Coordination Sphere Research Articles

Reductive Inner-Sphere Electrosynthesis of Ammonia via a Nonelectrocatalytic Outer-Sphere Redox.

Electrochemistry of outer-sphere redox molecules involves an essentially intact primary coordination sphere with minimal secondary sphere adjustments, resulting in very fast electron transfer events even without a noble metal-based electrocatalyst. Departing from conventional electrocatalytic paradigms, we incorporate these minimal reaction coordinate adjustments of outer-sphere species to stimulate the electrocatalysis of energetically challenging inner-sphere substrates. Through this approach, we are able to show an intricate 8e- and 9H+ transfer inner-sphere reductive electrocatalysis at almost half the energy input of a conventional inner-sphere electron donor. This methodology of employing outer-sphere redox species has the potential to notably improve the cost and energy benefits in electrochemical transformations involving fundamental substrates such as water, CO2, N2, and many more.

A Well-Defined Magnesium Complex of C70 6.

Controlling and understanding charge state and metal coordination in carbon nanomaterials is crucial to harnessing their unique properties. Here we describe the synthesis of the well-defined fulleride complex [{(Mesnacnac)Mg}6C70], 2, (Mesnacnac)=HC(MeCNMes)2, Mes=2,4,6-Me3C6H2, from the reaction of the β-diketiminate magnesium(I) complex [{(Mesnacnac)Mg}2] with C70 in aromatic solvents. The molecular structure of complex 2 was determined, providing the first high-quality structural study of a complex with the C70 6- ion. In combination with solution state NMR spectroscopic and DFT computational studies, the changes in geometry and charge distribution in the various atom and bond types of the fulleride unit were investigated. Additionally, the influence of the (Mesnacnac)Mg+ cations on the global and local fulleride coordination environment was examined.

The Asymmetrical Fe-O-Se Bonds in Fe2O(SeO3)2 Boosting Bifunctional Oxygen Electrocatalytic Performance for Zinc-Air Battery.

HereFe2O(SeO3)2/Fe3C@NC catalysts with high performance werefabricated for zinc-air batteries (ZABs). The experimental results confirmed that the existence of Fe-O-Se bonds in Fe2O(SeO3)2 crystal phase, and the Fe-O-Se bonds could obviously enhance ORR and OER catalytic performance of Fe2O(SeO3)2/Fe3C@NC. Density functional theoretical calculations (DFT) confirmed that the Fe2O(SeO3)2 in Fe2O(SeO3)2/Fe3C@NC had a higher d-band center of Fe atom and a lower p-orbital coupling degree with its own lattice O atom than Fe2O3, which leads to Fe site of Fe2O(SeO3)2 being more likely to adsorb external oxygen intermediates. The Fe-O-Se bonds in Fe2O(SeO3)2 results in the modification of coordination environment of Fe atoms and optimizes the adsorption energy of Fe site for oxygen intermediates. Compared with Fe2O3/Fe3C@NC, the Fe2O(SeO3)2/Fe3C@NC showed obvious enhancements of ORR/OER catalytic activities with a half-wave potential of 0.91 V for ORR in 0.1 M KOH electrolyte and a low overpotential of 345 mV for OER at 10 mA cm-2 in a 1.0 M KOH electrolyte. The peak power density and specific capacity of Fe2O(SeO3)2/Fe3C@NC-based ZABs are higher than those of Pt/C+RuO2-ZABs. The above results demonstrate that the asymmetrical Fe-O-Se bonds in Fe2O(SeO3)2 plays a key role in improving the bifunctional catalytic activities of ORR/OER for ZABs.

Mononuclear nickel(II) and copper(II) coordination compounds with ligands based on acetyl(benzoyl)acetone S-methylisothiosemicarbazones and 8-quinolinecarboxaldehyde. Synthesis and crystal structure

Template condensation of S-methylisothiosemicarbazones of acetyl- or benzoylacetone with 8-quinolinecarboxaldehyde in the presence of nickel(II) and copper(II) ions gave four new mononuclear coordination compounds [NiL1]I (I), [CuL1I] (II), [NiL2]I (III) и [CuL2I] (IV). The chemical composition of the products was confirmed by elemental analysis, IR spectroscopy, and mass spectrometry, and the crystal structure of compounds I and II was determined by X-ray diffraction analysis (CCDC no. 2266386, 2266387). X-ray diffraction study revealed a square planar coordination environment of the central ion of the cationic Ni(II) complex and square pyramidal geometry for the molecular Cu(II) complex.

Modifying the second coordination spheres of Fe active sites for electrocatalytic nitric oxide reduction in realistic electrochemical environment

The first and second coordination spheres in the coordination microenvironment may regulate the electronic structure of single-metal atoms supported on carbon matrix, which in turn modulates the catalyst’s catalytic activity. Simulating the kinetic process of electrocatalytic nitric oxide reduction reaction (NORR) by the theoretical modeling of electrochemical microenvironments helps understand the theoretical structure–activity relationship and guides a more rational design of electrocatalysts. In this study, density functional theory calculations combined with a constant-potential/hybrid-solvent model and microkinetic modeling are employed to study NORR mechanism on the carbon-based FeN4, FeN4-O and FeN4-B catalysts with different electronegativity atoms in the second coordination spheres under −1.00 ∼ 0.40 V vs. RHE. The free energy changes of all elementary reactions for NORR on the catalysts reveal that the optimal pathways for NORR on FeN4 produce both ammonia and hydroxylamine, proceeding through the reaction intermediates *NHOH. Within −1.00 ∼ -0.37 V vs. RHE, the kinetic barriers of the rate-determining steps for NORR increase sequentially on FeN4, FeN4-O, and FeN4-B, corresponding to the sequentially decreasing reaction rate constants. At −6.00 mA∙cm−2, the electrode potential for ammonia production on FeN4 catalyst is the lowest among the catalysts at −0.70 V vs. RHE, indicating it has higher electrocatalytic activity.

Microstructure and corrosion properties of Al1-xWxN coatings for potential use in gas turbine blades

Herein, a numerical approach of Al1-xWxN thin film coatings on Inconel 738LC superalloys for thermal barrier applications has been studied and the experimental analysis includes deposition of Al1-xWxN films on Si (100), glass and transparent quartz substrates at 40 % N2 flow rate using a dual target DC reactive magnetron sputtering technique to investigate the morphology, microstructure, chemical bonding and corrosion behaviour. AFM analysis revealed the rms roughness, Sq and average roughness, Sa increased with the increasing W content from 22 to 70 at.%. It was found that Al1-xWxN films tend to form tiny valleys on the film surface because the values of surface skewness, Ssk lie below zero. The TEM image showed a branched snowflake structure for the specimen of Al0.58W0.42N films with discrete spots in the SAED pattern, confirming the microcrystalline nature. The blue-shifting of Ecorr towards positive potential confirmed the lower corrosion resistance of WN films than those of AlN. XRD spectra of Al0.58W0.42N films showed an amorphous nature devoid of peaks, which is also confirmed by the SAED pattern. The quasi-passive oxide layer formation was spontaneous for WN films compared to the AlN films. The bending vibrations of AlN and WN showed the coordination environment of the metal centre in the Al1-xWxN films. The computational results indicated that the thermal barrier properties of Al1-xWxN films decreased with the increasing W content, i.e., AIN > Al0.58 W0.42N > WN.

Structural Changes and Differences in Intrinsic Photoluminescence of Four Cationic Two-Dimensional Lead Halide Frameworks Modulated by Synthesis Temperature.

Luminescent hybrid organolead halide materials with cationic inorganic frameworks and high chemical inertness have demonstrated broad application prospects in the visible light region. However, the corresponding relationship between structural changes and luminescence properties in such materials needs further clarification. Here, for the first time, we have successfully synthesized [Pb2X3](PDAH)(H2O) (X = Cl or Br, PDAH = C7H4NO4) single crystals via a facile hydrothermal method and then obtained [Pb11X14](PDA)4 (X = Cl or Br, PDA = C7H3NO4) at higher temperatures. The different synthesis temperatures resulted in significant differences in the luminescence properties of the two groups of structures. X-ray crystallography revealed the different degrees of distortion of the PbII centers' coordination environment between the two structures, which would significantly affect the electron-phonon coupling process under excited states and ultimately affect the emission properties originating from self-trapped excitons (STEs) of the two materials. In addition, density functional theory (DFT) calculations indicate that the two structures have different band gap characteristics due to the different proportions of inorganic and organic components, which also affect the optoelectronic properties of the two groups of materials. It is also worth mentioning that the broadband orange-light emission of [Pb11Br14](PDA)4 with a high photoluminescence quantum efficiency (PLQE) of 86% endows it with potential applications in WLEDs.

Designing V single atom embedded carbon moiety for the electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction by first principles study.

Development of an efficient electrocatalyst for the nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) to serve as an sustainable alternative to the Haber-Bosch process has proven highly challenging. Single atom catalysts (SACs), which have the maximum atom utilization efficiency, are among the most promising candidates. Single atoms can be incorporated to a catalytic system by doping or substitution or by attaching a molecular coordination complex to a substrate and the different insertion modes allow the chemical environment to be varied. We have used DFT to investigate vanadium SACS for NRR activity with a focus on varying the coordination environment ofthe V atom. Phthalocyanine, porphyrin and graphene like coordination environments with varying N-coordination have been studied. Vanadium phthalocyanine (VphN4) is the most promising of the investigated systems. It features a high selectivity relative the HER reaction and relatively strong binding of N2relatively H, which prevents poisoning of the surface by hydrogen. VphN4also has the lowest overpotential among the studied systems. The electrocatalytic properties of VphN4deposited as a monolayer on the Ag (111) surface have been investigated. This system, which already has been prepared, shows promising properties for use as a catalytic electrode for the NRR reaction.

Extensive reference set and refined computational protocol for calculations of 57Fe Mössbauer parameters.

Mössbauer spectroscopy is a powerful technique for probing the local electronic structure of iron compounds, because it reports in an element-selective manner on both the oxidation state and coordination environment of the Fe ion. Computational prediction of the two main Mössbauer parameters, isomer shift (δ) and quadrupole splitting (ΔEQ), has long been targeted by quantum chemical studies, and useful protocols based on density functional theory have been proposed. Here we present an extensive curated reference set of Fe compounds that is considerably larger and more diverse than literature precedents. We make a distinction between low-temperature and high-temperature experimental subgroups. This set is employed for optimizing a refined computational protocol utilizing the scalar version of the exact 2-component (X2C) Hamiltonian with the finite nucleus approximation. Attention is devoted to having an accurate and flexible all-electron basis set for Fe. We assess the performance of several DFT methods that cover all representative families and rungs of functionals and find that hybrid functionals with ca. 25-30% exact exchange offer the best accuracy for isomer shifts. The work establishes a refined general protocol of wide applicability that achieves good performance for the prediction of isomer shifts in a wider variety of systems than before, but the limitations of DFT for quadrupole splittings are also highlighted. Finally, comparison of calculated values with high-temperature experimental results shows that the use of an empirical correction factor is required to account for the second-order Doppler shift and to achieve the same quality of correlation as with the low-temperature data.

Synergistic integration of metallic Bi and defective TiO2 for enhanced photocatalytic NO removal

The construction of hybrid catalysts is an effective method to enhance catalytic performance, but research on the positioning of the load is limited. In this study, we synthesized two photocatalytic materials by controlling the bismuth-titanium ratio and the site value of Bi modification in the catalyst. The surface-modified photocatalyst, namely 1:0.9 Bi/TiO2, exhibits a photocatalytic efficiency of 68.9% for the abatement of ppb-level NO in the presence of visible irradiation. This efficiency was significantly superior to that of the corresponding one-step synthesized Bi/TiO2 (48.7%) and the TiO2 (18.6%). Furthermore, it promotes nitrate formation and suppresses the generation of toxic NO2. Capture experiments indicate that the same active species are involved in both surface-loaded and uniformly loaded catalysts. The differences in their performance can be attributed to the higher vacancy concentration in the surface-loaded catalysts and the different local coordination environments of vacancies in the catalysts, altering the adsorption capability of oxygen molecules. This work offers fresh perspectives ffor the generation of efficient photocatalysts.

Understanding the role of negative charge in the scaffold of an artificial enzyme for CO2 hydrogenation on catalysis.

We have approached the construction of an artificial enzyme by employing a robust protein scaffold, lactococcal multidrug resistance regulator, LmrR, providing a structured secondary and outer coordination spheres around a molecular rhodium complex, [RhI(PEt2NglyPEt2)2]-. Previously, we demonstrated a 2-3 fold increase in activity for one Rh-LmrR construct by introducing positive charge in the secondary coordination sphere. In this study, a series of variants was made through site-directed mutagenesis where the negative charge is located in the secondary sphere or outer coordination sphere, with additional variants made with increasingly negative charge in the outer coordination sphere while keeping a positive charge in the secondary sphere. Placing a negative charge in the secondary or outer coordination sphere demonstrates decreased activity by a factor of two compared to the wild-type Rh-LmrR. Interestingly, addition of positive charge in the secondary sphere, with the negatively charged outer coordination sphere restores activity. Vibrational and NMR spectroscopy suggest minimal changes to the electronic density at the rhodium center, regardless of inclusion of a negative or positive charge in the secondary sphere, suggesting another mechanism is impacting catalytic activity, explored in the discussion.

Functionalized Amorphous Carbon Materials via Reactive Molecular Dynamics Simulations.

We derive a database of atomistic structural models of amorphous carbon materials endowed with exohedral functional groups. We start from phases previously derived using the DynReaxMas method for reactive molecular dynamics simulations, which exhibit atomistic and medium-length-scale features in excellent agreement with available experimental data. Given a generic input structure/phase, we develop postprocessing simulation algorithms mimicking experimental preparation protocols aimed at: (1) "curing" the phase to decrease the defect concentration; (2) automatically selecting the most reactive carbon atoms via interaction with a probe molecular species, and (3) stabilizing the phase by saturating the valence of carbon atoms with single-bond functional groups. Although we focus on oxygen-bearing functionalities, they can be replaced with other monovalent groups, such as -H, -COOH, -CHO, so that the protocol is quite general. We finally classify reactive sites in terms of their location within the structural framework and coordination environment (edges, tunnels, rings, aromatic carbons becoming aliphatic) and try to single out descriptors that correlate with tendency to functionalization.

Antibacterial activity of Au(I), Pt(II), and Ir(III) biotin conjugates prepared by the iClick reaction: influence of the metal coordination sphere on the biological activity.

A series of biotin-functionalized transition metal complexes was prepared by iClick reaction from the corresponding azido complexes with a novel alkyne-functionalized biotin derivative ([Au(triazolatoR,R')(PPh3)], [Pt(dpb)(triazolatoR,R')], [Pt(triazolatoR,R')(terpy)]PF6, and [Ir(ppy)(triazolatoR,R')(terpy)]PF6 with dpb = 1,3-di(2-pyridyl)benzene, ppy = 2-phenylpyridine, and terpy = 2,2':6',2''-terpyridine and R = C6H5, R' = biotin). The complexes were compared to reference compounds lacking the biotin moiety. The binding affinity toward avidin and streptavidin was evaluated with the HABA assay as well as isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). All compounds exhibit the same binding stoichiometry of complex-to-avidin of 4:1, but the ITC results show that the octahedral Ir(III) compound exhibits a higher binding affinity than the square-planar Pt(II) complex. The antibacterial activity of the compounds was evaluated on a series of Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacterial strains. In particular, the neutral Au(I) and Pt(II) complexes showed significant antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus and Enterococcus faecium at very low micromolar concentrations. The cytotoxicity against a range of eukaryotic cell lines was studied and revealed that the octahedral Ir(III) complex was non-toxic, while the square-planar Pt(II) and linear Au(I) complexes displayed non-selective micromolar activity.

Spiral-concave Prussian Blue Crystals with Rich Steps: Growth Mechanism and Coordination Regulation.

Investigating the formation and transformation mechanisms of spiral-concave crystals holds significant potential for advancing innovative material design and comprehension. We examined the kinetics-controlled nucleation and growth mechanisms of Prussian Blue crystals with spiral concave structures, and constructed a detailed crystal growth phase diagram. The spiral-concave hexacyanoferrate (SC-HCF) crystals, characterized by high-density surface steps and a low stress-strain architecture, exhibit enhanced activity due to their facile interaction with reactants. Notably, the coordination environment of SC-HCF can be precisely modulated by the introduction of diverse metals. Utilizing X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy and in-situ ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy, we elucidated the formation mechanism of SC-HCF to Co-HCF facilitated by oriented adsorption-ion exchange (OA-IE) process. Both experimental data, and density functional theory confirm that Co-HCF possesses an optimized energy band structure, capable of adjusting the local electronic environment and enhancing the performance of the oxygen evolution reaction. This work not only elucidates the formation mechanism and coordination regulation for rich steps HCF, but also offers a novel perspective for constructing nanocrystals with intricate spiral-concave structures.

Hierarchical heterojunction comprising of in-situ derived TiO2 and salicylaldimine-supported Co catalysts in metal-organic frameworks for enhancing photocatalytic hydrogen generation

We present the design of a novel functional metal-organic framework here, denoted as Co-sal–NH2–MOF@TiO2, featuring the comprise of controllably in-situ grown TiO2 sheets from NH2-MOF(Ti) and [Co] catalytic sites stabilized by salicylaldimine moiety via site isolation for visible-light-driven hydrogen evolution from water. The hierarchical organization of TiO2 and Co catalyst within NH2-MOF (Ti) leads to outstanding photocatalytic performance, as evidenced by a H2 yield of 15,584 μmolg−1h−1 and turnover numbers (TON) reaching 5844 over 24 h. This catalyst also signifies distinctly enhanced activities of approximately 105-fold, 354-fold, 15-fold, and 100-fold, compared to the pristine NH2-MOF(Ti), MOF-derived TiO2, NH2-MOF(Ti)@TiO2 and the combination of [Co catalyst + NH2-MOF(Ti) + TiO2], respectively. EXAFs and XPS etc. analyses revealed a stable coordination environment for salicylaldimine-supported Co(II) catalytic unit, which integrated with in-situ grown TiO2 sheets can not only guarantee catalyst stability, but also generate much more densely packed light-harvesting heterojunction units and thus promote separation and transfer of photogenerated carriers between TiO2 and Co catalyst in NH2-MOF(Ti) under light through optimized band gap structure. This work outlines the in-situ construction of organic and inorganic hybrid heterojunction for H2 production from water.

Electronic Structure of a Neodymium(III) Tris(oxidiacetate) Complex from Luminescence Data and Ab Initio Calculations.

Neodymium(III) is a near-infrared emissive and magnetic ion, which has found use in various high-technology applications. Yet, accurate predictions of the luminescent and magnetic properties of neodymium(III) based on the coordination environment remain to be done. Guidelines exist, but to build structure-property relationships for this element, more data are needed. Herein, we present a high-symmetry starting point. The tris(oxidiacetate) complex of neodymium(III) was prepared and crystallized, and access to the experimentally determined structure allowed us to quantify the symmetry of the compound and to perform calculations directly on the same structure that is investigated experimentally. The luminescent properties were determined and the electronic structure was computed using state-of-the-art ab initio methods. All electronic transitions in the range from 490 to 1400 nm were mapped experimentally. Using a Boltzmann population analysis, the combination of the excitation and emission spectra revealed the crystal field splitting of the 18 lowest-energy Kramers levels that experimentally could be unambiguously resolved. This assignment was supported by ab initio calculations, and the crystal field splitting was well reproduced. The electronic structure reported for the tris(oxidiacetate) complex was used to deduce the coordination structure in aqueous solution. Finally, the results are compared to empirical trends in the literature for the electronic structure of neodymium(III).

Hydrogen Evolution Catalysis by Cobalt Complexes of an Aza‐bridged Bis‐1,10‐phenanthroline Ligand Bearing Pendant Basic Sites

A novel series of molecular Co(II) complexes with aza‐bridged bis‐1,10‐phenanthroline (bpa) ligands have been synthesized and reported for the catalytic hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Various nitrogen donor substituents are introduced at the aza‐bridge of the bis‐phenanthroline moieties render intramolecular basic sites in the complexes’ second‐coordination sphere. Modifying the pendant nitrogen donor significantly influences the catalytic HER performance. Among these, the cobalt complex with the (2‐pyridyl)methyl substituted bis‐phenanthroline ligand (L3) exhibits the most photocatalytic HER efficiency in both organic and aqueous media. Under optimized conditions with [Ru(bpy)3]2+ as a sensitizer and ascorbic acid as an electron donor, [CoII(L3)(TfO−)2] achieves an initial turnover frequency (TOF) of 1882 ± 65 h−1 per catalyst and a turnover number (TON) of 4842 ± 122 in a 3‐hour reaction period under the irradiation of visible light. Combined experimental and theoretical evidences illustrate that phenanthroline moieties of the bpa ligands act as electron mediators during the HER catalysis, while the pendant nitrogen donor substituents mediate proton transfer. This work provides a unique example for understanding the activity‐structure relationship of homogeneous HER catalyst concerning the redox‐active properties and second coordination sphere basic sites of organic ligand platforms.

Serial triphenylpropionic acid and N,N'-chelator mixed ligands Cu(II) complexes: Structure and biological properties

Three distinct copper(II) complexes were synthesized using 3,3,3-Triphenylpropionic acid (TPPA) and varying N,N'-chelators, resulting in unique structural and biological properties. The complexes [Cu(TPPA)2(Bipy)(H2O)2·(H2O)] (1), [Cu(TPPA)2(Phen)(H2O)2·0.5(H2O)] (2), and [Cu(TPPA)2(MeBipy)·2(C2H3N)] (3) were thoroughly characterized using single-crystal X-ray diffraction, PXRD, FT-IR, and NMR techniques to confirm their distinct geometries and coordination environments (TPPA=3,3,3-Triphenylpropionic acid, Bipy=2,2′-Bipyridine, Phen=1,10-Phenanthroline, and MeBipy=5,5′-Dimethyl-2,2′-Dipyridyl). Hirshfeld surface analysis provided quantitative insights into the molecular interactions within the complexes, while molecular docking studies revealed a strong binding affinity to PI3K kinase, with calculated binding energies of −10.4, −10.5, and −11.7 kcal/mol for complexes 1, 2, and 3, respectively. DNA fluorescence spectroscopy demonstrated significant ct-DNA binding, with the quencher rate coefficients of 0.1278 for complex 1, 0.2664 for complex 2, and 0.2434 for complex 3. When compared to sodium penicillin, which exhibited an OD600 value of 0.06, complex 2 and complex 3 demonstrated moderate antibacterial activity against Staphylococcus aureus with OD600 values of 0.176 and 0.219, respectively. The IC50 values of complexes 1, 2, and 3 in HepG2 cancer cell inhibition assays were determined to be 0.588, 0.357, and 0.397 μM, respectively. These results demonstrate their superior cytotoxicity compared to Cisplatin and Carboplatin. The findings suggest that these complexes may offer promising avenues for further research and development in antimicrobial and anticancer therapies.

Construction of N-Fe-S bridge in atomic iron catalyst for boosting Fenton-like reactions

Constructing the coordination environment of single-atom catalysts (SACs) can be an attractive technical strategy to regulate the generation of reactive oxygen species for Fenton-like reactions. Herein, we have constructed an asymmetric coordination of Fe single-atom catalyst (FeSA-NS-PCNS) with abundant N-Fe-S bridge (FeSA-N3S1) for robust Fenton-like reactions. 82.5 % of singlet oxygen (1O2) selectivity and high turnover frequency of bisphenol A degradation (0.568 min−1) were achieved at mild conditions. Experimental works and theoretical analyses illustrated that S doping breaks the inert environment of the original N-Fe-N symmetric coordination equilibrium and modulates the electron density of the atomic Fe center, which is beneficial for boosting PMS adsorption and reducing the energy barriers of vital *OH and *O intermediates. The coupling between the FeSA-N3S1 interface and peroxymonosulfate molecule boosts in-situ electron transfer through the N-Fe-S bridge, which induces more electron flow from the low valence Fe to OH* on the surface of Fe-*O-H, forming a high yield of 1O2. Moreover, we designed the Fenton-like reactions by FeSA-NS-PCNS membrane reactor for an efficient contaminant removal rate of over 90 % even after 11 cycles. This work provides a novel perspective on developing SACs with asymmetric coordination to regulate reactive oxygen species for the treatment of organic contaminants in water bodies.

Benchmark comparison study on metal single atom versus metal nanoparticle in photoredox catalysis: Which is better?

Reducing the size of metal nanoparticle (NP) cocatalyst down to single-atom level to improve photocatalytic efficiency is inevitably accompanied by the changes of its coordination environment, geometric configuration, electronic structure and active site. Thus, the construction of single metal atom (SA) photocatalyst is not necessarily a panacea for activity improvement toward target catalytic reactions. Herein, we report a critical and benchmark comparison in a reasonable framework of ZnIn2S4/Pt NP (ZIS/Pt NP) and ZnIn2S4/Pt SA (ZIS/Pt SA) towards photocatalytic hydrogen (H2) evolution, aiming to demonstrate which is better between Pt NP and Pt SA as cocatalyst in boosting photoredox catalysis. Mechanism study proves that the higher charge separation/transfer and weaker H* adsorption strength over ZIS/Pt NP than ZIS/Pt SA promote the more effective reduction of protons to H2, leading to the higher activity of ZIS/Pt NP than ZIS/Pt SA. Our work is expected to timely inspire the critical and rational thinking on the function and intrinsic mechanism of SA and NP cocatalysts in enhancing the photoredox catalysis performance.