Sedimentation Equilibrium Analytical Ultracentrifugation Research Articles

HOP is a monomer: Investigation of the oligomeric state of the co‐chaperone HOP

The co-chaperone Hsp70-Hsp90 organizing protein (HOP) plays a central role in protein folding in vivo, binding to both Hsp70 and Hsp90 and bringing them together in a functional complex. Reports in the literature concerning the oligomeric state of HOP have been inconsistent-is it a monomer, dimer, or higher order oligomer? Knowing the oligomeric state of HOP is important, because it places limits on the number and types of multiprotein complexes that can form during the folding cycle. Thus, the number of feasible models is simplified. Here, we explicitly investigate the oligomeric state of HOP using three complementary methods: gel filtration chromatography, sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), and an in vivo coexpression assay. We find that HOP does not behave like a monomeric globular protein on gel filtration. Rather its behavior is consistent with it being either an elongated monomer or a dimer. We follow-up on these studies using sedimentation equilibrium AUC, which separates on the basis of molecular weight (MW), independent of shape. Sedimentation equilibrium AUC clearly shows that HOP is a monomer, with no indication of higher MW species. Finally, we use an in vivo coexpression assay that also supports the conclusion that HOP is a monomer.

Stability of ligand-binding domain dimer assembly controls kainate receptor desensitization

AMPA and kainate receptors mediate fast synaptic transmission. AMPA receptor ligand-binding domains form dimers, which are key functional units controlling ion-channel activation and desensitization. Dimer stability is inversely related to the rate and extent of desensitization. Kainate and AMPA receptors share common structural elements, but functional measurements suggest that subunit assembly and gating differs between these subtypes. To investigate this, we constructed a library of GluR6 kainate receptor mutants and directly measured changes in kainate receptor dimer stability by analytical ultracentrifugation, which, combined with electrophysiological experiments, revealed an inverse correlation between dimer stability and the rate of desensitization. We solved crystal structures for a series of five GluR6 mutants, to understand the molecular mechanisms for dimer stabilization. We demonstrate that the desensitized state of kainate receptors acts as a deep energy well offsetting the stabilizing effects of dimer interface mutants, and that the deactivation of kainate receptor responses is dominated by entry into desensitized states. Our results show how neurotransmitter receptors with similar structures and gating mechanisms can exhibit strikingly different functional properties.

Outer Membrane Phospholipase A Dimer Stability Does Not Correlate to Occluded Surface Area

Despite the key roles of oligomeric membrane proteins (MPs) in many known cellular pathways, the principles governing their oligomer stability are not well-understood. Previous work with the alpha-helical MPs bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and glycophorin A (GpA) shows that lost buried surface area linearly correlated with perturbations in protein stability. Although this is a significant discovery, the predictive power of this correlation is limited by the data. Because both bR and GpA have alpha-helical secondary structural motifs, it is unclear whether this correlation would be observed for MPs with a beta-barrel motif. We addressed this question by measuring the thermodynamic consequences of interfacial amino acid changes at the dimer interface of beta-barrel MP outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA). We created sequence variants to reduce the contact surface area of the OMPLA dimer interface by introducing single-alanine substitutions and used sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation to determine the dimerization free energies for these variants. The integrity of each variant was verified by two functional assays: specific activity and resistance to thermal denaturation, which showed that structural changes were restricted to the local environment. Using this information, we calculated the anticipated packing defects due to side chain deletion and compared this to the free energy perturbations for each residue. Contrary to the findings with bR and GpA, our study found no correlation between the contact surface area lost and the perturbations to OMPLA dimer stability. We conclude that van der Waals packing may not be a strong predictor of stability for all membrane proteins.

Determination of membrane protein molecular weight using sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation.

Both the stoichiometry and stability of native membrane protein complexes pose challenges to understanding the biology of these proteins. Sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation is well recognized as a thermodynamically rigorous technique for determining these quantities for macromolecules. This unit describes the experimental strategies that can be used to extract this information for membrane proteins reconstituted in vitro in detergent micelle or detergent/lipid mixed micelle solutions.

Correlation between dissociation and catalysis of SARS-CoV main protease

The dimeric interface of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus main protease is a potential target for the anti-SARS drug development. We have generated C-terminal truncated mutants by serial truncations. The quaternary structure of the enzyme was analyzed using both sedimentation velocity and sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation. Global analysis of the combined results showed that truncation of C-terminus from 306 to 300 had no appreciable effect on the quaternary structure, and the enzyme remained catalytically active. However, further deletion of Gln-299 or Arg-298 drastically decreased the enzyme activity to 1–2% of wild type (WT), and the major form was a monomeric one. Detailed analysis of the point mutants of these two amino acid residues and their nearby hydrogen bond partner Ser-123 and Ser-139 revealed a strong correlation between the enzyme activity loss and dimer dissociation.

Oligomeric and functional properties of a debranching enzyme (TreX) from the archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus P2

A gene, treX, encoding a debranching enzyme previously cloned from the trehalose biosynthesis gene cluster of Sulfolobus solfataricus P2 was expressed in Escherichia coli as a His-tagged protein and the biochemical properties were studied. The specific activity of the S. solfataricus debranching enzyme (TreX) was highest at 75°C and pH 5.5. The enzyme exhibited hydrolysing activity toward α-1,6-glycosidic linkages of amylopectin, glycogen, pullulan, and other branched substrates, and glycogen was the preferred substrate. TreX has a high specificity for hydrolysis of maltohexaosyl α-1,6-β-cyclodextrin, indicating the high preference for side chains consisting of 6 glucose residues or more. The enzyme also exhibited 4-α-sulfoxide-glucan transferase activity, catalysing transfer of α-1,4-glucan oligosaccharides from one chain to another. Dimethyl sulfoxide (10%, v/v) increased the hydrolytic activity of TreX. Gel permeation chromatography and sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation revealed that the enzyme exists mostly as a dimer at pH 7.0, and as a mixture of dimers and tetramers at pH 5.5. Interestingly, TreX existed as a tetramer in the presence of DMSO at pH 5.5–6.5. The tetramer showed a 4-fold higher catalytic efficiency than the dimer. The enzyme catalysed not only intermolecular trans-glycosylation of malto-oligosaccharides (disproportionation) to produce linear α-1,4-glucans, but also intramolecular trans-glycosylation of glycogen. The results presented in this study indicated that TreX may be associated with glycogen metabolism by selective cleavage of the outer side chain.

The Staphylococcus aureus extracellular adherence protein (Eap) adopts an elongated but structured conformation in solution.

The extracellular adherence protein (Eap) of Staphylococcus aureus participates in a wide range of protein-protein interactions that facilitate the initiation and dissemination of Staphylococcal disease. In this report, we describe the use of a multidisciplinary approach to characterize the solution structure of full-length Eap. In contrast to previous reports suggesting that a six-domain isoform of Eap undergoes multimerization, sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation data revealed that a four-domain isoform of Eap is a monomer in solution. In vitro proteolysis and solution small angle X-ray scattering studies both indicate that Eap adopts an extended conformation in solution, where the linkers connecting sequential EAP modules are solvent exposed. Construction of a low-resolution model of full-length Eap using a combination of ab initio deconvolution of the SAXS data and rigid body modeling of the EAP domain crystal structure suggests that full-length Eap may present several unique concave surfaces capable of participating in ligand binding. These results also raise the possibility that such surfaces may be held together by additional interactions between adjacent EAP modules. This hypothesis is supported by a comparative Raman spectroscopic analysis of full-length Eap and a stoichiometric solution of the individual EAP modules, which indicates the presence of additional secondary structure and a greater extent of hydrogen/deuterium exchange protection in full-length Eap. Our results provide the first insight into the solution structure of full-length Eap and an experimental basis for interpreting the EAP domain crystal structures within the context of the full-length molecule. They also lay a foundation for future studies into the structural and molecular bases of Eap-mediated protein-protein interactions with its many ligands.

Measuring protein-protein interactions by equilibrium sedimentation.

This unit describes basic principles and practice of sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation for the study of reversible protein interactions, such as the characterization of self-association, heterogeneous association, and binding stoichiometry, as well as the determination of association constants. Advanced tools such as mass conservation analysis, multiwavelength analysis, and global analysis are introduced and discussed in the context of the experimental design. A detailed protocol guiding the investigator through the experimental steps and the data analysis is available as an internet resource.

Synapsis of loxP Sites by Cre Recombinase

Cre recombinase catalyzes site-specific recombination between 34-bp loxP sites in a variety of topological and cellular contexts. An obligatory step in the recombination reaction is the association, or synapsis, of Cre-bound loxP sites to form a tetrameric protein assembly that is competent for strand exchange. Using analytical ultracentrifugation and electrophoresis approaches, we have studied the energetics of Cre-mediated synapsis of loxP sites. We found that synapsis occurs with a high affinity (Kd = 10 nM) and is pH-dependent but does not require divalent cations. Surprisingly, the catalytically inactive Cre K201A mutant is fully competent for synapsis of loxP sites, yet the inactive Y324F and R173K mutants are defective for synapsis. These findings have allowed us to determine the first crystal structures of a pre-cleavage Cre-loxP synaptic complex in a configuration representing the starting point in the recombination pathway. When combined with a quantitative analysis of synapsis using loxP mutants, the structures explain how the central 8 bp of the loxP site are able to dictate the order of strand exchange in the Cre system.

Dimerization of the Erythropoietin Receptor Transmembrane Domain in Micelles

Erythropoietin receptor (EpoR) homodimerization is an initial regulatory step in erythrocyte formation. Receptor dimers form before ligand binding, suggesting that association between receptor proteins is dependent on the receptor itself. EpoR dimerization is an essential step in erythropoiesis, and misregulation of this dimerization has been implicated in several disease states, including multi-lineage leukemias; nevertheless, how EpoR regulates its own dimerization is unclear. In vivo experiments suggest the single-pass transmembrane helix is the strongest candidate for driving ligand-independent association. To address the self-association potential of this transmembrane segment, we studied its interaction energetics in micelles by utilizing a previously successful Staphylococcal nuclease (SN-EpoR TM) fusion protein. This fusion protein strategy allows expression of the EpoR transmembrane domain in Escherichia coli independent of the other EpoR domains. Sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation of the detergent-solubilized SN-EpoR TM demonstrated that the murine EpoR transmembrane domain self-associates to form dimers. Although this interaction is not as stable as the dimerization of the well-studied glycophorin A transmembrane dimer, the murine EpoR transmembrane domain dimer is more stable than the interactions of the colon carcinoma kinase 4 transmembrane domain. The same experiments with the human EpoR transmembrane domain, which differs from the mouse sequence by only three residues, revealed a less favorable interaction than that of the murine sequence and is only slightly more favorable than that expected for non-preferential binding. These results suggest that the mouse and human receptor proteins may differ in the roles they play in signaling.

199 POSTER Efficacy evaluation of the humanized anti-EGFR MAb h-R3 (nimotuzumab) in combination with radiotherapy in the treatment of patients with unresectable squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck

Receptor activator of NF-κB ligand (RANKL) is a type II transmembrane protein found on osteoblasts which functions as a major determinant of osteoclast differentiation and activation. RANKL mediates bone homeostasis through binding to the cognate ligand on osteoclasts, RANK, and a soluble decoy receptor, osteoprotegerin (OPG). We designed a construct encoding the extracellular domain of human RANKL that conformed to reports of native processing. To encourage folding and posttranslational modification of a normally membrane-inserted moiety, we expressed the RANKL truncate as a secreted protein using the signal sequence from OPG in a Trichoplusia ni cell line using a baculovirus expression vector. RANKL was purified by a three-step process including an OPG-Fc affinity column. SDS–PAGE and mass spectral analysis indicated that the protein was >99% pure and glycosylated. Circular dichroism spectra revealed that the protein exhibited structural elements similar to tumor necrosis factor-α. By BIAcore analysis, RANKL bound to OPG with an affinity of 6.7 nM. Sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation analyses established that our protein existed as a trimer. We conclude that our expressed human RANKL truncate is folded, is functional, and exhibits self-association consistent with other family members.

Conformation and stability of the Streptococcus pyogenes pSM19035-encoded site-specific β recombinase, and identification of a folding intermediate

Solution properties of beta recombinase were studied by circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy, size exclusion chromatography, analytical ultracentrifugation, denaturant-induced unfolding and thermal unfolding experiments. In high ionic strength buffer (1 M NaCl) beta recombinase forms mainly dimers, and strongly tends to aggregate at ionic strength lower than 0.3 M NaCl. Urea and guanidinium chloride denaturants unfold beta recombinase in a two-step process. The unfolding curves have bends at approximately 5 M and 2.2 M in urea and guanidinium chloride-containing buffers. Assuming a three-state unfolding model (N2-->2I-->2U), the total free energy change from 1 mol of native dimers to 2 mol of unfolded monomers amounts to deltaG(tot) = 17.9 kcal/mol, with deltaG(N2-->2I) = 4.2 kcal/mol for the first transition and deltaG(I-->U) = 6.9 kcal/mol for the second transition. Using sedimentation-equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation, the presence of beta recombinase monomers was indicated at 5 M urea, and the urea dependence of the circular dichroism at 222 nm strongly suggests that folded monomers represent the unfolding intermediate.

Energetics of Outer Membrane Phospholipase A (OMPLA) Dimerization

Outer membrane phospholipase A (OMPLA) is a widely conserved transmembrane enzyme found in Gram-negative bacteria, and it is implicated in the virulence of a number of pathogenic organisms. The regulation of the protein's phospholipase activity is not well understood despite the existence of a number of high resolution structures. Previous biochemical studies have demonstrated that dimerization of OMPLA is a prerequisite for its phospholipase activity, and it has been shown in vitro that this dimerization is dependent on calcium and substrate binding. Therefore, to fully understand the regulation of OMPLA, it is necessary to understand the stability of the protein dimer and the extent to which it is influenced by its effector molecules. We have used sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation to dissect the energetics of Escherichia coli OMPLA dimerization in detergent micelles. We find that calcium contributes relatively little stability to the dimer, while interactions with the substrate acyl chain are the predominant force in stabilizing the dimeric conformation of the enzyme. The resulting thermodynamic cycle suggests that interactions between effector molecules are additive. These energetic measurements not only provide insight into the activation of OMPLA, but they also represent the first quantitative investigation of the association energetics of a transmembrane beta-barrel. This thermodynamic study allows us to begin to address the differences between protein-protein interfaces in transmembrane proteins with a helical fold to those of a beta-barrel fold and to more fully understand the forces involved in membrane protein interactions.

FlhB Regulates Ordered Export of Flagellar Components via Autocleavage Mechanism

The bacterial flagellum is a predominantly cell-external super-macromolecular construction whose structural components are exported by a flagellum-specific export apparatus. One of the export apparatus proteins, FlhB, regulates the substrate specificity of the entire apparatus; i.e. it has a role in the ordered export of the two main groups of flagellar structural proteins such that the cell-proximal components (rod-/hook-type proteins) are exported before the cell-distal components (filament-type proteins). The controlled switch between these two export states is believed to be mediated by conformational changes in the structure of the C-terminal cytoplasmic domain of FlhB (FlhB(C)), which is consistently and specifically cleaved into two subdomains (FlhB(CN) and FlhB(CC)) that remain tightly associated with each other. The cleavage event has been shown to be physiologically significant for the switch. In this study, the mechanism of FlhB cleavage has been more directly analyzed. We demonstrate that cleavage occurs in a heterologous host, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, deficient in vacuolar proteinases A and B. In addition, we find that cleavage of a slow-cleaving variant, FlhB(C)(P270A), is stimulated in vitro at alkaline pH. We also show by analytical gel-filtration chromatography and analytical ultracentrifugation experiments that both FlhB(C) and FlhB(C)(P270A) are monomeric in solution, and therefore self-proteolysis is unlikely. Finally, we provide evidence via peptide analysis and FlhB cleavage variants that the tertiary structure of FlhB plays a significant role in cleavage. Based on these results, we propose that FlhB cleavage is an autocatalytic process.

The Transmembrane Domains of ErbB Receptors do not Dimerize Strongly in Micelles

The epidermal growth factor receptors (erbB) constitute an important class of single pass transmembrane receptors involved in the transduction of signals important for cell proliferation and differentiation. Receptor association is a key event in the signal transduction process, but the molecular basis of this interaction is not fully understood. Previous biochemical and genetic studies have suggested that the single transmembrane helices of these receptor proteins might play a role in stabilizing the receptor complexes. To determine if the erbB transmembrane domains could provide a driving force to stabilize the receptor dimers, we carried out a thermodynamic study of these domains expressed as C-terminal fusion proteins with staphylococcal nuclease. Similar fusion constructs have been used successfully to investigate the oligomerization and association thermodynamics of a number of transmembrane sequences, including that of glycophorin A. Using SDS-PAGE analysis and sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation, we do not find strong, specific homo or hetero-interactions between the transmembrane domains of the erbB receptors in micellar solutions. Our results indicate that any preferential interactions between these domains in micellar solutions are extremely modest, of the order of 1 kcal mol(-1) or less. We applied a thermodynamic formalism to assess the effect of weakly interacting TM segments on the behavior of a covalently attached soluble domain. In the case of the ligand-bound EGFR ectodomain, we find that restriction of the ectodomain to the micellar phase by a hydrophobic TM, even in the absence of strong specific interactions, is largely sufficient to account for the previously reported increase in dimerization affinity.

Dissecting Requirements for Auto-inhibition of Actin Nucleation by the Formin, mDia1

The mammalian formin, mDia1, is an actin nucleation factor. Experiments in cells and in vitro show that the N-terminal region potently inhibits nucleation by the formin homology 2 (FH2) domain-containing C terminus and that RhoA binding to the N terminus partially relieves this inhibition. Cellular experiments suggest that potent inhibition depends upon the presence of the diaphanous auto-regulatory domain (DAD) C-terminal to FH2. In this study, we examine in detail the N-terminal and C-terminal regions required for this inhibition and for RhoA relief. Limited proteolysis of an N-terminal construct from residues 1-548 identifies two stable truncations: 129-548 and 129-369. Analytical ultracentrifugation suggests that 1-548 and 129-548 are dimers, whereas 129-369 is monomeric. All three N-terminal constructs inhibit nucleation by the full C terminus. Although inhibition by 1-548 is partially relieved by RhoA, inhibition by 129-548 or 129-369 is RhoA-resistant. At the C terminus, DAD deletion does not affect nucleation but decreases inhibitory potency of 1-548 by 20,000-fold. Synthetic DAD peptide binds both 1-548 and 129-548 with similar affinity and partially relieves nucleation inhibition. C-terminal constructs are stable dimers. Our conclusions are as follows: 1) DAD is an affinity-enhancing motif for auto-inhibition; 2) an N-terminal domain spanning residues 129-369 (called DID for diaphanous inhibitory domain) is sufficient for auto-inhibition; 3) a dimerization region C-terminal to DID increases the inhibitory ability of DID; and 4) DID alone is not sufficient for RhoA relief of auto-inhibition, suggesting that sequences N-terminal to DID are important to RhoA binding. An additional finding is that FH2 domain-containing constructs of mDia1 and mDia2 lose >75% nucleation activity upon freeze-thaw.

Properties of a novel thermostable glucoamylase from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus in relation to starch processing.

A gene (ssg) encoding a putative glucoamylase in a hyperthermophilic archaeon, Sulfolobus solfataricus, was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli, and the properties of the recombinant protein were examined in relation to the glucose production process. The recombinant glucoamylase was extremely thermostable, with an optimal temperature at 90 degrees C. The enzyme was most active in the pH range from 5.5 to 6.0. The enzyme liberated beta-d-glucose from the substrate maltotriose, and the substrate preference for maltotriose distinguished this enzyme from fungal glucoamylases. Gel permeation chromatography and sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation analysis revealed that the enzyme exists as a tetramer. The reverse reaction of the glucoamylase from S. solfataricus produced significantly less isomaltose than did that of industrial fungal glucoamylase. The glucoamylase from S. solfataricus has excellent potential for improving industrial starch processing by eliminating the need to adjust both pH and temperature.

Characterization and manipulation of the Pseudomonas aeruginosa dimethylarginine dimethylaminohydrolase monomer--dimer equilibrium.

In mammals, the enzyme dimethylarginine dimethylaminohydrolase (DDAH) is implicated in the regulation of the cellular levels of asymmetric methylarginines, small molecule metabolites that themselves represent a family of endogenous inhibitors of nitric oxide synthase (NOS). The involvement of DDAH function in the regulation of NOS makes this enzyme a potentially attractive therapeutic target. DDAH from the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PaDDAH) is so far the only structurally tractable homologue of mammalian DDAH isoforms. To complement the recent crystal structure of this protein, we show by hydrodynamic measurements that PaDDAH exists in dynamic equilibrium between monomer (ca 29 kDa) and symmetric homodimer (ca 58 kDa) states with a dimer dissociation constant, K(d) approximately 500nM. For the purposes of NMR-based approaches to the study of this enzyme's interactions with substrate and inhibitor ligands, it would be useful to obtain the protein in monomeric form. Through detailed analysis of the homodimer PaDDAH crystal structure we identified key residues involved in the protomer-protomer interface and targeted these for mutation. The hydrodynamic and self-associative properties of a series of PaDDAH interface mutants were analyzed by concentration-dependent analytical size-exclusion chromatography and sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation. The individual substitution of several of the interface residues shifts the equilibrium position towards the monomer, which allowed the design of a double mutant variant (Arg40-->Glu, Arg98-->His) that behaves exclusively as a stable monomer, yet retains greater than 95% catalytic activity compared to wild-type. Comparative two-dimensional (1)H, (15)N heteronuclear NMR spectra indicate that the double mutant remains a monomer even at approximately 1 mM concentration. Accordingly, the double mutant PaDDAH is an attractive template for further NMR-based investigations of the enzyme mechanism and characterization of ligand-binding and inhibitor-binding profiles. These results indicate that dimerization of PaDDAH is not critical for the maintenance of the biological function of the protein. These results are discussed in the context of known modes of self-association between structurally related, but functionally distinct, members of the beta/alpha-propeller fold class.

Thermodynamics of glycophorin A transmembrane helix dimerization in C14 betaine micelles

We have used sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation to measure the free energy change for the glycophorin A transmembrane helix–helix dimerization in C14 betaine micelles. By varying the amount of micellar C14 betaine, we show that the protein association reaction in the micellar C14 phase behaves as an ideal-dilute solution. In this hydrophobic environment, the mole-fraction standard state free energy change for self-association of the SNGpA99 glycophorin A construct is −5.7 (±0.3, N=5) kcal mol−1 at 25 °C. Compared with previous results carried out in C8E5 micellar solutions, the free energy of dimerization is 1.3 kcal mol−1 less favorable in C14 betaine micelles. In contrast, when considered on a per-interface basis, the formation of the glycophorin A transmembrane dimer in C14 betaine micelles may be more favorable than the association of several designed transmembrane peptides.

Thermodynamics of glycophorin A transmembrane helix dimerization in C14 betaine micelles

We have used sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation to measure the free energy change for the glycophorin A transmembrane helix–helix dimerization in C14 betaine micelles. By varying the amount of micellar C14 betaine, we show that the protein association reaction in the micellar C14 phase behaves as an ideal-dilute solution. In this hydrophobic environment, the mole-fraction standard state free energy change for self-association of the SNGpA99 glycophorin A construct is −5.7 (±0.3, N=5) kcal mol −1 at 25 °C. Compared with previous results carried out in C 8E 5 micellar solutions, the free energy of dimerization is 1.3 kcal mol −1 less favorable in C14 betaine micelles. In contrast, when considered on a per-interface basis, the formation of the glycophorin A transmembrane dimer in C14 betaine micelles may be more favorable than the association of several designed transmembrane peptides.