In order to improve the logging interpretation accuracy for complex oil and water layers developed in tight sandstone reservoirs, this study takes the Chang 8 member of the Yanchang Formation in the Huanxian area as the research object, and two new fluid identification methods were constructed based on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) logging and array acoustic logging. Firstly, the reservoir characteristics of physical properties and conductivity were studied in the research area, and the limitations of conventional logging methods in identifying complex oil and water layers were clarified. Then, the sensitive parameters for identifying different pore fluids were established by analyzing the relationship between NMR logging and array acoustic logging with different pore fluids. On this basis, the fluid identification plate, composed of movable fluid apparent diffusion coefficient and effective porosity difference (Da-Δφe) by NMR logging data of D9TWE3 observation mode, and the other fluid identification plate, composed of apparent bulk modulus of pore fluid and elastic parameter sensitive factor (Kf-Fac), were constructed, respectively. Finally, these two fluid identification methods were used for reservoir interpretation of actual logging data. This study shows that the two new fluid identification methods constructed by NMR logging and array acoustic logging can effectively eliminate the interference of rock skeleton on logging interpretation, which make them more effective in identifying complex oil and water layers than the conventional logging method. Additionally, the two methods have their own advantages and disadvantages when used separately for interpreting complex oil and water layers, and the comprehensive interpretation of the two methods provides a technical development direction for further improving the accuracy of logging the interpretation of complex oil and water layers.