Practical Reasons Research Articles

2022 초등학교 도덕과 교육과정에서 영역 명 ‘초월’ 삭제와 해당 ‘내용 요소’ 이동에 따라 고려되어야 할 배경 학문의 주요 개념에 대한 고찰

Objectives The purpose of this study is to understand and examine the representative concepts of background disciplines that need to be considered following the deletion of the domain name ‘Transcendence’ and the re-location of relevant ‘content elements’ in the elementary school moral education curriculum. Methods To this end, this study explored the educational implications following the deletion of the ‘Transcendence’ domain and the relocation of relevant ‘content elements’. It aimed to understand the concept of metacognition, based on psychology, and scientific reflection. Additionally, it investigated the qualitative perspective that should be integrated with scientific reflection from experiential theory and examined a new dimension of artistic approaches. Furthermore, the study sought to identify the concept of metaphysical transcendence in philosophy, a core background discipline of moral education. Results In the process of deleting the ‘Transcendence’ domain and relocating the relevant ‘content elements’, the concepts of metacognition and scientific reflection, which are key concepts in psychology and experiential theory, were emphasized. This allowed for an understanding of self-knowledge and regulation, as well as scientific think-ing processes. Additionally, by synthesizing qualitative thinking with the concept of scientific reflection from ex-periential theory, it was possible to explore the artistic level of experience emphasized by Dewey. Particularly, as a core background discipline of moral education, the philosophical meaning of transcendence was examined through Plato’s theory of Ideas and allegories, Kant’s transcendental philosophy of practical reason and autonomy, and Hegel’s dialectical movement in speculative philosophy. Conclusions In the elementary school moral education curriculum, there are key concepts from background dis-ciplines that need to be considered following the deletion of the domain name ‘Transcendence’ and the relocation of relevant ‘content elements’. Future research on this matter should consider discussing the significance of these underexplored major concepts to ensure a more comprehensive understanding.

Em busca de uma ética administrativa pós-convencional no contexto das organizações públicas brasileiras

This theoretical paper presents a debate on the moral action of public agents, aiming to indicate propositions for post-conventional administrative ethics in Public Administration. The expression “post-conventional ethics” originates from the Theory of Moral Development, constructed from research into the development of moral reasoning. At the post-conventional level of development, individuals are capable of making judgments about their own society, from an outside perspective, based on universal foundations. Based on this theoretical basis and the ethical competence of public agents to act consciously and make judgments, the possibility of postconventional administrative ethics is discussed. As suggestions and recommendations, in the sense of propositions, the following are presented: the integration of descriptive and normative ethics in the decision-making process; the virtue of phronesis and the search for the right way in ethical decision-making; and education for moral action.

Deciphering consumer behaviours in the innovative hospitality settings

Purpose This study aims to analyse the antecedents and consequences of consumer participation behaviour in the hotel industry. It investigates how citizenship behaviour influences the link between participation and switching intention. It also investigates hotel innovativeness, brand identification and consumer value co-creation using the frameworks of innovation diffusion theory, social identity theory and social exchange theory. By combining different academic perspectives, the study provides a thorough grasp of the elements that influence consumer behaviour and loyalty to hospitality brands. Design/methodology/approach This study used a descriptive-analytical approach to survey 526 guests who stayed at five-star hotels affiliated with chains in Egypt. The hotels were chosen using stratified random sampling, which ensured representation across multiple segments. For practical reasons, convenience sampling techniques were used to pick research participants. To test the study hypotheses, structural equation modelling was used, which provided a strong statistical analysis to assess the correlations between variables and validate the suggested theoretical framework. Findings The research indicates that hotel innovativeness has a substantial impact on consumers’ brand identification and involvement behaviour, but not their propensity to move brands. The relationship between participation behaviours and intention to switch is mediated by consumer citizenship behaviour. Research limitations/implications The cross-sectional study methodology may not address causal linkages or developmental difficulties because it only collected data at one point in time. A longer study period is required, and the sample group’s breadth is restricted to five-star hotel guests from Egypt’s chain-affiliated hotels. Originality/value This study offers a thorough methodology for assessing how hotel innovation influences consumer brand identification. It also looks at how consumer brand identification affects involvement and switching intentions. The study also investigates the moderating influence of consumer citizenship behaviour in the link between involvement and switching intentions.

Practical Reasoning in DatalogMTL

Abstract DatalogMTL is an extension of Datalog with metric temporal operators that has found an increasing number of applications in recent years. Reasoning in DatalogMTL is, however, of high computational complexity, which makes reasoning in modern data-intensive applications challenging. In this paper we present a practical reasoning algorithm for the full DatalogMTL language, which we have implemented in a system called MeTeoR. Our approach effectively combines an optimised (but generally non-terminating) materialisation (a.k.a. forward chaining) procedure, which provides scalable behaviour, with an automata-based component that guarantees termination and completeness. To ensure favourable scalability of the materialisation component, we propose a novel seminaïve materialisation procedure for DatalogMTL enjoying the non-repetition property, which ensures that each rule instance will be applied at most once throughout its entire execution. Moreover, our materialisation procedure is enhanced with additional optimisations which further reduce the number of redundant computations performed during materialisation by disregarding rules as soon as it is certain that they cannot derive new facts in subsequent materialisation steps. Our extensive evaluation supports the practicality of our approach.

Organizational peer support for second victims in Vienna, Austria: The KoHi-project

Abstract Background Healthcare workers negatively affected by adverse events are known as Second Victims (SV). The Second Victim Phenomenon (SVP) is widespread globally and can result in various consequences, such as anxiety, loss of confidence, and defensive medicine. To address this, the KoHi-project offers organizational peer support for SVs at the Clinic Hietzing (KHI) in Vienna, Austria. Methods A five-hour training program prepared 122 volunteers as peer supporters (KoHis) at KHI. Initial assessment (KoHi-I) in 2019 using the SeViD-questionnaire was followed by a repeat (KoHi-V) in 2022. Additionally, peer supporters underwent quantitative evaluations after training (KoHi-II), each session (KoHi-III), and after three sessions (KoHi-IV). KoHi-I-III were descriptively analyzed, while KoHi-IV and -V await evaluation. Results Initial study showed a 43% SVP prevalence at KHI. Most KoHis joined for ethical reasons and skill improvement, displaying high motivation. Post-training, they reported increased competency in supporting SVs. KoHi-III showed 53.3% of sessions initiated by KoHis, often triggered by personal distress. KoHis rated their support as highly helpful (M = 8.57 on a ten-point Likert-scale) and felt minimal burden (M = 3.42 on a ten-point Likert-scale) afterward. No significant correlations were found. Conclusions SVP is widespread at KHI. The five-hour training adequately prepared KoHis. Underreporting or underutilization of the program is suspected, possibly due to self-stigmatization of SVs. Being a peer supporter appears safe for KoHis. Psychological safety of voluntary supporters should be prioritized in hospital peer support programs. European hospitals lack organizational support for SVs, highlighting the importance of interventions like KoHi. Key messages • The SVP is common among healthcare workers at KHI. • The implemented organizational peer support seems to not negatively impact the voluntary peer supporters’ wellbeing.

2.Y.1. Communication in participatory health research with refugees and migrants

Abstract Innovative approaches are needed to transform public health research and address health inequities. Participatory Health Research (PHR) is one such approach, which aims to maximize the participation of those whose life or work is the subject of the research in all stages of the research process. PHR has advantages for both research outcomes, including increased relevance, meaningfulness and impact of research, as well as for those involved, in terms of ownership and empowerment to address their health priorities. PHR with migrants has potential to reduce health inequities through the active involvement of migrants in research about their health. In a framework for refugee and migrant health in the WHO European Region, MacFarlane et al. (2022) recommend the research field of migration and health to adopt PHR as the norm, for ethical reasons and to support effective research-policy-practice translation. PHR with migrants is increasingly used but is still rare and adhoc in the field of migration health research. There are also potential practical and ethical challenges that warrant critical reflection. One persistent challenge is communication, where differences in culture, language and knowledge areas need to be considered in multiple ways, for example, in the development of participatory partnerships, in the conduct of data collection that takes place as a result of such participatory partnerships and in dissemination processes. The aim of the workshop is to share different approaches on PHR with migrants and propose solutions to common challenges in communication. The workshop will be structured in a first part where presenters will draw upon their experience in PHR with refugees and migrants covering a broad range of topics relating to communication, and a second part of open discussion with presenters and the audience. The workshop will address two key questions: what challenges have we experienced, and lessons learnt. Anne MacFarlane presents emerging evidence about music and singing as culturally attuned arts based methods that can create innovative opportunities for communication for partnership building, fieldwork and dissemination. Ana Gama presents on using idea-generation workshops with vignettes representing migrants with diverse health-literacy profiles and its potential to address communication challenges. Key messages • Participatory health research with migrants warrants critical reflection around communication, ethics and partnership-building. • In participatory health research, using innovative and creative methods can create opportunities to overcome communication barriers and build meaningful collaborations. Speakers/Panelists Anne MacFarlane University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland Ana Gama IHMT, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal

Sporting clubs’ perceptions about harmful industry sponsorship: Lessons from gambling research

Abstract Background Unlike tobacco, there are no restrictions relating to gambling sponsorship in Australian sports. While some sporting teams have voluntarily refused sponsorship deals with gambling companies and other harmful industries, many are still actively entering into or renewing such deals. There is limited understanding of why, despite widespread public concern, sporting organisations continue to engage in commercial partnerships with gambling companies and venues. This study aimed to qualitatively explore the ethical and related practical issues associated with gambling sponsorship. Methods In-depth interviews were held with 24 key decision makers in Australian community sporting organisations. Participants were asked questions relating to attitudes towards gambling, decisions about gambling sponsorship within their clubs, and issues relating to alternative sponsors and sponsorship disparities. Data was analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Results Interviews revealed the difficulty for sporting organisations to avoid harmful industry sponsorship. When deciding to align with gambling companies, sporting organisations had to consider their own values and the reputational impact of such deals, and balance this with the financial viability of the sporting organisation. Despite sporting organisations relying heavily on sponsorship deals, some stated they would refuse gambling sponsorship for ethical reasons but recognised that sporting clubs in poorer financial positions may be more vulnerable to taking up gambling sponsorship. Conclusions As elite sporting organisations begin to move away from gambling sponsorship, gambling companies may target community sport. The authors consider practical strategies to protect communities from sponsorship from harmful industries. Key messages • Sporting organisations navigate ethical dilemmas when considering gambling sponsorships, weighing values, reputation, and financial viability. Policy action is needed to protect local communities. • Community sporting organisations face increased risk of gambling sponsorship as elite sporting clubs move away, prompting the need for protective strategies.

Public health innovation labs framework development: a design study of GGD West-Brabant Netherlands

Abstract Introduction Innovation Labs are spaces that encourage the creation, development and testing of novel ideas within organizations.While there are known frameworks for the organization of such labs in the private sector, current literature does not reflect a framework for developing a public health Innovation Lab (PHI-Lab) specifically.The aim of this study was to develop an evidence-based framework for a PHI-Lab together with the Dutch Municipal Health Service(GGD). Methods Our design thinking study consisted of 4 phases: Discovering, Defining, Creating and Evaluating.An initial framework was developed based on the public and public health sectors in the literature.To create and evaluate the framework,a document analysis of the GGD was performed,and co-creation and testing sessions were organized with 11 internal and 11 external stakeholders of the GGD. Results The final PHI-Lab framework is composed of: rationale, enablers and barriers, environment, approach, outcomes and values. Findings emphasized practical reasons for investing in a PHI-Lab, such as the shortage of health professionals.Stakeholders highlighted that proactive leadership and innovation culture are crucial enablers for the setup of the PHI-Lab.The right space and human resources (environment) and methods including design thinking and cross-collaboration (approach) were highlighted as important strategies for overcoming innovation challenges.Despite barriers such as bureaucracy and resource limitations, tailoring solutions to organizational objectives is key to the PHI-Lab’s success and sustainability, with added values of inclusiveness, adaptability and fun. Conclusions This study highlighted some practical additions to the initial framework that are specific to the public health setting, although mostly an adaptation from the public sector.Findings emphasize that there isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution to develop a PHI-Lab.This framework has the intention of benefiting other public health organizations. Key messages • The framework has the intention of benefiting other public health organizations within established networks and partnerships. • Proactive leadership and innovation culture are crucial enablers for the organizational setup of the innovation lab.

Simultaneous Remote Monitoring of Multiple Automated Vehicles

As vehicle automation continues to become a more prevalent part of everyday life, remote operators may be able to contribute to making this technology safer and more efficient. Such operators could be expected to monitor vehicles until it is necessary for them to intervene. In recent years several countries have passed legislation mandating the implementation of remote operation, making it a plausible scenario. For many practical reasons, operators may monitor more than one vehicle. This study provides an initial look into how remote operators might perform when asked to attend to multiple concurrent displays using simulated automated vehicles. The initial results indicate that participants retained a comparable level of accuracy in detecting failures in automation as the number of vehicles they monitored rose from one to two, albeit with a higher workload. The results and the methodology provide insights into potential task designs for remote operators of automated vehicles.

Interpersonal Reasoning: A Philosophical Psychology of Testimonial Trust

AbstractAnscombe famously said, “It is an insult and it may be an injury not to be believed.” But what is it to believe someone? My aim is to show that understanding what it is to believe someone requires a conception of a distinctive kind of interpersonal reasoning. To do so, I develop an analogy between interpersonal reasoning and an Anscombean conception of practical reasoning. I suggest that the distinctive ‘form’ of interpersonal reasoning is recognition. I furthermore argue that this is to be understood as a primarily logical, rather than epistemological point. In concluding, I explain why a notion of interpersonal reasoning makes available an ethics of thought and, specifically, an account of testimonial injustice.

Scaffolding Bad Moral Agents

AbstractRecent work on ecological accounts of moral responsibility and agency have argued for the importance of social environments for moral reasons responsiveness. Moral audiences can scaffold individual agents’ sensitivity to moral reasons and their motivation to act on them, but they can also undermine it. In this paper, we look at two case studies of ‘scaffolding bad’, where moral agency is undermined by social environments: street gangs and online incel communities. In discussing these case studies, we draw both on recent situated cognition literature and on scaffolded responsibility theory. We show that the way individuals are embedded into a specific social environment changes the moral considerations they are sensitive to in systematic ways because of the way these environments scaffold affective and cognitive processes, specifically those that concern the perception and treatment of ingroups and outgroups. We argue that gangs undermine reasons responsiveness to a greater extent than incel communities because gang members are more thoroughly immersed in the gang environment.

Acting Out

Abstract When is it morally permissible for performers to portray characters from marginalized groups of which they are not a member? Although this question is philosophically underexplored, it has been commanding increasing attention in the public sphere, especially with respect to straight performers portraying queer characters. While the demand for increasing self-representation from marginalized communities is laudable, we argue that demanding performers to disclose their social identity is, in general, morally counterproductive. We make our case by focusing on recent instances where fans demanded that a performer disclose their sexual orientation, putting vulnerable performers in a harmful trilemma. In short, it will force many to either out themselves against their will, subject themselves to intense public backlash by taking the role without outing themselves, or forgo taking a role they want and at which they would excel. Instead, we propose that performers have a general (epistemic) obligation to learn about what their characters’ corresponding real-world experiences would plausibly be like, representing what they learned in their performances. We will argue that meeting this obligation typically entails learning about the values, broadly construed, of the community in question. If we are right, there is not even a general obligation that performers only take roles that correspond to their own social identity. Just as importantly, there is a strong moral reason not to demand that performers disclose aspects of their social identity in order to take on a role.

Pentoxifylline in COVID-19 and considerations for its research in long COVID.

Pentoxifylline (PTX) affects most blood components and the blood vessels, potentially modulating various conditions. Due to its impact on markers linked to COVID-19 severity, research has explored PTX for acute COVID-19. Following the widespread administration of COVID-19 vaccinations, there has been a notable and consistently growing increase in research focusing on long COVID. Consequently, our examination of relevant acute COVID-19 data shall additionally be contextualized into long COVID research. Various Databases were searched until July 2024 for all primary clinical studies on Pentoxifylline (PTX) in COVID-19. Studies were on acute infection with SARS-CoV-2 where PTX was an adjuvant to standard therapy for ethical and practical reasons under the circumstance. PTX generally reduced hospitalization duration and improved some inflammatory markers, but its impact on mortality was inconsistent. Adverse events were minimal. Meta-analysis revealed a significant reduction in hospitalization duration. This systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that adding pentoxifylline (PTX) to standard COVID-19 therapy may significantly reduce hospitalization duration and improve some inflammatory markers. However, its impact on mortality rates is inconclusive. Adverse events are minimal. PTX can be favorable as an add-on in managing acute COVID-19 and could reduce the risk of long COVID, as well as assist in managing many of its most common symptoms.

Axiological reflection for nursing ethics education: The missing link in understanding value conflicts.

Texts from various areas of the world highlight the importance of moral values like compassion and integrity in healthcare. Such values are held in high esteem by healthcare organisations and are actively 'taught' within nursing ethics education to ensure their presence within the future workforce. With such an emphasis, it is easy to overlook that moral values are not the only values that people, including nurses, hold. Other personal values - which may or may not conflict with moral values - are simultaneously present within individuals. Therefore, moral behaviour cannot be predicted solely by the presence/absence of certain moral values. Instead, it depends on how these integrate into an individual's broader values system.Using Schwartz's axiological Theory of Basic Human Values as a framework, I argue that moral values are but one part of an individual's greater personal values spectrum, which also includes, for instance, hedonism, achievement, and power. Within this spectrum, values are ordered hierarchically, influencing behaviour based on relative priority. When a conflict arises between moral and other personal values, the prioritisation of moral values is a requirement for moral behaviour.I discuss how socialisation in suboptimal clinical practice environments can cause moral values to be deprioritised and argue that the development of practical reasoning skills is paramount to learning to balance one's values and guide decision-making. I advocate for the integration of (meta-)axiological reflection - characterised by introspection and aimed at developing a deeper understanding of one's personal values spectrum - within nursing ethics education. This involves exploring the origin, meaning, and perceived relative importance of one's different personal values. By incorporating specific reflective exercises, students can increase self-awareness/insight and enhance their ability to recognise situations where conflicts between their moral values and other personal values may occur, which is likely to benefit moral decision-making in clinical practice.

Strengthening Teacher Agency: Supporting the Orchestration of Ethical Dilemmas With EthicApp

Developing ethical reasoning as a competence is gaining relevance in higher education settings influenced by the current demands of society. One approach to achieve this competence is to propose realistic ethical dilemmas to the students. Nevertheless, educators need help in integrating ethics education effectively in higher education due to curricular constraints and a lack of supportive structures. EthicApp is a social platform that aims to support teachers in designing and enacting learning scenarios to foster ethical reasoning. However, the introduction of a new tool such as EthicApp may have undesired consequences for teachers’ agency. The notion of teacher agency is complex and not sufficiently studied in Technology Enhanced Learning contexts. For this reason, we propose to study the implications of the use of EthicApp for teacher agency in the light of the metaphor of orchestration. The metaphor of orchestration in TEL offers a holistic approach to studying how teachers integrate technologies into their practice. This paper presents preliminary findings from a case study in which three higher education teachers orchestrated learning designs supported by EthicApp. Early findings indicate that, although managing the learning scenarios in real-time was perceived as demanding, EthicApp empowered the participant teachers to design innovative learning scenarios, raise awareness, and inform the adaptation of the learning scenarios.

Metaethical constructivism and the capacity of practical reason

Metaethical constructivism and the capacity of practical reason

A Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA)-Based Phantom for Prostate Cancer Detection Using Multiparametric Ultrasound: A Validation Study

Multiparametric ultrasound (mpUS) enhances prostate cancer (PCa) diagnosis by using multiple imaging modalities. Tissue-mimicking materials (TMM) phantoms, favoured over animal models for ethical and consistency reasons, were created using polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) with varying molecular weights (Mw). Methods: Four PVA samples, varying in Mw with constant concertation, were mixed with glycerol, silicon carbide (SiC), and aluminium oxide (Al2O3). Phantoms with varying depth and inclusion sizes were created and tested using shear-wave elastography (SWE). An mpUS phantom was developed to mimic prostate tissue, including isoechoic and hypoechoic inclusions and vessels. The phantom was scanned using supersonic ultrasound, strain elastography, and Doppler ultrasound. Validation was performed using radical prostatectomy data and shear-wave elastography. Results: The acoustic properties varied with enhancers like glycerol and Al2O3. Low Mw PVA samples had a speed of sound ranging from 1547.50 ± 2 to 1553.70 ± 2.2 m/s and attenuation of 0.61 ± 0.062 to 0.63 ± 0.05 dB/cm/MHz. High Mw PVA samples ranged from 1555 ± 2.82 to 1566 ± 4.5 m/s and 0.71 ± 0.02 to 0.73 ± 0.046 dB/cm/MHz. Young’s modulus ranged from 11 ± 2 to 82.3 ± 0.5 kPa across 1 to 10 freeze-thaw cycles. Inclusion size, depth, and interaction statistically affect the SWE measurements with p-value = 0.056327, p-value = 8.0039 × 10−8, and p-value = 0.057089, respectively. SWE showed isoechoic inclusions, prostate tissue, and surrounding tissue only. The Doppler velocity was measured in three different inner diameters. Conclusion: PVA mixed with enhancer materials creates an mpUS phantom with properties that mimic normal and abnormal prostate tissue, blood vessels, and soft tissue, facilitating advanced diagnostic training and validation.

Real‐Time Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Detection Using Maximum Likelihood Estimation with Single‐Shallow‐Nitrogen‐Vacancy Centers in Quantum Heterodyne Measurements

Single‐nitrogen‐vacancy (NV) centers in diamond are highly promising quantum nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) sensors. However, their exposure to many sources of noise, such as surface impurities, shot noise from avalanche photodiode overlaps, and spin‐state projection errors inherent in quantum systems, limits their usefulness. Often, long measurement durations are required to accumulate sufficient data for NMR signal detection via fast Fourier transform spectrometry. For practical reasons, methods to shorten the necessary accumulation time for NMR signal detection are greatly desired. In this article, an on‐line formulation of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) signal processing for quantum heterodyne NMR measurements is presented as a step toward this goal. This MLE method reduces the required data accumulation time by orders of magnitude and provides good estimates of target frequency locales in real time. These results are significant to practitioners of NMR detection with single‐NV centers in diamond who require a quick litmus test for potential signals when probing a wide area.

Correction: The Question of the Existence of Moral Reasons and Two Kinds of Scepticisms

Correction: The Question of the Existence of Moral Reasons and Two Kinds of Scepticisms

A Rossian Method for Applying Principles in AI

In the past several years there has been a rapid development of new technologies, applications, organizations, and institutions in the area of artificial intelligence (AI). At the same time, ethical reasoning about AI has not been able to keep up with the speed of these advances. As a result, developers are left to rely on existing rules, professional codes, policies and personal ethics which may not provide the appropriate guidance about ethical conduct and may require greater specificity (O'Leary). Many commentators have acknowledged the need for a clearer understanding of ethical values and principles to guide AI research. Drawing on insights from the formation of the field of biomedical ethics, we argue that AI ethics should make use of the method based on prima facie duties derived from W.D. Ross’ approach to ethics. A Rossian approach has proved influential in biomedical ethics. We further propose a modification to the list of principles proposed by Floridi and Cowls, arguing that the principles of explicability and accountability should be separated for ease of application. We argue that this method of applying principles is just what has been missing in AI ethics and is the crucial link between the now common lists of principles and putting them into practice in a way that can inform actual developments on the ground.