Estimation of realized fecundity (Freal, number of viable oocytes produced) is an essential, yet seldom-achieved element in the understanding of marine animal production and population dynamics. We used the Neutral Red (NR) vital stain to determine oocyte viability in spawns and gonad strippings of four species of commercially-important bivalves: Cerastoderma edule (L), Crassostrea gigas Thunberg, Mytilus edulis L, and Tapes philippinarum (Adams and Reeve). The utility of Trypan Blue as a complementary mortal stain was also assessed, and found to be unnecessary. Normal, live oocytes stained with NR, and were either spherical (mature oocytes) or pedunculated (immature oocytes); atresic/abnormal oocytes also stained with NR, allowing their ready recognition due to their abnormal shapes and cytoplasmic retraction. Dead oocytes did not stain with NR. Across the species studied, a considerable and highly variable proportion of spawned or stripped oocytes was either dead or non-viable; quantitative counts were performed for Cerastoderma edule, the only species for which > 5 spawns occurred. The high level and variability (34–85%) of dead or non-viable oocytes is consistent with a reproductive Red Queen dilemma, in which greater oocyte numbers do not translate to commensurately greater real fecundities, and also with a Sweepstakes Reproductive Success strategy, in which a large range of Freal confronts the considerable variability of intertidal environmental conditions. Neutral Red vital staining is a promising tool for the elucidation and optimization of crucial yet previously intractable aspects of bivalve hatchery production, genetic improvement, restocking, stock management, and conservation.
Read full abstract