Dark fermentation (DF) is a waste treatment bioprocess which produces biohydrogen and volatile fatty acids (VFAs) such as acetate or butyrate. DF can be coupled with microalgae cultivation, allowing VFA conversion into valuable biomass. Nevertheless, the process is hindered by slow butyrate consumption. In this study, novel artificial microalgae-bacteria consortia were used as a strategy to accelerate butyrate removal. Three microalgal strains with various trophic metabolisms, Chlorella sorokiniana, Euglena gracilis and Ochromonas danica, were cultivated on DF effluent that was either sterile or contained endogenous bacteria. Bacteria did not impact microalgal biomass production of C. sorokiniana or E. gracilis while accelerating butyrate removal rates 2 to 10-fold. O. danica greatly impacted microbial diversity, probably due to its phagotrophic metabolism. These results show that bacteria in organic rich effluents can greatly aid in substrate removal while allowing microalgal growth, inspiring bioprocesses coupling raw fermentation effluents with microalgae biomass production and valorization.