ABSTRACT The earliest stages of solid-state precipitation in age hardenable alloys, before the first ordered phase formation, are notoriously elusive, yet often of central importance to material properties quantification. The order–disorder precipitate transformations are currently accepted to proceed by long-range chemical ordering on a substructure extending through the particle, with the Al–Mg–Si alloy Guinier-Preston (GP) zone → β″ transformation representing the most well-documented example. It is shown here that the structurally distinct β″ phase arises directly from solute diffusion-controlled precipitation within a precipitate, providing an alternative pathway for the transformation of one precipitate to a more thermodynamically stable precipitate. The emergence of dispersed β″ nuclei in the otherwise fcc-based particle is revealed by structural and chemical signs of a significant spatial solute variation. Furthermore, upon reduced aging temperature, heavily structurally flawed final particles result from increasingly challenging nucleus coalescence. The highly localised origin of this process suggests that early-stage precipitate transformation mechanisms be revisited for other age hardenable alloys.