TECHNOLOGY AND CULTURE Book Reviews 185 need results from DeVries’s concentrating on military technology rather than embedding the topic in a broad study of war. Indeed, because this volume focuses on technology rather than war, it forms a useful complement to Philippe Contamine’s synthesis, War in the Middle Ages (New York, 1984). Readers of this book will come away with a comprehensive and useful view of the current state of much of the scholarship in medieval military technology, and the bibliography is a tool they will return to with profit. Unfortunately, minor errors remain unpurged; those who have visited London and seen the four original turrets rising above the White Tower will balk at the remark that the edifice once sported only three (p. 222). E. Malcolm Parkinson Dr. Parkinson, an associate professor of history at Worcester Polytechnic Institute, has written on tournaments in early modern Europe. He is a past president of the board of trustees of the Higgins Armory Museum, Worcester, Massachusetts, a museum of medieval and Renaissance arms, armor, and warfare. Turin, 1564—1680: Urban Design, Military Culture, and the Creation ofthe Absolutist Capital. By Martha D. Poliak. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1991. Pp. xxii + 267; illustrations, notes, index. $49.95. Military Architecture, Cartography and the Representation of the Early Modern European City: A Checklist of Treatises on Fortification in the Newberry Library. By Martha D. Poliak. Chicago: Newberry Library, 1991. Pp. xxxvi + 119; illustrations, notes. $15.00 + $1.50 handling (paper). Martha Poliak, in the introduction to her very ambitious book, promises to “synthesize the history of military architecture and urban design” in order to answer two “larger questions: How was the city planned and built? How were its forms endowed with meaning?” (p. 3). She proposes to address issues of the rulers’ gender, the role of ideology and political theory, and the place of public rituals and poetry in the creation of a capital city. Turin is a case study of the transformation of a small garrison town in the often-contested region of Piedmont into a city celebrated for its imposing design. The royal ambitions of the House of Savoy provided the driving force that extended the streets, renewed the fortifications, and adorned the city with palaces and churches while enforcing a regularity of design unsurpassed in its day. The succeeding dukes used every contrivance available to aspiring royalty to effect this change. They brought their family’s most valued relic, the Holy Shroud, to Turin in order to make it a destination of religious pilgrimages. They dazzled the populace and court alike with public 186 Book Reviews TECHNOLOGY AND CULTURE spectacles. Most important to Poliak is their use of both civil and military architecture to inspire awe in their more powerful neighbors. With evidence garnered from a vast body of archival documents, Poliak documents the ways in which the rulers of Turin attempted to fulfill their ambitions. Of interest to the readers of Technology and Culture will be the extent to which military architects, military strategy, and what Poliak calls “military spirit” shaped the entire city. She argues that the military expression of the dynastic ambition was the overarching principle that united every aspect of Turin’s design through unprecedented “regularity, uniformity, and auster ity” (p. 5). Poliak more than fulfills her promise of providing a “coherent narrative history.” I am afraid, however, that many of the themes she wished to explore get buried in layers of description. It is too easy for the reader to become mired in her evidence and to lose sight of her larger goals. As I reached the end of her text I hoped to find a conclusion that might recapitulate the ways in which all the details would fit into the larger picture. Instead, the book simply comes to an abrupt and unsatisfying halt. The level of detail, without a commen surate level of analysis and interpretation, only exasperated my impatience with certain editorial decisions. The excessive use of excerpts from the original sources in the footnotes and the reprinting of numerous photographs resulted in a long and expensive volume. Nonetheless, Poliak has provided an excellent description of the process of building Turin. Although...
Read full abstract