Raman Optical Activity Research Articles

Organization of Carotenoid Aggregates in Membranes Studied Selectively using Resonance Raman Optical Activity.

In living organisms, carotenoids are incorporated in biomembranes, remarkably modulating their mechanical characteristics, fluidity, and permeability. Significant resonance enhancement of Raman optical activity (ROA) signals of carotenoid chiral aggregates makes resonance ROA (RROA), a highly selective tool to study exclusively carotenoid assemblies in model membranes. Hence, RROA is combined with electronic circular dichroism (ECD), dynamic light scattering (DLS), molecular dynamics, and quantum-chemical calculations to shed new light on the carotenoid aggregation in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) liposomes. Using representative members of the carotenoid family: apolar α-carotene and more polar fucoxanthin and zeaxanthin, the authors demonstrate that the stability of carotenoid aggregates is directly linked with their orientation in membranes and the monomer structures inside the assemblies. In particular, polyene chain distortion of α-carotene molecules is an important feature of J-aggregates that show increased orientational freedom and stability inside liposomes compared to H-assemblies of more polar xanthophylls. In light of these results, RROA emerges as a new tool to study active compounds and drugs embedded in membranes.

(Resonance) Raman optical activity among chiroptical spectroscopies: Quo vadis?

AbstractAlthough the potential of Raman Optical Activity (ROA) spectroscopy in the field of organic and inorganic materials research has been well demonstrated, its practical application is still limited. This work shows historical background, current state of the art and challenges of ROA spectroscopy facing scientists today. Expectations and development prospects for the coming years are also discussed. Efforts have already been made to improve but also to properly interpret the ROA signal when the ROA technique is combined with other spectroscopies (i.e., ROA/Electronic Circular Dichroism and ROA/Circularly Polarized Luminescence). The paper shows how to intensify the ROA effect to shorten the spectrum accumulation time, control possible artefacts and support the analysis of ROA spectra with actual and new theoretical approaches. However, the challenge is to increase the interest in this technique among the academic community, develop reliable protocols and adapt them for practical use. National and international research networks can significantly contribute to the growth of methodologies and standardization in areas in which the ROA has so far been little used. This paper presents a perspective vision for the future progress of ROA alongside other chiroptical methods.

Conformations and hydration of halopropionic acids studied by molecular dynamics and Raman optical activity

Chiral 2-halopropionic acids and their derivatives were synthesized and their properties studied computationally using Raman and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy. For neat acids present as liquids small amount of water led to significant changes in the spectra, resulting even to flipping of some ROA band signs. We find this interesting for the role water plays in interpretation of vibrational optical activity spectra of biomolecules. Analysis of the results shows that when the water is present, it can change ROA band signs due to the changes in acidobasic equilibrium. Corresponding esters without acidic hydrogens do not exhibit such effects.

Revisiting the conformational transition model for the pH dependence of BSA structure using photoluminescence, circular dichroism, and ellipsometric Raman spectroscopy

Changes in pH affect metabolic pathways, primarily by modulating enzyme conformations, which is why a detailed analysis of pH-driven conformational transitions is required to understand the underlying biochemistry of diseases and biological organisms. In this work, we examined the pH-driven conformational dynamics of Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA), within the framework of the Foster Model. Circular Dichroism and Raman Optical Activity showed the conversion of helical into β-rich structures in the acid and basic regions, while an opening of BSA tertiary structure was shown by the upsurging of accessibility of ANS-BSA binding sites and the increasing of random contributions at regions F and B. We could then revisit the Foster Model by introducing two additional intermediate conformational states and structural reorganization at extreme pH values. This expanded model opens up new possibilities concerning protein-molecule interactions, promising far-reaching implications for fields such as drug design and biomaterials.

Raman optical activity study of deuterated sugars: deuterium labelling as a tool for structural analysis.

Structural analyses using Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy conventionally rely on vibrational signals in the fingerprint region ranging from 100 to 1800 cm-1. Use of deuterium labelling to observe ROA signals in the C-D stretching region provides additional information about a local structure of large molecular systems. So far, the potential of C-D stretching ROA signals for structural analysis has rarely been explored. In the present work, we synthesized model deuterated glucose monosaccharides and studied their ROA properties by employing molecular dynamics and density functional theory to interpret the spectra. A good agreement between the simulated and experimental spectra is achieved when the proper conformer ratios are considered. This shows the usefulness of ROA spectroscopy assisted by deuterium labelling for stereochemical and conformational analysis.

Pitfalls in the Optimization of Conformer Populations to Maximize the Similarity between Predicted and Experimental Chiroptical Spectra.

The conformational populations of pantolactone, epichlorohydrin, and N-acetyl-tryptophan methyl ester were investigated by using similarity analysis between their calculated and experimental chiroptical spectra. By performing the analysis on pantolactone using two different chiroptical methods, namely, vibrational circular dichroism and Raman optical activity, it was found that the optimal sets of conformers do not match between the two methods, indicating that the conformational populations obtained by optimizing the similarity between calculated and experimental spectra are unlikely to be more accurate than energy-based Boltzmann populations. Also, it was found for pantolactone, epichlorohydrin, and N-acetyl-tryptophan methyl ester that the similarity between calculated and experimental spectra would often not vary significantly if each of the populated conformers was discarded, one at a time. This observation indicates that more than one set of conformers can provide acceptable similarity between the predicted and experimental spectra. Therefore, the correct set of conformers cannot be accurately determined by similarity analysis.

On the use of property-oriented basis sets for the simulation of vibrational chiroptical spectroscopies

We computed vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra for a test set of six chiral compounds using two standard density-functionals and an array of basis sets. We analysed the performance of property-oriented basis sets using a quadruple-zeta basis as a reference against four key metrics. We find little qualitative difference between the spectra produced by the larger basis sets (ORP, LPolX, aug-cc-pVTZ, and aug-cc-pVQZ), though their quantitative metrics exhibit wide variations. The smaller basis sets (rDPS, augD-3-21G, augT3-3-21G, Sadlej-pVTZ, and aug-cc-pVDZ) performed better for VCD rotatory strengths than for the corresponding ROA circular intensity differences (CIDs). However, this trend diminishes as the basis-set size is increased, lending validity to the conclusion that more robust property-oriented basis sets are required for ROA spectral generation than that of VCD. We observed improved performance in the mid-infrared region compared to the high-frequency regime, as well as overestimation of VCD rotatory strengths in the latter region as compared to the reference. We conclude that the ORP and LPol-ds basis sets are the most efficient and effective choices of basis set for the prediction of VCD and ROA spectra, as they provide both highly accurate results at reduced computational expense.

Variability of the Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy

Spectroscopy of Raman optical activity (ROA) is rather rare because of its experimental demands and difficult interpretation of the spectra. Yet it is further developing and in the last decade we witnessed significant improvement of the experimental and theoretical methods. This brought about new knowledge regarding structure and behavior of molecules, and their interactions with light. We give a brief summary of the experience we and others obtained with this method. It appears that ROA spectroscopy gives unique information about molecules, suitable for determination of the absolute configurations, but also for studies of conformations and electronic structure.

Molecular Vibrations in Chiral Europium Complexes Revealed by Near-Infrared Raman Optical Activity.

Raman optical activity (ROA) is commonly measured with green light (532nm) excitation. At this wavelength, however, Raman scattering of europium complexes is masked by circularly polarized luminescence (CPL). This can be avoided using near-infrared (near-IR, 785nm) laser excitation, as demonstrated here by Raman and ROA spectra of three chiral europium complexes derived from camphor. Since luminescence is strongly suppressed, many vibrational bands can be detected. They carry a wealth of structural information about the ligand and the metal core, and can be interpreted based on density functional theory (DFT) simulations of the spectra. For example, jointly with ROA experimental data, the simulations make it possible to determine absolute configuration of chiral lanthanide compounds in solution.

Three-Dimensional Rotational Averaging Using Irreducible Sets of Linearly Independent Fundamental Isotropic Cartesian Tensors: A Computational Approach.

The theoretical formulation of linear and nonlinear molecular spectroscopies applied to isotropic samples (e.g., liquid or gas solutions) goes through a fundamental step known as the rotational averaging of Cartesian tensors. Rotational averaging of Cartesian tensors is a mathematical procedure from which the expressions for the rotationally invariant observables (e.g., rates or intensities), associated with a given spectroscopic process, can be found. In this work, the mathematical/computational procedure for finding the rotational averages of Cartesian tensors of any rank n, which is based on the use of the fundamental isotropic Cartesian tensors (FICTs), is discussed. Moreover, for the first time, a heuristic computational method for finding a set of linearly independent FICTs is proposed. The procedure has been tested for 2 ≤ n ≤ 12, where most of the linear and nonlinear molecular spectroscopies apply (e.g., one-photon and multiphoton absorption, emission, electronic circular dichroism, Raman optical activity, coherent and incoherent mth-harmonic generation, etc.). Finally, it is shown how this computational procedure can be extended for n > 12.

Spectroscopic Validation of Crystallographic Structures of a Protein Active Site by Chiroptical Spectroscopy.

Out-of-plane distortions of a cofactor molecule in a protein active site are functionally important, and in photoreceptors, it has been proposed that they are crucial for spectral tuning and energy storage in photocycle intermediates. However, these subtle structural features are often beyond the grasp of structural biology. This issue is strikingly exemplified by photoactive yellow protein: its 14 independently determined crystal structures exhibit considerable differences in the dihedral angles defining the chromophore geometry, even though most of these are at excellent resolution. Here we developed a strategy to verify cofactor distortions in crystal structures by using quantum chemical calculations and chiroptical spectroscopy, particularly Raman optical activity and electronic circular dichroism spectroscopies. Based on this approach, we identify seven crystal structures with the chromophore geometries inconsistent with the experimentally observed data. The strategy implemented here promises to be widely applicable to uncovering cofactor distortions at active sites and to studies of reaction intermediates.

Understanding the surrounding effects on Raman optical activity signatures of a chiral cage system: Cryptophane-PP-111

Cryptophane molecules are cage-like structures consisting in two hemispheres, each made of three benzene rings. These hemispheres are bound together with three O(CH2)nOlinkers of various lengths giving rise to a plethora of cryptophane derivatives. Moreover, they are able to encapsulate neutral guests: CH2Cl2, CHCl3, …; and charged species: Cs+, Tl+, …. Finally, they exhibit chiroptical properties thanks to the anti arrangement of the linkers between the hemispheres.This work focuses on the Raman optical activity (ROA) signatures of Cryptophane-111 (n=1 for each linker). More specifically, we aim at simulating accurately its ROA spectra with and without a xenon atom inside its cavity. Experimental data (Buffeteau et al., 2017) have already demonstrated the effect of the encapsulation in the low-wavenumbers region. To generate the initial structures, we rely on the novel Conformer–Rotamer Ensemble Sampling Tool (CREST) program, developed by S. Grimme and co-workers. This is required due to the flexibility provided by the linkers. The CREST algorithm seems promising and has already been used to sample the potential energy surface (PES) of target systems before the simulation of their vibrational spectroscopies (Eikås et al., 2022).We observe large similarities between the two sets of conformers (one with and one without Xe encapsulated), demonstrating the robustness of the CREST algorithm. For corresponding structures, the presence of xenon pushed the two hemispheres slightly further apart. After optimization at the DFT level, only one unique conformer has a Boltzmann population ratio greater than 1%, pointing out the relative rigidity of the cage. Based on this unique conformer, our simulations are in good agreement with the experimental data. Regarding xenon encapsulation, the (experimental and theoretical) ROA signatures at low wavenumbers are impacted: slight shifts in wavenumbers are observed as well as a decrease in relative ROA intensity for bands around 150 cm−1. The wavenumber shifts were very well reproduced by our simulations, but the experimental decrease in the ROA intensity was unfortunately not reproduced.

Effective fully polarizable QM/MM approaches to compute Raman and Raman Optical Activity spectra in aqueous solution

Raman and Raman Optical Activity (ROA) signals are amply affected by solvent effects, especially in the presence of strongly solute–solvent interactions such as Hydrogen Bonding (HB). In this work, we extend the fully atomistic polarizable Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics approach, based on the Fluctuating Charges and Fluctuating Dipoles force field to the calculation of Raman and ROA spectra. Such an approach is able to accurately describe specific HB interactions, by also accounting for anisotropic contributions due to the inclusion of fluctuating dipoles. To highlight the potentiality of the novel approach, Raman and ROA spectra of L-Serine and L-Cysteine dissolved in aqueous solution are computed and compared both with alternative theoretical approaches and experimental measurements.

Combination of Resonance and Non‐Resonance Chiral Raman Scattering in a Cobalt(III) Complex

AbstractResonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra with high sensitivity reveal details on molecular structure, chirality, and excited electronic properties. Despite the difficulty of the measurements, the recorded data for the Co(III) complex with S,S‐N,N‐ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid are of exceptional quality and, coupled with the theory, spectacularly document the molecular behavior in resonance. This includes a huge enhancement of the chiral scattering, contribution of the antisymmetric polarizabilities to the signal, and the Herzberg‐Teller effect significantly shaping the spectra. The chiral component is by about one order of magnitude bigger than for an analogous aluminum complex. The band assignment and intensity profile were confirmed by simulations based on density functional and vibronic theories. The resonance was attributed to the S0→S3 transition, with the strongest signal enhancement of Raman and ROA spectral bands below about 800 cm−1. For higher wavenumbers, other excited electronic states contribute to the scattering in a less resonant way. RROA spectroscopy thus appears as a unique tool to study the structure and electronic states of absorbing molecules in analytical chemistry, biology, and material science.

Combination of resonance and non-resonance chiral Raman scattering in a cobalt(III) complex.

Resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra with high sensitivity reveal details on molecular structure, chirality, and excited electronic properties. Despite the difficulty of the measurements, the recorded data for the Co(III) complex with S,S-N,N-ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid are of exceptional quality and, coupled with the theory, spectacularly document the molecular behavior in resonance. This includes a huge enhancement of the chiral scattering, contribution of the antisymmetric polarizabilities to the signal, and the Herzberg-Teller effect significantly shaping the spectra. The chiral component is by about one order of magnitude bigger than for an analogous aluminum complex. The band assignment and intensity profile were confirmed by simulations based on density functional and vibronic theories. The resonance was attributed to the S0®S3 transition, with the strongest signal enhancement of Raman and ROA spectral bands below about 800 cm-1. For higher wavenumbers, other excited electronic states contribute to the scattering in a less resonant way. RROA spectroscopy thus appears as a unique tool to study the structure and electronic states of absorbing molecules in analytical chemistry, biology, and material science.

Raman spectroscopy and Raman optical activity of blood plasma for differential diagnosis of gastrointestinal cancers

Improving the early diagnosis of gastrointestinal cancers is a crucial step in reducing their mortality. Given the non-specificity of the initial symptoms, the ability of any diagnostic method to differentiate between various types of gastrointestinal cancers also needs to be addressed. To detect disease-specific alterations in biomolecular structure and composition of the blood plasma, we have implemented an approach combining Raman spectroscopy and its conformation-sensitive polarized version, Raman optical activity, to analyze blood plasma samples of patients suffering from three different types of gastrointestinal cancer – hepatocellular, colorectal and pancreatic. First, we aimed to discriminate any type of gastrointestinal cancer from healthy control individuals; inthenext step, the focus was on differentiating among the three cancer types studied. The more straightforward of the two statistical approaches tested, the combination of linear discriminant analysis and principal component analysis applied to the entire spectral dataset, allowed the discrimination of cancer and control samples with 87% accuracy. The three gastrointestinal cancers were classified with an overall accuracy of 76%. The second method, the linear discriminant analysis applied to a selection of spectral bands, yielded even higher values. Cancer and control samples were distinguished with 89% accuracy and hepatocellular, colorectal and pancreatic cancer with an overall accuracy of 87%. The results obtained in our study suggest that the proposed approach may become a disease-specific diagnostic tool in daily clinical practice.

Cover Feature: Monitoring Conformation and Protonation States of Glutathione by Raman Optical Activity and Molecular Dynamics (ChemPlusChem 11/2023)

Cover Feature: Monitoring Conformation and Protonation States of Glutathione by Raman Optical Activity and Molecular Dynamics (ChemPlusChem 11/2023)

Study on Asymmetric Vibrational Coherent Magnetic Transitions and Origin of Fluorescence in Symmetric Structures.

In this work, the physical mechanisms of three highly efficient circularly polarized luminescent materials are introduced. The UV-vis spectra are plotted; the transition properties of their electrons at the excited states are investigated using a combination of the transition density matrix (TDM) and the charge difference density (CDD); combining the distribution of electron clouds, the essence of charge transfer excitation in three structures is explained. The resonance Raman spectrum of the three structures at the S1 and S2 excited states are calculated. The M, M-4 and M, M-5 structures are found to produce novel chirality by electronic circular dichroism (ECD) spectrum, and the reasons for the chirality of the M, M-4 and M, M-5 structures are discussed by analyzing the density of transition electric/magnetic dipole moments (TEDM/TMDMs) in different orientations. Finally, the Raman optical activity (ROA) of M, M-4, and M, M-5 are calculated, and the spectra are plotted. This study will provide guidance for the application of carbon-based nanomaterials in organic electronic devices, solar cells, and optoelectronics.

Comparative study of Raman spectroscopy techniques in blood plasma-based clinical diagnostics: A demonstration on Alzheimer’s disease

Nowadays, there are still many diseases with limited or no reliable methods of early diagnosis. A popular approach in clinical diagnostic research is Raman spectroscopy, as a relatively simple, cost-effective, and high-throughput method for searching for disease-specific alterations in the composition of blood plasma. However, the high variability of the experimental designs, targeted diseases, or statistical processing in the individual studies makes it challenging to compare and compile the results to critically assess the applicability of Raman spectroscopy in real clinical practice. This study aimed to compare data from a single series of blood plasma samples of patients with Alzheimer’s disease and non-demented elderly controls obtained by four different techniques/experimental setups – Raman spectroscopy with excitation at 532 and 785 nm, Raman optical activity, and surface-enhanced Raman scattering spectroscopy. The obtained results showed that the spectra from each Raman spectroscopy technique contain different information about biomolecules of blood plasma or their conformation and may, therefore, offer diverse points of view on underlying biochemical processes of the disease. The classification models based on the datasets generated by the three non-chiroptical variants of Raman spectroscopy exhibited comparable diagnostic performance, all reaching an accuracy close to or equal to 80%. Raman optical activity achieved only 60% classification accuracy, suggesting its limited applicability in the specific case of Alzheimer’s disease diagnostics. The described differences in the outputs of the four utilized techniques/setups of Raman spectroscopy imply that their choice may crucially affect the acquired results and thus should be approached carefully concerning the specific purpose.

Molecular Properties of 3d and 4f Coordination Compounds Deciphered by Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy.

Molecular properties of coordination compounds can be efficiently studied by vibrational spectroscopy. The scope of Raman spectroscopy has been greatly enhanced by the introduction of Raman optical activity (ROA) sensitive to chirality. The present review describes some of its recent applications to study the coordination compounds. 3d and 4f metal complexes often absorb the excitation light, or exhibit luminescence. Therefore, effects caused in ROA spectra by electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) must be taken into consideration.In 3d metal complexes ECD and circularly-polarized Raman scattering compete with the resonance ROA (RROA) signal. Pure RROA spectrum can thus be obtained by subtracting the so-called ECD-Raman component. CPL is frequently encountered in 4f systems. While it can mask the ROA spectra, it is useful to study molecular structure. These electronic effects can be reduced by using near-infrared excitation although vibrational ROA signal is much weaker compared to the usual green laser excitation scenario. The ROA methodology is thus complex, but capable of providing unique information about the molecules of interests and their interaction with light.