The EPR and optical spectra of two similar square planar CuO2N2 chelates, copper hydroxyquinolinate (CuOx2) and copper picolinate (CuPic2) have been investigated. By studying both molecules in a series of several paramagnetic and diamagnetic single crystal matrices, powders and solutions, the dependence of the g tensor, metal hyperfine (hfs) tensor, nitrogen hfs tensor and the optical d-d transitions on the host lattice was determined. The strong interactions of polar matrix groups with the substituted metal complex cause the major change in the magnetic parameters and the d-d optical transitions of these centrosymmetric planar d9 complexes. In both series of host metal complexes, the copper ligands changed stepwise from a nearly octahedral arrangement (strong axial coordination) to nearly square planar arrangement (negligible axial coordination). This change is accompanied by a total decrease in the Δg parameters of 30%–35%, a total increase in the ligand spin density of 15%, and a total increase in the d-d transition frequencies of 25%. The observed increase in covalency of the singly occupied orbital with increasing axial distortion of the ligand octahedron is in qualitative agreement with results of semiempirical MO calculations. The orthorhombic distortion of the g and A tensors shows significant coorelation with the Fermi contact parameter κ for the copper nucleus. A 2p/2s hybridization ratio of 5.8 for the nitrogen lone pair component of the singly occupied σ orbital has been found for CuOx2, as well as for CuPic2. The nitrogen hfs principal axis (Bx) coincides with one of the in plane g axes (gx) for CuPic2, while the gx and Bx axes differ by 12°–17° in the case of CuOx2. The nitrogen spin density is significantly smaller for CuOx2 than for CuPic2 at equal g shifts, indicating a stronger interaction of the phenolic oxygen in CuOx2 relative to the carboxylate oxygen in CuPic2 with the metal ion. These experimental results show the shortcomings of the simple LCAO model generally used to describe the electronic structure of metal complexes. The use of free ion (or atom) wavefunctions for example leads to large overestimations of the π delocalization parameters and of the amount of g dependence on covalency. In order to obtain agreement with experiment, a scaling parameter (as proposed by K. Ruedenberg in 1962) for the metal 3d part of the involved MO's should be introduced to account for the virtual expansion of the atomic orbitals in antibonding orbitals. Variations of the effective charge appear to be negligible. This expansion results in a smaller spin-orbit constant and a smaller <r−3>3d parameter. This effect contributes substantially to the generally observed reduced spin-orbit and metal hfs interactions in covalent transition metal complexes.
Read full abstract