Little is known about the coccidian parasites of the American alligator, Alligator mississippiensis (Daudin). To date, only two species of Eimeria Schneider, 1875 have been previously reported from A. mississippiensis. Here, we report from mensural and morphometric data on two new species of Eimeria from A. mississippiensis from Georgia, USA. Fresh feces were collected in June 2023 from a single captive juvenile male A. mississippiensis. Multiple samples were placed in individual zip-lock bags and aqueous potassium dichromate was added. They were examined for sporulated oocysts after flotation in Sheather's sugar solution, measured, and photographed. Samples contained oocysts representing two new species of Eimeria. Oocysts of Eimeria tellezae n. sp. are subspheroidal to ellipsoidal with a pitted bi-layered wall, measure (L × W) 34.5 × 31.5µm, and have a length/width (L/W) ratio of 1.1; a micropyle and polar granule were absent but an oöcyst residuum was present. Sporocysts are ellipsoidal and measure 17.2 × 7.7µm, L/W 2.2; a nipple-like Stieda body bearing one to several filaments was present but sub-Stieda and para-Stieda bodies were absent. The sporocyst residuum is composed of various-sized granules in a compact rounded or irregular mass, sometimes dispersed between the sporozoites. Oocysts of Eimeria daudini n. sp. are ellipsoidal with a pitted bi-layered wall, measure (L × W) 32.5 × 20.2µm, and have a length/width (L/W) ratio of 1.6; a micropyle and polar granule were absent but an oöcyst residuum was present. Sporocysts are ellipsoidal and measure 15.4 × 7.4µm, L/W 2.1; a nipple-like Stieda body bearing one to several filaments was present but sub-Stieda and para-Stieda bodies were absent. The sporocyst residuum is composed of various-sized granules in a compact rounded or irregular mass, sometimes dispersed between the sporozoites. Both new species can readily be distinguished from previously described eimerians from crocodilians, including those from A. mississippiensis. We document two new species of Eimeria from the American alligator. Currently, four species of Eimeria are known from A. mississippiensis examined from both east and west of the Mississippi River, USA.