In this paper, the authors electrolytically extracted niobium inclusions from heats of 1030 steel with FeNb, NbO2, and NbO additions. From energy-dispersive spectroscopy, the inclusion chemistry of these additions was found to be similar. Pure niobium oxide inclusions were never found in the steel. Inclusion size was measured using polished samples and electrolytically extracted samples. Statistical analysis found that the average inclusion size was larger on filtered samples compared to the polished samples. Since pure NbO inclusions were not found, it was thought that the niobium strengthening reported in the earlier literature might be actually due to a precipitation hardening effect. Precipitation heat treatments were done at 600, 625, and 650 °C (1112, 1157, and 1202 °F) after solutionizing at 1100 °C (2012 °F). The hardness was measured at aging times of 30, 45, 60, 75, and 90 min. The observed relation between hardness and aging time matched that expected for a precipitation hardening mechanism. It was therefore theorized that the NbO and NbO2 additions dissolved in the melt and form precipitates.
Read full abstract