Based on the fracture trace length distribution, conditions for the existence, uniqueness, and correctness of the fracture diameter distribution are given using Warburton’s fracture model. In particular, a solution for the fracture diameter distribution exists and is unique for all trace length probability density functions, hA(y), such that \(h_{A}(y)/\sqrt{y^{2}-x^{2}}\) is Lebesgue integrable on [x,∞). This condition is met by the uniform, exponential, gamma, lognormal, and power-law trace length distributions as well as by the trace length distributions that arise from a deterministic fracture diameter or from a discontinuous fracture diameter length distribution. Exponential, gamma, lognormal, and power-law trace length distributions satisfy necessary conditions for the diameter distribution to be non-negative, and necessary and sufficient conditions for the distribution to have unit integral over the real line. Negative values of the fracture diameter distribution arise when the trace has a uniform distribution and the lower bound of the fracture trace is greater than zero.