Facial nerve schwannoma is a very rare benign tumor representing less than 1% of intrapetrous lesions. Our patient is a forty-one year old female who has suffered from recurrent right facial palsy for the last six years. She was first misdiagnosed as having Bell’s palsy and received corticosteroids which resulted in little improvement. She then had facial nerve decompression surgery which resulted in a partial improvement. Since then, she has suffered from recurrent attacks of facial palsy. Two years ago, she came to our hospital seeking further treatment options. The final diagnosis made by MRI was a possible facial nerve tumor. To obtain a better facial outcome, total tumor removal was performed through the middle cranial fossa approach along with facial-hypoglossal nerve end-to-side anastomosis through transmastoid approach. Her hearing was preserved, and she obtained a better facial outcome than that of her preoperative level. In conclusion, facial nerve schwannoma has the potential to be misdiagnosed as Bell’s palsy which might lead to a delay in diagnosis, and end-to-side neurorrhaphy may be an effective alternative in a selected case.