PURPOSE: Fluctuations in estrogen during the menstrual cycle are thought to reduce athletic performance and aerobic capacity, hence, the purpose of this study was to determine the reliability of a menstrual cycle survey that proposes to assess the presence of symptoms and the perceived impact on training within collegiate athletes. METHODS: Seven NCAA-Division I women swimmers (19 ± 1 years, 30.1 ± 4.1 BMI), who trained normally participated in this study during the collegiate swim season. Athletes completed an electronic Visual Analog Scale (VAS) assessing menstrual status, as well as the presence and impact of symptoms twice within 30 minutes. Responses were recorded by marking a point on a 100-point line anchored by “not at all” and “often” in response to the presence of menstrual symptoms or “not at all” and “severely impacted” in response to the impact of menstrual symptoms on their training. Test re-test data were analyzed using two-tailed dependent samples t-tests and Intraclass Correlation coefficients (ICC3,1). RESULTS: A significant Intraclass Correlation was observed without a difference between surveys for the presence of mood swings (ICC:0.913, p = 0.143), loneliness (ICC:0.835, p = 0.395), headaches (ICC:0.835, p = 0.057) backaches (ICC:0.958, p = 0.125) and bloating (ICC:0.878, p = 0.198). A significant Intraclass Correlation was also observed without a difference between surveys in the perceived effect on training for cramps (ICC:0.823 p = 0.383), breast pain (ICC:0.818, p = 0.214), and bloating (ICC:0.817, p = 0.857). A significant difference between surveys was observed for athletes’ feelings of anxiousness (ICC:0.896, p = 0.022) and restlessness (ICC:0.707, p = 0.010); as well as the perceived effect anxiety (ICC:0.934, p = 0.041) and backaches (ICC:0.966, p = 0.009) had on training. CONCLUSION: Initial results from this survey suggest an electronic VAS may be a reliable measurement tool for some symptoms, including the frequency of mood swings, loneliness, backaches, bloating and possibly headaches, as well as the perceived effect cramps, breast pain and bloating have on training. Future research should focus on validating the results of this study against performance measures of participants as well as testing the reliability of participants with prior experience completing an electronic VAS.
Read full abstract