We have reported that germinomas could be diagnosed from clinical evaluations and radiological imagings, however the specificity was below 100% [J Clin Neurosci. 2014]. In order to precisely diagnose the patients with germinomas, we recently perform advanced MR imaging studies including MR spectroscopy (MRS) and minimum apparent diffusion coefficiency (minADC) study, and evaluation of serum tumor markers, i.e. HCG, beta HCG, HCG-CTP. This retrospective study was carried out to search the possibility of preoperative diagnosis with increased specificity in patients with germinoma-like tumors. Thirty consecutive patients with germinoma-like tumor underwent initial treatment from May 2007 to January 2015. Both minADC value and lipid peak on proton MRS were evaluated in 22 patients, minADC only in 5, and MRS only in 1 patient. Serum level of HCG, beta-HCG, and HCG-CTP were evaluated in 22 cases, HCG and beta-HCG in 5, and only beta-HCG in 1 case. With or without histological verifications, all of these patients received three courses of chemotherapy using ifosfamide, cisplatin, and etoposide or carboplatin and etoposide, and then received 24Gy whole ventricle irradiation. All patient drastically responded to the treatment and are alive with only one events of recurrence. Both low (<0.7x 10(-3)mm(2)/s) minADC value and lipid peak on proton MRS were observed in 20 patients among 22 who received both. Among these 20 patients, some elevations of tumor markers were detected in 7. Consequently, evaluation of minADC and proton MRS are useful to distinguish germinomas from other tumors, but some non-germinomas may show similar characteristics to germinoma. Combination with serum tumor marker evaluation, we may be able to distinguish the germinoma patients with higher specificity. It may be safe to say that unnecessary surgery can be avoided at least in 7 out of 20 patients who demonstrated both MRI and serum characteristics. Prospective study is warranted.
Read full abstract