The section span of the withdrawal space of fully mechanized top coal caving in an extra-thick coal seam is large, and with the gradual withdrawal of the hydraulic support, a series of strong dynamic pressure disasters occur in the withdrawal space, and the difficulty of surrounding rock support control increases sharply. In order to study the control mechanism of surrounding rock in the final mining withdrawal space in detail and put forward a reasonable support technology scheme, taking the large-section withdrawal space of an 8309 fully mechanized caving face in an extra-thick coal seam of a mine as the research object—through the theoretical investigation of whether the key blocks of the main roof are stably hinged under varied stopping coal caving distances and fracture locations of the main roof—the reasonable and optimal stopping coal caving distances and roadway formation time are determined. Using numerical simulation and similar simulation methods, the vertical stress and the maximum shear stress research indicators were introduced to verify the accuracy of the theoretical analysis results. The results show the following: (1) The reasonable stopping coal caving span is 1~2 times the cycle weighting interval, the best stopping coal caving distance in this geological condition is 30 m, and the best fracture position of the main roof is located above the goaf. (2) The migration of overlying strata in the withdrawal space has obvious zoning characteristics, and the zoning is as follows: a stopping coal caving area, support area of the hydraulic support, withdrawal channel area, and stopping coal pillar area. (3) According to the zoning characteristics of overlying strata movement, the asymmetric zoning support control scheme of the withdrawal space is proposed. The field monitoring results show that the maximum roof subsidence in the withdrawal space is 151 mm, the maximum internal squeezing amount of the stopping coal pillar is 82 mm, and the supporting and anchoring effect of each partition in the withdrawal space is good. The set of partition asymmetric support control schemes has been successfully applied to field practice.