Separated Local Field Experiments Research Articles

1H detection of heteronuclear dipolar oscillations with water suppression in single crystal peptide and oriented protein samples

Oriented sample solid-state NMR is a complementary approach to protein structure determination with the distinct advantage that it can be applied to supramolecular assemblies, such as viruses and membrane proteins, under near-native conditions, which generally include high levels of hydration as found in living systems. Thus, in order to perform 1H detected versions of multi-dimensional experiments water suppression techniques must be integrated into the pulse sequences. For example, 1H-windowed detection of 1H-15N dipolar couplings enable multi-dimensional NMR experiments to be performed. Here we show that the addition of a solvent suppression pulse during the z-filter interval greatly improves the sensitivity of the experiments by suppressing the 1H signals from water present. This is demonstrated here with a crystal sample submerged in water and then extended to proteins. The combination of solvent-suppressed 1H detected PISEMO and the use of a strip shield-solenoid coil probe configuration provides a two-fold sensitivity enhancement in both the crystal sample and Pf1 coat protein sample compared to the 15N direct detection method. Here we also examine protein NMR line-widths and sensitivity enhancements in the context of window detected separated local field experiments for protein samples.

Computer-generated pulse sequences for 1H-15N and 1Hα-13Cα separated local-field experiments

High-resolution separated local field (SLF) experiments are employed in oriented-sample solid state NMR to measure angular-dependent heteronuclear dipolar couplings for structure determination. While traditionally these experiments have been designed analytically by determining cycles of pulses with specific phases and durations to achieve cancellation of the homonuclear dipolar terms in the average Hamiltonian, recent work has introduced a computational approach to optimizing linewidths of the 1H-15N dipolar resonances. Accelerated by GPU processors, a computer algorithm searches for the optimal parameters by simulating numerous 1H-15N NMR spectra. This approach, termed ROULETTE, showed promising results by developing a new pulse sequence (ROULETTE-1.0) exhibiting 18% sharper mean linewidths than SAMPI4 for an N-acetyl Leucine (NAL) crystal. Herein, we expand on this previous work to improve the performance of the 1H-15N SLF experiment and extend the work beyond the original approach to new SLF experiments. The new algorithm, in addition to finding pulse durations and phases, now searches for the optimal on/off application scheme of radio frequency irradiation on each channel. This constitutes true de novo optimization, effectively optimizing every aspect of a pulse sequence instead of just phases and durations. With an improved ROULETTE algorithm, we have found a new 1H-15N pulse sequence, termed ROULETTE-2.0, yielding 32% sharper mean linewidths than SAMPI4 for NAL crystal at 500 MHz 1H frequency. Whereas both SAMPI4 and ROULETTE-1.0 have a window where the rf power on the I-channel is turned off, the new pulse sequence is entirely windowless. Furthermore, the reliability of the algorithm has been greatly improved in terms of avoiding false positives, i.e. well-performing pulse sequences in silica that fail to render narrow resonances in experiment. The program has been extended to the 13Cα-1Hα SLF experiments, using a 6 subdwell architecture similar to the 1H-15N optimization. Compared to the PISEMA pulse sequence, the mean 13Cα-1Hα linewidth is 17% sharper for the new pulse sequence, termed ROULETTE-CAHA. In addition to superior performance, the work demonstrates the broad applicability of the algorithm and its adaptability to different NMR experiments and spin systems.

Improving the quality of oriented membrane protein spectra using heat-compensated separated local field experiments.

Oriented sample solid-state NMR (OS-ssNMR) spectroscopy is a powerful technique to determine the topology of membrane proteins in oriented lipid bilayers. Separated local field (SLF) experiments are central to this technique as they provide first-order orientational restraints, i.e., dipolar couplings and anisotropic chemical shifts. Despite the use of low-E (or E-free) probes, the heat generated during the execution of 2D and 3D SLF pulse sequences causes sizeable line-shape distortions. Here, we propose a new heat-compensated SE-SAMPI4 (hcSE-SAMPI4) pulse sequence that holds the temperature constant for the duration of the experiment. This modification of the SE-SAMPI4 results in sharper and more intense resonances without line-shape distortions. The spectral improvements are even more apparent when paramagnetic relaxation agents are used to speed up data collection. We tested the hcSE-SAMPI4 pulse sequence on a single-span membrane protein, sarcolipin (SLN), reconstituted in magnetically aligned lipid bicelles. In addition to eliminating peak distortions, the hcSE-SAMPI4 experiment increased the average signal-to-noise ratio by 20% with respect to the original SE-SAMPI4.

Selective excitation for spectral editing and assignment in separated local field experiments of oriented membrane proteins

Spectroscopic assignment of NMR spectra for oriented uniformly labeled membrane proteins embedded in their native-like bilayer environment is essential for their structure determination. However, sequence-specific assignment in oriented-sample (OS) NMR is often complicated by insufficient resolution and spectral crowding. Therefore, the assignment process is usually done by a laborious and expensive “shotgun” method involving multiple selective labeling of amino acid residues. Presented here is a strategy to overcome poor spectral resolution in crowded regions of 2D spectra by selecting resolved “seed” residues via soft Gaussian pulses inserted into spin-exchange separated local-field experiments. The Gaussian pulse places the selected polarization along the z-axis while dephasing the other signals before the evolution of the 1H-15N dipolar couplings. The transfer of magnetization is accomplished via mismatched Hartmann-Hahn conditions to the nearest-neighbor peaks via the proton bath. By optimizing the length and amplitude of the Gaussian pulse, one can also achieve a phase inversion of the closest peaks, thus providing an additional phase contrast. From the superposition of the selective spin-exchanged SAMPI4 onto the fully excited SAMPI4 spectrum, the 15N sites that are directly adjacent to the selectively excited residues can be easily identified, thereby providing a straightforward method for initiating the assignment process in oriented membrane proteins.

Solid-State NMR/Dynamic Nuclear Polarization of Polypeptides in Planar Supported Lipid Bilayers.

Dynamic nuclear polarization has been developed to overcome the limitations of the inherently low signal intensity of NMR spectroscopy. This technique promises to be particularly useful for solid-state NMR spectroscopy where the signals are broadened over a larger frequency range and most investigations rely on recording low gamma nuclei. To extend the range of possible investigations, a triple-resonance flat-coil solid-state NMR probe is presented with microwave irradiation capacities allowing the investigation of static samples at temperatures of 100 K, including supported lipid bilayers. The probe performance allows for two-dimensional separated local field experiments with high-power Lee-Goldberg decoupling and cross-polarization under simultaneous irradiation from a gyrotron microwave generator. Efficient cooling of the sample turned out to be essential for best enhancements and line shape and necessitated the development of a dedicated cooling chamber. Furthermore, a new membrane-anchored biradical is presented, and the geometry of supported membranes was optimized not only for good membrane alignment, handling, stability, and filling factor of the coil but also for heat and microwave dissipation. Enhancement factors of 17-fold were obtained, and a two-dimensional PISEMA spectrum of a transmembrane helical peptide was obtained in less than 2 h.

Proton evolved local field solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance using Hadamard encoding: Theory and application to membrane proteins

NMR anisotropic parameters such as dipolar couplings and chemical shifts are central to structure and orientation determination of aligned membrane proteins and liquid crystals. Among the separated local field experiments, the proton evolved local field (PELF) scheme is particularly suitable to measure dynamically averaged dipolar couplings and give information on local molecular motions. However, the PELF experiment requires the acquisition of several 2D datasets at different mixing times to optimize the sensitivity for the complete range of dipolar couplings of the resonances in the spectrum. Here, we propose a new PELF experiment that takes the advantage of the Hadamard encoding (HE) to obtain higher sensitivity for a broad range of dipolar couplings using a single 2D experiment. The HE scheme is obtained by selecting the spin operators with phase switching of hard pulses. This approach enables one to detect four spin operators, simultaneously, which can be processed into two 2D spectra covering a broader range of dipolar couplings. The advantages of the new approach are illustrated for a U-(15)N NAL single crystal and the U-(15)N labeled single-pass membrane protein sarcolipin reconstituted in oriented lipid bicelles. The HE-PELF scheme can be implemented in other multidimensional experiments to speed up the characterization of the structure and dynamics of oriented membrane proteins and liquid crystalline samples.

A proton spin diffusion based solid-state NMR approach for structural studies on aligned samples.

Rapidly expanding research on nonsoluble and noncrystalline chemical and biological materials necessitates sophisticated techniques to image these materials at atomic-level resolution. Although their study poses a formidable challenge, solid-state NMR is a powerful tool that has demonstrated application to the investigation of their molecular architecture and functioning. In particular, 2D separated-local-field (SLF) spectroscopy is increasingly applied to obtain high-resolution molecular images of these materials. However, despite the common use of SLF experiments in the structural studies of a variety of aligned molecules, the lack of a resonance assignment approach has been a major disadvantage. As a result, solid-state NMR studies have mostly been limited to aligned systems that are labeled with an isotope at a single site. Here, we demonstrate an approach for resonance assignment through a controlled reintroduction of proton spin diffusion in the 2D proton-evolved-local-field (PELF) pulse sequence. Experimental results and simulations suggest that the use of spin diffusion also enables the measurement of long-range heteronuclear dipolar couplings that can be used as additional constraints in the structural and dynamical studies of aligned molecules. The new method is used to determine the de novo atomic-level resolution structure of a liquid crystalline material, N-(4-methoxybenzylidene)-4-butylaniline, and its use on magnetically aligned bicelles is also demonstrated. We expect this technique to also be valuable in the structural studies of functional molecules like columnar liquid crystals and other biomaterials.

Proton-Evolved Local-Field Solid-State NMR Studies of Cytochrome b5 Embedded in Bicelles, Revealing both Structural and Dynamical Information

Structural biology of membrane proteins has rapidly evolved into a new frontier of science. Although solving the structure of a membrane protein with atomic-level resolution is still a major challenge, separated local field (SLF) NMR spectroscopy has become an invaluable tool in obtaining structural images of membrane proteins under physiological conditions. Recent studies have demonstrated the use of rotating-frame SLF techniques to accurately measure strong heteronuclear dipolar couplings between directly bonded nuclei. However, in these experiments, all weak dipolar couplings are suppressed. On the other hand, weak heteronuclear dipolar couplings can be measured using laboratory-frame SLF experiments, but only at the expense of spectral resolution for strongly dipolar coupled spins. In the present study, we implemented two-dimensional proton-evolved local-field (2D PELF) pulse sequences using either composite zero cross-polarization (COMPOZER-CP) or windowless isotropic mixing (WIM) for magnetization transfer. These PELF sequences can be used for the measurement of a broad range of heteronuclear dipolar couplings, allowing for a complete mapping of protein dynamics in a lipid bilayer environment. Experimental results from magnetically aligned bicelles containing uniformly (15)N-labeled cytochrome b(5) are presented and theoretical analyses of the new PELF sequences are reported. Our results suggest that the PELF-based experimental approaches will have a profound impact on solid-state NMR spectroscopy of membrane proteins and other membrane-associated molecules in magnetically aligned bicelles.

Sensitivity enhancement in static solid-state NMR experiments via single- and multiple-quantum dipolar coherences.

We present a new method for enhancing the sensitivity in static solid-state NMR experiments for a gain in signal-to-noise ratio of up to 40%. This sensitivity enhancement is different from the corresponding solution NMR sensitivity enhancement schemes and is achieved by combining single- and multiple-quantum dipolar coherences. While this new approach is demonstrated for the polarization inversion spin exchange at magic angle (PISEMA) experiment, it can be generalized to the other separated local field experiments for solid-state NMR spectroscopy. This method will have a direct impact on solid-state NMR spectroscopy of liquid crystals as well as of membrane proteins aligned in lipid membranes.

Solid State NMR of Membrane Proteins: Towards Complex Structural and Functional Information for Bacterial ABC Class Importers

Despite the wealth of protein structural data available today, membrane protein structural characterization continues to pose a significant challenge in structural biology. Choosing the membrane mimetic is a challenge and often detergent micelles are employed. However, detergents are prone to induce distortions in the protein structure. An emerging technique, solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), provides a path to structural characterization using an environment similar to the native one, liquid crystalline lipid bilayers.Static solid state NMR experiments on proteins determine the orientation of the peptide planes with respect to the magnetic field. All 15N-1H dipolar couplings and anisotropic 15N chemical shifts observed in two dimensional separated local field experiments (PISEMA) lie within a butterfly shape in the spectrum. Special patterns called PISA wheels arise for uniformly aligned protein samples which directly reflect the orientation of protein secondary structure. Using these wheels the tilt angle of each helical axis from the magnetic field and membrane normal can be determined without complete structure determination. Consequently, a single data set allows for characterization of secondary structure in the membrane mimetic as well as providing a set of high resolution peptide plane orientations that can be used directly in structural refinement.Uniform alignment has been achieved for multiple proteins in our laboratory. Still, studies on larger membrane proteins are required to make solid state NMR a generally applicable technique for membrane protein structure characterization. One excellent example is SugAB, the transmembrane domain of an ABC importer from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. These transport proteins contain at least 10 transmembrane helices. This makes SugAB an excellent target for determining the utility of solid state NMR to structurally characterize large membrane proteins.

High-Resolution Characterization of Liquid-Crystalline [60]Fullerenes Using Solid-State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Liquid-crystalline materials containing fullerenes are valuable in the development of supramolecular switches and in solar cell technology. In this study, we characterize the liquid-crystalline and dynamic properties of fullerene-containing thermotropic compounds using solid-state natural abundance (13)C NMR experiments under stationary and magic angle spinning sample conditions. Chemical shifts spectra were measured in isotropic, liquid-crystalline nematic and smectic A and crystalline phases using one-dimensional (13)C experiments, while two-dimensional separated local-field experiments were used to measure the (1)H- (13)C dipolar couplings in mesophases. Chemical shift and dipolar coupling parameters were used to characterize the structure and dynamics of the liquid-crystalline dyads. NMR data of fullerene-containing thermotropic liquid crystals are compared to that of basic mesogenic unit and mesomorphic promoter compounds. Our NMR results suggest that the fullerene-ferrocene dyads form highly dynamic liquid-crystalline phases in which molecules rotate fast around the symmetry axis on the characteristic NMR time scale of approximately 10 (-4) s.

Heteronuclear isotropic mixing separated local field NMR spectroscopy

This paper presents a theoretical, numerical, and experimental study of a new class of separated local field (SLF) techniques. These techniques are based on the heteronuclear isotropic mixing leading to spin exchange via the local field (HIMSELF). It is shown that highly efficient and robust SLF experiments can be designed based on double channel windowless homonuclear decoupling sequences. Compared to rotating frame techniques based on Hartmann-Hahn cross polarization, the new approach is less susceptible to the frequency offset and chemical shift interaction and can be applied in the structural studies of macromolecules that are uniformly labeled with isotopes such as (13)C and (15)N. Furthermore, isotropic mixing sequences allow for transfer of any magnetization component of one nucleus to the corresponding component of its dipolar coupled partner. The performance of HIMSELF is studied by analysis of the average Hamiltonian and numerical simulation and is experimentally demonstrated on a single crystalline sample of a dipeptide and a liquid crystalline sample exhibiting motionally averaged dipolar couplings.

Remarkable reduction of rf power by ATANSEMA and DATANSEMA separated local field in solid-state NMR spectroscopy

We propose a novel approach to markedly reduce rf power for both 1H and observed nuclei during spin exchange for separated local field experiments. The rf power to satisfy the Hartmann–Hahn matching conditions during spin exchange for observed nuclei was arbitrarily reduced by alternating the directions of effective fields for 1H nuclei with unequal duration times and amplitudes. The proposed techniques were compared experimentally with those developed previously by the authors. The rf power for observed nuclei and average 1H were reduced by factors of 9 and 2, respectively, for 13C NMR signals of liquid crystalline 5CB.

2-D homonuclear correlation and separated local field experiments for solids with strong homonuclear dipolar couplings

An experiment for acquiring two-dimensional homonuclear correlation spectra of nuclei in solids in the presence of strong homonuclear dipolar couplings is described. The experiment utilizes a multiple-pulse homonuclear decoupling sequence with an effective precession axis parallel to the rotating frame z-axis during the evolution and detection periods. A multiple-pulse sequence that suppresses chemical shift and heteronuclear dipolar coupling evolution and scales the static homonuclear dipolar coupling is proposed for the mixing period. The evolution during the mixing period is analogous to the dynamics of the mixing period in solution-state TOCSY experiments, and can be interpreted as the oscillatory exchange of longitudinal magnetization between coupled spins. For nuclides with large gyromagnetic ratios, the static homonuclear dipolar interaction will be substantially larger than the mechanisms used to develop internuclear correlations in solution state 2-D experiments, which should make it possible to establish correlations over much longer distances and with significantly shorter mixing times. Extensions to separated local field experiments are discussed.