Preoperative Selection Criteria Research Articles

Consistency of patient-reported outcomes after cholecystectomy and their implications on current surgical practice: a prospective multicenter cohort study

BackgroundPersistent postoperative pain (up to 41 %) and significant practice variation necessitate better patient selection for cholecystectomy. Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) are nowadays known to serve as a tool for better patient selection, although variability within these subjective outcomes may be a point for debate. This study determines associations of both the preoperative pain and patient characteristics with PROMs at 24 weeks after cholecystectomy. In order to evaluate variability of PROMs, we also determined consistency of these outcomes in time.MethodsThis prospective multicenter cohort study included adult patients diagnosed with uncomplicated symptomatic cholecystolithiasis. Twenty-four weeks after surgery, a questionnaire study was carried out, containing Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index (GIQLI) and Patients’ Experience of Surgery Questionnaire. Results were compared to preoperative data and results 12 weeks post-cholecystectomy. Logistic regression analyses were performed to determine associations. Additional post hoc analysis on associations between preoperative selection criteria and PROMs was done.ResultsA total of 360 patients (85 %) responded. Postoperative absence of pain was reported by 59.2 %. Associated characteristics were symptoms ≤1 year prior to surgery [OR 1.85 (95 % CI 1.11–3.09)] and high baseline GIQLI score [OR 1.04 (95 % CI 1.02–1.05)]. General improvement in abdominal symptoms and positive result of surgery were found in 90 %; no preoperative variables were significantly associated. PROMs showed consistency at 12 and 24 weeks postoperatively. Post hoc analysis showed no significant associations.ConclusionPROM-based preoperative selection criteria need to be considered to select those patients who achieve freedom of pain after surgical treatment of uncomplicated symptomatic cholecystolithiasis. Other patients might consider cholecystectomy as successful, but are less likely to be free of pain. Usefulness of PROMs is underscored as they proved to be consistent in time in evaluating surgical outcome.

How to Best Predict Success of the Transobturator Male Sling

Although the male sling is a popular and effective option to treat stress urinary incontinence, the reported success rates are highly variable. Detailed knowledge of the factors affecting male sling outcome can improve clinical efficacy and provide realistic expectations for patients. The objective of this article is to review the current literature that identifies factors associated with surgical outcome, with the goal of optimizing pre-operative selection criteria. Since most practitioners prefer the transobturator approach, the retrourethral transobturator sling (i.e., AdVance™ sling) is the focus of this review.

Living donor hepatectomy: Study of donor profile and perioperative complications

IntroductionDonor morbidity is of prime concern in living donor liver transplant (LDLT). Several centers in India have reported outstanding outcomes of LDLT. This study intends to reiterate the importance of donor safety in liver transplantation. Aims and objectivesTo review the outcome of donor hepatectomies in LDLT at our center. Materials and methodsThis study retrospectively analyzes the outcomes of 34 consecutive living donor hepatectomies performed between Apr 2007 and Jun 2013. Complications following major donor hepatectomy were stratified according to Clavien classification of postoperative surgical complications. ResultsNine living donors had perioperative complications. Grade 1 complications were most frequent (20.6%); grade 2 in 6%; while none had any higher grades of complications. No donor mortality was present. ConclusionMeticulous preoperative donor selection criteria and adherence to predefined surgical protocols can ensure minimal donor morbidity.

Ambulatory thyroidectomy: Recommendations from the Association Francophone de Chirurgie Endocrinienne (AFCE). Investigating current practices

Cervical hematoma with airway compromise is a severe complication that may be rapidly lethal or result in irreversible cerebral anoxia if the hematoma is not urgently decompressed. It is therefore indispensable to know the essential relevant elements as well as predictive criteria for this complication before envisioning ambulatory thyroidectomy. The Association francophone de chirurgie endocrinienne (AFCE) sought to answer several questions raised by the proposal of ambulatory thyroidectomy and to propose recommendations based on a review of the literature, an inquiry sent out to members of the AFCE, and an in-depth research of the medicolegal risks involved, based essentially on jurisprudence. The details scrutinized included preoperative selection criteria, the characteristics of the operation and the basic elements of postoperative surveillance. The standard today is at least an overnight hospital stay. In fact, hospital stay can be less than 24h because the risk of cervical compressive hematoma is very unusual beyond this interval. Ambulatory (outpatient) thyroidectomy (0 nights) is possible under certain conditions for highly selected patients according to criteria described in the literature that also define relative contra-indications. In case of life-threatening or functional complications, the surgeon stands first in the line of responsibility. The surgeon must therefore ensure that the patient and family were fully informed of the contra-indications, the normal course of postoperative events, of pertinent elements of postoperative surveillance and of the conditions under which the patient can be safely discharged. The surgeon must also realize that this type of management is time-consuming.

Single-centre evaluation of the extraperitoneal and transperitoneal approach in robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy

Robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP) is feasible using either an extraperitoneal (EP) or a transperitoneal (TP) approach. This study reports on the experience of a single hospital using both techniques. From July 2009 to March 2011, 170 patients underwent RARP. EP was chosen in 103 patients and TP in 67. TP was preferred in cases previous mesh hernia repair or if extended lymph-node dissection (LND) was considered necessary. Otherwise, EP was performed; it was preferred in cases of obesity (body mass index (BMI) > 30 kg/m(2)) or previous intra-abdominal surgery. There were no significant differences in preoperative mean age (64.4 vs 65.6 years), BMI (26.5 vs 26.3 kg/m(2)) or prostate size (51.8 vs 55.8 cm(3)) between EP and TP patients. Owing to preoperative selection criteria, prostate-specific antigen levels and the average Gleason score were significantly lower in EP than in TP patients (p < 0.001). Whereas access time and time for anastomosis did not differ significantly (21 vs 19 min, p = 0.11, and 26 vs 24 min, p = 0.36, respectively), overall surgical time was significantly longer in TP (225 vs 191 min, p < 0.001). Blood loss was equal in both groups (EP 276 vs TP 281 ml, p = 0.88). Complication rates were lower in EP (n = 7, 6.8% vs n = 8, 12%, p = 0.024). Time until first defecation and last analgesic treatment were significantly shorter in EP (p < 0.05). The results of the current evaluation underline the clinical advantages of an extraperitoneal approach for RARP. However, a transperitoneal approach is still considered necessary for extended LND or special clinical conditions. Robotic teams should be trained using both approaches.

P2-16-16: Nipple Sparing Mastectomy and Immediate Breast Reconstruction: Critical Appraisal of Five Year, Single Centre Outcomes.

Abstract Background Approximately 5,000 patients undergo breast reconstruction annually in the United Kingdom ( 2:1 ratio of immediate versus delayed respectively). Whilst skin sparing mastectomy is an accepted modality for local control in appropriately selected patients, nipple preservation remains controversial. In over 1,800 peer reviewed nipple sparing mastectomy (NSM) cases, the local event rate attributable to NAC preservation following NSM (therapeutic and prophylactic) is 0.16% with no evidence of deleterious impact on disease free survival. This study aims to evaluate in a selected cohort of patients, the oncological safety and aesthetic outcome of nipple- sparing mastectomy and immediate breast reconstruction (IBR). We highlight the surgical technique used and propose in/exclusion criteria. Material and Methods: Patients were identified retrospectively from our Institution's electronic patient records and WinPath™ database by searching clinical codes corresponding to NSM &amp; IBR, performed by the senior authors (IJL and RD) between January 2004 and December 2008. Pre-operative selection criteria included: 100% pre-operative lesion characterisation; 5mm margin acceptance; submission of separate nipple core specimens for paraffin block histological assessment and re-excision of all involved/close margins. Follow-up data was verified from patients’ case notes, histo- pathological review and standardised photographic views. Endpoints include: local recurrence rate, disease free survival, peri-operative NAC subcutaneous tissue loss and validated aesthetic outcome measures. Results*: 84 patients underwent NSM &amp; IBR for invasive disease. The mean age was 52.1 years and a median follow-up of 38 months. IBR utilised autologous tissue (latissimus dorsi or transverse rectus abdominus musculocutaneous flaps) with/without implant prosthesis. There was one case of local recurrence (1.2%) in a patient who declined re-excision of close/involved margins and no recorded breast cancer related deaths. Peri-operative complication rates were within the national mastectomy breast reconstruction audit outcome guidelines. Conclusion: In this cohort of patients, nipple sparing mastectomy and immediate breast reconstruction achieves comparable oncological outcomes with excellent aesthesis relative to traditional ablative procedures for local control. Nipple preservation although not evaluated independently does enhance cosmetic outcomes. *(Preliminary analysis) Citation Information: Cancer Res 2011;71(24 Suppl):Abstract nr P2-16-16.

Pre-operative prediction of post–VAD implant mortality using easily accessible clinical parameters

Mortality rates are high after implantation of a ventricular assist device (VAD), occurring mainly in the early phase post-implant during the time in the intensive care unit (ICU). Pre-operative selection criteria, which predict successful outcome, are difficult to evaluate. We implemented a pre-operative risk score to predict mortality in the ICU after VAD implantation by using easily obtained and quickly accessible clinical parameters. In 241 VAD patients, 100 pre-operative markers were related to mortality in the ICU using univariate analysis and ROC curves, followed by multinomial logistic regression analyses. The mortality rate in the ICU was 32.0%. Univariate statistical analysis revealed 34 parameters that were significantly associated with mortality in the ICU. Of these, multinomial logistic regression identified 13 markers as significant risk factors. These included demographic data (age >50 years); clinically/procedurally relevant data (ischemic cardiomyopathy [ICM], re-do surgery, on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation [ECMO], on intra-aortic balloon pump [IABP], previous cardiac surgery, ventilation, emergency implant, inotropic support, renal replacement therapy, pre-operative resuscitation, transfusion) and laboratory values (blood urea nitrogen [BUN] >40 mg/dl, creatinine >1.5 mg/dl, lactate >3 mg/dl, platelets <100 x 10(3)/microl, white blood cell [WBC] count >13 x 10(3)/microl, C-reactive protein [CRP] >8 mg/dl, hemoglobin <12 g/dl, hematocrit <35%, lactate dehydrogenase [LDH] >500 U/liter, creatine kinase [CK] >200 U/liter, troponin >20 ng/ml). A weighted risk score was implemented with a maximum of 50 points. The risk for mortality in the ICU was as follows: low (15.8%), <15 points; medium (48.2%), 16 to 30 points; and high (65.2%), >30 points. Easily obtained and quickly accessible clinical parameters can inform potential patients, relatives, and physicians pre-operatively about the risk of death in the ICU after VAD implantation.

Microendoscopic Discectomy for Lumbar Disc Herniation

A retrospective review involving 873 consecutive cases of lumbar disc herniation treated by microendoscopic discectomy (MED) was conducted and a mean 28-month follow-up was performed. The purpose of this study was to describe the MED technique for lumbar disc herniation and report long-time outcome and complications. The conception of MED was introduced in 1997. Long-time outcome has not been described. A total of 873 consecutive patients with lumbar disc herniation were treated with the METRx system. Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) was used to quantify pain relief. The degree of pain and disability was also measured by visual analog scale (VAS) and modified MacNab criteria. A control group of 358 patients treated with standard open discectomy was used for comparison. There was significant improvement in the mean preoperative and postoperative VAS and ODI score for the MED and open groups, and there was no statistical difference of the pain improvement between the two groups. For the MED group, average length of hospital stay was 4.8 days; mean time to return to work or normal activities was 15 days; average operative blood loss per level was 44 mL. These were significantly less than open group. MED is an effective microendoscopic system with fine long-term outcome in treating lumbar disc herniation. The endoscopic approach allows smaller incisions and less tissue trauma, compared with standard open microdiscectomy. Strict adherence to well-defined preoperative selection criteria could ensure optimal postoperative outcome.

Breast Reduction Surgery in the UK and Ireland–Current Trends

This paper reviews the current status of bilateral breast reduction surgery in the UK and Ireland. It examines the pre-operative, operative and postoperative management of women. A questionnaire established information about surgeons' experience, bilateral breast reduction work-load, pre-operative assessment, selection criteria, issues of operative technique and postoperative management. This was sent to 230 consultant plastic surgeons working in the NHS in the UK and Ireland. There was a 61% response rate. Of respondent surgeons, 82% always perform pre-operative photography, 71% never do a mammogram even in patients above the age of 50 years. Body mass index (BMI) is the most commonly used criteria for patient selection (60%). Two-thirds of the surgeons use an inferior pedicle technique and 75% of surgeons work in health authorities that restrict breast reduction surgery. There was significant variation in practice among surgeons performing bilateral breast reduction. This may reflect a lack of evidence base for practise. Published literature focuses almost exclusively on the description of different techniques. Further work is required to evaluate the role of pre-operative mammography, specimen mammography, antibiotics and selection criteria for surgery.

Long-term Results of Frey's Procedure for Chronic Pancreatitis: A Longitudinal Prospective Study on 40 Patients

Only limited prospective data are available regarding the long-term outcome of local resection of the pancreatic head in combination with longitudinal pancreaticojejunostomy in patients with chronic pancreatitis. From 1997 to 2001, 40 patients affected by chronic pancreatitis were subjected to the Frey's procedure. Preoperative selection criteria included confirmed diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis, dilation of Wirsung's duct to a diameter greater than 6 mm, and the absence of obstructive chronic pancreatitis secondary to fibrotic stenosis at the pancreatic body or tail. Preoperative pain was present in 38 cases (95%), and follow-up was performed in all patients at least once yearly up to 2003 (median 60 months, inter percentile range 20.1-79.6). Postoperative morbidity occurred in three cases (7.5%). The percentage of pain-free patients was 94.7%, 93.7%, 87.5%, and 90% at 1, 2, 3, and 4/5 years after surgical operation, respectively. After surgery, three patients developed diabetes. Both the body mass index and quality of life showed statistically significant improvements at all follow-up intervals. Whenever surgery is indicated, the short-term and long-term outcomes confirm that Frey's procedure is an appropriate means of management for patients with chronic pancreatitis in the absence of doubts of neoplasia and/or distal ductal obstruction.

929 POSTER Pre-operative selection criteria for operability in recurrent ovarian cancer. a study of the AGO organkommission ovar and the AGO ovarian cancer study group (AGO-OVAR)

929 POSTER Pre-operative selection criteria for operability in recurrent ovarian cancer. a study of the AGO organkommission ovar and the AGO ovarian cancer study group (AGO-OVAR)

Neonatal thoracoscopic repair of congenital diaphragmatic hernia: selection criteria for successful outcome

Background/Purpose Complications of open conversion, hypercarbia, and intestinal injury have plagued minimally invasive approaches to congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) repair in neonates. To safely begin using minimally invasive techniques for neonatal CDH repair, we formulated preoperative selection criteria and operative techniques that would enhance chances for successful thoracoscopic primary diaphragm repair and uncomplicated outcome. Methods During the period from January 2003 to October 2004, neonates were selected for thoracoscopic CDH repair using anatomic and physiologic criteria. Anatomically, all patients were required to have stomach in the abdomen by radiography. Physiologically, all patients were required to be on minimal ventilator support with preoperative ventilator peak inspiratory pressures in the low 20s mm Hg. No patient could have clinical evidence of pulmonary hypertension at the time of surgery. Thoracoscopic CDH repair was performed using 3 trocars (3 and 5 mm). The hernia contents were reduced into the abdomen using 5–mm Hg insufflation, and the diaphragms were repaired primarily using interrupted 3-0 Ethibond simple sutures (Ethicon, Inc, Piscataway, NJ). Posterolateral diaphragm stitches were passed around the posterolateral ribs and tied extracorporeally. Results Thirty neonates with CDH were admitted to Children's Hospital Boston and Vanderbilt Children's Hospital during the study period. Eight patients (27%) met selection criteria and 7 underwent thoracoscopic CDH repair. Primary diaphragmatic repair was successfully accomplished thoracoscopically in all neonates without perioperative complication. Preoperative anatomic criteria correlated accurately with intact esophageal hiatus and primary diaphragm repair. Physiologically, each patient tolerated intrathoracic insufflation and CDH repair without clinical pulmonary hypertension or blood pressure lability. Three patients had intraoperative respiratory acidosis that was reversed with ventilator changes. Operative times averaged 152 minutes and ranged from 212 to 106 minutes. Postoperative mechanical ventilation ranged from 0 to 7 days, and the length of hospitalization ranged from 5 to 32 days. Longest follow-up has been 17 months. One patient required reoperation for recurrent CDH at 10 months after repair, but there have been no other long-term complications. Conclusions Neonatal thoracoscopic CDH repair is safe in selected patients who have good preoperative pulmonary function and anatomy amenable to primary diaphragmatic repair. A wider range of neonates may be acceptable for thoracoscopic CDH repair with increasing surgical experience.

Pre-operative selection criteria for operability in recurrent ovarian cancer. A study of the AGO Organkommission Ovar and the AGO Ovarian Cancer Study Group (AGO-OVAR)

5004 Background: The role of cytoreductive surgery (CS) in recurrent ovarian cancer (ROC) has not been clearly defined. Patient selection for CS remains arbitrarily and depends more on center’s preference than on established selection criteria. Methods: The AGO performed a retrospective study evaluating criteria for CS in ROC. 25 institutions documented their pts with CS for invasive epithelial ROC performed 2000–2003. Results: 268 pts were included, mean age was 59.5 years (23–83) and 108 pts (40.4%) had a treatment-free-interval of 12 months or less. 146 pts (55%) received platinum-based chemotherapy following surgery. Complete tumor removal was achieved in 133 pts (50%). Complete resection was associated with significantly longer survival compared to CS leaving any residuals (median 45.2 vs 19.7 months; HR 3.71 (95% CI 2.27–6.05); p< 0.0001). Variables associated with a higher probability for complete resection in multivariate analysis were good performance status (ECOG 0 vs >0; OR 2.56 (95%CI 1.49–4.42); p< 0.001), no ascites (< vs > 500ml; OR 4.26 (1.62–11.24); p<0.003), no residuals after 1st surgery (0 vs >0 mm; OR 2.09 (1.20–3.64); p=0.009) and no evidence for peritoneal carcinosis in pre-OP diagnostics (yes vs no; OR 2.67 (1.34–5.32); p=0.005). A complete resection was possible in 81% if these 4 variables were present. Prognostic factors in multivariate analysis for survival after a secondary cytoreductive surgery were complete surgical resection at recurrence (0 vs > 0 mm; OR 2.86 (1.66–4.93); p<0.001), post-OP platinum chemotherapy (yes vs no; OR 1.83 (1.16–2.88); p=0.009) and no ascites (< vs > 500 ml; OR 2.09 (1.18–3.71);p=0.012). Conclusions: Only patients with complete resection seems to benefit from radical surgery. The presence of the 4 variables as shown above helped to predict surgical outcome. Based on these data the AGO will evaluate this new panel of selection criteria in a prospective multi-institutional study. No significant financial relationships to disclose.

Liver Transplant Results for Hepatocellular Carcinoma Applying Strict Preoperative Selection Criteria

Introduction Liver transplantation is currently the best therapeutic option for small hepatocellular carcinoma (HC) in selected cirrhotic patients. The main aim of this study was to analyze the results of a recent series of liver transplant cirrhotic patients with small HC applying strict preoperative selection criteria. Patients and methods During a period of 6 years we performed 53 liver transplants with a final diagnosis of HC on cirrhosis. The selection criteria for liver transplantation (LT) by modern imaging techniques were the Milan criteria (TNM I and II of the modified classification). Results Of the 53 patients, 44 (83%) were transplanted with preoperatively known HC, and 9 (17%) with incidental HC. The mean time on the waiting list was 74 ± 62 days. Despite using strict selection criteria, 23 patients (43%) exceeded the Milan criteria in the specimen and 17 (32%) even exceeded the extended criteria of the UCSF. With a mean follow-up of 2 years, only two patients have developed recurrences. The overall survival at 1, 3, and 5 years was 80%, 70%, and 70%, respectively. The survival of patients that exceeded the Milan or USF criteria at 1, 3, and 5 years was 72% and 76%; 67% and 69%; 67% and 69%, respectively. Conclusions The results of liver transplantation for HC are excellent when applying strict preoperative selection criteria. The current imaging methods lead to a considerable infrastaging percentage (30% to 40%), extending the indications for liver transplant due to HC beyond the scope that clinical reports would justify.

Perioperative determinants of morbidity and mortality in elderly patients undergoing cardiac surgery*

Objective To determine perioperative predictors of morbidity and mortality in patients ≥75 yrs of age after cardiac surgery. Design Inception cohort study. Setting A tertiary care, 54-bed cardiothoracic intensive care unit (ICU). Patients All patients aged ≥75 yrs admitted over a 30-month period for cardiac surgery. Intervention Collection of data on preoperative factors, operative factors, postoperative hemodynamics, and laboratory data obtained on admission and during the ICU stay. Measurements and Main Results Postoperative death, frequency rate of organ dysfunction, nosocomial infections, length of mechanical ventilation, and ICU stay were recorded. During the study period, 1,157 (14%) of 8,501 patients ≥75 yrs of age had a morbidity rate of 54% (625 of 1,157 patients) and a mortality rate of 8% (90 of 1,157 patients) after cardiac surgery. Predictors of postoperative morbidity included preoperative intraaortic balloon counterpulsation, preoperative serum bilirubin of >1.0 mg/dL, blood transfusion requirement of >10 units of red blood cells, cardiopulmonary bypass time of >120 mins (aortic cross-clamp time of >80 mins), return to operating room for surgical exploration, heart rate of >120 beats/min, requirement for inotropes and vasopressors after surgery and on admission to the ICU, and anemia beyond the second postoperative day. Predictors of postoperative mortality included preoperative cardiac shock, serum albumin of <4.0 g/dL, systemic oxygen delivery of <320 mL/min/m2 before surgery, blood transfusion requirement of >10 units of red blood cells, cardiopulmonary bypass time of >140 mins (aortic cross-clamp time of >120 mins), subsequent return to the operating room for surgical exploration, mean arterial pressure of <60 mm Hg, heart rate of >120 beats/min, central venous pressure of >15 mm Hg, stroke volume index of <30 mL/min/m2, requirement for inotropes, arterial bicarbonate of <20 mmol/L, plasma glucose of >300 mg/dL after surgery, and anemia beyond the second postoperative day. During the study period, the study cohort used 6,859 (21.5%) ICU patient-days out of a total 31,867 ICU patient-days. Nonsurvivors used 2,023 (30%) ICU patient-days and patients with morbidity used 5,903 (86%) ICU patient-days. Conclusions Severe underlying cardiac disease (including shock, requirement for mechanical circulatory support, hypoalbuminemia, and hepatic dysfunction), intraoperative blood loss, surgical reexploration, long ischemic times, immediate postoperative cardiovascular dysfunction, global ischemia and metabolic dysfunction, and anemia beyond the second postoperative day predicted poor outcome in the elderly after cardiac surgery. Postoperative morbidity and mortality disproportionately increased the utilization of intensive care resources in elderly patients. Future efforts should focus on preoperative selection criteria, improvement in surgical techniques, perioperative therapy to ameliorate splanchnic and global ischemia, and avoidance of anemia to improve the outcome in the elderly after cardiac surgery. (Crit Care Med 1998; 26:225–235)

Weight loss following vertical banded gastroplasty: intermediate results of a prospective study.

Morbidly obese patients who undergo purely restrictive bariatric operations may fail to maintain satisfactory long-term results. In an attempt to achieve the best possible outcome after restrictive procedures, we have employed preoperative selection criteria and are following this selected patient group over time in order to evaluate long-term success. From June 1994 through August 2000, 166 morbidly obese patients underwent various bariatric procedures at our institution. Of these patients, 35 underwent vertical banded gastroplasty (VBG) based on selection criteria, including degree of obesity and dietary habits and eating behavior. All patients were seen at 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months postoperatively and yearly thereafter. Average follow-up time now is 4.1 years (29-75 mos.), and follow-up is 100%. A multivitamin and mineral supplement is administered to all patients for at least 6 months. Radiology examination is performed in all patients on the 4th postoperative day and at each yearly visit, in order to check for staple-line disruption and stomal stenosis. Early postoperative morbidity was 5.7%. Late postoperative morbidity was 22.8%. A significant number of patients had some degree of stomal stenosis as shown by radiology examination, but to date there has been no need for surgical revision. There has been no early or late mortality. Weight loss results expressed as average percent excess weight loss (% EWL) were as follows: 61% (28-90) at 1 year, 61% (20-90) at 2 years, 57% (13-91) at 3 years, 56% (25-87) at 4 years and 37% (24-59) at 5 years following surgery. A significant number of patients with excellent weight loss had a high frequency of vomiting. Evaluation by BAROS showed that 25% of patients had an overall unsatisfactory outcome. Anemia and iron deficiency were found in 46% and 32% of VBG patients respectively. Recurrence of preexisting comorbidities was significant if lost weight was regained. In spite of preoperative selection of patients for VBG, a significant percentage of patients had poor overall results in terms of weight loss, quality of life, and resolution of preexisting comorbidities. For these reasons and based on the long-term results published by others, VBG is no longer our preferred surgical option in morbidly obese patients.

Does choice of hearing selection criterion and reporting criteria affect the hearing preservation rate in vestibular schwannoma surgery?

With increasing refinement in the surgery of vestibular schwannoma the aims of complete tumor removal and facial nerve preservation have been largely fulfilled. However, the reputation of and place for hearing-preservation surgery still remain uncertain. A major part of this uncertainty is the result of difficulties in interpretation of the various reported results of hearing-preservation surgery. Meaningful comparison between series is difficult because of the varied number of postoperative reporting criteria commonly in use today. Although it is acknowledged that the postoperative reporting criteria affect the hearing-preservation rates, what is not readily appreciated is that preoperative selection criteria for hearing-preservation cases can also significantly affect the success rate of hearing-preservation acoustic neuroma surgery. This article models the many possible outcomes of hearing-preservation schwannoma surgery by use of the previously reported Cambridge series as an illustrative example. With these models some understanding can be gained of the effect of choosing various preoperative and postoperative hearing criteria on the overall hearing-preservation success rate. (Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1999;121:313-7.)

Selection criteria for internal rectal prolapse repair by Delorme's transrectal excision.

The aim of this study was to review our results of Delorme's transrectal excision for internal rectal prolapse, with a view to determining preoperative selection criteria associated with a satisfactory outcome. Between 1992 and 1998, 20 patients with internal rectal prolapse underwent Delorme's transrectal excision. The last patient was excluded from the study because of a follow-up period shorter than six months. The remaining 19 patients were prospectively followed up and classified into two groups according to their preoperative selection criteria. Group I consisted of eight patients operated on between January 1992 and October 1993 who were selected for surgery after medical treatment during a three-month period failed to improve symptoms. Initial results were reviewed, with a follow-up of at least six months, to assess predictive criteria correlating with poorer surgical outcome. These adverse criteria were used to exclude patients from selection into Group II, which included 11 patients operated on between June 1994 and June 1997. In each group the degree of improvement of symptoms was graded: Grade 1 = complete improvement with resolution of all symptoms; Grade 2 = significant improvement with resolution of dyschezia but not of other symptoms; Grade 3 = no improvement; and Grade 4 = worsened condition or reoperation. The two groups were compared according to ultimate outcomes. Of the Group I patients, three had preoperative chronic diarrhea, one had proximal internal rectal prolapse with rectosacral separation at defecography, and the other two were incontinent to liquid stool. An additional patient had incontinence to liquid stool but no diarrhea. Three other patients had major perineal descent (>9 cm). Results were Grade 1 for one patient, Grade 2 for one patient, Grade 3 for five patients, and Grade 4 for one patient (subsequent abdominal rectopexy). Data review showed that proximal internal prolapse with rectosacral separation at defecography, preoperative chronic diarrhea, fecal incontinence, and descending perineum (>9 cm on straining) were associated with a poorer outcome (Grades 3 and 4). These adverse criteria were used to exclude patients from selection into Group II. In this group results were Grade 1 for seven patients and Grade 2 for four patients. During the course of follow-up (mean, 43; standard deviation, 19; range, 8-73 months), outcome was better in Group II (P = 0.007). CONCLUSION. These data suggest that a favorable outcome can be achieved after Delorme's transrectal excision for internal rectal prolapse by applying stringent patient-selection criteria.

Is partial nephrectomy appropriate treatment for unilateral Wilms' tumor?

Purpose : After nephrectomy for unilateral Wilms' tumor (WT), two potential hazards threaten the remaining kidney. The development of a metachronous WT (2% to 3%), and decrease in renal function after chemotherapy. Our study aims included: (1) to clarify how many WT patients could benefit from partial nephrectomy (PN) without jeopardizing the high cure rate, (2) to establish the function of the kidney remnant, and (3) to test the radiological criteria for preoperative selection of PN candidates. Methods : A retrospective analysis of 90 consecutive cases of histologically verified WT (1982 to 1992) was carried out. Data were studied independently by the surgeon, the radiologist, and the pathologist. The preoperative selection criteria for PN were functioning kidney, tumor confined to upper or lower pole leaving two thirds of the kidney tumor free, and no hilar or vascular structures involved. After PN, renal function was estimated by a calculated creatinine clearance (CC) combined with the assessment of the relative function of each kidney by renal scintigraphy. Results : There were 46 boys and 44 girls with median age at diagnosis of 3 years 6 months (range, 3 months to 16 years 7 months). Stage I disease occurred in 40 patients, stage II in 23, stage III in 16, and stage IV occurred in 11 patients. Nearly all patients received preoperative chemotherapy. Radiological analysis of 85 available data sets (5 missing) suggested that PN was possible in 13 patients, and data were inconclusive in two. All 13 patients selected by the radiologist appeared to be in agreement with the pathological criteria for resectability. Of these cases, complete resection by PN was performed in five, could have been possible in retrospect in two, and appeared impossible in six. In two more patients, PN was performed; in both cases the radiologist had predicted PN to be impossible. Median follow-up after PN was 61 months, range, 45 to 167 months. Two patients died of distant metastasis, and no local recurrence occurred. Five are in remission with a median CC level of 110 mL/min, range, 85 to 124. Relative functions of the kidney remnants were 20% to 50%. Contralateral nephrectomy for progressive obstruction was performed in one, but CC level remained normal (85 mL/min). Comparing the preoperative radiological prediction with the combined surgical and pathological findings in a 2 × 2 frequency table, the sensitivity of the radiological findings could be calculated to be 80%, the specificity 97%, and the accuracy 87%. Conclusions : (1) Partial nephrectomy is safe in approximately 10% of Wilms' tumor patients. (2) The function of the kidney remnant remains well, and even permits contralateral nephrectomy. (3) Preoperative imaging shows an accuracy of 87% to predict the possibility for partial nephrectomy.

Acoustic Tumor Surgery: Prognostic Factors in Hearing Conservation

Preoperative selection criteria for hearing conservation surgery in patients with acoustic tumors continues to be unresolved. The level of hearing that is worth saving is still debatable. However, most acoustic tumor surgeons agree that hearing preservation is less likely the larger the tumor. We reviewed the results of 106 middle fossa acoustic tumor removals with attempted hearing preservation. Measurable postoperative hearing remained in 59% of 97 cases analyzed for postoperative hearing results. Tumor size, preoperative auditory brain-stem response, and preoperative electronystagmography were found to be useful in predicting successful postoperative hearing preservation. We found no correlation between the level of preoperative hearing and our ability to preserve measurable postoperative hearing. A new classification system is proposed for reporting hearing results after acoustic tumor surgery. It is based on functional hearing results and we believe it is simpler than previously proposed systems.