Reviewed by: Silent Serial Sensations: The Wharton Brothers and the Magic of Early Cinema by Barbara Tepa Lupack Richard D. Deverell (bio) Silent Serial Sensations: The Wharton Brothers and the Magic of Early Cinema By Barbara Tepa Lupack. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2020. 408 pages, 59 halftones, 1 map, 6" x 9". $22.95 paper, $10.99 ebook. In Silent Serial Sensations: The Wharton Brothers and the Magic of Early Cinema, literature and film scholar Barbara Tepa Lupack examines the lives and work of Leo and Ted Wharton, creators of an independent film production studio in Ithaca, New York, during the 1910s. Tracing the influence of the Whartons' work on the film industry during the silent era, Lupack argues that their serials, "which aroused the enthusiasm of audiences worldwide, played a vital role in the evolution of cinema as a mass medium and as a form of entertainment for people of all ages and backgrounds; and they became forerunners of today's ubiquitous crime and mystery procedurals and sensation-filled commercial blockbusters" (xi). Lupack's analysis proceeds chronologically, with each chapter largely focusing on the production of a specific film. She uses this to her advantage, so that the vignettes of production and filming mirror the themes the Whartons examined in their work. Lupack writes that, in their short films, "The Whartons spoke directly to the concerns [End Page 431] of their age and to the interests of their audiences" (13). These themes included the New Woman and feminism of the early twentieth century, particularly through shorts with women protagonists such as The Exploits of Elaine from1914 to 1915 (84). Works like The Mysteries of Myra (1916) blended sexuality with the occult while advancing special effects techniques, thereby entertaining their audiences while contributing to popular culture portrayals of the New Woman and the supernatural (132–33, 146–47). Lupack discusses how the Whartons used their films to address other contemporary social issues, including concerns about disreputable institutions, eugenics, and the eventual creation of the United Way, though their message came second to their professional standards of filmmaking and the need to turn a profit (192, 185–88, 219). With war on the horizon, the Wharton brothers similarly tapped into fears of foreign sabotage (165, 211, 219). Like many films from this period, a great deal of the Whartons' work was lost to time, so Lupack bases her close readings of the films on any extant clips, the archived scripts, and production photographs. In likening the Wharton brothers to other film histories, Lupack describes the complicated mechanism for film censorship, with state boards employing varying standards and even some municipalities denying content that the state itself approved. In addition to navigating these official censors, the Whartons worked with William Randolph Hearst, who was a hands-on producer and often dictated content or required reshoots to match his ideological vision (165, 175, 177, 202–03). Filming in New York, the Whartons made extensive use of the varied geography surrounding Ithaca and the Finger Lakes region (52, 54, 69). Upstate New York offered further benefits due to its proximity to New York City and New Jersey, then the headquarters of the American film industry (22–23). Unfortunately, following World War I, the film industry moved out west to Los Angeles (227). This, combined with the Whartons' own financial woes once they went fully independent and no longer relied on Hearst for funding and promotion, ended both their business and the film industry in Ithaca (237). Lupack draws extensively on the Wharton Collection in the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections at Cornell University, the Wharton Collection at the History Center in Tompkins County, New York, and the Wharton Studio Photographs Collection at Ithaca College. She uncovers a great deal of the local involvement in and reaction to the Whartons' productions via newspapers such as the Ithaca Journal, the Cornell Daily Sun, and the Cornell Alumni News. These accounts help fill in some of the gaps in official studio production records as they feature more human interest stories that help bring the Whartons and their cadre of actors and studio hands to life. Finally, Lupack uses film trade publications including Moving Picture World...
Read full abstract