Robertson's Mutator Research Articles

Independent evolution of transposase and TIRs facilitated by recombination between Mutator transposons from divergent clades in maize

Nearly all eukaryotes carry DNA transposons of the Robertson's Mutator (Mu) superfamily, a widespread source of genome instability and genetic variation. Despite their pervasive impact on host genomes, much remains unknown about the evolution of these transposons. Transposase recognition of terminal inverted repeats (TIRs) is thought to drive and constrain coevolution of MuDR transposase genes and TIRs. To address the extent of this relationship and its impact, we compared separate phylogenies of TIRs and MuDR gene sequences from Mu elements in the maize genome. Five major clades were identified. As expected, most Mu elements were bound by highly similar TIRs from the same clade (homomorphic type). However, a subset of elements contained dissimilar TIRs derived from divergent clades. These "heteromorphs" typically occurred in multiple copies indicating active transposition in the genome. In addition, analysis of internal sequences showed that exchanges between elements having divergent TIRs produced new mudra and mudrb gene combinations. In several instances, TIR homomorphs had been regenerated within a heteromorph clade with retention of distinctive internal MuDR sequence combinations. Results reveal that recombination between divergent clades facilitates independent evolution of transposase (mudra), transposase-binding targets (TIRs), and capacity for insertion (mudrb) of active Mu elements. This mechanism would be enhanced by the preference of Mu insertions for recombination-rich regions near the 5' ends of genes. We suggest that cycles of recombination give rise to alternating homo- and heteromorph forms that enhance the diversity on which selection for Mu fitness can operate.

Mu-seq: Sequence-Based Mapping and Identification of Transposon Induced Mutations

Mutations tagged by transposon insertions can be readily mapped and identified in organisms with sequenced genomes. Collections of such mutants allow a systematic analysis of gene function, and can be sequence-indexed to build invaluable resources. Here we present Mu-seq (Mutant-seq), a high-throughput NextGen sequencing method for harnessing high-copy transposons. We illustrate the efficacy of Mu-seq by applying it to the Robertson’s Mutator system in a large population of maize plants. A single Mu-seq library, for example, constructed from 576 different families (2304 plants), enabled 4, 723 novel, germinal, transposon insertions to be detected, identified, and mapped with single base-pair resolution. In addition to the specificity, efficiency, and reproducibility of Mu-seq, a key feature of this method is its adjustable scale that can accomodate simultaneous profiling of transposons in thousands of individuals. We also describe a Mu-seq bioinformatics framework tailored to high-throughput, genome-wide, and population-wide analysis of transposon insertions.

Molecular analysis of high-copy insertion sites in maize.

High-copy transposon mutagenesis is an effective tool for creating gene disruptions in maize. In order to molecularly define transposon-induced disruptions on a genome-wide scale, we optimized TAIL-PCR to amplify genomic DNA flanking maize Robertson's Mutator insertions. Sample sequencing from 43 Mutator stocks and the W22 inbred line identified 676 non-redundant insertions, and only a small fraction of the flanking sequences showed significant similarity to maize repetitive sequences. We further designed and tested 79 arbitrary primers to identify 12 primers that amplify all Mutator insertions within a DNA sample at 3.1-fold redundancy. Importantly, the products are of sufficient size to use as substrates or probes for hybridization-based identification of gene disruptions. Our adaptation simplifies previously published TAIL-PCR protocols and should be transferable to other high-copy insertional mutagens.

Robertson's Mutator transposons in A. thaliana are regulated by the chromatin-remodeling gene Decrease in DNA Methylation (DDM1).

Robertson's Mutator transposable elements in maize undergo cycles of activity and then inactivity that correlate with changes in cytosine methylation. Mutator-like elements are present in the Arabidopsis genome but are heavily methylated and inactive. These elements become demethylated and active in the chromatin-remodeling mutant ddm1 (Decrease in DNA Methylation), which leads to loss of heterochromatic DNA methylation. Thus, DNA transposons in plants appear to be regulated by chromatin remodeling. In inbred ddm1 strains, transposed elements may account, in part, for mutant phenotypes unlinked to ddm1. Gene silencing and paramutation are also regulated by DDM1, providing support for the proposition that epigenetic silencing is related to transposon regulation.

Duplication and suppression of chloroplast protein translocation genes in maize.

The HCF106 (high chlorophyll fluorescence) gene of maize encodes a chloroplast membrane protein required for translocation of a subset of proteins across the thylakoid membrane. Mutations in HCF106 caused by the insertion of Robertson's Mutator transposable elements have been mapped to chromosome 2S. Here we show that there is a closely related homolog of HCF106 encoded elsewhere in the maize genome (HCF106c) that can partially compensate for these mutations. This homolog maps on chromosome 10L and is part of the most recent set of segmental duplications in the maize genome. Triple mutants that are disrupted in both the HCF106 and Sec-dependent protein translocation pathways provide evidence that they act independently. The HCF106c gene accounts for a previously reported exception to the correlation between epigenetic suppression of hcf106 and methylation of Mutator transposons. We also demonstrate that insertions of Robertson's Mutator elements into either introns or promoters can lead to mutations whose phenotypes are suppressed in the absence of Mu activity, while alleles with insertions in both positions are not suppressed. The implications of these observations are discussed.

Analysis of Mutator-induced mutations in the iojap gene of maize.

The recessive nuclear mutation iojap (ij) in maize produces striped plants with normal chloroplasts in green sectors and poorly developed chloroplasts in the white sectors. The ij mutation is also characterized by an array of additional phenotypic affects which suggests a pivotal role for Ij in chloroplast development. The Ij gene from maize has been isolated; however, the sequence has not provided information on the action of the Ij gene product. As an extension of the analysis of the Ij gene we have generated a number of independent transposon insertion mutations using the Robertson's Mutator (Mu). Insertions were found to be distributed throughout the 5' half of the gene and all showed a similar striping pattern to that of the original ij mutation, ij-ref. While several of the new mutant alleles produced ij-homologous transcripts none produced detectable levels of the Ij polypeptide product. Chloroplast development in some cells appears to be able to proceed in the absence of the Ij polypeptide.

Site-selected transposon mutagenesis at the hcf106 locus in maize.

The High chlorophyll fluorescence106 (Hcf106) gene in maize is required for chloroplast membrane biogenesis, and the hcf106-mum1 allele is caused by the insertion of a Robertson's Mutator Mu1 element into the promoter of the gene. Seedlings homozygous for hcf106-mum1 are pale green and die 3 weeks after germination, but only in the presence of Mutator activity conferred by active, autonomous Mu regulatory transposons elsewhere in the genome. When Mutator activity is lost, the mutant phenotype is suppressed, and homozygous plants have an almost wild-type phenotype. To isolate derivative alleles at the hcf106 locus that no longer require Mutator activity for phenotypic expression, we have developed a method for site-selected transposon mutagenesis in maize. This procedure, first described for Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila, involves using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to screen pools of individuals for insertions and deletions in genes of known sequence. Pools of seedlings segregating for the progenitor allele hcf106-mum1 were screened by PCR for insertions and deletions associated with Robertson's Mutator. In a 360-bp target region, two new insertions and one deletion were identified in only 700 Mu-active gametes screened. One of the insertions was in the progenitor hcf106-mum1 allele and the other was in the wild-type allele, but all three new alleles were found to have break-points at the same nucleotide in the first intron. Unlike the hcf-106-mum1 progenitor allele, the deletion and one of the insertions conferred pale green seedling lethal phenotypes in the absence of mutator activity. However, the second insertion had a weak, viable phenotype under these conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Coordinate suppression of mutations caused by Robertson's mutator transposons in maize.

Transposable elements from the Robertson's Mutator family are highly active insertional mutagens in maize. However, mutations caused by the insertion of responder (non-autonomous) elements frequently depend on the presence of active regulator (autonomous) elements for their phenotypic effects. The hcf106::Mu1 mutation has been previously shown to depend on Mu activity in this way. The dominant Lesion-mimic 28 mutation also requires Mu activity for its phenotypic effects. We have used double mutants to show that the loss of Mu activity results in the coordinate suppression of both mutant phenotypes. This loss can occur somatically resulting in large clones of cells that have a wild-type phenotype. Autonomous and non-autonomous Mutator elements within these clones are insensitive to digestion with methylation-sensitive enzymes, suggesting extensive methylation of CG and non-CG cytosine residues. Our data are consistent with the sectors being caused by the cycling of MuDR regulatory elements between active and inactive phases. The pattern of sectors suggests that they are clonal and that they are derived from the apical cells of the vegetative shoot meristem. We propose that these cells are more likely to undergo epigenetic loss of Mu activity because of their longer cell division cycle during shoot growth. Coordinate suppression of unlinked mutations can be used to perform mosaic analysis in maize.

Genetic analysis of 63 mutations affecting maize kernel development isolated from Mutator stocks.

Sixty-three mutations affecting development of the maize kernel were isolated from active Robertson's Mutator (Mu) stocks. At least 14 previously undescribed maize gene loci were defined by mutations in this collection. Genetic mapping located 53 of these defective kernel (dek) mutations to particular chromosome arms, and more precise map determinations were made for 21 of the mutations. Genetic analyses identified 20 instances of allelism between one of the novel mutations and a previously described dek mutation, or between new dek mutations identified in this study; phenotypic variability was observed in three of the allelic series. Viability testing of homozygous mutant kernels identified numerous dek mutations with various pleiotropic effects on seedling and plant development. The mutations described here presumably arose by insertion of a Mu transposon within a dek gene; thus, many of the affected loci are expected to be accessible to molecular cloning via transposon-tagging.

The role of the ameiotic1 gene in the initiation of meiosis and in subsequent meiotic events in maize.

Understanding the initiation of meiosis and the relationship of this event with other key cytogenetic processes are major goals in studying the genetic control of meiosis in higher plants. Our genetic and structural analysis of two mutant alleles of the ameiotic1 gene (am1 and am1-praI) suggest that this locus plays an essential role in the initiation of meiosis in maize. The product of the ameiotic1 gene affects an earlier stage in the meiotic sequence than any other known gene in maize and is important for the irreversible commitment of cells to meiosis and for crucial events marking the passage from premeiotic interphase into prophase I including chromosome synapsis. It appears that the period of ameiotic1 gene function in meiosis at a minimum covers the interval from some point during premeiotic interphase until the early zygotene stage of meiosis. To study the interaction of genes in the progression of meiosis, several double meiotic mutants were constructed. In these double mutants (i) the ameiotic1 mutant allele was brought together with the meiotic mutation (afd1) responsible for the fixation of centromeres in meiosis; and with the mutant alleles of the three meiotic genes that control homologous chromosome segregation (dv1, ms43 and ms28), which impair microtubule organizing center organization, the orientation of the spindle fiber apparatus, and the depolymerization of spindle filaments after the first meiotic division, respectively; (ii) the afd1 mutation was combined with two mutations (dsy1 and as1) affecting homologous pairing; (iii) the ms43 mutation was combined with the as1, the ms28 and the dv1 mutations; and (iv) the ms28 mutation was combined with the dv1 mutation and the ms4 (polymitotic1) mutations. An analysis of gene interaction in the double mutants led us to conclude that the ameiotic1 gene is epistatic over the afd1, the dv1, the ms43 and the ms28 genes but the significance of this relationship requires further analysis. The afd gene appears to function from premeiotic interphase throughout the first meiotic division, but it is likely that its function begins after the start of the ameiotic1 gene expression. The afd1 gene is epistatic over the two synaptic mutations dsy1 and as1 and also over the dv1 mutation. The new ameiotic*-485 and leptotene arrest*-487 mutations isolated from an active Robertson's Mutator stocks take part in the control of the initiation of meiosis.

Mutational analysis of morphogenesis of the maize embryo

SummaryMorphogenesis of the maize embryo is controlled by many genes. A group of 51 embryo‐specific (emb) mutations representing at least 45 independent mutation events and many different gene loci have been isolated from active Robertson's Mutator stocks. The authors have reported previously that the embryo phenotype of 27 of these mutations, characterized by examining mature embryos in fresh dissection. The maximal development capacity of the 24 emb mutations are reported here which have not been reported previously. All result in retarded embryos that are morphologically abnormal. Three of the mutants are blocked during the first phase of morphogenesis, the period in which the basal‐apical asymmetry is established and the embryo is regionalized into suspensor and embryo proper. Nineteen mutants are blocked during the second phase, the period in which radial asymmetry appears, the embryonic axis is established at a different angle than the original basal‐apical axis of the zygote and the vegetative organ primordia of the adult plant make their first appearance. Two mutants are blocked or altered during the third phase, the period in which vegetative structures are elaborated. Some of the mutants affected in the first phase of morphogenesis may have defective mechanisms for establishing basal‐apical asymmetry, including possibly the asymmetric distribution of morphogenic determinants. Similarly, some of the mutants affected in the second phase may be altered in the mechanisms establishing radial asymmetry and the origin of the meristems. Mutations of the first type may act as early as the first cell division when the zygote undergoes a transverse division, while mutations of the second type are likely to act during the proembryo and transition stages. Both types include mutations affecting embryo pattern formation. Mutations affecting the third phase of morphogenesis may identify genes regulating reiterative morphogenic processes of vegetative plant development and events of embryo maturation. This group of 24 mutations is like that reported previously in representing genes that are crucial to embryo morphogenesis.

Molecular cloning and characterization of iojap (ij), a pattern striping gene of maize.

Iojap (ij) is a recessive striped mutant of maize affecting the development of plastids in a local and position-dependent manner on the leaves. The ij-affected plastids are transmitted to some of the progeny even when the function of the nuclear gene is restored. Developmental defects during embryogenesis and leaf proliferation are other phenotypic characteristics of ij. The extent of striping and the degree of developmental arrest in ij depend upon genetic background. To understand the diverse and unique phenotypic expression of ij, a transposon tagging experiment has been conducted using Robertson's Mutator (Mu). A new ij mutant was obtained from crosses of the reference allele of (ij-ref) to Mu lines. Subsequent genetic and molecular studies showed that the mutant carried a new ij allele (ij-mum1) from the Mu lines and contained a Mu1 element that cosegregated with the iojap phenotype. A 6.0 kb EcoRI genomic DNA fragment containing the Mu1 element was cloned. ij-ref is unstable, and revertants (Ij-Rev) have been obtained. Using the flanking DNA from the genomic clone as a probe, DNA polymorphisms were detected between ij-ref and these revertants. Further, transcripts were restored to the normal level in Ij-Rev seedlings. Comparison of genomic DNA clones from ij-ref, ij-mum1 and Ij indicated that the ij-ref allele contained 1.5 kb of additional DNA related to a transposable element, Ds. Germinal and somatic revertant alleles were derived by excision of this 1.5 kb element from ij-ref. The structure of the Ij gene and the DNA sequence of its transcribed region were determined. The Ij gene encodes a 24.8 kDa protein that showed no significant sequence similarity with proteins listed in databases.

Expression and distribution of cytosolic 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase isozymes in maize.

Maize (Zea mays L.) cytosolic 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase isozymes (EC 1.1.1.44; 6-PGD) are encoded by unlinked loci Pgd1 and Pgd2. Two families from a Robertson's Mutator line were isolated which have no detectable expression of Pgd2. These Pgd2-null mutants and a Pgd1-null line were used to generate plants homozygous for null alleles at both cytosolic 6-PGD loci. The specific activity of 6-PGD in the double-null mutant was between 20 and 30% of wild-type levels in root extracts. The double-null mutant was reproductively viable in a moderate environment, suggesting that wild-type levels of cytosolic 6-PGD activity are not essential for growth. Isozyme dimer ratios in roots, leaves, and scutellum were binomial and reflected the wild-type gene copy number. 6-PGD isozymes showed tissue- and cell type-specific expression.

Genetic study of the loss and restoration of Mutator transposon activity in maize: evidence against dominant-negative regulator associated with loss of activity.

The Mutator system of transposable elements is characterized by a family of transposons called Mu transposons that share common termini and are actively transposing in Robertson's Mutator (Mu) lines of maize. Mu lines lose transposition activity during propagation by either outcrossing or inbreeding. This loss of transposition activity, which can occur at non-Mendelian frequencies, is in the form of loss of forward transposition activity resulting in a decrease in the generation of new mutations, as well as the loss of mutability of Mu transposon induced mutations, and it has been correlated with hypermethylation of the Mu elements. Previous studies have concluded that restoration of Mutator transposon activity by crossing inactive lines back to active lines is incomplete or transient, and depends upon the sex of the inactive parent. Further, it has been proposed that the inactive system is dominant to the active system, with the dominance possibly mediated through a negative regulatory factor that is preferentially transmitted through the female. In this study, we have examined the frequencies of loss and restoration of Mu transposon activity using a Mu line carrying an insertion in the bronze 1 locus. We find that transmission of Mu transposon activity to non-Mu plants can occur at high rates through males and females, but individual cases of decreased transmission through the male were observed. We also find that in crosses between inactive-Mu and active-Mu plants, reactivation was efficient as well as heritable, regardless of the sex of the inactive parent. Similar results were obtained whether the inactivation occurred in an outcross or a self. In all cases examined, loss of Mu transposon activity was correlated with hypermethylation of Mu elements, and reactivation was correlated with their demethylation. Our results indicate that an inactive Mu system does not exhibit dominance over an active Mu system. We conclude that contrary to current models, inactivation and its maintenance is not obligatorily associated with a dominant negative regulatory factor whether nuclear or cytoplasmic, and we propose a revised model to account for these and other observations.

Isolation and Characterization of 51 embryo-specific Mutations of Maize.

A plant embryo consists of an embryonic axis, which eventually grows into the adult body, and one or two nutritive structures, the cotyledons. In the grasses embryo morphogenesis can be divided into three periods: during the first the embryo is regionalized into an embryo proper and suspensor, during the second the embryonic axis is established, and during the third vegetative structures are elaborated. Maize, with its well-characterized embryo-genesis, powerful genetics, and transposon tagging stocks, offers an attractive system for mutational analysis of these events. We have isolated 51 embryo-specific (emb) mutations from active Robertson's Mutator maize stocks. These are single-gene recessive lethals that represent at least 45 independent mutation events. Each of the 25 mutations was located to a chromosome arm using a B-A translocation set that uncovers approximately 40% of the genome; the same test failed to locate 20 others. The embryo phenotype of 27 mutations was characterized by examining mature mutant embryos in fresh dissection: the various emb mutations differ in phenotype and each is consistent in its expression. All 27 mutations result in retarded embryos that are morphologically abnormal. Nine mutants are blocked during the first period; 10 mutants are blocked during the second period; and eight mutants are blocked during the third period. Based on both the genetic and developmental data, it is likely that there are many loci that can mutate to give the emb phenotype and that these genes are crucial to the morphogenesis of the embryo.

Molecular characterization of four shrunken mutations induced in Mutator lines in Zea mays L

Four shrunken (sh) mutants were independenty isolated from Robertson's Mutator lines. A molecular analysis of each mutant determined that the lesions responsible for these mutations were due to DNA inserations located within the 5′ untranslated region of the sh gene. Two of the insertions were similar in size to Mu1, the predominant transposable element found in all Mutator lines. However, one insertion was 5.5 kb, which, thus far, is the largest insertion observed in a mutant allele isolated from an active Mutator line. These results imply that DNA insertions other than Mu1 and Mu1.7 elements may be involved in, or activated by, Mutator.

The Mu1 maize transposable element induces tissue-specific aberrant splicing and polyadenylation in two Adh1 mutants.

Insertions of the maize transposable element Robertson's Mutator (Mu) into intron 1 of the Adh1 gene have produced a number of mutant alleles altered in quantitative expression. It has previously been shown that transcription and mRNA accumulation are reduced for two of these alleles, Adh1-S3034 and Adh1-S4477. In this report, we describe the presence of Mu1-hybridizing polyadenylated transcripts in roots of anaerobically induced seedlings of these same mutants. Sequence analysis of Mu1-hybridizing clones from a cDNA library of S3034 RNA indicated that these transcripts originated from the Adh1 locus and were produced by alternative processing of S3034 pre-mRNA. Approximately half of the cDNAs represented transcripts that had not undergone excision of the intron containing the 1.4-kilobase Mu1 insertion but were processed in response to signals present in the transposable element. Mu1 contains a donor splice site in the 5'-terminal inverted repeat that can be joined to the Adh1 exon 2 acceptor, resulting in removal of most of the Mu1 sequences from the pre-mRNA; alternatively this donor can be spliced to an acceptor within Mu1, removing an 89-nucleotide intron. Mu1 also contains polyadenylation signals that are used to produce truncated transcripts. These Mu1 transcripts produced by aberrant splicing and polyadenylation were not detected in RNA isolated from developing kernels.

The Mu1 Maize Transposable Element Induces Tissue-Specific Aberrant Splicing and Polyadenylation in Two Adh1 Mutants

Insertions of the maize transposable element Robertson's Mutator (Mu) into intron 1 of the Adh1 gene have produced a number of mutant alleles altered in quantitative expression. It has previously been shown that transcription and mRNA accumulation are reduced for two of these alleles, Adh1-S3034 and Adh1-S4477. In this report, we describe the presence of Mu1-hybridizing polyadenylated transcripts in roots of anaerobically induced seedlings of these same mutants. Sequence analysis of Mu1-hybridizing clones from a cDNA library of S3034 RNA indicated that these transcripts originated from the Adh1 locus and were produced by alternative processing of S3034 pre-mRNA. Approximately half of the cDNAs represented transcripts that had not undergone excision of the intron containing the 1.4-kilobase Mu1 insertion but were processed in response to signals present in the transposable element. Mu1 contains a donor splice site in the 5'-terminal inverted repeat that can be joined to the Adh1 exon 2 acceptor, resulting in removal of most of the Mu1 sequences from the pre-mRNA; alternatively this donor can be spliced to an acceptor within Mu1, removing an 89-nucleotide intron. Mu1 also contains polyadenylation signals that are used to produce truncated transcripts. These Mu1 transcripts produced by aberrant splicing and polyadenylation were not detected in RNA isolated from developing kernels.

Somatically heritable switches in the DNA modification of Mu transposable elements monitored with a suppressible mutant in maize.

Many transposable elements in maize alternate between active and inactive phases associated with the modification of their DNA. Elements in an inactive phase lose their ability to transpose, their ability to excise from reporter alleles and, in some cases, their ability to enhance or suppress mutant phenotypes caused by their insertion. The maize mutant hcf106 is a recessive pale green seedling lethal caused by the insertion of the transposable element Mu1. We show that the hcf106 mutant phenotype is suppressed in lines that have lost Mu activity. That is, homozygous hcf106 seedlings are dark green and viable when transposable elements belonging to the Robertson's Mutator family are modified in their terminal inverted repeats, a diagnostic feature of inactive lines. This property of the mutant phenotype has been used to follow clonal leaf sectors containing modified Mu elements that arise from single somatic cells during plant development. The distribution of these sectors indicates that epigenetic switches involving Mu DNA modification occur progressively as the meristem ages.

Mu transposable elements are structurally diverse and distributed throughout the genusZea

The Robertson's Mutator stock of maize exhibits a high mutation rate due to the transposition of the Mu family of transposable elements. All characterized Mu elements contain similar approximately 200-bp terminal inverted repeats, yet the internal sequences of the elements may be completely unrelated. Non-Mutator stocks of maize have a 20-100-fold lower mutation rate relative to Mutator stocks, yet they contain multiple sequences that hybridize to the Mu terminal inverted repeats. Most of these sequences do not cohybridize to internal regions of previously cloned Mu elements. We have cloned two such sequences from the maize line B37, a non-Mutator inbred line. These sequences, termed Mu4 and Mu5, have an organization characteristic of transposable elements and possess approximately 200-bp Mu terminal inverted repeats that flank internal DNA, which is unrelated to other cloned Mu elements. Mu4 and Mu5 are both flanked by 9-bp direct repeats as has been observed for other Mu elements. However, we have no direct evidence that they have recently transposed because they have not been found in known genes. Although the internal regions of Mu4 and Mu5 are not related by sequence similarity, both elements share an unusual structural feature: the terminal inverted repeats extend more than 100 bp internally from Mu-similar termini. The distribution of these elements in maize lines and related species suggests that Mu elements are an ancient component of the maize genome. Moreover, the structure of the Mu termini and the fact that Mu termini are found flanking different internal sequences leads us to speculate that Mu termini once may have been capable of transposing as independent entities.