Durable Pulmonary Vein Isolation Research Articles

What we have learned: is pulmonary vein isolation still the cornerstone of atrial fibrillation ablation?

Ablation of atrial fibrillation (AF) is an established treatment option for symptomatic patients. The cornerstone of all ablation strategies is electrical isolation of the pulmonary veins (PVs). Ablation strategies going beyond PV isolation (PVI) might be considered in the setting of recurrent AF despite durably isolated PVs. The lack of persistent PVI, however, limits the opportunities to perceive the real impact of this endpoint on AF suppression and to fully understand the benefit of extended ablation strategies going beyond. To overcome this limitation, novel and innovative ablation systems have been developed to facilitate acute PVI and to increase its durability. These systems include balloon-based ablation devices incorporating different energy sources such as cryo energy, laser, or radiofrequency current, but also new energy sources such as pulsed field ablation as a non-thermal energy source. These technologies could advance catheter ablation of AF to an early stage of the disease and to the primary treatment tool. The current manuscript focuses on the past, the present, and the future value of PVI as the cornerstone for interventional treatment of AF and on how to achieve durable PVI during the first procedure and to further improve the clinical success rates of AF ablation. It also analyses extended ablation strategies going beyond PVI and their impact.

Durable pulmonary vein isolation with diffuse posterior left atrial ablation using low-flow, median power, short-duration strategy.

To target posterior wall isolation (PWI) in atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation, diffuse ablation theoretically confers a lower risk of conduction recovery compared to box set. We sought to assess the safety and efficacy of diffuse PWI with low-flow, medium-power, and short-duration (LF-MPSD) ablation, and evaluate the durability of pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) and PWI among patients undergoing repeat ablations. We retrospectively studied patients undergoing LF-MPSD ablation for AF (PVI + diffuse PWI) between August 2017 and December 2019. Clinical characteristics were collected. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was performed to study AF/atrial flutter (AFL) recurrence. Ablation data were analyzed in patients who underwent a repeat AF/AFL ablation. Of the 463 patients undergoing LF-MPSD AF ablation (PVI alone, or PVI + diffuse PWI), 137 patients had PVI + diffuse PWI. Acute PWI with complete electrocardiogram elimination was achieved in 134 (97.8%) patients. Among the 126 patients with consistent follow-up, 38 (30.2%) patients had AF/AFL recurrence during a median duration of 14 months. Eighteen patients underwent a repeat AF/AFL ablation after PVI + diffuse PWI, and 16 (88.9%) patients had durable PVI, in contrast to 10 of 45 (23.9%) patients who had redo ablation after LF-MPSD PVI alone. Seven patients (38.9%) had durable PWI, while 11 patients had partial electrical recovery at the posterior wall. The median percentage of area without electrical activity at the posterior wall was 70.7%. Conduction block across the posterior wall was maintained in 16 (88.9%) patients. There was a high rate of PVI durability in patients undergoing diffuse PWI and PVI. Partial posterior wall electrical recovery was common but conduction block across the posterior wall was maintained in most patients.

Thawing plateau time indicating the duration of phase transition from ice to water is the strongest predictor for long-term durable pulmonary vein isolation after cryoablation for atrial fibrillation

Abstract Funding Acknowledgements Type of funding sources: Foundation. Main funding source(s): Helse Vest, Norway (LBS), and the Research Council of Norway (SYC). Background Cryoballoon ablation is an important method for pulmonary vein (PV) isolation in treatment of atrial fibrillation (AF). Previous studies have shown that thawing time, but not freezing time or temperature, impacts PV reconnection during long-term follow-up. However, it is unknown whether the entire or only part of the thawing stage plays a critical role. Purposes This study aimed to clarify the relationship between the durability of PV isolation and the time of phase transition from ice to water indicated by thawing plateau (TP) time during a cryoballoon ablation. Methods In this retrospective study, 241 PVs from 71 patients who underwent a repeat AF ablation 526 (IQR: 412, 675) days after a cryoballoon ablation were analyzed. The predictive value of procedural parameters for the durability of PV isolation were evaluated. Definitions of different phases of the temperature-time curve are shown in Figure 1. TP Time is defined as the time from 0 to 10°C inside the balloon in the thawing period (the plateau on the curve). Results Reconnection was observed in 101 (41.9%) PVs of 53 patients (74.6%). Durable PV isolation was associated with significantly longer TP Time compared with PV reconnection (26.0 vs. 11.0 s, P<0.001). The proportion of durable PV isolations increased with TP Time in a dose-proportional manner (Figure 2). The cut point for PV reconnection was TP Time <15 s with a positive predictive value of 82.1% (sensitivity=63.4%, specificity=90.0%) while for durable PV isolation the cut point was TP Time >25 s with a positive predictive value of 84.6% (sensitivity=55.0%, specificity=86.1%). After the analysis of multivariable logistic regression, location of PV (P<0.01), and TP Time (P<0.05) were shown as independent predictors for durable PV isolation. None of nadir temperature, initial cooling time, effective freezing time, initial thawing time, or late warming time was independent predictor. Accumulated TP Time for all PVs showed a positive linear correlation with the plasma level of troponin T (ρ=0.624, P<0.01). Conclusions TP Time is an independent predictor for the durability of PV isolation, and it presents in a dose-proportional manner. TP Time <15 s predicts long-term reconnection while TP Time >25 s predicts durable PV isolation.

Durability of pulmonary vein isolation following cryoballoon ablation: lessons from a large series of repeat ablation procedures

Abstract Funding Acknowledgements Type of funding sources: None. Background The cryoballoon technology has been widely proven to be effective in achieving acute pulmonary vein (PV) isolation and favorable clinical outcome. To date, little information is still available about occurrence of late PV reconnection after cryoballoon ablation. Purpose To assess the rate of durable PV isolation following cryoballoon ablation of atrial fibrillation in the setting of repeat procedures. Methods and Results A total of 154 consecutive patients (90 male, 58.4%; mean age 60.6±12.6 years) underwent a repeat procedure, after a mean 21.5±12.4 months (median 14 months), after index ablation using the 28-mm second-generation cryoballoon. All repeat ablations were performed using a 3-dimensional electro-anatomical mapping system. Among all 590 PVs, including 26 left common ostiums (LCOs), 99 (16.8%) showed a PV reconnection in 86 patients (1.15 per patient). Persistent PV isolation could be documented in 491 of 590 PVs (83.2%). In 68 of 154 patients (44%), all PVs were electrically isolated. In the multivariable analysis, balloon nadir temperature (p<0.01) and time to PV isolation (P=0.02) independently predicted late PV reconnection. Conclusions The rate of late PV reconnection after second-generation cryoballoon ablation was low (1.15 PVs/patient). Globally, the rate of durable PV isolation assessed during repeat procedures was 83.2%. The balloon nadir temperature and faster time to isolation were independently associated with durable PV isolation.

Pulsed field ablation of atrial fibrillation: recurrence rate after first pulmonary vein isolation and first insights into durability at redo procedures

Abstract Funding Acknowledgements Type of funding sources: None. Background Pulsed field ablation (PFA) is newly available for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) and combines the benefits of high procedural efficacy and safety. Independent data on the recurrence-rate of atrial fibrillation (AF) after PVI and on PVI durability during redo procedures are scarce. Purpose We report data on the recurrence rate of AF after first PVI using PFA and first insights into findings of PVI durability during redo procedures. Methods Consecutive AF patients undergoing a first PFA PVI at our center between May 2021 and August 2021 were included. PVI was verified by 3D-electroanatomical mapping (3D-EAM), and additional PFA lesions were applied when necessary until all PV were isolated. Seven-day Holter ECGs were performed at 3 and 6 months after ablation. After a blanking period of 3 months, episodes of AF/AT lasting more than 30 seconds were considered as AF-recurrence. Results 41 Patients, median age 69 (interquartile range 62-73) years, 24% female, 56% persistent AF, underwent first PVI by PFA. All PVs were successfully isolated using a multipolar PFA catheter. Median total procedure time including 3D-EAM was 104 (85-121) min. Total fluoroscopy time and dose were 26 (19-30) min and 671 (323-1248) Gym2. Acute complications occurred in 1 (2.4%) patient (cardiac tamponade requiring drainage). Early recurrence of AF during the blanking period occurred in 1 (2.4%) patient. Median follow-up time was 107 (91-152) days. Recurrence of AF after the blanking period was detected in 5 (12%) patients, 1 (6%) in paroxysmal AF and 4 (17%) in persistent AF patients, respectively. Redo procedures in 3 (7.3%) patients with AF recurrence confirmed durable isolation of 12/12 (100%) pulmonary veins and showed no evidence of PFA lesion regression. Conclusion AF recurrence rates after PVI by means of PFA are low. Durable isolation of 12/12 pulmonary veins (100%) and no evidence of PFA lesion regression was observed during redo procedures in patients with AF recurrence.

Pulmonary vein isolation with high power, short duration ablation leads to shorter procedure times associated with high success rates: a Prospective Randomized Trial

Abstract Funding Acknowledgements Type of funding sources: None. Background The single procedure success rates of durable pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) for paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (AF) varies between 85 and 90 %. This prospective, randomized study investigated the efficacy of high power, short duration ablation in a temperature-controlled mode versus standard power settings in terms of single-procedure arrhythmia-free outcome, safety and procedural time. Methods and results A total number of 176 patients undergoing de-novo catheter ablation for paroxysmal AF were randomized to two different treatment arms. In group-A patients, PVI was performed with RF-energy with standard power settings of 30 Watts in a temperature-controlled mode. The ablation procedure in group B was performed with RF-energy with higher power settings of 45 Watts. In both groups the ablation was performed with ablation index (AI) and following the CLOSE protocol (Biosense Webster Thermocool STSF). A total of 88 patients were randomized into each group without significant differences in baseline characteristics. During a mean follow-up of 12 ± 4 months after a single procedure, 79 (90%) patients of group A were free of arrhythmia recurrence versus 82 (93 %) patients in group B (p=ns). With regard to the procedural data, the procedure time was significantly shorter in group B (115.35 ± 15.38 versus 96.45 ± 17.19; p<0.01), the flouroscopy time and dose area were also significantly lower in Group B (9.66 ± 3.86 vs 5.45 ± 2.35; 330.84 ± 150.36 vs 202.51 ± 135.23) and total ablation times were significantly shorter in group B ((Table 1). Both procedures were performed with a low number of complications, no pericardial effusion was seen in either group, in both groups two patients had a significant hematoma of the groin with the need of surgical repair. Conclusions RF-ablation with high power (45 Watts) in combination with ablation index and following the CLOSE protocol leads to shorter procedure times, a lower total ablation time and a good safety profile.

Durability of pulmonary vein isolation following cryoballoon ablation: Lessons from a large series of repeat ablation procedures.

IntroductionThe second-generation cryoballoon (CB) has emerged in the last decade as an effective treatment for atrial fibrillation (AF). This study sought to analyze the rate of PV reconnection following CB ablation, evaluate the most frequent PV sites of conduction recovery and finally to assess procedural and biophysical indicators of reconnection in a large cohort of patients undergoing repeat ablation for recurrence of atrial arrhythmias.Methods and ResultsA total of 300 consecutive patients (189 males, 63%; mean age 63.0 ± 11.1 years) underwent a repeat ablation after 18.2 ± 10.8 months from the index CB ablation. All repeat ablations were performed using a 3-dimensional electro-anatomical mapping system. Among all 1178 PVs, 209 (17.7%) showed a late PV reconnection in 177 patients (1.18 per patient), at the time of repeat ablation procedure. Overall, persistent PV isolation could be documented in 969 of 1178 PVs (82.3%). In 123 of 300 patients (41%), persistent isolation could be demonstrated in all PVs, whereas PV reconnection could be documented in 177 patients (59%). In the multivariable analysis, nadir temperature (p = 0.03), time to PV isolation (p = 0.01) and failure to achieve − 40 °C within 60 s (p = 0.05) were independently associated with late PV reconnection.ConclusionsThe rate of late PV reconnection after CB ablation was low (1.18 PVs/patient). The most frequent sites of reconnections were the superior-anterior portions for the upper PVs and the inferior-posterior portions for the lower PVs. Faster time to isolation, colder nadir temperatures and achievement of − 40 °C within 60 s were associated with durable PV isolation.

Impact of a time-to-effect-guided ablation protocol in cryoballoon ablation on the durability of pulmonary vein isolation.

Cryoballoon (CB)-based pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) has proven to be as effective as radiofrequency-based ablation. Different ablation protocols took the individual time-to-isolation (TTI) into account aiming at shorter but equally or even more effective freeze cycles. The current study sought to assess the impact of the TTI on PVI durability in patients undergoing a repeat procedure for recurrence of atrial tachyarrhythmia (ATA). In 205 patients with ATA recurrence after previous CB-based PVI, a total of 806 pulmonary veins (PVs) were identified. A total of 126out of 806 PVs (16%) were previously treated with a TTI-guided ablation (Protocol #1; TTI + 120 s), in 92/806 (11%) PVs TTI was only monitored (m) but fixed freeze cycles were applied (Protocol #2; mTTI) and in 588/806 (73%) a fixed freeze cycle was applied without mTTI. There was no difference in the PV-reconduction rate between the groups (p = .23). The right inferior pulmonary vein (RIPV) showed overall significantly higher reconduction rates compared to the other PVs (RIPV-left inferior PVp < .003, -left superior PVp < .001, -right superior PVp < .013). Twenty-one patients (10%) were demonstrated to have only electrical reconduction of the RIPV, while all other PVs were still electrically isolated. The TTI-based CB ablationprotocol did not show significant differences regarding PV-reconduction rates compared to the other ablation protocols.

High-Frequency, Low-Tidal-Volume Mechanical Ventilation Safely Improves Catheter Stability and Procedural Efficiency During Radiofrequency Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation

High-Frequency, Low-Tidal-Volume Mechanical Ventilation Safely Improves Catheter Stability and Procedural Efficiency During Radiofrequency Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation

Cavotricuspid isthmus ablation guided by force-time integral - A randomized study.

BackgroundForce‐time integral (FTI) is an ablation marker of lesion quality and transmurality. A target FTI of 400 gram‐seconds (gs) has been shown to improve durability of pulmonary vein isolation, following atrial fibrillation ablation. However, relevant targets for cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) ablation are lacking.HypothesisWe sought to investigate whether CTI ablation with 600 gs FTI lesions is associated with reduced rate of transisthmus conduction recovery compared to 400 gs lesions.MethodsFifty patients with CTI‐dependent flutter were randomized to ablation using 400 gs (FTI400 group, n = 26) or 600 gs FTI lesions (FTI600 group, n = 24). The study endpoint was spontaneous or adenosine‐mediated recovery of transisthmus conduction, after a 20‐min waiting period.ResultsThe study endpoint occurred in five patients (19.2%) in group FTI400 and in four patients (16.7%) in group FTI600, p = .81. First‐pass CTI block was similar in both groups (50% in FTI400 vs. 54.2% in FTI600, p = .77). There were no differences in the total number of lesions, total ablation time, procedure time and fluoroscopy duration between the two groups. There were no major complications in any group. In the total population, patients not achieving first‐pass CTI block had significantly higher rate of acute CTI conduction recovery, compared to those with first‐pass block (29.2% vs. 7.7% respectively, p = .048).ConclusionsCTI ablation using 600 gs FTI lesions is not associated with reduced spontaneous or adenosine‐mediated recurrence of transisthmus conduction, compared to 400 gs lesions.

Pulmonary vein isolation using cryoballoon ablation versus RF ablation using ablation index following the CLOSE protocol: A prospective randomized trial.

The single procedure success rates of durable pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) for paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (AF) varybetween 80% and 90%. This prospective, randomized study investigated the efficacy of cryoballoon PVI (CBA) versus PVI with radio-frequency (RF)-energy following the CLOSE protocol (ablation index [AI], interlesion distance ≤6 mm, surround flow catheter) in terms of single-procedure arrhythmia-free outcome and safety. A total number of 150 patients undergoing de novo catheter ablation for paroxysmal AF were randomized to two different treatment arms. In group A patients, PVI was performed with the 23 or 28 mm cryoballoon (Artic Front™Balloon in conjunction with an Achieve Mapping Catheter, Medtronic Inc.). The ablation procedure in group B was performed with RF-energy, using AI and following the CLOSE protocol. PVI using AI incorporates stability, contact force (CF), time, and power. The CLOSE protocol combines AI and ≤6 mm interlesion distance using a surround flow catheter (Biosense Webster Thermocool STSF). A total of 75 patients were randomized into each group without significant differences in baseline characteristics. During a mean follow-up of 12 ± 4.5 months after a single procedure, 64 (85.33%) patients of group A were free of arrhythmia recurrence versus 65 (86.67%) patients in group B (p = ns). A total of 14 patients (group A: 7 [9.33%]; group B: 7 [9.33%]; p = ns) underwent a redo-procedure. No significant difference between both groups was observed in terms of PV recovery (group A: 4 [5.33%] vs. group B: 3 [4%]; p = ns). In two patients of group A and four patients of group B, the PVs were durably isolated, whereas the patients had AF recurrence caused by extra-PV AF sources. Two patients of each group had continued paroxysmal AF but did not undergo redo-procedure. Patients of group A showed significantly more AF recurrence during the blanking period of 3 months (group A: 14 [18.67%] vs. group B: 6 [8%]; p < .05). With regard to the procedural data, the procedure time was significantly shorter in group A (70.53 ± 16.13 vs. 115.35 ± 15.38; p < .01); the flouroscopy time and dose area product showed no significant differences (Table 2). Both procedures were performed with a low number of complications; no pericardial effusion was seen in either group; in group A two patients had a significant hematoma of the groin with the need for surgical repair. Cryoballoon PVI and PVI using ablation index following the CLOSE protocol are equally efficient in achieving durable PV isolation. In this study, cryoballoon ablation led to significantly more AF recurrence during the blanking period.

The target ablation index values for electrical isolation of the superior vena cava.

The ablation index (AI), developed as a radiofrequency (RF) catheter ablation composite component endpoint, which incorporates contact force (CF), time, and power in a weighted formula, has been reported to be useful for a durable pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) to treat atrial fibrillation (AF). No study has reported the target AI value for the SVC isolation (SVCI). In this study, we aimed to investigate the target AI for the SVCI. Thirty-six AF patients who underwent an initial SVCI were enrolled. Ablation was performed at 556 points. The sites where dormant conduction was induced or additional ablation was needed were defined as touch up sites (n = 36). We compared the energy deliver time, power, generator impedance (GI) drop, local bipolar voltage, contact force (CF), force-time integral (FTI), and AI between the touch up sites and the no touch up sites (n = 520). The FTI and AI were significantly lower at the touch up sites (touch up sites vs. no touch up sites; FTI, 126.5 [99.3-208.8] vs. 244 [184-340.8], p < 0.0001; AI, 350.1 ± 43.6 vs. 277.2 ± 21.8, p < 0.0001). The median value of the AI at the no touch up sites was 350, and no reconnections were seen where the minimum AI value was more than 308. Most of the touch up sites were located in the anterior wall and lateral wall (anterior wall, 20/36 sites [55.6%]; lateral wall, 10/36 sites [27.8%]; septal wall, 6/36 sites [16.7%]; posterior wall, 0/36sites [0.0%]). The target AI value for the SVCI should be 350, and at least 308 would be needed.

Irreversible Electroporation Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation: Status and Challenges

Abstract Pulsed electric field (PEF) is a novel energy source by which high-voltage electric pulses are used to create irreversible electroporation. PEF is non-thermal and highly tissue-dependent in which specific targeting of the atrial myocardium is achieved and sparing of adjacent tissues is feasible, theoretically increasing the safety of the procedure, which could potentially break the trade-off between effective lesions and collateral damage and substantially improve risk-benefit ratios in atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation. Although recently published trials have shown a clear effect of AF ablation, large-scale clinical trials are lacking. Current clinical evidence has demonstrated significant efficacy in achieving durable pulmonary vein isolation without ablation-related adverse events. However, their putative benefits regarding efficacy, efficiency, and safety remain to be proven in randomized controlled trials.

Impact of catheter contact angle on lesion formation and durability of pulmonary vein isolation

PurposeThis study is aimed to evaluate the impact of catheter contact angle on lesion formation and durability of pulmonary vein isolation (PVI).MethodsBoth in vitro experiment and retrospective observational study were conducted. For in vitro experiment, radiofrequency lesions were created on explanted swine hearts in three different catheter contact angles (0°, 45°, and 90°). In the retrospective observational study, we assessed patients who had undergone repeat catheter ablation due to atrial fibrillation recurrence after initial PVI. When pulmonary vein (PV) reconnection was observed, we analyzed the previous ablation points within and without the gap area. The gap areas were where ablation had changed the PV activation sequence or eliminated the PV potential in the repeat session.ResultsIn the in vitro experiment, lesion width was the smallest (5.3 ± 0.4 mm) in perpendicular contact compared to 0° (vs 5.8 ± 0.5 mm, p = 0.040) and 45° (vs 6.4 ± 0.4 mm, p < 0.001). In the retrospective observational study, we assessed 666 tags of 16 patients with PV reconnections, and 60 tags were in the gap area. Tags in the gap area had longer interlesion distance (odds ratio [OR] 1.49, p < 0.001), greater contact force variability (OR 1.03, p = 0.008), and higher rate of perpendicular contact (OR 3.26, p < 0.001) on multivariate analysis.ConclusionsPerpendicular contact was associated with a smaller lesion and higher rate of PV reconnection.

Acute efficacy of contiguous versus temporally discontiguous point-by-point radiofrequency pulmonary vein isolation in patients with paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: a randomized study.

Durable pulmonary vein (PV) isolation (PVI) determines the clinical success of catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation. In this randomized study, we investigated whether the temporally discontiguous deployment of ablation lesions adversely affected the acute efficacy of PVI. Thirty-six consecutive patients with drug-refractory paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (aged 59 ± 11, 58% males) were randomized 1:1 to either discontiguous (D-PVI) or contiguous (C-PVI) encircling radiofrequency (RF) lesions around ipsilateral PVs. A contact force-sensing catheter was used targeting a final interlesion distance < 6mm and the ablation index of 400-450 (anterior wall) and 300-350 (posterior wall). The study endpoint was defined as failure of first-pass PVI or acute PV reconnection during a waiting time (> 30min) followed by adenosine challenge. The total RF time, number of RF lesions, and mean interlesion distance were comparable in both groups. Total endpoint rates were 1/36 (3%) in the D-PVI vs 4/36 (11%) in the C-PVI groups; P = 0.34 for superiority, P = 0.008 for non-inferiority. Adenosine-induced reconnection of right PVs was the only endpoint in the D-PVI group. In the C-PVI group, first-pass PVI failed in 2 right PVs and spontaneous reconnection occurred in 2 other circles (left and right PVs). Temporally discontiguous deployment of RF lesions is not associated with lower procedural PVI efficacy when strict criteria for interlesion distance and ablation index are applied. The development of local edema around each ablation site does not prevent effective RF lesion formation at adjacent positions. clinicaltrials.gov (NCT03332862).

Radiofrequency Lesion Quality Markers: Current State of Knowledge

The long-term efficacy of radiofrequency catheter ablation is highly dependent on the location and size of the lesions delivered via the ablation catheter. This is particularly the case for radiofrequency ablation for atrial fibrillation, where contiguous, transmural lesions are required for durable pulmonary vein isolation. Therefore, reliable lesion quality markers that accurately relate to lesion size in the context of 3D mapping have been sought to improve the reliability of conduction block. Force–time integral, Ablation Index and Lesion Size Index are metrics currently used in clinical practice. Several studies have shown better clinical outcomes using these indices compared with using contact force alone or no marker at all. A theoretical limitation of these composite lesion indices is that they rely on input values such as contact force, application duration and power. A recent technology assessessing local tissue impedance (an output measure) has shown promising results. Temperature, another output measure, is not routinely used due to the significant impact of catheter irrigation on readings, but two recent catheter technologies have sought to overcome this obstacle. This paper provides an update on the current knowledge on these lesion quality markers.

Radiofrequency ablation to achieve durable pulmonary vein isolation.

Pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) by radiofrequency (RF) ablation is an important alternative to antiarrhythmic drugs in the treatment of symptomatic atrial fibrillation. However, the inability to consistently achieve durable isolation of the pulmonary veins hampers the long-term efficacy of PVI procedures. The large number of factors involved in RF lesion formation and the complex interplay of these factors complicate reliable creation of durable and transmural ablation lesions. Various surrogate markers of ablation lesion formation have been proposed that may provide information on RF lesion completeness. Real-time assessment of these surrogates may aid in the creation of transmural ablation lesions, and therefore, holds potential to decrease the risk of PV reconnection and consequent post-PVI arrhythmia recurrence. Moreover, titration of energy delivery until lesions is transmural may prevent unnecessary ablation and subsequent adverse events. Whereas several surrogate markers of ablation lesion formation have been described over the past decades, a 'gold standard' is currently lacking. This review provides a state-of-the-art overview of ablation strategies that aim to enhance durability of RF-PVI, with special focus on real-time available surrogates of RF lesion formation in light of the biophysical basis of RF ablation.

High-power short-duration versus standard-power standard-duration settings for repeat atrial fibrillation ablation

IntroductionHigh-power short-duration (HPSD) ablation is a novel strategy using contact force-sensing catheters optimized for radiofrequency ablation for atrial fibrillation (AF). No study has directly compared HPSD versus standard-power standard-duration (SPSD) contact force-sensing settings in patients presenting for repeat ablation with AF recurrence after initial ablation.MethodsWe studied consecutive cases of patients with AF undergoing repeat ablation with SPSD or HPSD settings after their initial pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) with temperature controlled non-contact force, SPSD or HPSD settings between 6/23/14 and 3/4/20. Procedural data collected included radiofrequency ablation delivery time (RADT). Clinical data collected include sinus rhythm maintenance post-procedure.ResultsA total of 61 patients underwent repeat ablation (36 SPSD, 25 HPSD). A total of 51 patients (83.6%) were found to have pulmonary vein reconnections necessitating repeat isolation, 10 patients (16.4%) had durable PVI and ablation targeted non-PV sources. RADT was shorter when comparing repeat ablation using HPSD compared to SPSD (22 vs 35 min; p = 0.01). There was no difference in sinus rhythm maintenance by Kaplan–Meier survival analysis (log rank test p = 0.87), after 3 or 12-months between groups overall, and when stratified by AF type, left atrial volume index, CHA2DS2-VASc score, or left ventricular ejection fraction.ConclusionWe demonstrated that repeat AF ablation with HPSD reduced procedure times with similar sinus rhythm maintenance compared to SPSD in those presenting for repeat ablation.

Ablation Index-guided point-by-point ablation versus Grid annotation-guided dragging for pulmonary vein isolation: A randomized controlled trial.

IntroductionRadiofrequency (RF) atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation using a catheter dragging technique may shorten procedural duration and improve durability of pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) by creating uninterrupted linear ablation lesions. We compared a novel AF ablation approach guided by Grid annotation allowing for “drag lesions” with a standard point‐by‐point ablation approach in a single‐center randomized study.MethodsEighty‐eight paroxysmal or persistent AF patients were randomized 1:1 to undergo RF‐PVI with either a catheter dragging ablation technique guided by Grid annotation or point‐by‐point ablation guided by Ablation Index (AI) annotation. In the Grid annotation arm, ablation was visualized using 1 mm³ grid points coloring red after meeting predefined stability and contact force criteria. In the AI annotation arm, ablation lesions were created in a point‐by‐point fashion with AI target values set at 380 and 500 for posterior/inferior and anterior/roof segments, respectively. Patients were followed up for 12 months after PVI using ECGs, 24‐h Holter monitoring and a mobile‐based one‐lead ECG device.ResultsProcedure time was not different between the two randomization arms (Grid annotation 71 ± 19 min, AI annotation 72 ± 26 min, p = .765). RF time was significantly longer in the Grid annotation arm compared with the AI annotation arm (49 ± 8 min vs. 37 ± 8 min, respectively, p < .001). Atrial tachyarrhythmia recurrence was documented in 10 patients (23%) in the Grid annotation arm compared with 19 patients (42%) in the AI annotation arm with time to recurrence not reaching statistical significance (p = .074).ConclusionsThis study shows that a Grid annotation‐guided dragging approach provides an alternative to point‐by‐point RF‐PVI using AI annotation.

Cryoballoon Ablation Strategy in Persistent Atrial Fibrillation.

Background: Cryoballoon ablation is established for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) in paroxysmal atrial fibrillation (AF). The objective was to evaluate CBA strategy in consecutive patients with persistent AF in the initial AF ablation procedure.Material and Methods: Prospectively, patients with symptomatic persistent AF scheduled for AF ablation all underwent cryoballoon PVI. Technical enhancements, laboratory management, safety, single-procedure outcome, predictors of recurrence, and durability of PVI were evaluated.Results: From 2007 to 2020, a total of 1,140 patients with persistent AF, median age 68 years, underwent cryoballoon ablation (CBA). Median left atrial (LA) diameter was 45 mm (interquantile range, IQR, 8), and Congestive heart failure, Hypertension, Age ≥75 years (doubled), Diabetes mellitus, prior Stroke or TIA or thromboembolism (doubled), Vascular disease, Age 65 to 74 years, Sex category (CHA2DS2-VASc) score was 3. Acute isolation was achieved in 99.6% of the pulmonary veins by CBA. Median LA time and median dose area product decreased significantly over time (p < 0.001). Major complications occurred in 17 (1.5%) patients including 2 (0.2%) stroke/transitory ischemic attack (TIA), 1 (0.1%) tamponade, relevant groin complications, 1 (0.1%) significant ASD, and 4 (0.4%) persistent phrenic nerve palsy (PNP). Transient PNP occurred in 66 (5.5%) patients. No atrio-esophageal fistula was documented. Five deaths (0.4%), unrelated to the procedure, occurred very late during follow-up. After initial CBA, arrhythmia recurrences occurred in 46.6% of the patients. Freedom from atrial arrhythmias at 1-, and 2-year was 81.8 and 61.7%, respectively. Independent predictors of recurrence were LA diameter, female sex, and use of the first cryoballoon generation. Repeat ablations due to recurrences were performed in 268 (23.5%) of the 1,140 patients. No pulmonary vein (PV) reconduction was found in 49.6% of the patients and 73.5% of PVs. This rate increased to 66.4% of the patients and 88% of PVs if an advanced cryoballoon was used in the first AF ablation procedure.Conclusion: Cryoballoon ablation for symptomatic persistent AF is a reasonable strategy in the initial AF ablation procedure.