΔLCSMtilt: -5±15 mm Hg) or in ΔDBP (ΔRCSMsup: -4±11 mm Hg; ΔRCSMtilt: -5±11 mm Hg; ΔLCSMsup: -4±8 mm Hg; ΔLCSMtilt: -4±11 mm Hg). A non-significant tendency to greater prolongation of SCL in the older group (n = 28; age > 40) with ΔRCSMsup 71±92 ms vs in the younger group (n=11; age ≤ 40) ΔRCSMsup 36±38 ms was absent with tilt and was not observed with LCSM either supine or upright. Using US localization of the CA bifurcation, there is no added value to performing CSM in the upright position compared to supine testing. In fact, there is a tendency to a lesser bradycardic response and no greater BP lowering in the upright position.
Read full abstract