Rauber's Sickle Research Articles

Mosaic and Regulation Phenomena during the Early Formation of the Chick Blastoderm

After culturing symmetrically hemisectioned unincubated chicken blastoderms, asymmetric hemiembryos developed (indicating mosaic development). In the present study, we observed that after prolonged culture, the further asymmetric development (way with no possible return) becomes profoundly disturbed, more particularly the Rauber's sickle-dependent phenomena: gastrulation and the formation of the coelomo-cardiovascular complex with absence of heart and pericard development. By contrast, the neural plate develops symmetrically. Asymmetrical ablation of Rauber's sickle and the neighboring upper layer results in the development of an apparently normal symmetrical embryo. Indeed, at the unoperated side, a normal half coelomo-cardiovascular system develops with a unilateral or bilateral heart tube and pericard formation (indicating regulation). Both regulation and mosaicism indicate that during normal early development, the interaction between the left and right sides of the caudal area centralis of the blastoderm is indispensable, depending on the spatial relationship between the elementary tissues (upper layer, Rauber's sickle, endophyll).

Mosaic versus regulation development in avian blastoderms depends on the spatial distribution of Rauber's sickle material

We describe how to prepare unincubated avian eggs to obtain a greater number of clearly visible Rauber's sickles for experimental embryology. After hemi-sectioning of unincubated chicken (Gallus domesticus) blastoderms and cultivating both halves in vitro, two kinds of development can be discerned: (1) when the unincubated blastoderms were hemi-sectioned according to the plane of bilateral symmetry, going through the middle region of Rauber's sickle, we obtained two hemi-embryos (a left and a right one). Each contained a half primitive streak, localized at the cut edge (starting from the most median part of Rauber's sickle) giving rise to a half mesoblast mantle and half area vasculosa, thus indicating mosaic development (each part of the whole fertilized egg would be able to form independently on its own). (2) When the unincubated blastoderm is hemi-sectioned more obliquely, going through a more lateral part of Rauber's sickle (sickle horn), two complete bilaterally symmetrically miniature embryos will form, indicating the so-called regulation phenomena. We demonstrate that these two types of development are in reality due to the different spreading and concentration of Rauber's sickle tissue (containing gamma ooplasm) around the area centralis. Embryonic regulation thus must not be considered as a kind of totipotent regeneration capacity of isolated parts of the unincubated avian blastoderm, but depends on the spatial distribution of a kind of extraembryonic tissue (Rauber's sickle) built up by the oblique uptake of gamma ooplasm (ooplasmic mosaicism) at the moment of bilateral symmetrization (Callebaut [1994] Eur Arch Biol 105:111-123; Callebaut [2005] Dev Dyn 233:1194-1216).

Origin, fate, and function of the components of the avian germ disc region and early blastoderm: Role of ooplasmic determinants

In the avian oocytal germ disc region, at the end of oogenesis, we discerned four ooplasms (alpha, beta, gamma, delta) presenting an onion-peel distribution (from peripheral and superficial to central and deep. Their fate was followed during early embryonic development. The most superficial and peripheral alpha ooplasm plays a fundamental role during cleavage. The beta ooplasm, originally localized in the peripheral region of the blastodisc, becomes mainly concentrated in the primitive streak. At the moment of bilateral symmetrization, a spatially oblique, sickle-shaped uptake of gamma and delta ooplasms occurs so that gamma and delta ooplasms become incorporated into the deeper part of the avian blastoderm. These ooplasms seem to contain ooplasmic determinants that initiate either early neurulation or gastrulation events. The early neural plate-inducing structure that forms a deep part of the blastoderm is the delta ooplasm-containing endophyll (primary hypoblast). Together with the primordial germ cells, it is derived from the superficial centrocaudal part of the nucleus of Pander, which also contains delta ooplasm. The other structure (gamma ooplasm) that is incorporated into the caudolateral deep part of the blastoderm forms Rauber's sickle. It induces gastrulation in the concavity of Rauber's sickle and blood island formation exterior to Rauber's sickle. Rauber's sickle develops by ingrowth of blastodermal cells into the gamma ooplasm, which surrounds the nucleus of Pander. Rauber's sickle constitutes the primary major organizer of the avian blastoderm and generates only extraembryonic tissues (junctional and sickle endoblast). By imparting positional information, it organizes and dominates the whole blastoderm (controlling gastrulation, neurulation, and coelom and cardiovascular system formation). Fragments of the horns of Rauber's sickle extend far cranially into the lateral quadrants of the unincubated blastoderm, so that often Rauber's sickle material forms three quarters of a circle. This finding explains the regulative capacities of isolated blastoderm parts, with the exception of the anti-sickle region and central blastoderm region, where no Rauber's sickle material is present. In avian blastoderms, there exists a competitive inhibition by Rauber's sickle on the primitive streak and neural plate-inducing effects of sickle endoblast. Avian primordial germ cells contain delta ooplasm derived from the superficial part of the nucleus of Pander. Their original deep and central ooplasmic localization has been confirmed by the use of a chicken vasa homologue. We conclude that the unincubated blastoderm consists of three elementary tissues: upper layer mainly containing beta ooplasm, endophyll containing delta ooplasm, and Rauber's sickle containing gamma ooplasm). These elementary tissues form before the three classic germ layers have developed.

Induction of the avian coelom with associated vitelline blood circulation by Rauber's sickle derived junctional endoblast and its fundamental role in heart formation

In histological sections through chicken blastoderms of different ages we describe the temporospatial relationship between junctional endoblast, the formation of blood islands (appearing first from a peripherally migrating mesoblastic blastema), and the formation of coelomic vesicles developing later in/and from a more superficially extending mesoblastic blastema (coelomic mesoblast). After unilateral removal of the Rauber's sickle-derived junctional endoblast in early streak blastoderms (stage 2-4; Vakaet [1970] Arch Biol 81:387-426) and culture to stage 11 (Hamburger and Hamilton [1951] J Morphol 88:49-92), we observed that the early formation of the coelomic cavity was locally or totally disturbed in the operated area. Besides the simultaneous absence of blood islands, the coelomic vesicles did not form normally. Instead of regularly aligned coelomic vesicles, progressively forming the coelomic cavity by fusion, some voluminous irregular cavities appeared. Thus, the extent of the coelomic cavity was greatly reduced and the operated side was considerably smaller than the unoperated side. Furthermore, in the youngest operated blastoderms the cranial portion of the involved coelomic cavity (hemipericardial cavity) exhibited rudimentary development and usually did not reach the region of the foregut endoderm. This resulted in the absence of the myoepicardium and associated endocardium at this side. In another experiment, after removal of the junctional endoblast at one side of the chicken blastoderm, a fragment of quail junctional endoblast was placed isotopically. This resulted, after further in vitro culture, in the restoration of the formation of coelomic vesicles and accompanying subjacent blood islands in the immediate neighborhood of the apposed quail junctional endoblast. Also, the pericardium and primary heart tube developed normally. Similarly, by using the quail-chicken chimera technique, we demonstrated that the splanchnic mesoderm cells of the pericardium develop in intimate association with the most cranial part of the junctional endoblast (derived from the Rauber's sickle horns). Our experiments indicate that the coelom and, in particular, the pericardium and primary heart tube form progressively (in time and space) under the inductory influence of Rauber's sickle and junctional endoblast.

Competitive inhibition by Rauber's sickle of the primitive streak and/or (pre)neural plate inducing effects of sickle endoblast in avian blastoderms.

When in unincubated chicken blastoderms the Rauber's sickle is (sub)totally mechanically removed by selective scraping, the further evolution of the blastoderm in culture is often profoundly disturbed, going from only expansion of the upper layer and preneural plate formation to the development of a slowly growing miniature embryo. Our results suggest that the developmental potencies of the embryo are related to the presence or absence of Rauber's sickle material left after its removal. This can be checked after culture by the presence or nonpresence of junctional endoblast (derived from Rauber's sickle) and the concomitant induction of blood islands in the immediate neighborhood. Our study thus indicates that without Rauber's sickle (in the cases of successful total selective removal), an avian blastoderm cannot develop normally, even in the presence of an intact caudal marginal zone. After placing a fragment of quail sickle endoblast on the anti-sickle region of unincubated chicken blastoderms from which the Rauber's sickle was (sub)totally removed, different developmental scenarios were seen, according to the degree of removal, both in the anti-sickle as in the sickle regions. 1) If Rauber's sickle activity is strongly reduced, then besides a centripetally directed miniature embryo, induced by the remnants of the autochthonous Rauber's sickle, an additional centripetally directed embryo or preneural plate (without accompanying blood islands) develops in the anti-sickle region under inductory influence of the apposed quail sickle endoblast. We make a distinction between a neural plate and a preneural plate. The latter consists of a thickening of the upper layer (with the same initial aspect as a neural plate) adjacent to endophyll or sickle endoblast in the absence of chordomesoblast and gastrulation phenomena. 2) If Rauber's sickle activity is totally absent, then the inducing power of the sickle endoblast fragment becomes maximal and, starting from the anti-sickle region, one single embryo (without blood islands) extending over the whole area centralis appears. 3) If much of the Rauber's sickle material has been left in the blastoderm, then the inducing activity of the sickle endoblast, placed on the anti-sickle region, will be totally suppressed (although the sickle endoblast remains intact) and neither a preneural plate nor a primitive streak was induced. After placing a fragment of quail sickle endoblast on the anti-sickle region of an unincubated chicken blastoderm from which the Rauber's sickle and surrounding tissues were completely excised, an embryo was always induced by the sickle endoblast in the adjacent upper layer of this anti-sickle region. In the absence of sickle endoblast, this never occurred. Thus, our experiments demonstrate that in the absence of the Rauber's sickle, a parent tissue (sickle endoblast) induces both gastrulation and neurulation phenomena, while in the full presence of Rauber's sickle these functions are totally suppressed. Moreover, Rauber's sickle not only organizes gastrulation and blood island formation by itself but also influences neurulation at a distance (in space and time) by part of its cell lineage (i.e., sickle endoblast). Our study suggests that the inhibitory effect of Rauber's sickle on its parent tissue (sickle endoblast) represents an early mechanism impairing polyembryony, so that only a single primary major organizer (Rauber's sickle) remains active in the young avian germinal disc.

Positional information by Rauber's sickle and a new look at the mechanisms of primitive streak initiation in avian blastoderms.

The present experimental in vitro study suggests that a primitive streak (PS) in avian blastoderms is induced by diffusion of morphogenetic substances emanating from Rauber's sickle. Indeed, even without direct contact between a quail Rauber's sickle and the reacting upper layer (by interposition of a vitelline membrane), a PS can be induced in the isolated area centralis or antisickle region of unincubated chicken blastoderms. The so-formed PSs are localized below the vitelline membrane in the immediate neighborhood of the apposed Rauber's sickle material. This seems to indicate that Rauber's sickle organizes the formation of the avian PS according to the basic concept of "positional information." The morphogenetic substances seem to have an effect only on the formation of a PS. Each part of Rauber's sickle seems to have, point by point, the same thickening and PS-inducing effect on each corresponding part of the underlying upper layer (UL). By a mechanism of sliding over the basement membrane and fusion, this finally results in the formation of one single median PS. Our study shows that a PS can be induced in the total absence of hypoblast (sickle endoblast) or caudal marginal zone, by only the presence of Rauber's sickle material. In contrast, the differentiation of mesoblast into blood islands under the influence of Rauber's sickle and neural tissue development are impaired by the interposition of a vitelline membrane. The latter could be due to the absence of a normal interaction of Rauber's sickle-derived sickle endoblast with endophyll and/or upper layer and the absence of cranial migration of the mesoblast. Thus, earlier studies and the present study indicate the existence of a temporospatially bound cascade of gastrulation and neurulation phenomena and blood island formation in the avian blastoderm, starting from Rauber's sickle, the primary major organizer with inducing, inhibiting, and dominating potencies. The latter not only plays a role by secretion of signaling molecules, but also influences development by its cell lineages (junctional endoblast and sickle endoblast).

Rauber's sickle and not the caudal marginal zone induces a primitive streak, blood vessels, blood cell formation and coelomic vesicles in avian blastoderms.

By using the quail-chicken chimera technique, we studied the reactivity and the eventual developmental or inducing capacities of the avian caudal marginal zone (in comparison with Rauber's sickle), when associated in vitro with different avian blastoderm components. If a fragment of quail sickle endoblast is placed on the caudal marginal zone of a whole unincubated chicken blastoderm, then a secondary miniature embryo will develop in this caudal marginal zone. The primitive streak and accompanying neural plate of the secondary embryo are directed peripherally into the caudal germ wall, away from Rauber's sickle. Thus, the 'mirror image development' indicates that the upper layer of the caudal marginal zone can react in the same way as the upper layer of the area centralis, because of the presence of sickle endoblast. A quail Rauber's sickle fragment placed on an isolated anti-sickle region always induces a primitive streak directed centrally. After prolonged culture, blood vessels and associated coelomic vesicles are formed. By contrast if a quail caudal marginal zone is placed on an isolated chicken anti-sickle region, the primitive streak, blood vessels and coelomic vesicles do not form. Thus, in contrast to the inducing effect of Rauber's sickle, the caudal marginal zone has no inducing effect by itself, even in the absence of the dominating effect of Rauber's sickle.

Avian sickle endoblast induces gastrulation or neurulation in the isolated area centralis or isolated anti-sickle region respectively.

By the quail-chicken chimera technique, we studied, in culture, the inducing effect of sickle endoblast (derived from Rauber's sickle by centripetal and cranial migration) on the isolated Rauber's sickle-free central part of the area centralis or on the isolated Rauber's sickle-free anti-sickle region from unincubated chicken blastoderms. Just as Rauber's sickle, the flat one-cell-thick sickle endoblast (Stage 2-3, Hamburger & Hamilton, 1951) induces a primitive streak (PS) and a neural plate in the area centralis. If a vitelline membrane is interposed between the sickle endoblast and the area centralis, then a small primitive streak is still induced, suggesting the effect of a diffusible factor on PS formation. In the adjacent upper layer of an isolated anti-sickle region the apposed sickle endoblast induces only a (pre)neural plate. By contrast, this (pre)neural plate inducing effect is rapidly and totally suppressed after grafting on the anti-sickle region of whole unincubated blastoderms. This suggests dominating positional information phenomena emanating from Rauber's sickle over the whole blastoderm. After grafting sickle endoblast either on the isolated area centralis or on isolated anti-sickles, no junctional endoblast and no blood islands developed. This suggests that the differentiation of Rauber's sickle material into sickle endoblast is irreversible. Our results indicate that Rauber's sickle material under the form of sickle endoblast also influences early neurulation phenomena (at distance in space and time). The present study indicates the existence of a temporo-spatially bound cascade of gastrulation and neurulation phenomena and blood island formation in the avian blastoderm, starting from Rauber's sickle, the primary major organizer with inducing, inhibiting and dominating potencies. The latter not only plays a role by secretion of signalling molecules (positional information) but it also influences development by its cell lineages (junctional endoblast and sickle endoblast).

Avian junctional endoblast has strong embryo-inducing and -dominating potencies.

In the present study, we demonstrate that quail junctional endoblast fragments have powerful embryo-inducing potencies when placed on the deep side of the upper layer (UL) of the anti-sickle region of unincubated chicken blastoderms. Moreover, in most cases the inducing potencies of the autochthonous Rauber's sickle-endophyll complex were inhibited at distance. Also, junctional endoblast still in situ in an early streak embryo strongly inhibits the inducing capacities of a Rauber's sickle - endophyll complex apposed on the deep side of the upper layer of the cranial part of the area pellucida. So junctional endoblast, besides embryo inducing potencies also seems to dominate and to inhibit at distance the gastrulation potencies of an ectopically placed or autochthonous Rauber's sickle - endophyll complex.

Endophyll orients and organizes the early head region of the avian embryo.

By placing endophyll on the caudal area marginalis situated behind Rauber's sickle of avian unincubated blastoderms, we observed after using the quail-chick chimera system and culture the development of a (pre)neural plate or a miniature embryo, head-oriented towards this endophyll. A Rauber's sickle fragment placed in the same conditions gives no reaction. If we place endophyll close to Hensen's node (stage 4 Vakaet, 1962) on an isolated anti-sickle region of an avian unincubated blastoderm in vitro, a similar endophyll-oriented development takes place after culture. Under the same conditions, but in the absence of endophyll, a Hensen's node provokes a thickening of the upper layer in the immediate neighbourhood, eventually with formation of a neural axis, oriented according to the original caudocranial direction of the graft. Our study indicates that avian endophyll (from unincubated blastoderms) can induce in the upper layer a (pre)neural plate, with or without neural folds. By interaction with sickle endoblast coming from Rauber's sickle (the early gastrulation organizer: Callebaut and Van Nueten, 1994), or from Hensen's node (a later avian organizer: Waddington, 1932), it can orient or re-orient the head region and the caudocranial direction of an induced miniature embryo. The conclusions from our embryological experiments are in agreement with the results obtained by recent molecular biology studies.

Interaction of central subgerminal ooplasm with the elementary tissues (endophyll, Rauber's sickle and upper layer) of unincubated avian blastoderms in culture.

By placing a central subgerminal ooplasmic mass over isolated parts (alone or in association) of unincubated avian blastoderms and culture, we obtained an improvement in, or in some cases restoration of normal development. The evolution of small rectangular fragments (isolates) excised from different regions of the unincubated blastoderm was observed in association or not with subgerminal ooplasm. The only type of differentiation that was clearly distinguished in these isolates (taken from the caudocentral area centralis region) was a so-called 'primary neurula' formed by the endophyll and an associated thickened upper layer. In the present study, we also demonstrate that after removal of the area centralis from an unincubated caudal blastoderm quadrant, the upper layer (UL) and endophyll can no longer be restored from the associated subgerminal ooplasm (and form a miniature embryo), as is the case after removal of the endophyll alone. A deep layer (containing the endophyll) reformed during the migration of Rauber's sickle-derived cells into the neighbouring central subgerminal ooplasm only in the presence of the upper layer. This suggests that the upper layer has an early influence on the cells containing the original central deep ooplasm (delta ooplasm) to form the endophyll. The present study offers supplementary arguments in favour of the hypothesis that the endophyll is an inductor of preneurulation.

Induction of (pre) gastrulation and/or (pre) neurulation by subgerminal ooplasm and Rauber's sickle in cultured anti-sickle regions of avian unincubated blastoderms.

Rauber's sickle fragments from unincubated quail blastoderms, associated or not with chicken central subgerminal ooplasm, were placed on the deep side of the upper layer (UL) of the isolated anti-sickle region of unincubated chicken blastoderms and cultured in vitro. When only a Rauber's sickle fragment was placed, we observed always a pronounced thickening of the UL (pregastrulation) in the immediate neighbourhood. Some times a primitive streak (PS) developed. When the Rauber's sickle fragment was "sandwiched" between the UL and a central subgerminal ooplasmic mass [containing the nucleus of Pander (1817)], always a (pre)neural plate accompanied by endophyll developed, not or well associated with a primitive streak. In the latter case a complete miniature embryo developed. De novo formation of endophyll was observed. As it contained quail nuclei it was derived from Rauber's sickle cells which colonized the subgerminal ooplasm. Our experiments indicate that the uncommitted upper layer (UL) of the anti-sickle of unincubated blastoderms constitutes an excellent reactor tissue for inductions. The thickening induced in the UL of the anti-sickle region by Rauber's sickle initiates (pre)gastrulation and the thickening induced by endophyll initiates (pre)neurulation. In the beginning, pregastrulation and preneurulation seem to be independent phenomena. It is only later, when both become correctly linked at the right place and time, that a normal embryo will develop.

Only the endophyll-Rauber's sickle complex and not cells derived from the caudal marginal zone induce a primitive streak in the upper layer of avian blastoderms.

From unincubated quail blastoderms, we have excised, caudal marginal zones (caudally from Rauber's sickle), upper layer fragments covering Rauber's sickle or Rauber's sickle fragments alone (as controls), and placed them on the ventral side of the cranial quadrant of unincubated chicken blastoderms. Also, quail Rauber's sickle fragments, all or not associated with quail endophyll, were placed on the ventral side of isolated central upper layer discs of prestreak chicken blastoderms from which the deep layer was previously removed. Only the Rauber's sickle-derived cells (sickle endoblast cells), placed on unincubated or shortly incubated blastoderms induce, after culture, a primitive streak (PS) and a normal embryo. This indicates, together with previous experimental evidence, that even in the presence of endophyll, neither the deep part of the caudal marginal zone nor the upper layer above it can induce a primitive streak. This experimental study affords further evidence that the function of the avian Rauber's sickle is homologous to the function (mesoderm induction) of the vegetal dorsalizing cells (Nieuwkoop centre) in amphibian blastulas.

Avian gastrulation and neurulation are not impaired by the removal of the marginal zone at the unincubated blastoderm stage.

In the present study, we removed the whole area marginalis, Rauber's sickle and the peripheral part of the area centralis from unincubated chicken blastoderms (st IV, Vakaet, 1962a). By placing a fragment of a quail Rauber's sickle (functioning as early gastrulation organizer: Callebaut and Van Nueten, 1994) at different places and oriented in different directions on the remaining central part of the area centralis, we observed, after in vitro culture, a normal embryonic development. This indicates that the area marginalis itself is not indispensable for gastrulation and neurulation. Our study also indicates that none of the three elementary tissues (Rauber's sickle, endophyll and upper layer) of the avian unincubated blastoderm present an irreversible functional polarity.

Spatial relationship between endophyll, primordial germ cells, sickle endoblast and upper layer in cultured avian blastoderms.

By isotopic quail-chicken chimera experiments of the Rauber's sickle or by radioactive labelling and isotopically replacing of the caudal endophyllic sheet in unincubated avian blastoderms, followed by culture, we demonstrated that the displacement of the endophyll by the cranially extending sickle endoblast is not exclusively a mechanical phenomenon, as suggested by earlier studies (Vakaet, 1962 a, b). Indeed, our study suggests that the sickle endoblast also migrates centripetally very soon (already after 5 h) in and through the caudal endophyll before ingression of upper layer cells takes place. We also describe the early spatial relationship between the three elementary tissues (endophyll, Rauber's sickle, upper layer) (Callebaut et al, 1996a) and the induction phenomena between quail sickle endoblast and chicken upper layer (UL) during the formation of the primitive groove. The latter already develops before ingression occurs. We found no evidence for an endophyllic origin of avian primordial germ cells.

Sex Differences in Morbidity and Mortality

HE differences between men and women in relation to the processes that lead to death are of more than passing interest for the student of human constitution. This branch of human biology, it has been emphasized (Pearl and Ciocco, I936; Ciocco, I936a, b), has for one of its major objectives to discover and eventually measure the stable organic correlationintegrated biological relations-between the morphological, physiological, psychological, and pathological traits of the individual. Therefore, the differences in morbidity and mortality observed for the two sexes assume special importance not only because the individuals of the two sexes are on the whole also morphologically and functionally differentiated but primarily because the sex dimorphism reflects a dissimilar biological make-up. This, it is of course realized, does not mean that sex differentiation is due simply to the chromosomal constitution of the individuals. In the first place, as Danforth (I93z) ably points out, the results of investigations on sex linkage have shown clearly that the so-called sex chromosomes are, one might say, only incidentally concerned with sex differentiation. Besides, as a result of the work of Bridges and of all those who have confirmed and extended his observations (Bridges, I932), it is accepted that the characteristics of each of the sexes are deternmined not only by the absence or presence of one of the sex chromosomes but also by the quantitative balance between the number of sex and autosomal chromosomes. The original simple scheme is further relegated into the background when an explanation is sought for Goldschmidt's observations on the alteration of the sex ratio and on the production of intersexes as the result of crosses between certain varieties of tussock moths. The conclusion which Goldschmidt (I9I7) reached and which he has maintained since (cf. Goldschmidt, I938), is that "every individual is -able to develop into one sex or the other or any stage between; further that every individual contains all the elements necessary for the development of either sex and its attributes; further that these elements or substances must have a certain quantitative relation to each other in order to secure to one of them the control of development; and that the introduction of quantities in a cross which do not fit the given quantity of the other partner set up the sex differentiation in favor of the higher quantity." That the final differentiation of sex is dependent also on extra-chromosomal factors is universally admitted today, thanks to the many observations and experimentations reported on gynandromorphism and sex reversal. Thus, the observation by Crew (I973) of the broody hen transformed through disease into a potent rooster is well known. Equally familiar are the studies of Hertwig (I906) continued and elaborated further by